You've probably heard by now that Bill Hobbs is leaving his job at Belmont University. He hasn't said one way or another, but speculation on the internets is that it has something to do with an article in the Nashville alt-weekly about a "cartoon" he posted on some shadow blog of his. Michael Silence has the complete blog roundup.
Having also been the victim of stalking and threats by an alt-weekly, which led to an unfortunate chain of events that ended in me shutting down my previous blog after being "outed" in the mainstream daily paper (which ironically has much larger circulation than the alt-weekly that made threats but never actually carried through on them) I guess I'm obligated to have an opinion. After the jump...
It sucks.
Is Bill Hobbs an opinionated, egotistical jerk? Mostly. Is he a partisan right-wing hack who doesn't cut anybody any slack? You bet. Was his "cartoon" distasteful and borderline racist? Probably. Was posting his "cartoon" stupid and ill-advised in light of how it might reflect on his employer and the political campaign he was advocating? Most likely. Did he deserve to lose his job over it (if that is in fact what happened)? No.
I'd venture to guess that Hobbs just said what lots of Tennessee conservatives, including some folks at Belmont, were thinking but were too politically correct to say themselves. That doesn't seem fair, does it? It seems like a fellow ought to be able to have and express his own opinions outside the workplace without fear of retribution or media witch hunts and hit-pieces.
But that's not how it works in real life. Trust me on that one.
Anyway, Hobbs is probably better off. He'll find another job somewhere with an organization that respects free speech. Like maybe a less conservative, more progressive outfit. Anyway, I hope Bill Hobbs and his family will be OK. It's just blogging, folks. Pixels arranged on a screen. People take this shit way too seriously.
OK, then.
UPDATE: Lots more roundup at Nashville is Talking. Start at the top and scroll down.
|
|
Discussing:
- Sam Seder takes on 20 MAGA loving supporters (1 reply)
- TN Legislature bullying Townsend? (14 replies)
- Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth orders a halt to offensive cyber operations against Russia (2 replies)
- Right thing, wrong way (2 replies)
- A Home with South Knox Bubba (and Mrs. Bubba) (5 replies)
- ‘A disruptive effect’: How slashing staff at the Social Security Administration is sparking fears the system could collapse (4 replies)
- Vitamin A or cod liver oil are not the cure or prevention for Measles (1 reply)
- For financial security, back the Dems... (1 reply)
- Fired CFPB chief says Musk may have another goal for gutting the agency (1 reply)
- Downtown Knoxville parking requires smartphone and credit? (3 replies)
- ‘There is no question this was a setup’: Amb. Susan Rice on Trump’s Oval Office ambush of Zelesnky (5 replies)
- Tennessee's US Senators pushed worst Trump nominees (1 reply)
TN Progressive
- Ever Seen a Cover done this fine? (RoaneViews)
- Saturday Snark (set to music) (RoaneViews)
- Feel Good Friday (RoaneViews)
- Trae (RoaneViews)
- (Whitescreek Journal)
- Lee's Fried Chicken in Alcoa closed (BlountViews)
- Alcoa, Hall Rd. Corridor Study meeting, July 30, 2024 (BlountViews)
- My choices in the August election (Left Wing Cracker)
- July 4, 2024 - aka The Twilight Zone (Joe Powell)
- Chef steals food to serve at restaurant? (BlountViews)
- Blount County, TDOT make road deal for gun mfg ignoring town of Louisville,TN, (BlountViews)
- Winter at the Big Rocks (Whitescreek Journal)
TN Politics
- Medicaid recipients struggle to find mental health care. Looming cuts could make it harder. (TN Lookout)
- Lawyers for former Tennessee House Speaker: feds have evidence to discredit witnesses (TN Lookout)
- TDEC: $100M Duck River budget ask could be used toward regional Tennessee River pipeline (TN Lookout)
- Get the antacids ready as Trump administration cuts damage Tennessee (TN Lookout)
- A failure of imagination in the Tennessee Legislature (TN Lookout)
- Some U.S. Republicans are pushing to keep energy tax credits. Tennessee lawmakers aren’t among them. (TN Lookout)
Knox TN Today
- Vols fall in SEC, open NCAA against Wofford (Knox TN Today)
- NYPD to KPD: Morgan, family found their home (Knox TN Today)
- Living better longer (Knox TN Today)
- HEADLINES 3/17 (Knox TN Today)
- The magic of St. Patrick’s Day: More than just green beer (Knox TN Today)
- Food City customers donate $51K+ to Project Help (Knox TN Today)
- Covenant Health recognized as one of ‘America’s Greatest Workplaces for Women’ (Knox TN Today)
- Down goes Auburn, Vols face Florida (Knox TN Today)
- Vols top Texas, Auburn is next (Knox TN Today)
- Softball to host UConn; basketball awaits brackets (Knox TN Today)
- ‘Hummingbirds – Our Feathered Rainbows,’ a Zoom program on April 3 (Knox TN Today)
- Ijams River Rescue + Carson Dailey ++ (Knox TN Today)
Local TV News
- Claxton community shows support for 9-month-old after liver transplant (WBIR)
- MCSO: Two dead after fire in Monroe County (WATE)
- 'As the day progressed, the smoke got heavier' Cocke County resident spots Hall Top wildfire from his backyard (WATE)
- Missing North Carolina teen's truck seen near Harriman (WATE)
- Woman facing DUI charge after vehicle crashes into building (WATE)
- Morristown Police Department searching for missing 20-year-old (WATE)
- Knoxville Track Club completes longest group run three weeks ahead of marathon weekend (WATE)
- Knox Shamrock Fest offers St. Patrick's Day fun for all ages at World's Fair Park for a good cause (WBIR)
- Wednesday marks 5 years since first COVID-19 case declared in Knox County (WBIR)
- Nashville bill proposes grant fund to keep students safe as they walk to school (WBIR)
- Whataburger eyes Crossville for new location near Buc-ee's (WBIR)
- City grants Knoxville College request for 30 days to secure part of decaying campus landmark (WBIR)
News Sentinel
State News
- UTC men face Middle Tennessee in NIT; women to also play again - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Chattanooga Knows: What TV personality faced a battle with oral cancer in the 1970s? - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Vitello’s Vols now 20-0 after three-game sweep of Gators - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Chattanooga area has most hemp shops per capita in Tennessee - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
Wire Reports
- Venezuelan Families Fear for Relatives as Trump Celebrates Deportations to El Salvador - The New York Times (US News)
- Oklahomans survey devastation after hundreds of homes are destroyed and damaged by wildfires - The Associated Press (US News)
- Oil prices jump; optimism over China's consumption stimulus boosts Asia shares - Reuters (Business)
- China’s retail sales strengthen at the start of the year, industrial data tops expectations - CNBC (Business)
- Brown University Professor and Doctor Is Deported to Lebanon Despite a Judge’s Order - The New York Times (US News)
- Trump dismantles Voice of America with executive order - BBC.com (US News)
- Democratic Party’s favorability hits record low: Poll - The Hill (US News)
- What will happen to payment stocks in a recession? Bernstein takes clues from 2008 (V:NYSE) - Seeking Alpha (Business)
- As AI nurses reshape hospital care, human nurses are pushing back - The Associated Press (Business)
- Stock futures fall as Bessent dismisses market worries: ‘Corrections are healthy’ - MarketWatch (Business)
- Calera man loses home in tornado, stays with daughter in jail: Police chief says relief effort raises questio - AL.com (US News)
- Wall Street's recession odds are starting to look like a coin flip as Trump refuses to back down on his trade war - Fortune (Business)
- Stock-market bulls abandoned by Trump won’t be saved by Jerome Powell and the Fed - MarketWatch (Business)
- US shoppers cut spending as economic outlook concerns mount - Financial Times (Business)
- Severe Weather System Brings High Winds and Tornado Threat to the East Coast - The New York Times (US News)
Local Media
Lost Medicaid Funding
Search and Archives
TN Progressive
Nearby:
- Blount Dems
- Herston TN Family Law
- Inside of Knoxville
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jim Stovall
- Knox Dems
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Outdoor Knoxville
- Pittman Properties
- Reality Me
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
Beyond:
- Nashville Scene
- Nashville Post
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Journal
- TN Lookout
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South
As one who was familiar with
As one who was familiar with so many of his posts over much time at the old SKB, though NOT a reader of his blog (masochism's not my thing), I'd say Mr. Neal's comments were spot on and covered the matter as well as is warranted.
P.S. edit
"his" being Hobbs's, of course.
What Would Conservatives Do?
Hobbs is fortunate to have the support and sympathy of the entire blogging community. Imagine the situation with a progressive losing a job over, say, a Bush/Hitler cartoon. Would there be unanimous support from the right? References to First Amendment rights no matter how “wrong” the opinion?
No.
We would hear about personal responsibility and irrational hatred of Bush and America. We would hear about that American taliban, the ACLU, no doubt poised to come to the defense of the terrorist supporting, freedom hating, morally bankrupt lefty communist.
Does knowing this affect liberals’ support for Hobbs?
No.
Does Hobbs understand this and will it make him a better person, better writer, better American?
Sadly, no.
Thanks, Randy
Randy, Thanks for your post. I did a stupid thing and am paying a price for it. I'm also learning from it. I know you and I have different views on lots of issues, but I have always appreciated your willingness to engage in debate with civility.
Alt-Weeklies and Bloggers
Randy, given your collision with the Metro Pulse and mine with the Nashville Scene, I wonder if alt-weeklies feel more threatened by bloggers and related online interactive media than do the big dailies. Alt-weeklies are supposed to be fearless and willing to tackle uncomfortable subjects and challenge the establishment, but increasingly they are owned by moneyed chains that are part of the establishment, and increasingly less likely to challenge that establishment.
Grassroots-run blogs and related types of online interactive media, especially forums like the old SKB and mine, have more freedom to do the jobs the alt-weeklies claim to be doing. Perhaps they fear that.
owned by people that are part of the establishment
Alt-weeklies are supposed to be fearless and willing to tackle uncomfortable subjects and challenge the establishment, but increasingly they are owned by moneyed chains that are part of the establishment, and increasingly less likely to challenge that establishment.
Here is an example of what you just wrote about Bill. It doesn't matter who wrote it what matters is that it was published. It advocates voter disenfranchisement. But the Metro Pulse did have a article on bondage last week so I guess it is okay. According to the Metro Pulse we are supposed to bow down before the Republican/Democrat Party. They, and only they, have the wisdom and in this case the authority, to select our candidates.
(link...)
9th District, Seat A — Larry Clark is out, thankfully, and we hope the Republicans come up with a good candidate, since there is no Democrat on the August ballot.
5th District, Seat C — A vote for John Griess wisely sends the decision to the Republican Party.
4th District, Seat A — A vote for term-limited John Schmid will put the decision for an August candidate in the hands of the GOP, where it belongs in this instance.
3rd District, Seat A — Wanda Moody is term-limited out, but a vote for her in the GOP primary insures the best bet for a good August candidate.
2nd District, Seat B — Billy Tindell, who can’t succeed himself, deserves your vote, so the Democrats can pick an eligible candidate to stave off any write-ins.
So, does anyone else
picture R. Neal sitting around smoking a stogie through a long holder, a la Hunter Thompson?
I get the feeling that, were the mainstream media not so corrupt and venal, Neal woulda made a hell of a muckraker.
this stinks....
He is remarking on this post:
I think, from the very level blog coverage of Mr. Hobbs, it is fair to say there was no effort by the Democrats or liberal bloggers to silence Mr. Hobbs. InstaPundit has InstaFlipped and InstaSpinned this issue into one of left v. right, when in fact it was a Liberal blogger going after "Republican State Senator Jim Bryson’s gubernatorial capaign" and not Hobbs. And all this time I thought InstaHeh was an example of how one should go after politicians. I'm guessing things change.
InstaP did say "if", so that does help his end of the argument a little.
If Instapundit was a liberal left leaning loony, and some wonder if he really is, would we all read his blog? --more bad Monday humor.
Hobbs' Stigmata
Hobbs and his role in the "insurgent" campaign of Bryson would have gone completely unnoticed short of this action. It's not exactly something that you could conceivably call high profile even before the kerfuffle erupted (onto a sidebar on a local indie alt-weekly -- talk about your tempest in a teapot). Raising a big stink about his getting the pole-axe might have been the only way to raise his profile in that campaign, since he'd already gone into hiatus from his eponymous blog.
But, by impugning the motives of his perceived "persecutors," he gets to claim martyrdom. I guess that amounts to political capital in some circles. To me, it's shrug-worthy.
On paper, I guess I'm sorry Hobbs lost his job in this vortex, but you know, this doesn't amount to a molehill in the politics of personal destruction. It's not like he was framed or stung, dragged into court, bankrupted, jailed, etc. I mean, for chrissakes. Hobbs will land on his feet; he wasn't articulating anything which isn't in the mainstream of GOP thought.
____________________________
Wasabi peas are people! They're people!
Getting into this late.
I distinctly remember Hobbs going on and on and on and on about the Dixie Chicks, and how free speech was not free, and how they deserved what they were getting- which wasn't nearly what Hobbs said they were. What comes around goes around I suspect. I always think about karma in my daily dealings. Perhaps Hobbs should have been as well. Perhaps a little more compassion in his conservatism- which isn't really conservatism?
What Axel said
Raising a big stink about his getting the pole-axe might have been the only way to raise his profile in that campaign, since he'd already gone into hiatus from his eponymous blog.
Amen, brother.
Was just talking to someone about how Republicans can't really call themselves conservatives by any stretch, since they seem hell-bent on sinking the U.S. dollar and the economy along with it.
Wow. Wonder how their heads aren't exploding from all the hypocrisy.