From wbir.com ...

His current plans for Knox Falls would feature a waterfall on the south waterfront and an observation area on the northern side of the Tennessee River. It would also include a water show with lights and music.

Waterfall on South Waterfront

Chris Field's picture

WtF???

I am just waiting for Allen Funt to come around the corner. I thought this was a joke when I saw the headline. This is, without a doubt, the dumbest, chinziest idea I have ever heard. An electric light show accompanied by music every fifteen minutes?!? It would ruin Knoxville! What is even more distressing is the generally positive response it is getting in comment sections. Am I losing my mind here?

Rachel's picture

No. No. No.

No. No. No.

jbr's picture

I haven't decided what I

I haven't decided what I think of the waterfall yet, but I like the vision of interesting entities along the waterfront connected by park like connections, instead of high rises that... "usually create a wall that physically and psychologically cuts off the waterfront."

I have mentioned before I would like to see an incline railcar up to Ft Dickerson and/or the other Civil War forts above the river.

I think a fully glass enclosed performance venue would be good that gives an energetic visual to the waterfront on a regular basis.

Access needs to be easy via boat, bike and foot

I hope there is a paddle craft lane for kayak, canoe, SUP on the south side of the river the length of the waterfront with numerous access points on the shore. I also think it should be a no wake zone for power boats.

10 Qualities of a Great Waterfront Destination

bizgrrl's picture

Everyone seems to be working

Everyone seems to be working to make Knoxville great again. Heh.

Is this like the rodeo idea? It's not April 1.

Bagwell estimated the waterfall project would cost a “few million dollars.” When asked if he would give money toward the project, Bagwell said he has spent money designing the idea and using a drone to capture aerial footage of the site. He has yet to submit the idea to the city.

I'm not sure if it is being proposed to have the music going most of the day in cycles of 15-30 minutes. I think music along the river on a fairly continuous basis would be annoying, especially if it is loud enough to be heard on the north side of the river.

Downtown Knoxville could eventually grow to be a theme park! The waterfall, music, lights, then add cool rides across the river along with a theme park area for more rides, fair food, etc.

Yeehaw!

Roscoe Persimmon's picture

Bagwell is Jimmy Haslam's father in law, so better

get your Maiden of the Mist kayak's ready, the Pilot WaterFall is coming, they'll even tint the water and the river orange on game days, filter through some fresh coffer in front of the river for everyone to drink and get a free copy of the News Sentinel on Fridays.

Somebody needs to ask Victor Ashe what he thinks about a WaterFall on the South Knoxville Riverfront, he's a perceptive person.

R. Neal's picture

I am not Victor Ashe but this

I am not Victor Ashe but this is one of the dumbest ideas I have ever heard.

Looking at the KNS comments, it seems to be a big hit. Probably all RIVR Media employees.

My favorite comment suggested using solar power to pump the water up. I'm not an engineer, but I'm guessing it would take a lot more power than a huge solar array could produce.

On the other hand, you could use turbines in the waterfall to recapture some of the power. TVA does this at Racoon Mountain, so genius!

lol2's picture

Universe Knoxville

Part two?

zoomfactor's picture

The amount of money coming in would be phenomenal!

Here we go again: "Let's make a DESTINATION ATTRACTION!" (Flashbacks to Worsham Watkins, Universe Knoxville, habititrails, etc.)

reform4's picture

I did the math

The cost to pump the water would run $6,000,0000 / year.

That's why all big waterfalls are natural.

Average Guy's picture

Jesus!

No wonder Splash Country tickets are so expensive.

Could you show the math?

Somebody's picture

Splash Country's entire

Splash Country's entire volume of pumped water would be a tiny fraction of what's pictured draining out of Baptist Hospital. You really don't have to work the math to get the gist of it.

Average Guy's picture

To me,

the gist is the $6 million(?) annual figure you put on it.

Could care less, but if you put a number on it for public consumption, you should explain it.

Somebody's picture

I didn't put a number on it.

I didn't put a number on it. My estimate would be 'a whole lot.' Maybe even a whole heckuva lot.

reform4's picture

Calculator and assumptions

(link...)

1000 cubic feet per second (very roughly 1000 feet wide, 1 foot deep, 1 ft/sec flow rate, $0.10 per kWh. I think I used a 33' head (lift), which is pretty optimistic.

Some other water engineers posting on the new story on FB did their own calcs and came up with$8M to $9M.

Somebody's picture

Erosion.

I wonder what kind of erosion that sort of flow would cause on all that limestone below, and how long it would take to cause a major structural collapse of the built area above.

reform4's picture

Niagra Falls

Loses something like 27" a year.

Since the waterfall would be artificial, I assume the 'lip' would be built from some kind of concrete, which probably wouldn't erode very much. Now, where it hits the bottom (and underwater), that would be the issue.

And you'd have to mark off the area from boats, swimmers, etc with buoys because of the hydraulics... that's where the new 'hazard to navigation' and narrowing to the navigable channel wouldn't pass TVA muster. Not even remotely.

Average Guy's picture

Initial instinct; WTF?!

But I have seen seen a show on the river many moons ago and enjoyed the setting. And as the WFP south lawn seems like a nonstarter, it'd be good to have a downtown option for outdoor music larger than the Square.

The waterfall? Ehh. Kudzu? Ehh.

If it is the falls, keep it away from the bridges. The support structures would not need the stress.

Elwood Aspermonte's picture

Taxpayers have thrown millions at the waterfront

what's a few million more, the riverfront is all appearance over the substance of what is there anyway, Regal will be there (Regal is already here), new parking garage (parking garages are already there) student rental housing will be there (there's an abundance of student housing on that side of the river already)but the riverfront will look better, look a bit nicer and we'll all feel better about downtown Knoxville, regardless if any of the projects put any new people on a meaningful payroll or whether or not the public picks up the costs again, again, and again.

Anonymous0721's picture

Well people aren't gonna throw money at a sh*thole

It's important that the ever expanding downtown area looks nice. I'm happy my money is going to these projects. The waterfall idea seems a bit excessive. Downtown Knoxville isn't the Bellagio. But most ideas I've seen I'm totally in favor for. Personally, I think it would be a great little luxury shopping district with brand name retailers. Just outside of our main tourist areas such as market square and gay street, full of great, successful local businesses

P.S. Am I the only one who gets pissed off by the unnecessarily difficult captcha codes?

bizgrrl's picture

Captcha complexity fix,

Captcha complexity fix, register.

Race Bannon's picture

Dumb Idea

This is the dumbest thing I've heard since Earl Worsham wanted to put a dome over Market Square.

DubV's picture

As long as we are looking to

As long as we are looking to Pigeon Forge as a model for urban development, I have a few more ideas for attracting tourists to downtown knoxville:

- Turn KMA into a lazer tag arena
- Turn Market Square into a shifter kart track
- Turn Blount Mansion into "Billy Blount's Paranormal Paradise of Haunted Horrors"

jbr's picture

I think there should be

I think there should be multiple entities along the south waterfront. Not just put all resources in a huge wide waterfall. Just too extreme.

When the economy dips again will the water get turned off and/or repairs not be done? then there is a big ugly eyesore there.

Maybe a much narrower tall waterfall that the Riverwalk will go in behind might be interesting.

Maybe he can set up a trust to provide maintenance funds.

How about a small Civil War museum along the waterfront with focused info about the Civil War forts overlooking the river.

How about a dynamic art section that changes every few months with local artists works

Rotating performance area. One week Market Square, the next week the waterfront. Music, movies, plays.

To me student apartments do not benefit Knoxville on the waterfront. Students are going to be in Knoxville anyway. Somewhere. The waterfront could be used to bring in folks from other places outside of Knox County to boost the economy. And a place for locals to be entertained.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives