Fri
Feb 23 2007
01:09 pm
Stacey X in the House: No lottery for the needy
By: R. Neal

Stacey X has introduced legislation that would prohibit anyone receiving public assistance of any kind from collecting lottery prizes (PDF format). Do lottery prizes include scholarships?

Topics:
Number9's picture

Doesn't stand a chance...

Submitted by Number9 on Fri, 2007/02/23 - 1:54pm.

From the Bill:

No Families First, food stamp, WIC, TennCare or other such recipient who receives state or federal economic or medical assistance due to indigency shall be entitled to collect a lottery prize.

Breathtakingly unconstitutional.

CE Petro's picture

Nightmare

Submitted by CE Petro on Fri, 2007/02/23 - 5:30pm.

This doesn't stand a chance...it would be an absolute nightmare. Lottery retailers would have to ask if each and every person that win's $1+ if they are on public assistance. I imagine lottery retailers will shoot this down pretty fast.

DHS already requires notification of winnings of $600 or more. And the lottery requires ID to collect winnings of $600 or more. Draw your own conclusions.

Tamara Shepherd's picture

Applicable in California

Submitted by Tamara Shepherd on Fri, 2007/02/23 - 9:21pm.

Actually, California enacted their state lottery sometime during the years I lived there (summer 1981 to summer 1987), and this *was* their state law. They also forbade any incarcerated persons from winning. I distinctly remember, because California's first *two* jackpot winners were unable to collect!

Dunno if their law was ever struck down...

CE Petro's picture

How Was This Enforced?

Submitted by CE Petro on Sat, 2007/02/24 - 9:37am.

Tamara, I can understand enforcing the collectability of large prizes, but when the large portion of prizes are under $100, how does that become enforcable?

Tamara Shepherd's picture

Dunno...

Submitted by Tamara Shepherd on Sat, 2007/02/24 - 9:58am.

Since I never once played California's (or Tennessee's) lottery, I really don't know, Petro. I agree that it sounds awfully bothersome to retail clerks. Randy, maybe California's law and Campfield's bill both apply just to these jackpot prizes?

But unconstitutional? Isn't it comparable to food stamp recipients being unable to purchase beer and cigarettes (with their food stamps) at the grocery store?

FYI, the same year TN enacted the lottery, I was tracking a companion bill that would have made one semester of Personal Financial Management mandatory in our high schools. It failed. *There* was the Big Gov legislation I could have supported...

LadyVols's picture

food stamp, WIC, TennCare or

Submitted by LadyVols on Fri, 2007/02/23 - 3:17pm.

food stamp, WIC, TennCare or other such recipient"

These are the people who play it and the ones who IT takes the most money from. All the studies show the POOR are robbed by this thing and the rich get the "school" money.

talidapali's picture

IMNSHO...

Submitted by talidapali on Fri, 2007/02/23 - 4:20pm.

seems to me Stacey X sure likes to screw poor people over coming and going...

Maybe he should just say it out loud..."Well, if they have no bread, then let them eat cake..."

SmileyCentral.com

"You can't fix stupid..." ~ Ron White"

"I never said I wasn't a brat..." ~ Talidapali

Up Goose Creek's picture

lottery

Submitted by Up Goose Creek on Sat, 2007/02/24 - 10:40am.

My first reaction is to support any bill that would discourage poor folks from throwing away money on the lottery. But I see where this is ridiculous. Besides, the welfare recipient would sell their ticket to a middleman. Add that to the fees from predatory businesses and it becomes even harder to climb out of poverty.

I agree with Tamara that personal financial management should be mandatory in our schools.

____________________________________
Less is the new More - Karrie Jacobs

R. Neal's picture

I agree with Tamara that

Submitted by R. Neal on Sat, 2007/02/24 - 10:52am.

I agree with Tamara that personal financial management should be mandatory in our schools.

Yeah. Where's that bill?

Tamara Shepherd's picture

Fin mgmt bill

Submitted by Tamara Shepherd on Sat, 2007/02/24 - 3:10pm.

That was back in '02, Randy. Dunno if anything comparable has been introduced since. Might be that the process would need to be started all over again.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Upcoming events:

View all

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives