Fri
Nov 15 2013
08:27 am

A photographer taking pictures of elk at Cataloochee Valley in North Carolina was approached and batted around by an elk.

The photographer was probably lucky he wasn't hurt.

I couldn't find a working youtube video. Here is a UK article with the best video I could find.

Andy Axel's picture

Rutting season. Not a good

Rutting season. Not a good time to be stalking wild animals.

fischbobber's picture

Furthermore

Now the elk, rather than the photographer, is labeled a nuisance. Think of how many human altercations are caused by humans interfering with the rut rut within our own species and then ask yourself if it is really necessary to spread this sort of stupidity across all the other organisms that we share the earth with. We should leave nature alone to the extent that animals can propagate as God intended. We don't let elk play football, you know.

JaHu's picture

I'm curious why nobody came

I'm curious why nobody came to the guys aid.
It's definitely a neat video though.

bizgrrl's picture

I wondered the same thing,

I wondered the same thing, but then would it be a good idea for a tourist to come to his aid? Could assistance by an amateur have caused problems? I also wondered why the guy didn't get up sooner.

AnonymousOne's picture

I heard they put the elk

I heard they put the elk down. No zoo to take it? Seems extreme.

bizgrrl's picture

According to a report from

According to a report from WATE, you are correct. That is not what I expected. This is very sad.

Doesn't seem right. Again, stupid humans ruining nature. Is it also stupid government departments running parks? They make this area of Catalooche Valley available to tourists to see elk in the wild. Are the elk really in the wild or are they being lured to this area to entertain tourists?

Andy Axel's picture

Hope it was worth the

Hope it was worth the picture.

If a wild animal is within 100 yards, just stay in the car. It's better for you and it's best for the animal.

fischbobber's picture

Elk Reintroduction Project

(link...)

Here is a brief overview of the Elk Reintroduction project. I'm not sure how current it is. These elk came from a Canadian herd and have always interacted with humans. Since guns are not allowed in the park (a good thing) the elk have never learned to react to humans as a predator, to them we're just another creature in the woods. As a result, their inclination would not be to view use as a dominant species. Hence the problem with the photographer.

While I'm not an expert in elk psychology, it's pretty clear that the photographer triggered some sort of response mechanism in the elk. Clearly it wasn't mortal fear and rage since the guy is still alive and relatively unharmed, but any sort of response that could be deemed aggressive should be taken seriously from an 800 lb. animal. The elk wasn't even full grown. My guess would be that it was the adolescent elk version of rolling a yard with toilet paper. But that would just be a guess.

The elk are really in the wild, but the habitat is good enough in the Cataloochee Valley that the main herd has stayed there, so they have become a tourist attraction as well.

WhitesCreek's picture

There isn't a good solution, only a safe one

A wild animal getting acclimated to humans is one thing. That wasn't what was happening. That elk had fixated on a human as one of them. This is more typical of people who mistakenly raise a buck fawn which fixates on humans. Everything is fine until one day when the male animal goes through puberty and has those raging hormones that drive mating behavior. Then it wants to fight, sometimes to the death depending on the species. If a deer, turkey, elk, etc. has fixated on humans and a human happens to be around at the wrong time, the animal goes into fight mode, usually with tragic results for the human...or mating mode which is even worse to my way of thinking. Accepted practice is to put the animal down once it is discovered. Even in a zoo setting it have become the practice to avoid letting non domesticated animals become fixated on humans.

If you put out food for a wild animal that can be OK under very strict circumstances such as severe weather events. If you lure it to you with food in order to "tame" it, you are most likely signing its death warrant. Feeding bears, even unintentionally, will absolutely get them killed. Feeding raccoons generally winds up with the person doing the feeding hating raccoons and wanting to do the killing in fairly short order.

I completely agree with the decision to out this elk down, but I don't like that it had become necessary.

fischbobber's picture

Fixation over acclimation

Good explanation of the situation. There are obvious problems reintroducing a formerly native species into an area frequented by humans and your explanation is appreciated. The trigger response comment was based on extensive experience with dogs (All dogs will bite, it is only the circumstance that triggers the bite that varies from dog to dog.).

Interestingly (at least to me) I was involved in a nature/nurture discussion with my son earlier today over human behavior. As that discussion progressed, it quickly became apparent that what I didn't know far surpassed what I did as far as human behavior as well.

I stand humbled.

JaHu's picture

No zoo to take it? Seems

No zoo to take it? Seems extreme.

I know... couldn't there have been a better option?

This is sad. I could almost understand putting him down if he had attacked the photographer like a raging bull. But the elk was meticulously gentle when he prodded the man with his antlers.

AnonymousOne's picture

Animals in most busy national

Animals in most busy national parks coexist with humans. Like in Yellowstone or Smokeys. Granted it's a delicate balance, but that's the way it is.

The park people can be a little too purist, I think. It's never going to be the same before man found it.

Seems like a zoo or wildlife refuge could have helped out.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives