Sat
Jun 11 2011
12:54 pm

Today's online column by Greg Johnson is another full bore attack on one of the KNS' mythical targets: the "educational intelligentsia." The reason his undies are all in a bunch is the release of a report on the effectiveness of Tennessee's Pre-K program using test data from 2004-2007 that found little by way of long term benefits. Armed with one study that covers the start-up phase of Tennessee's program Johnson offers up this piece of pap...

Government can't solve every problem, and the ephemeral advantage of Pre-K, to this humble scribe, proves once again that until parental involvement - not just in PTA meetings and bake sales and such - improves for at-risk kids, they will revert to their pre-Pre-K performance patterns. Until reformers acknowledge that parents are key and devise strategies to provoke their engagement, no amount of money or time or effort will improve at-risk outcomes.

Of course this "humble scribe" could actually do his job as a journalist/opinion-ator and conduct a little research to see if the subject is as clear cut as he'd like us to believe. Had he done so he might have come across this 25 year longitudinal study from Chicago showing significant long-term benefits for at-risk children participating in Pre-K programs.

Relative to the comparison group receiving the usual services, program participation was independently linked to higher educational attainment, income, socioeconomic status (SES), and health insurance coverage, as well as lower rates of justice-system involvement and substance abuse.

Every program is different, and there is simply no way to make definitive statements one way or another as to long-term benefits of Tennessee's universal Pre-K. Put simply, it is not settled science. However, wrapped in the warmth of ideological purity, all that Mr. Johnson requires is one short term study that speaks to his cognitive biases to make broad truth statements about the way things are. Research is not required. All that is required is faith.

EricLykins's picture

Is the Reynolds study saying

Is the Reynolds study saying that providing access to not only child but comprehensive family services early on the key to provoke parental engagement?

"When you follow people for more than two decades, an understanding of how early experiences shape later development can be achieved," Reynolds notes. "A chain of positive influences initiated by large advantages in school readiness and parent involvement leads to better school performance and enrollment in higher quality schools, and ultimately to higher educational attainment and socioeconomic status."

Findings demonstrate that effects of sustained school-based early education can endure through the third decade of life. Previously, Reynolds and colleagues documented the cost benefits of early education, demonstrating an 18 percent annual return on investment for society. However, policy has yet to support the kind of early interventions needed to solve persistent societal issues.

"Unfortunately, we still spend very little on prevention," says Reynolds. "Only 3 percent of the $14 billion dollars allocated to school districts to serve low-income children under Title I of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act No Child Left Behind goes to preschool. Yet preschool programs are one of the most cost-effective of all social programs."

He explains that since about half of the achievement gap between children from higher and lower economic statuses at age 10 already exists at age 5, education interventions need to start even earlier. "State and federal policies don't reflect the knowledge of how much earlier these gaps appear, and therefore the need to start as early as possible," he says.

Based on this and earlier studies, Reynolds and Temple say the key to CPC's success lies in both the quality of the program and its teachers, the opportunity for more than one year of participation, small classes, comprehensive family services, structured activity-based curricula focusing on language and literacy, and attention to continuity of learning from preschool to the early school grades.

Stick's picture

Yep... That is one of the big

Yep... That is one of the big problems with the instrumental ways we measure effectiveness. It's all about test scores. However, there are many apparent benefits to Pre-K programs such as Head Start that include parental involvement, health measures, etc. There's a lot more than meets the eye, but none of that matters to folks like Johnson. They're looking for things that confirm what they already believe.

Mary the prez's picture

Thank you, Stick!

Johnson's lack of any real research in any of his 'columns' is so apparent, and his opinions so biased, I am sure he gets most of the negative mail received by KNS.
The worst example I remember, in recent memory featured this February, was his adoration of the 'pro-life', anti-abortion group that paid for the appearance of FOX NEWS star Mike Huckabee who supposedly in support of these 'groups'. At $200 per pop, I am sure those wealthy white folk were disappointed to learn that his speech and comments were more about himself and "should I run for President".

The details about the group in question would definitely qualify for punishment from our new TN Law that forbids showing "emotionally disturbing photos, in any public place". And a further investigation of the ring leader painted a picture of one of the worst prevaricators, supposedly an "all life is sacred" spokesman, claiming disgusting 'facts' about Planned Parenthood, including some lying nonsense about stacks of human body parts at their facilities!
There should be a disclaimer with each of Johnson's right wing 'opinion pieces', saying that 99% of each one is totally unsubstantiated, made up, hate-filled rhetoric, with nary a FACT in sight.

Stick's picture

More from the

More from the Tennessean...

(link...)

Commonsense's picture

Pre-K

The question should be where would these at risk children be if not for Pre-K? If they are on grade level, this is better than they would have been. Catching up is success in this situation.

smalc's picture

Yes, this has always been my

Yes, this has always been my point. If there is no difference (at least on the holy test grades)in the at-risk kids at 3rd grade, shouldn't that be seen as a success? We have a wingnut school board member in Loudon County who constantly beats this dead horse.

I suppose it could be twisted either way when you are trying to confirm your own beliefs.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives