Mon
Sep 17 2007
10:10 am

State Sen. Jim Kyle calls for an emergency oversight meeting:

Citing concerns that recent operational missteps could damage consumer confidence in the Tennessee Education Lottery, Democratic Leader Sen. Jim Kyle, D-Memphis, on Thursday called for a meeting of the General Assembly’s Lottery Oversight Committee to be convened as soon as possible.

The article notes recent problems such as listing the wrong jackpot amount and software problems that prevented drawing of certain numbers. Just this past Saturday the Mrs. tried to buy a Powerball ticket but the computers were down. She was told that the problem was occurring statewide.

A recent KNS editorial also discussed the ongoing problems with racial and socioeconomic disparity among lottery scholarship beneficiaries.

The former are operational problems that should be easy to fix. Frankly, I'm a little surprised they are even occurring because Rebecca Paul (now Rebecca Paul Hargrove) is nationally recognized as an outstanding lottery CEO. She did an exemplary job launching Florida's lottery before moving North to Georgia and now to Tennessee. Maybe there's something about the Tennessee political climate that make her job tougher here.

The latter are policy issues that go beyond the lottery, or even education in Tennessee, and will be a lot harder to fix.

Andy Axel's picture

Maybe there's something

Maybe there's something about the Tennessee political climate that make her job tougher here.

Maybe it's something inherent in the way that lottery business is conducted.

Paul is probably the best-paid "public servant" in the state.

All of this is to say, frankly, that I'm not surprised. When the lottery first came to Tennessee, some folks I was talking to said that it was only a matter of time before a scandal developed.

____________________________

I'm a guy in a Reagan mask -- and I'm running for President!

bizgrrl's picture

The lottery machine just

The lottery machine just keeps on screwing up.

This is almost funny. Ya think the people of Tennessee will continue to buy lottery tickets even if the odds are doubled (pretty high odds as it is) due to stupidity on the part of the lottery providers? Is it stupidity or intentional? Does someone have a plan to rip-off the lottery and these instances are trial and error to see what can be gotten away with?

WhitesCreek's picture

The Lottery

The Lottery is a tax on the stupid.

So why do we have to wait behind them in line? Why don't lottery purchasers have to go into a segregated area like say, smokers?

(Anonymous)'s picture

Lottery

Why should anyone wait behind you for whatever ur buying. Cause ur a paying customer. And u were first

ap9633's picture

tennessee lottery

It's one thing to say ther was a glitch in the system! I have been an avid player of cash3 and cash4 for over a year now. It seemed to me as soon as the computer drawings started it was like all the payout amounts went down to under 10'000 dollars for each drawing! It seems to me that someone knows what numbers are being played. Computers can be controlled!

TIM's picture

i agree with you

i agree with you totally........if you go to other lottery websites such as kentucky you will notice they're payout amount daily .......versus tennessee's payout .....we are being screwed there will be more winnings and a bigger payout on a single number once they go back the the balls

Joe328's picture

Computer can be programed.

I have no problem with a computer selecting numbers for tickets, but not the actual drawing. Computers selecting the winning numbers sounded like a scam from the start. Ping pong balls can't be programed and are not that difficult to operate.

Anonymous's picture

balls can be rigged

It would seem to me that it would be just as easy to rig the balls as it would be the computer. I recently watched the video on the lottery's website showing how the computer works. It says that information can only go out and not in. I also heard someone make a good point the other day. They said the lottery gets paid when the sale is made, they do not collect the non-winning amount. With that being said the lottery would do better if more people play, and we all know more people play when themselves or others are winning. After hearing all this information it would seem like if the lottery corp were to ever rig the system they would rig it for more people to win.... just a thought.

Anonymous's picture

ball cant be rigged ?

it quit easy to have preselected balls hidden under the table behind the curtain and lifted up while all the others just keep on spinning. if the auditors took their job seriously, they would show the balls in order before loading into the machine and then flush them into a tube after the game for all to see. can the balls be rigged ? if people are involved, you bet !

To Rig or Not to Rig's picture

It's easy to rig a home game, why not

Every poker player knows that the game is not about skill but 90% luck, and 10% manipulation of luck through cheating. That's considered skill in all poker, especially no limit Texas Hold'Em.

The lottery is no different, but just the house is controlled by different shysters. Why is Vegas switching to computerized poker rooms with no human dealers? Because controlling a computer is far easier than controlling many people. Everyone knows the shuffle machines at all poker rooms can be controlled with radio transmitters that can arrange the cards any which way for any hand. The lottery is a lot easier to control than a poker hand dealt to 9 or 10 players, with a seemingly genuine cut by the dealer to make it look random.

The lottery balls, whether by computer or solid balls, are easy to control in a controlled environment designed to look random. Everyone who's been to a carnival knows that the point to making anything look fair is to hide the fact that it is not even close to fair or random. If you've ever been the house or the one choosing winners to lotteries, you will know a hundred and one ways to rig the outcome to let only those you want to win, win. This is true for every lottery exceeding $10,000 in value that human nature will constantly find ways to outrig each other's fixed jackpot system.

Magnets, weights, air pressure, radio control, false bottoms, mirrors -- these are but a handful of the modern magician's bag of tricks. Ever notice that most lotteries are won in rural areas even though most tickets are bought in the city? That makes a nice annual report for the lottery commission.

Tamara Shepherd's picture

Retention rates among HOPE Access Grant recipients?

Since someone's dredged up this year-old thread on the HOPE Lottery Scholarship, I'll share a question/concern I had just recently...

I became aware this past summer of the qualifying criteria for the HOPE Access Grant, a lottery program expansion made in 2004.

Freshmen with only a 2.75 *weighted* high school GPA and an ACT score as low as 18 qualify for this 1-year non-renewable grant of $2,750 to attend a 4-year school or $1,750 to attend a 2-year school. Their families must have a household income of $36,000 or less.

In their sophomore years and beyond, HOPE Access Grant recipients must apply for the regular HOPE Lottery Scholarship and meet that renewal criterion, namely a 3.0 GPA in college coursework.

As it affects scholarship retention rates, I'm curious to know the incidence of HOPE Access Grant recipients actually *raising* their GPAs to 3.0 or higher in their first year of college.

I would expect to find that HOPE Access Grant recipients have a greater tendency to lose their funding than even students narrowly qualifying for the regular HOPE lottery scholarship in their freshman year.

Shouldn't the qualifying criteria for the HOPE Access Grant be stiffer? Is this lottery program a "black hole" of particular concern, you think? What colleges even admit a student with an 18 on his/her ACT (I know Pellissippi locally doesn't)?

Details here: (link...)

TIM's picture

THE TRUTH OF THE MATTER

This is an email i sent to the Tennessee Lottery .......

I'm writing in regards of how this lottery drawing is being conducted. I play Lottery on a daily basis and have been for quite some time now. I've noticed that the generated computer has been changing 1 number on a regular basis and that doesn't appear to be a coincidence. However I realize that a computer can be programmed to do exactly what one wants it to do. My most important question is will Tennessee ever return to the live drawings in which the balls are in play (or) place with human involvement . I've also noticed Tennessee has been the lowest payout state on a single number. In regards to this email I would appreciate some feedback in hopes of seeing some changes in how Tennessee's lottery is being conducted.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives