There is talk that Obama and the DNC are maneuvering to keep Hillary Clinton's name off the first nominating ballot at the Democratic National Convention. In my mind, any candidate who got "pledged" delegates during the primaries should be on the first ballot and there should be a roll call vote. That includes Obama, Clinton, and Edwards.
It should also be noted that none of these candidates gained enough "pledged" delegates during the primaries to secure the nomination. So how is it fair to have a "symbolic" vote for only one candidate?
And regarding "pledged" delegates, they aren't. According to party rules, any delegate, "pledged," "super," or otherwise, can vote for anybody they want. There are no hard and fast commitments until there is a vote -- just like elections, which are decided by the votes on election day, not survey polls leading up to it. Perhaps this is why the Obama camp is worried, given criticism of their recent campaign adjustments.
There is at least one organized effort to keep the Democratic National Convention democratic:
The Denver Group was recently formed to ensure that Howard Dean and the Democratic National Committee conduct the Democratic Party's presidential nomination process in keeping with democratic principles at the Party's convention this August. This means an open convention, which includes Senator Clinton's name on the ballot, allowing speeches by Clinton supporters on behalf of her candidacy, and the taking of a roll call vote, all of which is the norm.The Denver Group, organized by Marc Rubin and Heidi Li Feldman, is a non-connected committee, established on June 24, 2008. It is not affiliated with Hillary Clinton for President, any candidate for President, or any political party.
"The Democratic Party has an obligation to adhere to democratic principles and allow the delegates Senator Clinton earned, which represent more than 18 million Democratic primary voters, to be counted in a roll call vote and for superdelegates to be able to cast their votes for the candidate of their choice at the convention where it counts," said Rubin.
The Denver Group's website is here.
(Memo to Obamanauts and assorted Clinton Haters: This is not advocating for Hillary Clinton. This is advocating for an open and fair nominating process so the nominee isn't tainted going forward.)
Topics:
|
|
Discussing:
- Burchett at Cotton Eyed Joes last Saturday (2 replies)
- This presidential administration has no ethics? (2 replies)
- Burchett and Schumer got it right (3 replies)
- ‘A disruptive effect’: How slashing staff at the Social Security Administration is sparking fears the system could collapse (5 replies)
- New venue lawn at Midland in Alcoa (1 reply)
- Sam Seder takes on 20 MAGA loving supporters (1 reply)
- TN Legislature bullying Townsend? (14 replies)
- Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth orders a halt to offensive cyber operations against Russia (2 replies)
- Right thing, wrong way (2 replies)
- A Home with South Knox Bubba (and Mrs. Bubba) (5 replies)
- Vitamin A or cod liver oil are not the cure or prevention for Measles (1 reply)
- For financial security, back the Dems... (1 reply)
TN Progressive
- What Trae Said! (RoaneViews)
- Ever Seen a Cover done this fine? (RoaneViews)
- Saturday Snark (set to music) (RoaneViews)
- Feel Good Friday (RoaneViews)
- (Whitescreek Journal)
- Lee's Fried Chicken in Alcoa closed (BlountViews)
- Alcoa, Hall Rd. Corridor Study meeting, July 30, 2024 (BlountViews)
- My choices in the August election (Left Wing Cracker)
- July 4, 2024 - aka The Twilight Zone (Joe Powell)
- Chef steals food to serve at restaurant? (BlountViews)
- Blount County, TDOT make road deal for gun mfg ignoring town of Louisville,TN, (BlountViews)
- Winter at the Big Rocks (Whitescreek Journal)
TN Politics
- Tennessee Attorney General backs Trump’s birthright citizenship ban (TN Lookout)
- Tennessee poultry experts say egg prices due to remain high (TN Lookout)
- Poll from pro-Nashville Fairgrounds group finds opposition to NASCAR on site (TN Lookout)
- Youth gun deaths in the US have surged 50% since 2019 (TN Lookout)
- Stockard on the Stump: Rose jabs Gov. Lee, not his likely opponent, in gubernatorial kickoff (TN Lookout)
- Flu deaths rise as anti-vaccine disinformation takes root (TN Lookout)
Knox TN Today
- Boo Carter lights up Vol football practice (Knox TN Today)
- ACSO’s Dakota Williams: 2024’s Deputy of the Year (Knox TN Today)
- First Hero Kid Award deadline is March 31 (Knox TN Today)
- HEADLINES 3/24: Hitchhiking octopus to local job fair (Knox TN Today)
- Second Harvest, a food pantry? Hardly … (Knox TN Today)
- Saving a lamb: Lessons in advocacy and empathy (Knox TN Today)
- World Oral Health Day honored by Poligrip and RAM (Knox TN Today)
- Creatine – not just for muscles anymore? (Knox TN Today)
- DeRoyal acquires waste fluid management assets (Knox TN Today)
- Covenant Health Knoxville Marathon is coming (Knox TN Today)
- Barnes’ adjustment stops UCLA, sends Vols to Indy (Knox TN Today)
- Lady Vols to return to court as NCAA tourney arrives (Knox TN Today)
Local TV News
- Knox County AG hails effort to curb flow of drugs from Detroit down I-75 (WATE)
- Tennessee Highway Patrol investigating school bus crash in Roane County (WATE)
- Knoxville nonprofit working to break cycle of gun violence through cultural arts (WATE)
- 'Prevent it from spreading' Measles survivor encourages vaccination after case confirmed in Tennessee (WATE)
- Police investigating Knoxville auto shop that customers say held cars for months or years (WATE)
- Anakeesta begins spring season with improvements to ADA accessibility (WATE)
- Ijams River Rescue volunteers remove 17.2 tons of trash, find unusual items during Tennessee river cleanup (WBIR)
- Democratic lawmakers propose 'Pot for Potholes Act,' allowing recreational marijuana sales in TN to increase road repair revenue (WBIR)
- TN Congressman John Rose announces plans to run for governor in 2026 (WBIR)
- Knox Co. to pay woman $71K in lawsuit over Sheriff's Office posting mugshot of her without religious headscarf (WBIR)
- 'He treats everyone respectfully and with kindness' | Pigeon Forge High School students praise their SRO (WBIR)
- Tennessee residents face debris woes after Hurricane Helene's impact (WBIR)
News Sentinel
State News
- Hamilton County sheriff spent nearly five weeks, over $5k on travel during past 14 months, records show - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Chattanooga proposes overhaul of tree ordinance - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- UTC junior guard Honor Huff’s conditioning pays off in NIT run - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Opinion: We don’t have to cater to public opinion - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
Wire Reports
- Trump Live Updates: Tariffs, Federal Layoffs and Greenland Backlash - The New York Times (US News)
- Jordan briefs Trump on plans to rein in federal judges - POLITICO (US News)
- Stock futures are little changed after major averages post back-to-back gains: Live updates - CNBC (Business)
- 23andMe is filing for bankruptcy. Here's what it means for your genetic data - NPR (Business)
- USPS head Louis DeJoy steps down as Trump officials consider Postal Service overhaul - NPR (US News)
- Surprising China news sends Tesla stock soaring - TheStreet (Business)
- Three blazes burn in North Carolina, part of wildfires in swath of eastern U.S. - The Washington Post (US News)
- Greenland’s government hits back at Donald Trump over US visit to Arctic island - Financial Times (US News)
- Ex-Meta VP Raised Back-to-Back Mega Funding Rounds for New Startup - Business Insider (Business)
- What is glioblastoma, the aggressive brain cancer that killed former US Rep. Mia Love? - The Associated Press (US News)
- Snoopy and 'Peanuts' pals are coming to Starbucks: See limited-edition cups - USA TODAY (Business)
- Hyundai, Trump announce $21 billion US investment, new steel plant - Reuters (Business)
- 23andMe has filed for bankruptcy. Here is how to delete your data. - Business Insider (US News)
- Trump Says He May Give A ‘Lot’ Of Tariff Breaks: Here’s What To Know About ‘Liberation Day’ As Reciprocal Tariffs Loom - Forbes (Business)
- Growth expectations plummet as fund managers mimic Buffett - Fortune (Business)
Local Media
Lost Medicaid Funding
Search and Archives
TN Progressive
Nearby:
- Blount Dems
- Herston TN Family Law
- Inside of Knoxville
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jim Stovall
- Knox Dems
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Outdoor Knoxville
- Pittman Properties
- Reality Me
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
Beyond:
- Nashville Scene
- Nashville Post
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Journal
- TN Lookout
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South
When do they traditionally
When do they traditionally have the roll call vote? The last night?
It's a good idea to have the vote and include Clinton and Edwards. It shouldn't be a problem. Obama claims the nomination, the crowds roar, all is well in the garden.
A Typical Day at the
A Typical Day at the Convention - Democratic National Convention
Nominee
No matter who I supported in the primary once it's over I go with the nominee.This ones over & Obama is the nominee.Therefore,I believe Clinton delegates should vote for Obama.
But as R's pointed out if you are a duly elected delegate you can vote for who you want & if delegates want put Clinton's name up & vote for her thats their right under the rules.
At the '68 Democratic Convention McCarthy & McGovern had 0 chance of winning but were placed in nomination for a cause.Ditto for Jackson @ the '84 & '88 Democratic Conventions.
On the other hand @ the '68 Republican Convention Rockefeller & Reagan were placed in nomination because they thought they could force a 2nd ballot & win.Ditto for HHH @ the'72 Democratic Convention & Reagan @ the '76 Republican Convention.
Clinton delegates can make the case for the cause of her being the first woman to have a real shot @ the presidency.If delegates want to pursue that they can.However,there is no chance of her winning.
But what Clinton folks must be very careful about is how many of her delegates are now actively supporting Obama & are going to vote Obama @ the convention.In my opinion if Clinton misplays her hand & is placed in nomination & only gets 4-500 votes it will hurt her.It could be Clinton is placed in nomination then,after the roll call,Senator Clinton from the floor(she is a super delegate)moves the nomination unanimouse.
Again it is every delegates right to vote for whoever they want but I believe when it's over it's over & this ones over.
I hear you, Bill, but a
I hear you, Bill, but a couple of points.
It's not over and there is no nominee. I will be on board with the nominee, too, when there is one. There won't be one until there is a vote at the convention.
Second, neither Clinton nor Edwards have formally withdrawn their name from consideration for the nomination.
Lastly, Obama does not have the votes yet. He has non-binding commitments of superdelegate votes.
I agree, however, that Obama will likely win the nomination. It should be on the up and up, though. If Clinton and Edwards want to formally withdraw their names from consideration beforehand, that's fine.
The fat lady's done sung her song.
R I really do think it's over.
However,you are correct under the rules there is no nominee & indeed delegates can vote for anyone they choose.That's what Kennedy argued in '80 & Hart in '84.
With respect to Edwards most if not all of his delegates have said they will vote Obama.Plus,most if not all super delegates have done the same.
If delegates vote for Clinton thats fine with me.But as I said if she misplays this & only gets a fraction of her "pledged" delegate vote it woud be bad for her.
Anybody that knows me knows once we have a nominee;local,state or national..I'm with em.Not everybody agrees & when I get behind a candidate,in a New York second,thats defeated a candidate I supported for the nomination..I've been called a turn coat or worse..but thats the way I roll.So I'm for Clinton delegates voting Obama.If others roll different thats fine.
R,I think the fat lady's done sung her song.
Obama will win the nomination.
Following the Rules...
I'm with you on following the rules, but "Fair" challenging of the current pledged delegate count doesn't necessarily equal "Untainted".
In an election where Party Unity might decide the election, an unnecessary challenge could be counterproductive, adding more controversy and fueling existing resentment.
Within the confines of the DNC rules, allow the Obama to go unchallenged, or with minimal symbolic challenge. Hillary Clinton could voluntarily make this happen, and the Clintons could begin to repair the wounds of a toughly fought primary, and their own place in history.
challenging of the current
challenging of the current pledged delegate count
Not sure I follow you there. I'm just saying there should be a roll call vote for the record. No candidate has a majority of pledged delegates.
