From the "News-O-Rama" feeds over there on the right:
• Clinton wins big in Puerto Rico (AP Politics)
• Puerto Rico moves Obama closer to nomination (AP Politics)
OK, then.
On a side note, it's funny, but not really, that the media wants to keep this thing going to stoke viewer interest when every credible analysis shows a win is mathematically impossible for Clinton at this point. (Unless there is a sea change of delegate voting at the convention.)
I will also be amused on Wednesday when enough "superdelegates" declare for Obama, who couldn't win it in the regular primary either, to put him over the top. I'm reminded of the March/April talk at Daily Kos and elsewhere re. how undemocratic it would be if Clinton were to win based on "superdelegates."
We're through the looking glass. Yay Obama! On to Symbolic Moral Victory in November!
|
Topics:
|
|
Discussing:
- Open AI escapes, hacks competitor (3 replies)
- Bravo to Michaela Barnett (3 replies)
- Federal Government sending marketing (campaign) messages? (1 reply)
- Knox SOUP Announces New Name, November 5 Community Dinner, and Call for Project Proposals (1 reply)
- Oconaluftee, Cherokee, Newfound Gap (1 reply)
- Pedestrians be careful, drivers (and pedestrians) not attentive (3 replies)
- Check and Recheck your ballot when voting (5 replies)
- Bernie Sanders vs AI (1 reply)
- SoKno discombobulation continues (2 replies)
- Execution failed!!! (3 replies)
- GOP Senator "deserves the obloquy" (2 replies)
- AI company going public says "existential risks to humanity" (2 replies)
TN Progressive
- Blount County pausing on housing growth? (BlountViews)
- Tues., Oct. 20, 2026, Free Flu Shots at Blount County Health Dept. (BlountViews)
- View from the Overlook (Whitescreek Journal)
- Alcoa property taxes will probably not go up (BlountViews)
- Smith & Wesson not a good fit for Blount County (BlountViews)
- WATCH THIS SPACE. (Left Wing Cracker)
- America As It Is Right Now (RoaneViews)
- A friend sent this: From Captain McElwee's Tall Tales of Roane County (RoaneViews)
- The Meidas Touch (RoaneViews)
- Massive Security Breach Analysis (RoaneViews)
- (Whitescreek Journal)
- My choices in the August election (Left Wing Cracker)
TN Politics
- Pro-voucher group spent big on Blackburn, but not in the state House, throwing expansion into doubt (TN Lookout)
- Photo essay: The Equity Alliance, building Tennessee’s Black community for a decade (TN Lookout)
- Some US House Dems urge a national moratorium on buildup of new data centers (TN Lookout)
- US Senate seeks to restore campaign finance watchdog during lame-duck session (TN Lookout)
- US Senate Dems call for pause on router installation that caused air travel ground stop (TN Lookout)
- SpaceX cleaning up 5,000-gallon chemical spill at Southaven facility (TN Lookout)
Knox TN Today
- Let’s Talk: Youth — Zoo opens new doors for Knox County families (Knox TN Today)
- Book Whisperer brings Nonfiction November (Knox TN Today)
- Young Reader’s Shelf: Stories that grow grateful hearts (Knox TN Today)
- Fast start helps CAK eliminate Evangelical Christian School in Division II-AA quarterfinals (Knox TN Today)
- Mama Said: Lie down with dogs, get up with fleas (Knox TN Today)
- Signing Day: Knoxville-area athletes take their talents to college (Knox TN Today)
- A second chance to sing: Pellissippi State helps student overcome homelessness (Knox TN Today)
- Loudon woman’s gingerbread creations earn national recognition (Knox TN Today)
- Pilot celebrates Heiskell travel center reopening with $10,000 community gift (Knox TN Today)
- Let’s Talk: Neighbors — Second chances, new beginnings and holiday happenings (Knox TN Today)
- Belmont to host Lady Vols for first time in 49 years (Knox TN Today)
- Consumption (Knox TN Today)
Local TV News
- WIVK's Joey and Nancy Show earns third CMA nomination (WATE)
- Pedestrian hit by vehicle, critically injured while trying to cross Chapman Highway (WATE)
- 14th-ranked Tennessee knocks off No. 2 Michigan State (WATE)
- How predators target children online and what you can do to keep them safe (WATE)
- Knoxville mayor says no tax increase needed to fund $70M venue renovations (WATE)
- William Blount head coach Robert Reeves steps down after five seasons (WATE)
News Sentinel
State News
Wire Reports
