Sun
Aug 5 2007
05:42 pm

One thing I've found annoying in my two months of living in Maryville is the propensity of drivers to fail to follow through on left-hand turns when a light turns red. Everywhere else I've lived - rural Michigan, Chicago, northern Virginia - when you plan to make a left turn at a light, you go out into the intersection and when the traffic is clear you complete your turn (this is if you don't have a left-turn arrow). Sometimes oncoming cars are beating the yellow so you have to wait until they are through before you complete your turn, even if that means following through on a red. I've seen this done in front of police officers multiple times and I've never seen anyone get pulled over for it. From what I understand, you are legally allowed to complete the left turn if you've begun it under green or yellow, even if the light has just turned right. You just cannot ENTER the intersection after the light is red.

Well, I've seen cars just sit there at the light all over Maryville instead of completing the turn. Sometimes it's downright dangerous to sit there, like when cars on US321 South fail to complete the left turn onto Broadway and find themselves stuck in the middle of traffic (there's an upcoming hilltop but by the time the light turns red, it's obvious that no more cars are coming over the hill.) What gives here? Why don't people follow through in their left turns? Very few intersections have red-light cameras - none in Maryville. Is the law different in Tennessee? Or are drivers just excessively timid?

Topics:
talidapali's picture

left turns...

Some cops will ticket you if you pull up into the intersection, wait, and complete a left turn after the light has turned red. Some folks will jump the green light for the cross street and flatten you. Some folks are too sacred to make the turn. Some intersections have redlight cameras and, if you are in the intersection when the light turns red for you, you get a nice fat ticket in the mail with a lovely mugshot of your car and license plate.

SmileyCentral.com

_________________________________________________
"You can't fix stupid..." ~ Ron White"
"I never said I wasn't a brat..." ~ Talidapali

Elrod's picture

Delayed green

I don't see how you can get hit on cross traffic starting at the green because the green light is delayed about 5 seconds.

The weirdest thing is when drivers actually pull into the intersection - past the white line - and then stall there after the red, thereby blocking cross traffic. That seems most dangerous.

Joe328's picture

Left turn

Apparently you have never been behind me at a left turn. I move to the middle of the intersection and turn left on red, including redflex camera intersection. Never had a ticket for this in 38 years of driving in the Knoxville area. I do stop short of white line marking the intersection, check for pedestrians, and traffic before making a right on red. Please, be careful in Maryville, some traffic lights have a trailing green for oncoming traffic.

Joe328's picture

Trailing Green

Elrod, I am not sure if your question is for my post. Trailing green is when oncoming traffic continues with green and usually a left turn signal after you get the red signal. The only one I can recall is on US 411, south of Maryville, near Subway. North bound US 411 will indicate red, while south bound US 411 will continue with green and added left turn signal. Maryville is bit slow on compliance with Uniform Traffic Code.

Stan G's picture

Elrod

Joe328 is talking about the intersection of Sandy Springs Road with West Broadway Avenue. Heed his advice. The cycle starts by allowing south only traffic with a left hand turn signal, then goes to green in both directions with no left hand signal, and then it returns to south only traffic with a left hand turn before going to red in both directions. If you are north bound and pull into the intersection to turn left on yellow to access the Food Lion Shopping Center or the package store, you'll find an eighteen wheeler in you passenger seat.

Elrod's picture

Nope

I wasn't talking about that intersection, which sounds horribly designed. I'm talking mostly of the Broadway/321 intersection near City Hall.

Also, the Washington Street/321 intersection is bizarre. Why don't they just put a blinker in there for 321N. Making a right turn on red from the left lane is permitted - and weird. Lots of tourists stop there indefinitely (understandably) and get honked at.

Mello's picture

Pet peeve

Elrod, you are not alone. We were taught to pull into the intersection and wait until traffic clears to turn. The other half screams at the Maryville drivers who won't complete the turn. There are multiple intersections around here that you will never get through if you don't.

Have you had the chance yet to become familiar with the create your own right hand turn lane concept? No, I am not talking about the creative use of the center turn lane as an entrance ramp. I mean the cross the solid white line and leave the road and drive for 100's of yards on the berm before the turn type of creative driving....

Carole Borges's picture

I do it like you do Elrod

Though I have to admit I always feel a bit uncertain that it okay here in TN. That's the way I was taught. If you don't pull up and then complete the turn, you end up fouling up the traffic when the light changes.

Maybe someone can help me out on this problem. Sometimes I feel confused if there is a turn signal. If the turn signal is off, does that mean you can't turn, even if there is no traffic coming toward you in the opposite lane?

Stan G's picture

Elrod

I understand that you were not talking about that particular intersection. My comment and Joe328's were offered as a little friendly advice from those who have attempted left-hand turns on yellow as you suggest only to be surprised by on coming traffic.

Mello,

Don't believe that I seen many folks travel for 100's of yards on the shoulder although I am not doubting that some do. I find the shoulder useful as a short deceleration lane when turning right from a section of road where the speed limit is 50 mph.

Not sure where you live, but in my part of the country the shoulder is used as a passing land when cars have stopped waiting to make a left-hand turn. It helps to keep those of us who walk along the shoulder awake and agile.

Stan G's picture

Carole

While I'm still here, I go on the assumption that left-turns are permitted at those intersections where there is neither a sign nor a red arrow indicating that a turn is not permitted.

Elrod's picture

Chicago

Nowhere do they "complete the left turn" more aggressively than in Chicago. But that's because there are very few left-turn arrows, so without the aggressive yellow light left, you'd never turn left at all.

Carole Borges's picture

Chicago driving

Chicago is my hometown and I can say without qualification it has to be the most corrupt police department in the nation. Paying off policemen was not only possible, it was expected. The city had a 3-moving-violations-and-we-snatch your-driver's-license rule. The way the cops set it up (and they had like one police car per block), it was impossible not to get two tickets right away. These you usually paid, but when the officer wrote you the third ticket, you were supposed to slip him a discrete bribe when you handed him your license and registration. Almost everyone who had been driving for any length of time and also any outsiders who had moved there and who were used to seeing only an occasional cop on the road had two violations. Everyone drove with the knowledge they were vulnerable to the bribery system.

My landlord Angelo was a cop. This guy had to pay quite a bit of money to get on the force because he was too short, too dumb, and too nervous to be accepted on his own. Even with someone fudging his grade he still failed the exam twice. Evetually, he was told by the tough guys that if he didn't get more answers right on the third exam the deal was off.

One day Angelo told me he had taken a watermelon for a bribe. He felt kind of ashamed for doing it, but that it was a very kind thing to do as the old "nigger" he'd stopped didn't have any cash. He also told me about beating up guys who were handcuffed and how the rule was to never act like it was upsetting to you. A few years after he was on the force, he wanted to make sargeant, but he simply couldn't afford to pay the steep bribery fee that would move him up.

I found this guy beyond appalling, but he was my landlord and affordable apartments weren't easy to find. I was young and naive in the 1960s, so I never said anything to him. I just listened and hated him.

It was a huge relief when I moved to Boston, a city which thrives on automotive anarchy. In Boston, drivers often "choose" which lights to stop at; they park almost anywhere and sometimes leave their cars running; and the speed limit is seen as more of a "suggestion" than a real law. Driving in Boston is crazy, but it keeps you alert, teaches you to be cooperative with other drivers, and often makes practical sense. In rural areas if you stop at a stop sign and no one is coming in any direction, you'd better not sit there or the person behind you will pull around you with a sneer, toss you the finger and move on. I've always considered it much more challenging than driving in NY city.

I love Chicago, but not the police force. I'll take Boston driving anytime.

Socialist With A Gold Card's picture

What the state says

According to the Tennessee Drivers' Handbook (warning: big-ass PDF), proceeding into an intersection and just sitting there before you have clearance to complete the turn could get you a ticket. Page 60 of the PDF says:

You should not enter an intersection unless you can get through it without having to stop. You should wait until traffic in front of you clears so that you are not blocking the intersection. If your vehicle is left blocking an intersection (with or without a traffic signal) it prevents other traffic from proceeding and you could be ticketed for this type of action.

--Socialist With A Gold Card


"I'm a socialist with a gold card. I firmly believe we need a revolution; I'm just concerned that I won't be able to get good moisturizer afterwards." -- Brett Butler

Elrod's picture

Not really

The blurb you cite doesn't say you can't go into the intersection. It says you cannot camp out there and block other traffic. Of course it's best not to enter an intersection unless you can complete the turn in one motion. But it only says you can get ticketed for blocking oncoming or side traffic. And I've seen many cars do just that: go out into the intersection and then stop, and never complete the turn even after the light turns red. Then they're stuck out there blocking traffic, especially for cars from the right trying to make a left turn.

bizgrrl's picture

TDH says, "You should not

TDH says, "You should not enter an intersection unless you can get through it without having to stop."

Elrod says, "when you plan to make a left turn at a light, you go out into the intersection and when the traffic is clear you complete your turn..."

Now, Elrod, it doesn't really make sense that you think you should be able to go out into the intersection and "wait" for the opportunity to run the red light.

I have done what you describe many times. I too have done it in several states. I also, though, don't see any problem with not doing it. There are very few intersections that require running a red light to get where you are going. If I felt running a red light was necessary, I would drive a different route.

smalc's picture

I'm glad someone called him

I'm glad someone called him on this. I don't think you should pull into an intersection at all. Don't cross the line unless you can go through, so says the law and me. :)

Joe328's picture

TCA 58-8-129 Left turn at intersection

TCA 58-8-129 titled "Left Turn at Intersection", makes no reference about stopping in the intersection.

Mello's picture

what law?

Here is 55-8-129 The driver of a vehicle within an intersection intending to turn to the left shall yield the right-of-way to any vehicle approaching from the opposite direction which is within the intersection or so close thereto as to constitute an immediate hazard, but the driver, having so yielded and having given a signal when and as required by this chapter, may make such left turn, and the drivers of all other vehicles approaching the intersection from the opposite direction shall yield the right-of-way to the vehicle making the left turn

Joe328's picture

Left turn OK?

Sorry about the typo on the code reference. Now that you have the correct code posted, is the left turn legal?

Stan G's picture

...and the drivers of all

...and the drivers of all other vehicles approaching the intersection from the opposite direction shall yield the right-of-way to the vehicle making the left turn

Right, you know the person approaching from the other direction who is planning to run the yellow light is going to yield because of TCA 55-8-129. And you know the officer is going to cite the other driver for failing to yield. And you are looking forward to a visit from The Great Pumpkin.

The one good thing about being pessimistic is - at least it shows you understand the situation. -- Unknown

KC's picture

This isn't New York or Boston

Or, in other words, just because they do it somewhere else, doesn't mean you should do it here.

Use common sense, don't run red lights. If someone's trying to turn left in front of me, I'll slow down if I can to give them a break so he/she can turn. Some other drivers won't and will probably be lining you up in their crosshairs if they think you're trying to turn in front of them. I'll go to lights that have turn signals and backtrack, just to be safe, if the light, and the intersection, without a turn signal is particularly dangerous where on coming traffic approaches at Mach 1.

Most of all, use common sense, be patient (so you don't wind up one), and be careful out there.

Carole Borges's picture

I like the advice that says

"Don't be dead right." I always use my own judgement in place of blind obedience to signs. I am a defensive driver. I try to stay alert at all times to the holistic situtation. I don't depend on pthers to always obey the law, and yes patience is important to safety. Courtesy too.

Carole Borges's picture

Sorry for the double post... I twitched and it sent

"Don't be dead right." I always use my own judgement in place of blind obedience to signs. I am a defensive driver. I try to stay alert at all times to the holistic situtation. I don't depend on others to always obey the law, and yes patience is important to safety. Courtesy too.

redmondkr's picture

I'll go to lights that have

I'll go to lights that have turn signals and backtrack, just to be safe......

I frequently go a good bit out of my way to avoid problem intersections. Being "from around here" I use a lot of back roads to get from here to there. Being retired helps, too, since I am rarely in a hurry to get there.

I have often thought that traffic laws are nothing but codified common courtesy, something of a rarity nowadays.

I have also noticed that the size of your vehicle has a bearing on driver courtesy. More drivers tend to "take liberties" with me when I am on my motorcycle than they do when I am in my F150 pickup. The experience in my Honda sedan is somewhere in between.


Visit us at

Wearybottom Associates

R. Neal's picture

Priuses (Prii?) apparently

Priuses (Prii?) apparently rank about the same as motorcycles on the automotive food chain.

In fact, there's open hostility sometimes. It's quite bizarre. And I don't even have an Al Gore bumper sticker, or any other kind of bumper stickers.

I'm going to get one of those big-ass air horns like diesel tractor trailers use. (Is that legal?)

bizgrrl's picture

I'm going to get one of

I'm going to get one of those big-ass air horns like diesel tractor trailers use. (Is that legal?)

I don't know about a big-ass air horn, but we could definitely use a better horn than the candy-ass horn the car has now.

R. Neal's picture

Yeah, it's so European it

Yeah, it's so European it sounds French!

redmondkr's picture

I almost included my rant

I almost included my rant about big rig drivers in that comment but I'm only half way through my first cuppa coffee.

When you bought the Prius, I was really jealous until I thought about the perils of driving a small, efficient vehicle.


Visit us at

Wearybottom Associates

Joe328's picture

Running a red light?

Use common sense, don't run a red light.

The question is, are you running a red light? If a vehicle is in the intersection when the light turns red, its legal to continue. Its also safe since cross traffic has a delayed green of five seconds. It is illegal and dangerous to backup, just to clear the intersection. I see drivers who will not enter the intersection for a left turn on red, but will turn left as soon as the light turns green into oncoming traffic, without a signal. Searching for a traffic light with a left signal is just not practical, its also time consuming and polluting.

Some drivers, myself included, may make unsafe decision, thinking it was the safest move. "If common sense was that common, more people would have it (author unknown)."

Virgil Proudfoot's picture

The basic problem

I always figured the real problem was that East Tennesseans need to pause for a moment of prayer and study before attempting anything rash, like moving their vehicles when the light turns red.

Paul Witt's picture

I'm with you on this one

I'm with you on this one Elrod. It took me a while to get used to this and other traffic oddities after moving down from Ohio.

Mello's picture

Good* Tennessee Driving

There are some real problem intersections here in Blount County and yes, this which I am now writing should probably be over on Blountviews instead of here....

I never said I pull out in the intersection to turn. I hate doing it and I try to avoid places where it really needs to be done to make a left turn. Far too often I find I must pull into the intersection to turn because my car is low and when there is a line of Hummers and SUVs directly ahead in the opposite left turn lane- I can not freaking see around them to make sure the lane is clear so that I may make the turn at all.

We have a student driver in our house so I ask him what the handbook says. It simply says Do Not Block Intersection. Ok, don't block it. I take that to mean if I am in the intersection turning and the light turns red I don't stay there, I get the heck out of the intersection when the road is clear. Easy!

I am sure by now Elrod and our friends who bleed scarlet and gray have seen a few other unique features down here.

The No, you go first! No YOU go first! action that can occur at any four way stop. While I don't get upset when this happens at stop signs it completly freaks me out when I am pulling into the center of 321 and the guy who is actually traveling on 321 and wants to turn into the road I am leaving does this.