I don't see how calling for a vote is an "unnecessary challenge," or how it's counterproductive, or a challenge at all. But it will put the debate to rest, and reinforce unity. That's just my opinion.
I agree on the last point that Clinton could make it all moot. But that's up to her, and she hasn't. (Although she is signaling that she's running for Senate in 2012 and has asked to be allowed to transfer general election campaign funds to that race, I believe.)
I agree. I don't quite get
I agree. I don't quite get all this media-driven hand-wringing regarding Democratic party unity.
If the GOP had had a close primary, would we be seeing all these doubts raised that the party would rally behind the nominee?
Brian A.
I'd rather be cycling.
Depends on the Split...
If you had a Libertarian-Right candidate who was fairly moderate on social issues and a Social Conservative candidate who was populist on economic issues standing as close in pledged delegates as Obama-Clinton, you wouldn't just be hearing about disunity, but about whether or not the whole party would split apart.
At its most bitter, the Obama-Clinton split was along identity lines. If that had played out differently, it could have been ruinous for the whole of the Democratic Party. By the end, though, the split was largely between blue collar moderates for Clinton and a progressive/African-American alliance for Obama because Democratic women voters didn't manage to form and hold together as a cohesive voting block. I don't think that's quite as dangerous a division and one more easily healed than an African-American versus Woman split.
McCain is the best possible GOP candidate to move on Hillary's supporters given his reputation as a moderate maverick, but I think there's just way too much Bush Baggage for him to overcome this year (at least I'm hoping so).
Because there weren't
Because there weren't significant policy differences between Obama and Clinton, I didn't make much of the rift. I guess I don't put as much stock into identity politics as some people do.
Brian A.
I'd rather be cycling.
Its Up To Hillary and Her Delegates
Here is the thing, they can't stop her. In 2004, two names were called, John Kerry and Dennis Kucinich. The DNC can't and won't change the rules so that only Barack Obama's name can be thrown out there. But what the other candidates can do, is refuse the nomination by the convention delegates, release them from their pledge, and ask them to support the presumptive nominee.
This decision won't be Pelosi, Dean, or Obama's, it'll be Hillary Clinton's. However, they'll probably not talk much about the issue until the convention, to save the Super-delegates from being inundated with calls from the Insanocrat Deadenders who think Hillary still has a shot at the nomination.
Pledges and then pledges
While it's true that elected delegates can vote however they choose, the campaigns take great pains to pick delegates who pledge strong loyalty to their candidate. So the sense in which a delegate is pledged is that the delegate himself/herself pledged support.
Party regulars have a lot to lose if they go their own way after a public vow of support. Clinton's supporters will remain firm if not released.
Insurgents have passion. Obama's supporters will remain firm, too, although the caucus processes may elect delegates who are a little more subject to changing their minds.
Liberty and justice for all.
My home
Dean Confirms Hillary Will
Dean Confirms Hillary Will Be On Ballot
FYI
Talked to a Clinton delegate yesterday.
Didn't think Hillary would be placed in nomination.
"She doesn't want that." was the way the Clinton
delegate put it.
2004 Convention
In 2004 I went to Boston as a pledged delegate for Edwards. Even though Kerry had secured the nomination, I still proudly cast my pledged vote for Edwards as a symbolic gesture for my support of Edwards.
It is the right of EVERY delegate to cast their vote. Although I support Obama, his campaign and the DNC have turned my stomach to think they will try to stop Democracy and not allow folks to cast their vote. As mentioned above, Obama does NOT have the nomination. He doesn't have the pledged votes to win. This is the big difference between now and 2004. And they are worried as they should be. It would only take a handful of delegates to change the outcome to Clinton. And quite frankly, if team Obama and the DNC keep trying to deny people the right to vote, I will gladly switch my vote to Clinton.
Oh, I seriously doubt
Oh, I seriously doubt Edwards will be on the ballot. He might not even be at the convention.