Tennessee Guerilla Women has a post by Paul Krugman on the health insurance proposal Bush has been discussing lately.
While proposing this high-end tax break, Mr. Bush is also proposing a tax increase - not on the wealthy, but on workers who, he thinks, have too much health insurance. The tax code, he said, "unwisely encourages workers to choose overly expensive, gold-plated plans. The result is that insurance premiums rise, and many Americans cannot afford the coverage they need."
I'm always afraid when people with no clue try to come up with solutions to important issues. I heard part of this proposal discussed on the radio today, i.e. tax people paying more for health insurance. I wonder if they realize some people have to pay more just to get some basic coverage because they are identified as uninsurable by health insurance companies. Who will determine the definition of a "gold-plated plan"?
Oh, Thoughts of an Average Woman has the scoop on "gold-plated plans".
Bush wants to cap how much a family or individual can pay for a health insurance policy.
It would work like this: The administration would cap the amount of benefits that can remain tax free at $15,000 for a family and $7,500 for an individual. Anyone whose health insurance cost more than that would pay taxes on the difference. For example, a family with coverage costing $16,000 a year would pay taxes on $1,000.
|
|
Discussing:
- U.S. Treasury Dept. data breach? (2 replies)
- 19 (was 13) states to sue over Treasury data breach (2 replies)
- Hail, Caesar! (1 reply)
- Trump: U.S. takeover of Gaza Strip, "Riviera of the Middle East" (2 replies)
- Let them eat cake... (2 replies)
- How an arcane Treasury Department office became ground zero in the war over federal spending (6 replies)
- TN Voucher bill contracts with Arkansas reject (1 reply)
- Are Meta/Zuckerberg paying a bribe? (3 replies)
- Plane crash in the Potomac (3 replies)
- Maryville Jan. 6 felon, pardoned, faces sentencing for conspiracy to murder federal employees conviction (3 replies)
- Google Maps will change the Gulf of Mexico to the Gulf of America (2 replies)
- Bridgestone closes a tire plant in Tennessee with 700 layoffs and other reductions (2 replies)
TN Progressive
- Must Read (RoaneViews)
- It's Time to Call For the Arrest of Elon Musk! (RoaneViews)
- Books (RoaneViews)
- Tennessee Legislature...Theme Park or Rocky Horror? (RoaneViews)
- (Whitescreek Journal)
- Lee's Fried Chicken in Alcoa closed (BlountViews)
- Alcoa, Hall Rd. Corridor Study meeting, July 30, 2024 (BlountViews)
- My choices in the August election (Left Wing Cracker)
- July 4, 2024 - aka The Twilight Zone (Joe Powell)
- Chef steals food to serve at restaurant? (BlountViews)
- Blount County, TDOT make road deal for gun mfg ignoring town of Louisville,TN, (BlountViews)
- Winter at the Big Rocks (Whitescreek Journal)
TN Politics
- The Lower Mississippi River’s largest ecosystem restoration project got the federal go-ahead (TN Lookout)
- Democratic AGs allege Trump administration is freezing federal funds despite court order (TN Lookout)
- The state of our society: A prophetic perspective on Tennessee and Memphis (TN Lookout)
- Tennessee’s own EV charging program still running as Trump hits brakes on federal grants (TN Lookout)
- Lawsuits multiply against Trump barrage of orders as Democrats struggle to fight back (TN Lookout)
- U.S. Department of Justice backs out of Tennessee transgender care case (TN Lookout)
Knox TN Today
- Tennessee-Kentucky used to be so much fun (Knox TN Today)
- Rural Metro honors 3 in life-saving rescue from December fire (Knox TN Today)
- Track Trump’s Executive Orders and the litigation to block them +++ (Knox TN Today)
- The Caregiver Café panel discussion on March 11 (Knox TN Today)
- Zoo Knoxville’s Dolly passes away (Knox TN Today)
- Hundreds race to finish line at Covenant Kids Run kickoff (Knox TN Today)
- Restorative sleep: Let’s improve our sleep habits (Knox TN Today)
- HEADLINES: New KTT column (Knox TN Today)
- Premier Transportation drivers complete training (Knox TN Today)
- No. 4 Volunteers overwhelm Oklahoma, 70-52 (Knox TN Today)
- Breaking: Knox schools to close Monday-Tuesday (Knox TN Today)
- Lady Vols upset No. 5 UConn for signature win (Knox TN Today)
Local TV News
- United States Transportation Secretary to visit East Tennessee (WATE)
- Daniel Boone's Gavin Pearce 300th student to solo fly with the F.L.I.G.H.T. Foundation (WATE)
- Deputies seeking missing man last seen in Dandridge (WATE)
- Morgan County continues cleaning up debris with help from volunteers (WATE)
- Lady Vols fall in another close contest against LSU (WATE)
- Sheriff: Potential planned shooting at McMinn High School prevented, press conference (WATE)
- Megan Boswell Trial Day 3 | Defense questions evidence after prosecution shows edited text exchange (WBIR)
- TN convict pleads guilty to 2013 killing of Knoxville woman whose body has never been found (WBIR)
- Here are the 14 Big Lots stores staying open in Tennessee (WBIR)
- Heart of the Matter: Blount County Sheriff James Berrong (WBIR)
- KCS naming facilities committee to consider naming Gibbs High School baseball field after Morgan Wallen (WBIR)
- Sevierville releases statement after 'comments, emails and phone calls' targeting city staff over RV dealer's overly-tall flagpole (WBIR)
News Sentinel
State News
- William Gary Tucker Obituary - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Braves head to spring training with some roles unsettled - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Five questions as UTC kicks off spring football practice - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Dear Abby: Man’s delusions put brother in a difficult spot - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
Wire Reports
- Trump says he will announce 25% steel and aluminum tariffs Monday, and more import duties are coming - The Associated Press (US News)
- Find out if you’ll be affected by 3 big storms hitting this week - The Washington Post (US News)
- CWG Live updates: Calm today before snowstorm starts Tuesday - The Washington Post (US News)
- Capitol agenda: Johnson falls behind in budget race, Gabbard and RFK Jr. coming up - POLITICO (US News)
- McDonald's posts biggest US sales decline in nearly five years - Reuters.com (Business)
- Hyatt to acquire Playa Hotels for $2.6 billion - CNBC (Business)
- The ‘Magnificent Seven’ companies just did something they haven’t in two years. Goldman says it’s time to make a shift. - MarketWatch (Business)
- Trump tells Treasury to stop minting 'wasteful' pennies - BBC.com (Business)
- Macron unveils $112B AI investment package, France’s answer to US’ Stargate - TechCrunch (Business)
- This Man Won Birthright Citizenship for All - The New York Times (US News)
- New York’s top court to consider noncitizen voting in city elections - POLITICO (US News)
- The Senate gives Trump his Cabinet — and their compliance - POLITICO (US News)
- Union sues Russell Vought over DOGE access to CFPB and attempts to shutter bureau - NBC News (Business)
- Vance and Musk attack judicial authority as Trump’s agenda gets pushback from courts - PBS NewsHour (US News)
- Trump’s ‘interesting problem’ with Treasuries - Financial Times (Business)
Local Media
Lost Medicaid Funding
Search and Archives
TN Progressive
Nearby:
- Blount Dems
- Herston TN Family Law
- Inside of Knoxville
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jim Stovall
- Knox Dems
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Outdoor Knoxville
- Pittman Properties
- Reality Me
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
Beyond:
- Nashville Scene
- Nashville Post
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Journal
- TN Lookout
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South
Dead on Arrival
This proposal will never get through Congress, and Bush knows it. It's just his token nod toward doing something about health care.
Unless you're with Tony Snow, and think it's one of those diamonds.
In which case I've got a bridge in NY to show ya.
This proposal will never get
This proposal will never get through Congress, and Bush knows it. It's just his token nod toward doing something about health care.
I agree. They just want to get on record that they tried to fix health insurance. Having had private insurance (not provided by an employer) for over 20 years, this is a serious topic for me. I really don't want them making it any harder to get private health insurance than it already is. A reason to hope for a 65th birthday, Medicare, if it's still offered when I reach that age.
Rising Costs
I also agree that this proposal won't get through Congress, but, as one that has been uninsured for a lengthy time (self-employed) it amazes me that there is even discussion about taxing those that are considered "over insured." Even the premier plans neglect needed basic health care, as I was trying to sho with the exclusions. Hearing problems? Foot problems? Vision? Dental? All of these should be part of basic health care, and they aren't.
The book I am currently reading is specifically about the excesses in the health care industry -- Money-driven Medicine, by Maggie Mahar. Very interesting reading, and definately worth the read. Knowing that the pharmaceuticals, insurance industry and for-profit doctor groups and hospitals are a major part of the rising cost in health care, rarely does anyone address "reform," such as responsibility, in these areas.
the whole change health care discussion is extremely discouraging, mostly because so many people "buy into" the spin (for instance the pharmaceuticals spend $800m a year on research & development)
the other thing that really bothers me about the rising cost discussion is blaming the rise in cost on the uninsured. Many non-profit hospitals do not treat the uninsured unless it is a dire emergency, contrary to popular belief. Also, the uninsured are charged more than double (sometimes as much as 10 times) that of an insured person for any given procedure. Think about the implications of that -- for instance, if a hospital charged an uninsured person double and collects half of that, they have collected the same as they would have from an insured person. On top of that, hospital collection tactics are so extreme, so much so that some state AG's have been going after hospitals for their collection tactics.
Granted, I'm not completely through the book, but it appears that even Maggie Mahar falls into the "blame the uninsured for rising costs" as well. However, the rest of the book (so far) is quite eye-opening.
bizgrrl
"I'm always afraid when people with no clue try to come up with solutions to important issues."
Yabbut most political solutions are exactly what you describe.
www.lesjones.com
Bush is also proposing a tax
Bush is also proposing a tax increase - not on the wealthy, but on workers who, he thinks, have too much health insurance.
I think we need to add a tax on the filthy rich to pay for everyone's health care, then sit back and watch how fast health costs come down.
Adrift in the Sea of Humility
health prices vs health costs
I think we need to compare and contrast true health care costs from health care prices...
This is a horrible plan!
doesn't the current way health insurance works, work for MOST people?
My concern is what happens when many of us are no longer under an employee-sponsored group plan?
I have a genetic condition... the last time I had medically necessary treatment for it was 26 years ago, and have had no complications from that incident, nor any complications since requiring medically necessary treatment.
But because 1 out of 10 people with this condition needs ongoing medical attention, the other 9 of us with little to no complications are deemed uninsurable.
I have read articles about people being denied health insurance for JOCK ITCH!
So even if I agree they won't cover complications related to the condition, I sure as heck shouldn't get anything else that everyone else gets unrelated to this condition b/c under Bush's plan I must buy private health insurance...
What's going to happen to us "uninsurable". And having read lists of uninsurable conditions, it's probably ruled out about 80% of people who have seen a DR for anything in the near past.
IF he goes with this plan, I think they MUST ensure that no one LOSES coverage who already has it now. Force the Insurance company (i.e. BCBS) to sell the policy to the individual at the same rate it costs under employee-sponsored (about $450/month in my case), and keep all the HIPAA rules that are currently in place, and adjust premiums with inflation.
But then I fear the poor kid with Jock Itch who just graduated college and is off on his own now and can't get insurance at any price.
That's one part of the
That's one part of the problem.
That kid won't buy insurance (unless he gets a job that provides it) because he's immortal and invincible etc. And if he does, the insurance companies have special pools of low risk policyholders like him so they can sell him cheap policy with few benefits that they never have to pay out on anyway.
What we need is ONE BIG POOL and EVERYBODY INTO THE POOL.
I suggest Medicare, with sliding scale premiums based on income until 65 then it's free.
I had to start buying my own
I had to start buying my own health insurance for me and my son a couple of years ago. I was asked 1 question by the salesman. He asked if we used more than 3 prescriptions a month. We do and he told me that the only plan we could get was a HIPPA plan from BCBS. It was over $700 in 2004. In 2005, it went up to over $1000 and now it's over $1350 a month. That's over $16,000 a year and it's no gold-plated plan! I have a $1000 individual deductible and $2000 family. There are no co-payments, except for medicines. If we go to the doctor, we have to pay the full amount.
We have no serious medical problems. Financially, we would do better if I put that money into the bank and paid all our medical expenses from it. But I'm terrified that one of us will get sick and then what would we do
Wow
CL, your situation is unfortunately all too common. As Randy has pointed out several times, the tying of health insurance to employment status is a major contributor to the problem of insurance affordability. Although I don't think a single-payer system is necessarily the best solution, it is utterly ludicrous that someone in your situation has to pay such high premiums, yet someone with the same medical conditions who works for a large employer would pay only a tenth of that amount for much better coverage.
Instead of a single-payer system, Congress could simply pass a law that requires each insurance company to provide the same coverage for the same premium to all of its customers, regardless of pre-existing conditions, employment status, or group membership. The insurance companies could then compete to provide the lowest premiums to their customers across the board, thereby preserving the falsely vaunted "market competition" the conservatives so dearly love. Each insurance company could provide a menu of policies, providing a wide range of coverage and deductible options. An insurance company with millions of customers would be able to implement such a policy with only a minor tweaking of the actuarial calculations they now use.
Insurance affordability is only part of the problem; the issue of medical cost inflation is the other main part of the problem, and it would have to be addressed at the same time. But I think that insurance homogenization across the population would go a long way toward reducing the burden on folks like you and your son. It could also serve as a mechanism to provide affordable insurance to the 47 million who currently have none. If premiums were calculated across an entire customer base instead of negotiated employer by employer, the whole country would benefit.
--Socialist With A Gold Card
"I'm a socialist with a gold card. I firmly believe we need a revolution; I'm just concerned that I won't be able to get good moisturizer afterwards." -- Brett Butler
Another option...
New laws around 401K plans allow employers to automatically enroll their employee in the plan for up to 2% of their salary unless the employee requests, in writing, not to participate.
I have known people who have had the ability to get insurance with their company's group plan for as little as $25/pay period who choose not to b/c they'd rather have the latest ipod accessory...
They should do this for health insurance. Automatic enrollment unless otherwise requested in writing not to participate.
Also, if Bush's plan flies, which it probably won't, any company who chooses to drop their group plans and provide the employees with cash instead...
An individual should be allowed to roll over their group plan into an individual policy with the same insurance company, same level of coverage, etc..., with the same premium they had before (employee + company contriubutions). And, increase premiums only with inflation.
Steven Colbert on Bush's health care proposal
It's so simple. Most people who couldn’t afford health insurance also are too poor to owe taxes. But...if you give them a deduction from their taxes they don’t owe, they can use the money they're not getting back from what they haven't given to buy the health care they can't afford.