The student driver converstation in our car when this happens-

Ok, who has the right of way, you or him?

He does, I have a stop sign and he is in the road already.

Good. Now he is waving us on to come out infront of him. What do we do now?

We wave, yell and point to TCA that shows him he is the only one with right of way and if I pull out and he changes his mind and hits me- we get the ticket.

Correct!

While it is not so much of a problem out here on 321 W, it is a huge problem for drivers who are leaving Topside Rd and want to turn north on Alcoa highway. Talk about taking your life in your own hands. Drivers leaving Topside Road turning north do not seem to understand that they never have right of way and pull right out in front of cars trying to turn from the north bound Alcoa onto Topside.

Chance are good when you see an Alcoa City Officer with a car pulled over out there someone as has done just that.

Mello's picture

Sympathetic turnsignals

Now- this is one thing I miss about Old Tennessee... no one around here seems to do this any more...

Carole Borges's picture

What are sympathetic turn signals?

That term has had my mind rumbling around for a few days now.

KC's picture

There's a joke

There's a joke I've heard about Knoxville drivers, and living here for nearly 43 years, I know there's a lot of truth in it.

"When car makers first began thinking about moving the dimmer switch for headlights from the button on the floor to the lever on the steering wheel, they decided to experiment on cars being driven in Knoxville.

At first they weren't sure if moving the switch would work, because Knoxville drivers kept getting their feet hung up in the steering wheel."

The Dude's picture

When the intersection at the

When the intersection at the new Maryville Building/Blockbuster went "left turn on green no arrow", I could have cried. And yes, there are guys that seem to get off by speeding up, or even slowing down, as you are trying to turn left. Very annoying.

Elrod's picture

Timidity

I actually don't think drivers around here are overly timid or "too friendly." Considering the number of cops out there, drivers go at a reasonably brisk pace on 321 toward Townsend, for example. On backroads drivers rarely clog up the roadway going under the speed limit. In Michigan I found drivers to be much more timid, even to the point of danger. On interstates drivers would go slow in the left lane and clog up traffic, which would inevitably make it less safe. The only thing they did better up there was drive in snow.

All of this is why I was curious about the left-turn issue. This ain't Chicago or New York, but it's more aggressive than rural Michigan. So why the reticence with left-turns at intersections? And I'm talking about intersections where it's safe to follow through with the turn as the light turns red. It would make sense in Michigan, but not here.

bizgrrl's picture

Sympathetic turn

Sympathetic turn signal...

As I recall from a previous explanation, it is when someone in front of you is turning and you use your turn signal to let those behind you know someone is turning, it is not necessarily you that is turning but someone ahead.

Mello's picture

correct! Sympathetic turnsignals

And something that only happens in the Old part of East Tennessee...

Elrod- like most things in life, it is simply that the folks who learned to drive here were never taught the pull up and take command of the intersection technique. Much like some were taught to toss their beer cans out the window and leave unwanted dogs on rural county roads. See Blountviews on that...

smalc's picture

On the subject of TN traffic

On the subject of TN traffic customs...

Some have the custom for oncoming traffic to pull to the side of the road when meeting a funeral procession.

I can vaguely remember the law being changed several years back to make this illegal, in response to a fatal accident. Am I remembering correctly? I just looked at the driver's manual online and it says nothing about it being illegal, and in fact calls it a "common and accepted practice."

I personally think it is a hazard to do so and can't see how it shows respect. You can show respect if the procession is in your direction or at intersections.

redmondkr's picture

Some have the custom for

Some have the custom for oncoming traffic to pull to the side of the road when meeting a funeral procession.

In 1991, I went to the funeral of a friend in Clinton. Burial was at Bookwalter just north of Sharp's Gap in Knoxville. The procession was a lengthy one along Clinton Highway with traffic passing us in the inside lane. Just inside Knox County a big rig driver pulled alongside the rearmost car and remained there until we exited the highway at Tillery.


Visit us at

Wearybottom Associates

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives