It was pretty easy to miss the news coverage of Tennessee’s biggest piece of “education reform” legislation in nearly 20 years.
Tennessee’s Race to the Top application was due on Tuesday, January 19, 2010.
On Monday, January 11—just eight days before the application deadline—Governor Bredesen called a special session of the legislature to introduce, explain, and seek passage of his First to the Top Act of 2010, which he said would pave the way to a successful grant application.
However, legislators were never permitted to review the Race to the Top application to which the First to the Top Act of 2010 referred.
On-lookers were even more in the dark. During the five day period in which legislators were considering the Act (in a vacuum), the News-Sentinel ran only three news stories on two days—and one of those, just two paragraphs by Tom Humphrey, carried an inoperable link to the remainder of the news story.
Neither did the News-Sentinel provide any link to the text of the Act itself.
Here’s what we got:
continued...
Monday, January 11, 2010: “Special session legislation questions not instantly answered.”
Two paragraphs and an inoperable link?
Monday, January 11, 2010: “Bills for schools draw scrutiny.”
Excerpts:
"I think everything we hear raises another set of questions," Rep. Harry Tindell, D-Knoxville, said at one point in a briefing for representatives. Multiple questions were also raised at a similar hearing for senators.
"It kind of puts us in a precarious situation of wondering what we're building and buying here," he said.
Another provision gives the state authority to contract for consultants to operate a failing school system, which one lawmaker said "sounds to me a little like corporate takeover of schools."
Specifics will be included in the state's application, which is still being drafted, (Education Commissioner Tim Webb) said. Officials said the administration is reluctant to give too many specifics, concerned that other states will use the information to advance their own applications.
In the Senate hearing, Knoxville Republican Sens. Tim Burchett and Jamie Woodson both said they would like elaboration. Webb said he would offer more explanation later in the week.
Wednesday, January 13, 2010: “TEA drops opposition to Race to the Top.”
At times the debate was notably intense.
For example, Rep. Les Winningham, D-Huntsville, complained at one point that the bill raised the possibility of "selling out to the federal government."
He and others also said the administration needs to provide legislators with a copy of the application to be filed with the federal government giving plans for use of money received. Officials contend that releasing the application details could hurt the state's chances by revealing plans to other states competing for the money.
"There just a real fear out there that the data is going to be used against teachers," (TEA President Earl H. Wiman) told the Senate committee, adding that he hopes the Legislature will subsequently consider legislation to address "student accountability and parental responsibility."
The bill would allow the state to contract with private entities or nonprofits for operation of failing schools.
Then, after the fact:
Saturday, January 16, 2010: “Education measure passes with ease.”
This is how the state’s website (innocuously) characterized the Act.
But here is the actual text of the Act.
"Extraordinary session," indeed.
|
|
Discussing:
- Bernie Sanders vs AI (1 reply)
- SoKno discombobulation continues (2 replies)
- Execution failed!!! (3 replies)
- GOP Senator "deserves the obloquy" (2 replies)
- AI company going public says "existential risks to humanity" (2 replies)
- Michaela Barnett for Congress TN-02 (2 replies)
- Timing is everything (2 replies)
- Presidential protest? Deja vu? (3 replies)
- Republican midterm strategy 2026 (2 replies)
- Kerbela Development: Understanding the Appeal and What Happens Next (1 reply)
- 865 Neyland Entertainment District announcement (3 replies)
- Federal court rules Constitution doesn't guarantee clean water (2 replies)
TN Progressive
- View from the Overlook (Whitescreek Journal)
- Alcoa property taxes will probably not go up (BlountViews)
- Smith & Wesson not a good fit for Blount County (BlountViews)
- Pellissippi Parkway extension delayed again (BlountViews)
- Blount County early voting record turnout (BlountViews)
- WATCH THIS SPACE. (Left Wing Cracker)
- America As It Is Right Now (RoaneViews)
- A friend sent this: From Captain McElwee's Tall Tales of Roane County (RoaneViews)
- The Meidas Touch (RoaneViews)
- Massive Security Breach Analysis (RoaneViews)
- (Whitescreek Journal)
- My choices in the August election (Left Wing Cracker)
TN Politics
- Trump’s DOJ demands California halt ballots to suspected noncitizens (TN Lookout)
- Nashville airport announces nonstop Air France flight (TN Lookout)
- John Cole’s Tennessee: Security blanket (TN Lookout)
- Social Security benefits increase will hit 3.6% in 2027 (TN Lookout)
- Tennessee GOP senator seeks one-month gas tax break (TN Lookout)
- Tennessee puts constitutional amendment questions near top of the ballot next to governor’s race (TN Lookout)
Knox TN Today
- Let’s Talk: Schools — Students build skills, serve veterans and find new opportunities plus more (Knox TN Today)
- Tennessee and Alabama, then to now (Knox TN Today)
- The Book Whisperer & daughter go book store hopping (Knox TN Today)
- Daily Connections for Wednesday, October 14, 2026 (Knox TN Today)
- Knoxville high school sports roundup: Volleyball crowns champions as golf season reaches finish line (Knox TN Today)
- Mama Said: Home is where the heart is (Knox TN Today)
- The Big Takeaways— Grace Christian 50, Sevier County 48 (Knox TN Today)
- Young Reader’s Shelf: From fall fields to winter courts, sports stories inspire young readers (Knox TN Today)
- Youth Scoop: Halloween crafts, zoo adventures and family fun (Knox TN Today)
- Pellissippi State research shows library instruction improves student success (Knox TN Today)
- Desperado? Part 2 (Knox TN Today)
- He vanished into thin air (Knox TN Today)
Local TV News
- Knox County zoning official could face removal after alleged assault outside Heritage Hubs event (WATE)
- Descendants, advocates fight to preserve historic Sevier County cemetery from proposed development (WATE)
- Does a poll worker marking your ballot disqualify it? Sec. of State debunks rumor (WATE)
- Knoxville woman charged for home security system despite cancellation (WATE)
- Free burn permits required in Tennessee starting Oct. 15 to prevent wildfires (WATE)
- From classroom to lab: New fellowship gives students hands-on AI research opportunities at Oak Ridge National Lab (WATE)
News Sentinel
State News
- Pasquali’s Pix: Tide to prevail in Neyland for first time since 2020 - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Record highs set Tuesday, Wednesday and forecast for Thursday - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Trial and error best method for data centers? - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- For the first time, a potentially habitable rocky planet shows signs of an atmosphere - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
Wire Reports
- Nasdaq ends sharply lower as hot inflation data stirs rate-hike worries - Reuters (Business)
- Sexual assault reported at frat house near University of Chicago - The Guardian (US News)
- Golden Corral says locations are closing. Here's what we know - USA Today (Business)
- Roller coaster rider’s death puts spotlight on the safety of ever more thrilling rides - AP News (US News)
- Florida man arrested on murder charge in ex-fiancée's 2011 disappearance - CBS News (US News)
- Ilhan Omar Investigation Aims to Build Case for Stripping Her Citizenship - WSJ (US News)
- Corruption Trial Begins for Former Oakland Mayor Sheng Thao and City Contractors - The New York Times (US News)
- Anthropic revenue jumps to $16.8bn in third quarter - Financial Times (Business)
- Ukraine's Starlink restrictions raise suspicions of Musk, Trump retaliation - Axios (US News)
- Netflix TV Executives Lisa Lang McMullen, James Oh, Carolina Garcia and Andrew McQuinn Among Layoffs - The Hollywood Reporter (Business)
- 'Yikes': CoreWeave stock tanks on bond yield woes, CEO blames market acting 'irrationally' - Yahoo Finance (Business)
- Trump says Taiwan will buy Alaska LNG. The project is still in flux. - Politico (US News)
- Bank of America hired 1,000 contractors to patch software flaws exposed by Anthropic's Mythos - CNBC (Business)
- Apple retakes $5 trillion market cap, only second company to eclipse milestone number - Yahoo Finance (Business)
- Toilet paper and secret recorders: What we know about the arrest of the Saudi OpenAI engineer - BBC (Business)
Local Media
Lost Medicaid Funding
Search and Archives
TN Progressive
Nearby:
- Blount Dems
- Herston TN Family Law
- Inside of Knoxville
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jim Stovall
- Knox Dems
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Outdoor Knoxville
- Pittman Properties
- Reality Me
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
Beyond:
- Nashville Scene
- Nashville Post
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Journal
- TN Lookout
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South

Final vote
I neglected to reference the final vote on the Act, reported in that last story, here:
Thanks for the recap. I admit
Thanks for the recap. I admit to not paying much attention to this at all while it was going on. At the time, I suspected the rush was to cash in on the $billions in free federal funding, and I think everyone had their eye on that prize and not the unintended (or intended) consequences. The moral of the story is we need to always look the gift horse in the mouth.
I missed a single news story
In reviewing those 14 month-old news stories at KNS, I found my own comment on just the first Monday, January 11 story (with the inoperable link), in which I reported to KNS that I couldn't read the story.
Since I don't see that I made any comment on the second news story having run that Monday, I guess I looked at the newspaper just once that day, earlier.
I don't see that I commented on the Wednesday, January 13 story at all, which probably means I missed it.
And by the time that Saturday, January 16 story ran it was a done deal, of course.
I missed a single news story that Wednesday, reporting the most important "education reform" measure Tennessee was considering in nearly 20 years--so, like everyone else, I was left in the dark until its provisions began to take effect.
Susan Bodary
I note in that second story that Tom Humphrey doesn't appear to realize this Susan Bodary was the paid consultant who drafted Tennessee's RttT application. All he wrote was:
However, Bodary's employer, Bill Gates grantee Education First Consulting, acknowledges her paid consultant status at their website, as follows:
And as to Gates' own role in drafting our app, I'll again link Joanne Barken's Winter 2011 article in Dissent magazine, "Got Dough? How Billionaires Rule Our Schools," in which Barken outlines Gates' fervid interest in picking some "education reform" winners, thusly:
I'm still just "buffoned" that we, Humphrey, KNS, legislators even, seemed to understand scarce little about the implications of the Act--until now.
bingo-
Jan 11, 2010 the plan is still being drafted.
Those letters of support are dated from Nov 20, 2009 to Jan 16. Pretty damn amazing all the astroturf support letters Bredesen was able to churn out when no one saw the plan.
When did TEA sign? Was it after the bill was passed? I am not seeing it in either the application or appendix.
TEA letter dated after vote on Act
I looked it up last night: The Act was passed Friday, January 15 and the TEA letter of support is dated Saturday, January 16--just in time for the grant application deadline of Tuesday, January 19.
The TEA letter is the very first one in the appendix containing letters of support.
See pdf page 27 of 185, here.
TEA's letter
TEA signed on to the four bullet points. Ok. And they did note the following-
.
Student acheivement to carry 50 percent or 35 percent weight?
I was confused by an October 2010 news story on the Teacher Evaluation Advisory Committee's draft plan being piloted at four schools locally this year.
In it, KNS reported that "at least 50 percent of teachers’ evaluation would be based on student achievement."
Elsewhere, though, I've read only that Bredesen originally wanted student achievement to count for "at least 50 percent," but that TEA backed him down to its counting for just 35 percent before they'd offer their letter of support with the January 2010 RttT app.
So are we now talking 50 percent again because TEA subsequently agreed to this weighting, or was TEA screwed in this regard, too?