- Mary Peltola flips Alaska seat, giving Democrats a 56-44 edge in Senate - The Washington Post (US News)
- Wall Street prepares for Anthropic IPO frenzy, despite broader AI stock slump - Reuters (Business)
- Nasdaq futures rise as Nvidia gains on earnings beat and solid outlook: Live updates - CNBC (Business)
- Garcia gives Trump allies early warning on the investigations to come - Politico (US News)
- Mullin heads to Congress to face questions over flight disruptions, football trip and immigration - AP News (US News)
- Target earnings squash estimates as inflation-weary shoppers see great deals - Yahoo Finance (Business)
- Flood threat grows across Central Florida as additional inches of rain move in - WESH (US News)
- FAA signed off on router replacement just before ground stop, report states - Mashable (Business)
- Rubio says there's 'zero' information that U.S. outages are caused by a malign actor - NPR (Business)
- Police to reinvestigate case against man charged in Tasia Fortune’s killing - CNN (US News)
- Trump Administration Presses Ahead in Legal Battle Over U.S. Attorneys - The New York Times (US News)
- Record diesel prices drive UK inflation to 1-year high of 3.6% - CNBC (Business)
- Gold Steadies Near 14-Month Low as Rate-Hike Pressure Mounts - Bloomberg.com (Business)
- Acting Navy secretary faces scrutiny over communication with Congress - Federal News Network (US News)
- Nvidia bought itself a little breathing room in the Jensen Huang comeback fight - Business Insider (Business)
Local Media
Lost Medicaid Funding
Search and Archives
TN Progressive
Nearby:
- Blount Dems
- Herston TN Family Law
- Inside of Knoxville
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jim Stovall
- Knox Dems
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Outdoor Knoxville
- Pittman Properties
- Reality Me
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
Beyond:
- Nashville Scene
- Nashville Post
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Journal
- TN Lookout
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South

The Supers are the problem.
If you eliminate the Super Delegates, Obama has already won.
It would take 1697.5 pledged delegates to win and Obama has 1740 already.
It is the very fact that there are 290 Supers who haven't committed that is keeping this thing going and going and going...
If you eliminate the Super
However, as Obama's legions liked to remind everyone, there are rules to be followed, and the SD's are part of the equation, for good or for ill.
And it's funny that you would talk about a non-existent standard to evaluate this, as "if" that's a legitmate consideration, then I don't see how the consideration of other metrics (like primary wins in states with big Electoral Vote totals or the popular vote) are any less legitimate. The vote minus the superdelegates is just as relevant as the popular vote or projected Electoral College contributions, isn't it? That is, there's one way that the nomination is ultimately settled - 50% +1 of the voting delegates at the convention.
Bug or feature?
Explain (hopefully, to the widespread satisfaction of the KV audience) why this big break hasn't already come. Any theories? I'm still trying to work this one out - but one thing that keeps sticking in my head is that if Obama's case is so compelling, why haven't they simply knuckled under to inevitability and broken for Obama? Is the outcome really all that certain?
This isn't a rhetorical question, by the way. I really don't know, and I don't presume to know.
____________________________
"It's gettin' so a businessman can't expect no return from a fixed fight. Now, if you can't trust a fix, what can you trust?"
Vast left-wing conspiracy
That was if superdelegates had pushed her over the top after losing the committed delegate count, a reasonable complaint since the superdelate is a un-democratic concept.
Not really an issue since Obama is winning in every significant metric except "states where his name did not appear on the ballot," where Clinton has a narrow lead.
Ditto
Its dishonest to somehow say that Obama will have won because of superdelegates. He's already wont he pledge delegate race, its just that with the large number of superdelegates it would be impossible for anyone to win without them if the nomination is contested all the way through the end of the primary calendar.
Its dishonest to somehow say
It's perfectly honest to say that the SD's will have put him over the top. At this point, it's perfectly honest to say that he needs them to hit the magic number. It's perfectly honest to say that his current lead in the superdelegates gives him an important edge, as well.
Bug or feature?
____________________________
"It's gettin' so a businessman can't expect no return from a fixed fight. Now, if you can't trust a fix, what can you trust?"
You're right, which is why I
You're right, which is why I said it would be dishonest to say he won because of superdelegates; in fact, the super-d endorsements followed his wins in primaries and caucuses, not the other way around.
I don't know if bug or feature is the right word, its simply the way it is.
"Inevitability" hasn't been
"Inevitability" hasn't been a word I've seen used to describe the Obama candidacy, until he amassed this big lead in commited delegates and SDs. It's Hillary for whom that term was coined, and the SDs were larded with party operatives who owe the Clintons, or hope to owe them in the future (like our own Bill Owen). It was her race to lose, and the SDs were her firewall. That cracked when John Lewis defected.
Given that she's closed strong in the last lap of the closest race in party history, I'm not surprised that so many delegates are holding out -- a core of Clinton loyalists, a bunch of would-be Clinton loyalists (like Al Gore), who no longer have any love left for the Clintons but are reluctant to come out against her unless they absolutely must, true undecideds who have doubts about Obama's electability but fear the consequences of going against the probable winner, political animals like Phil Bredesen who want to be double-dog sure they don't damage their own political futures and people like Donna Brazile, whose career as a pundit is best served by waiting it out, even though there's no doubt as to which way she's leaning -- particularly after this past weekend.
And finally, there's Jimmy Carter, who's going to be for Obama, but is trying to heighten the drama. or something.
Seems to me the operative word is sure. It's still just hard to accept that the Clintons will lose this race, even for someone like me who doesn't support her.
Good analysis.
Good analysis.
And regarding the dueling
And regarding the dueling headlines dichotomy:
Maybe that's because it's hard to take Hillary's victory in the Puerto Rican primary seriously, given that it doesn't fit her "I'm winning all the states Democrats must win" theme -- since Puerto Ricans living on the island don't have the right to vote in general elections.
So by Hillary's own argument, PR's 51 delegates don't mean squat in the electability argument, unless you want to factor in all the Newyoricans -- and unless the world slips its axis, New York's going to go Democrat regardless.
So, by Hillary's own reckoning,South Dakota and Montana are far more important than Puerto Rico.
*Although my saying this pisses off my Puerto Rican mama' muy terible.
the SDs were larded with
So much for that theory.
One Tennessee Democrat, a superdelegate, who has made the transition from Clinton to Obama is Bill Owen, a former state senator from Knoxville and a Democratic National Committee member.
Owen congratulated Obama and said it is “vitally important” for America to change its course in both its foreign and domestic policies.”
“Sen. Hillary Clinton and the entire Clinton campaign stands ready to work in any way possible to elect a Democrat as president of the United States, and to elect Barack Obama as that president,” Owen said, despite Clinton not conceding the nomination Tuesday night.
In addition to Bredesen, state Democratic Party Chairman Gray Sasser and superdelegate Inez Crutchfield endorsed Obama.
____________________________
"It's gettin' so a businessman can't expect no return from a fixed fight. Now, if you can't trust a fix, what can you trust?"
We shall be released--
Bill Owen's joining with the rest of the Democratic Party to endorse Obama the day after he nailed down the nomination proves what? He's got enough brain cells left to know there are new asses to be kissed. By next week, he'll be running errands for Michelle Obama.
You're going to need to pick a whole lot more of these delicious nits to get a full belly's worth.
Heck, even the New York delegation is announcing today, after calling Hillary and demanding to be released yesterday.
Rangel and those other 22 Congress persons were itching to get out from under the Clinton yoke.
I guess it proves that he's
I guess it proves that he's a politician and not a [Clinton] partisan after all. Wonder of wonders.
Just as Clinton is now promising to bust her ass to help Obama get elected:
Maybe my dog-whistle monitor is broken, but I don't see a stealth "out clause" incorporated into this written statement...
(I suspect we'll see how many paranoid fantasies - entertained by extremist followers in both camps - simply fail to materialize in the coming months, such as the alleged "whitey" video that Larry Johnson keeps pimping.)
____________________________
"It's gettin' so a businessman can't expect no return from a fixed fight. Now, if you can't trust a fix, what can you trust?"
(I suspect we'll see how
(I suspect we'll see how many paranoid fantasies - entertained by extremist followers in both camps - simply fail to materialize in the coming months, such as the alleged "whitey" video that Larry Johnson keeps pimping.)
Whitey/Why'd he? -- yeah, they were breathlessly awaiting that one over at Egalia's Monday -- it was supposed to save Hillary's presidency.
But Larry Johnson seems like a super-weird case. Is he really as close to Joe Wilson as he claims? The more I read, the more fucked up Johnson looks/sounds. Hell, even Michelle Malkin is warning her peeps not to trust him about the Whitey vid. Or anything. And you know how much she'd love to have some real dirt on the Obamas.
(link...)
Whitey/Why'd he? -- yeah,
The fact that it hasn't shown up means either (a) it doesn't exist, or (b) it exists but it wasn't made available to the Clintons, or (c) it exists, the Clintons have a copy, and they haven't used it.
Given how ruthless and efficient that the Clinton oppo operation was supposed to be, my guess is that this would be in the hands of the Clintons already if it existed at all. That sort of undercuts the meme that Clinton would do anything to win.
But we'll see if this turns out to be a GOP October Surprise.
Given that Johnson is ex-Agency, as Wilson's wife is, that is plausible.
____________________________
"It's gettin' so a businessman can't expect no return from a fixed fight. Now, if you can't trust a fix, what can you trust?"
My reading suggests that MO
My reading suggests that MO was trashing Bush regarding the New Orleans response, saying "Why'd he take three days to get down there?" etc. rather than "Whitey take three days to get down there."
That 'Whitey' crap is just some stupid racist's notion of how black people talk amongst themselves, and doesn't even sound like a real person.
So I'm betting that they got all built up for some big bomb with Michelle talking bad about white people with Louis Farrakahn and were terribly disappointed to find out that it was an Operation Push Ladies Social with Mrs Farrakahn -- not her old man -- in attendance. And the only white person getting badmouthed was GWB.
All in all, a dud and a minor embarrassment.
Evidently some Clinton supporters were carting Larry Sinclair around San Juan last week, though. Seemed pretty desperate -- Sinclair can't even get on Fox. But I do kinda love that one -- if Barak's gay, I'm betting he can find somebody way cuter than that guy to do.
Whitey do take three days.
Whitey do take three days. And three years later, still no clue.
The "mystery video"
The "mystery video" update:
The coincidence would be too much to be believed.
(link...)
____________________________
"It's gettin' so a businessman can't expect no return from a fixed fight. Now, if you can't trust a fix, what can you trust?"
Sounds like Primary Colors.
Sounds like Primary Colors. Docufiction.
(I've been halfway following this. Instapundit had a link to this Johnson guy promising to produce the video on Monday when all would be revealed. It's Friday. No video. What an elaborate hoax. Guess he got some traffic.)
Well, my early reading re
Well, my early reading re the Whitey vid was wrong, since the occasion preceded Hurricane Katrina by at least a year.
The rumor is an evolving, moving target. Johnson is looking like a cross between Geraldo opening Al Capone's vault, Joe McCarthy waving his 'list' and a standard-grade nutcase. Embarrassing -- or should be, if he and his followers weren't batshit crazy.
I guess the search for the smoking gun will go on to the next phase.
Hell, even Michelle Malkin
Hell, even Michelle Malkin is warning her peeps not to trust him about the Whitey vid. Or anything. And you know how much she'd love to have some real dirt on the Obamas.
Well, she did say that if people made a big fuss about a bogus issue now then it would make it harder to smear the Obamas later.
And what, you ask, am I doing reading Michelle Malkin? I was just curious when I heard she was warning people off - sure didn't sound like her.
Dang it
I know there are some harsh things
that can said about Bill Owen.
I've said em.
But dang it..I like the ole boy.
"Inevitability" hasn't been
I saw it as early as February coming from the Obama camp. Here it is, three months later, and the majick number is still not surpassed.
2/21/08 - Obama's campaign manager, David Plouffe, dismissed the Clinton camp's hopes of making a comeback when the power states of Texas and Ohio hold their primaries on March 4. "This is a wide, wide lead right now," Plouffe said in a conference call with reporters. "The Clinton campaign keeps saying the race is essentially tied. That's just lunacy."
There's been an air of triumphalism despite those and other errant predictions from Obama's team in the days and weeks since. (Still, the national primary isn't exactly a south-side scrabble over supposedly illegitimate petitions.)
My feeling is that those uncommitted are basically waiting for Clinton to drop out. (And speaking of our most prominent SD: personally, I wish that Al Gore had fought 1/10th as hard to become president as Hillary has to become the nominee. He had a clearer case.)
____________________________
"It's gettin' so a businessman can't expect no return from a fixed fight. Now, if you can't trust a fix, what can you trust?"
Tenacious H
I wish that Al Gore had fought 1/10th as hard to become president as Hillary has to become the nominee. He had a clearer case.
Amen to that.
Liberty and justice for all.
My home
Ditto.
Ditto.
Andy, here's a possible
Andy, here's a possible answer to the question of why SDs are taking so long to jump:
(link...)
hubris
Somewhere I read an old quote from Sen Clinton
that went something like this
"This race will be over..midnight..western time
Feb 5th.."
That's hubris.
The Clinton campaign just wasn't on the ground in the
caucuses that choose delegates...allowing Obama to gain
140 or so delegates.
In Idaho,Colo,Kansas,Wash.state & Minn
The Clinton campaign was not really there.
In Nev a caucus she won
But when the process was over
Obama won,14-11,in delegates.
She won the Tex primary but didn't
get her folks to the Tex
caucus
Obama ended up with 4 more
delagates in the state than Clinton.
Plus Clinton thinking it would be over super tuesday
Sen Clinton's campaign wasn't ready for the contestes
held from 2/9 thru 3/11.
Of the 15 contest held during that time
Clinton only won the delegate race in 2
states Ohio & R.I.
HUBRIS.
But then curtain was raised on the
3rd act.
Sen Clinton dusted herself off
gave it all she had..
Winning Pa.,Ind.,Ky.,West Va. & P.R.
But it was just not enough.
I've been for Obama since he started
talkin up a run in the late fall of
'06.
He's run a good race & is close to winning.
But Sen.Clinton will be kicking herself
for not fighting him in the caucus states
& no plan for the 4 weeks after super tuesday
HUBRIS!!!
Another good analysis. I
Another good analysis. I thought it was over for her after IN and NC. She won in IN, but didn't beat the spread in either place which was a must by that point.
As I said before, her campaign was like the scene in Butch and Sundance when they're hiding in the rocks up on a cliff, looking out over the plains at their pursuers in the distance, saying "Who ARE those guys?"
Yes she didn't get people to the caucuses. Was it because of how her campaign was being run, or because some of her "blue-collar working class" base couldn't necessarily make it to a caucus? Or both? I'd be in favor of doing away with caucuses (and not just because Clinton did poorly in them). But I guess that's up to the state parties. Does state law cover it, too?
Wish I could remember where
Wish I could remember where I read this, but it was from a credible mainstream source that was attempting to explain the Clinton campaign's shortcomings. Anyhow, the story was that the campaign team assembled to plan for post Super Tuesday, and Mark Penn told them that there was nothing to worry about, because Hillary was going to have a big win in California and take all those delegates. Everybody in the room was stunned, and Ickes went ballistic and confronted him, asking Penn if he was truly unaware that the Dems don't do Winner Take All primaries (actually, I believe there was one, but I don't remember which). Evidently this was news to Penn.
I reckon there'll be lots of fingerpointing in the postmortem stage.
*On edit: Google is a wonderful thing:
(link...)
(link...)
Yes she didn't get people to
Yes she didn't get people to the caucuses. Was it because of how her campaign was being run, or because some of her "blue-collar working class" base couldn't necessarily make it to a caucus? Or both? I'd be in favor of doing away with caucuses (and not just because Clinton did poorly in them). But I guess that's up to the state parties. Does state law cover it, too?
Here's one person's account of the Washington caucuses:
Is there anything more undemocratic than a caucus?
In my Seattle caucus today, overwhelmingly for Obama, us Hillary supporters were older, and less aggressive than the Obama supporters. We didn't have a chance against the Obama caucus machine. First, the put 90 Obama supporters right in the middle between Hillary supporters and the undecideds. While they had been asked to move to the side first, they en-mass said "No, put Clinton over there." I tried to talk about fairness, and democracy but wasn't heard over the Obama cheers and Clinton character assassination.
Frankly, if our next presidential nominee is going to be selected by a small subset of the population I don't want it to be made by many of the Obama supporters I met today. (And yes, caucusing means that a selection is being made by a much smaller sample of the state than if you hold a primary. People work, have childcare obligations, are sick and infirm and have a whole host of reasons why they can't make it to a caucus.) Don't get me wrong, some were nice...but, some were awful. They can't say the same about the Clinton supporters because we were a much quieter and less aggressive group. My partner just wanted to help people.
Intimidation is a factor in caucuses. It's something the democratic party has to deal with which is why I want the democratic party to do away with them completely. The last thing democrats need when trying to build party unity is one half winning votes by scaring the other half.
Caucus V. Primary
The only technical difference between a caucus and a primary is that a primary is run by the State, a caucus is run by the state party. Sometimes state parties use caucuses because the state does not want to pay for the primary, other times its so they can have more control over the process or get access to people's info, or get people more involved in party politics.
In some cases caucuses (like New Mexico) allow people to essentially cast paper ballots, while in others (like IA or WA) they use division of the house. In fact, in Michigan, had they gone through with their caucus, they would've allowed people to vote online, vote all day long, and vote absentee; which would've been more democratic (in my mind) than some of the state run primaries.
Ultimately, we can't simply do away with caucuses because those are up to the states, and we can't expect all states to pay for costly primaries and hold them when the National committee wants them to. Unless we nationalize our election process, we will still have funky rules and procedures in the various states, for good or bad.
The only technical
The only technical difference between a caucus and a primary is that a primary is run by the State, a caucus is run by the state party.
In some cases caucuses (like New Mexico) allow people to essentially cast paper ballots, while in others (like IA or WA) they use division of the house.
I'm thinking the big difference is how voting is made accessible to the people. The masses get to vote in a primary over an extended period versus the available few that are able to attend the caucus at a specified time on a specified day.
didnt see the need
I think Clinton's campaign just
didn't believe spending money
in caucus states was smart.
Ia was the exception & spent some
in Nev.
But they thought Super Tuesday was the big cheese
& put folks on the ground & money in the media for
those contestes.
Obama is the first insurgent to win the
nomination since '76.
For 30+yrs we've all watched Kennedy,Hart,Jackson,
Brown,Bradley & Dean make big splashes as the next
new thing..but never winning.
I think Clinon's campaign thought..we will beat the field super tuesday.
The insurgent's money will dry up along with their
support.
Game over.
When did the superdelegate
When did the superdelegate thing start? It seems custom made to prevent insurgencies.
Theories
If it's a postmortem, mine is that Obama has much better appeal. Discounting Appalachia, GOP mischief voters, angry women, etc.
(Hiding...)
Super
Super delegates:
(link...)
Rationale For Super-Delegates
The Democratic Party established this system in part in response to the nomination of George McGovern in 1972. McGovern took only one state and had only 37.5 percent of the popular vote. Then in 1976, Jimmy Carter was a dark-horse candidate with little national experience. Super-delegates were implemented in 1984.
Super-delegates are designed to act as a check on ideologically extreme or inexperienced candidates. It also gives power to people who have a vested interested in party policies: elected leaders. Because the primary and caucus voters do not have to be active members of the party (in New Hampshire they can sign up and sign out going-and-coming at the polls), the super-delegate system has been called a safety-value.