Politifact labels the TNGOP assertion that the current redistricting process was "the most open in history" as "false", even though it was done completely behind closed doors and so secretively it was rushed through the Legislature so fast that nobody had the chance to notice they forgot to include all the counties in TN.
Contrast that with Politifacts branding of TNDEM's statement Congressman DesJarlais's January schedule as having only six workdays as "liar, liar, pant's on fire", beacuse they took the word of a DesJarlais staffer who claimed the Congressman was working hard and only took one personal day. Politifact posted this statement from the staffer: "One of the things the congressman has been very good at is maintaining an open dialogue with his constituents about what goes on up here in Congress." If anything should be labelled "Pants On Fire" it would be that statement. DesJarlais has never held an open meeting in my county since he was elected.
Since there is no way to comment on the Politifacts post the question is, "Who is going to fact check Politifact?"
|
|
Discussing:
- Sam Seder takes on 20 MAGA loving supporters (1 reply)
- TN Legislature bullying Townsend? (14 replies)
- Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth orders a halt to offensive cyber operations against Russia (2 replies)
- Right thing, wrong way (2 replies)
- A Home with South Knox Bubba (and Mrs. Bubba) (5 replies)
- ‘A disruptive effect’: How slashing staff at the Social Security Administration is sparking fears the system could collapse (4 replies)
- Vitamin A or cod liver oil are not the cure or prevention for Measles (1 reply)
- For financial security, back the Dems... (1 reply)
- Fired CFPB chief says Musk may have another goal for gutting the agency (1 reply)
- Downtown Knoxville parking requires smartphone and credit? (3 replies)
- ‘There is no question this was a setup’: Amb. Susan Rice on Trump’s Oval Office ambush of Zelesnky (5 replies)
- Tennessee's US Senators pushed worst Trump nominees (1 reply)
TN Progressive
- Ever Seen a Cover done this fine? (RoaneViews)
- Saturday Snark (set to music) (RoaneViews)
- Feel Good Friday (RoaneViews)
- Trae (RoaneViews)
- (Whitescreek Journal)
- Lee's Fried Chicken in Alcoa closed (BlountViews)
- Alcoa, Hall Rd. Corridor Study meeting, July 30, 2024 (BlountViews)
- My choices in the August election (Left Wing Cracker)
- July 4, 2024 - aka The Twilight Zone (Joe Powell)
- Chef steals food to serve at restaurant? (BlountViews)
- Blount County, TDOT make road deal for gun mfg ignoring town of Louisville,TN, (BlountViews)
- Winter at the Big Rocks (Whitescreek Journal)
TN Politics
- Medicaid recipients struggle to find mental health care. Looming cuts could make it harder. (TN Lookout)
- Lawyers for former Tennessee House Speaker: feds have evidence to discredit witnesses (TN Lookout)
- TDEC: $100M Duck River budget ask could be used toward regional Tennessee River pipeline (TN Lookout)
- Get the antacids ready as Trump administration cuts damage Tennessee (TN Lookout)
- A failure of imagination in the Tennessee Legislature (TN Lookout)
- Some U.S. Republicans are pushing to keep energy tax credits. Tennessee lawmakers aren’t among them. (TN Lookout)
Knox TN Today
- Vols fall in SEC, open NCAA against Wofford (Knox TN Today)
- NYPD to KPD: Morgan, family found their home (Knox TN Today)
- Living better longer (Knox TN Today)
- HEADLINES 3/17 (Knox TN Today)
- Oldfield Law + Second NARC bust + + (Knox TN Today)
- The magic of St. Patrick’s Day: More than just green beer (Knox TN Today)
- Food City customers donate $51K+ to Project Help (Knox TN Today)
- Covenant Health recognized as one of ‘America’s Greatest Workplaces for Women’ (Knox TN Today)
- Down goes Auburn, Vols face Florida (Knox TN Today)
- Vols top Texas, Auburn is next (Knox TN Today)
- Softball to host UConn; basketball awaits brackets (Knox TN Today)
- ‘Hummingbirds – Our Feathered Rainbows,’ a Zoom program on April 3 (Knox TN Today)
Local TV News
- Tennessee residents face debris woes after Hurricane Helene's impact (WBIR)
- MCSO: Two dead after fire in Monroe County (WATE)
- 'As the day progressed, the smoke got heavier' Cocke County resident spots Hall Top wildfire from his backyard (WATE)
- Missing North Carolina teen's truck seen near Harriman (WATE)
- Woman facing DUI charge after vehicle crashes into building (WATE)
- Morristown Police Department searching for missing 20-year-old (WATE)
- Knoxville Track Club completes longest group run three weeks ahead of marathon weekend (WATE)
- Knox Shamrock Fest offers St. Patrick's Day fun for all ages at World's Fair Park for a good cause (WBIR)
- Wednesday marks 5 years since first COVID-19 case declared in Knox County (WBIR)
- Nashville bill proposes grant fund to keep students safe as they walk to school (WBIR)
- Whataburger eyes Crossville for new location near Buc-ee's (WBIR)
- City grants Knoxville College request for 30 days to secure part of decaying campus landmark (WBIR)
News Sentinel
State News
- UTC men face Middle Tennessee in NIT; women to also play again - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Chattanooga Knows: What TV personality faced a battle with oral cancer in the 1970s? - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Chattanooga area has most hemp shops per capita in Tennessee - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- One man dead in Saturday shooting, authorities investigating - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
Wire Reports
- European shares rise, while Wall St futures sag - Reuters (Business)
- Trump says he and Putin will discuss land and powerplants in Ukraine ceasefire talks - The Guardian (US News)
- Trump says Ukraine-Russia peace talks looking at ‘dividing up certain assets’ - CNN (US News)
- Forever 21 Operator Files for Bankruptcy - The New York Times (Business)
- Judge demands Trump admin. explain why doctor was deported despite order - Axios (US News)
- China Economic Pickup Tops Forecasts Before Tariff Pain Deepens - Yahoo Finance (Business)
- Oklahomans survey devastation after hundreds of homes are destroyed and damaged by wildfires - The Associated Press (US News)
- US tornadoes, wildfires and dust storms leave 40 dead and 'staggering' damage - BBC.com (US News)
- CNBC Daily Open: U.S. consumers think inflation will shoot up in the year ahead - CNBC (Business)
- With Deportations, Trump Steps Closer to Showdown With Judicial Branch - The New York Times (US News)
- Trump dismantles Voice of America with executive order - BBC.com (US News)
- Calera man loses home in tornado, stays with daughter in jail: Police chief says relief effort raises questio - AL.com (US News)
- Trump’s Multimillionaire Treasury Secretary Calls Stock Market Drop ‘Healthy’ - Rolling Stone (Business)
- The Fed Is in Wait-and-See Mode. Investors Want Reassurance It Will Act If Needed - Bloomberg (Business)
- Wall Street's recession odds are starting to look like a coin flip as Trump refuses to back down on his trade war - Fortune (Business)
Local Media
Lost Medicaid Funding
Search and Archives
TN Progressive
Nearby:
- Blount Dems
- Herston TN Family Law
- Inside of Knoxville
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jim Stovall
- Knox Dems
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Outdoor Knoxville
- Pittman Properties
- Reality Me
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
Beyond:
- Nashville Scene
- Nashville Post
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Journal
- TN Lookout
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South
No way! They're fair and
No way! They're fair and balanced! A Republican cannot tell a lie. Hell, a Boy Scout would lie first! /s
Good lord.
Let me get this straight. You're claiming bias over an assessment of whose lie is the bigger lie? Okay.
To me, the fact someone would make that case speaks volumes about the divergence from reality that is modern political discourse, and it is a far bigger deal than whatever distinctions lie between Politifact's designations of "false" and "pants on fire." Both things are factually incorrect.
Seriously. Nobody does the home team any favors by trying to point out that the other guy is technically a bigger liar. It's like saying "our baseball team only takes the most sophisticated performance-enhancing drugs that are harder to detect, and may or may not be easily defined by current rules as illegal, but the other guys are clearly jacked up on testosterone!" If you're a partisan who wants to attract the votes of that vast, uncommitted middle ground, try demonstrating that you hold your side up to a higher standard.
Oh, and by "higher standard," I do not mean "our lies are more nuanced."
Missed the point, did you?
Just pointing out the obvious fact that the "impartial" refs are not impartial.
Missed the point, did you?
Just pointing out the obvious fact that the difference between a "lie" and a "damn lie" is fairly inconsequential.
If it quacks like a duck...
If you set yourself up as the arbiter of truth, You really shouldn't make obvious errors of fact yourself. It's the bias, stupid. So far it looks like a pattern to me.
OK, since I'm "stupid," spell
OK, since I'm "stupid," spell it out for me. Help me understand where you're documenting "bias" with this example.
With my limited intellect, what I see you getting worked up about is this: On one hand, Politifact looked at Ron Ramsey's assertion that this year's redistricting effort has been the most open, etc, in history, and rated it "false," and provided evidence that it was, in fact, false. Then they looked at Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee's assertion that Republican Representative Scott Dejarlais had only worked six days in all of January, 2012. They rated that as "Pants on Fire," which is one stop more false than "false," and they offered information demonstrating how the assertion is not accurate.
Politifact defines the two categories this way: "FALSE – The statement is not accurate. PANTS ON FIRE – The statement is not accurate and makes a ridiculous claim."
In both cases, they cited information that any reasonable person would say refutes the claim, so both claims as reviewed were at least false. So from there, you seem to see a bias in their distinction that only the Dejarlais claim was noted as false, but also that it makes a ridiculous claim. I suppose you could argue that Ramsey's claim should also have rated "Pants on Fire," but I don't see how anyone with any sense could find that the claim about Dejarlais is anything but ridiculous. Politifact did note that the DCCC didn't offer anything but the calendar for when Congress is in session as evidence for their claim. It's a ridiculous claim. I don't know much about Dejarlais, but that evidence could be used to make the same claim about 434 other people, and I would call it ridiculous unless pictures of Congressmen in conga lines on cruise ships are offered up as additional proof.
When Congress is out of session, Members of Congress spend time in their district meeting with constituents and speaking to Rotary Clubs and whatever. This Congressman's office offered examples from his schedule suggesting as much, so barring evidence to the contrary, the reviewed statement is just one more example of stupid political distortions made by political operatives. I think it's fair to say that this was a ridiculous claim. (What I can't figure out is why, with the plethora of genuine fodder for criticism of these yokels that's available, anyone would make the effort to come up with this whopper.)
So your whole assertion of bias lies with Politifact failing to also find Ramsey's claim to be not only false, but ridiculously so. I can totally see the argument that it should've been or could've been rated "Pants on Fire," but it's a distinction without a difference, and I don't see how it clearly documents any great bias, other than your own.
Frankly, I think the whole Politifact thing is a gimmick, and that our friends in the press should be doing this sort of reviewing of the veracity of political claims as a matter of course in all their reporting, not just with great fanfare in a special "Truth-O-Meter" section. Instead, most reporting gets the "he said, she said" treatment, allowing false information to get a pass, and false equivalencies to be the order of the day when offering "balance" in everyday reporting. That's where the real problem lies.
It's a figure of speech
It's a figure of speech intended to punctuate what is important and what isn't, in this case having a demonstrable bias when claiming infallible truth. But if you can somehow twist it to mean that you have been raised to the level egregiousness that I would go to the trouble to personally insult, I can't stop you, though you would be incorrect in this case as well. (My last response to this sophistry)
Fascinating
I was mostly having a little fun responding to the "stupid" remark, and you made a point to respond to that, but not to my actual argument. Then you declare you're done responding to "sophistry," offering nothing to back up that claim, either. What that says to me is you've got nothing to offer. You made an assertion about bias, cited an example that doesn't prove you point, and offer scant little to back your argument, or to refute mine. That's pretty weak, isn't it? Or are you the arbiter of truth, whose assertions and opinions are fact, requiring no explanation?
How can something some people
How can something some people tout as such a great thing be so ridiculous? You can fool all of the the people some of the time?
Facts?
I recommend Doonesbury. And I recommend the entire week's worth of myfacts.
Hah. I saw those and
Hah. I saw those and Politifact is exactly what came to mind. I do love Doonesbury.