Sat
Oct 22 2022
06:45 am

As the population grows in the area new apartments are being built. It is a sight to see as these apartment buildings go up. There is anticipation as to how they will look when they are done. However, when watching a recent apartment complex going up in Alcoa, it looks like they are building tinderboxes.

Right across the street from the Alcoa apartment complex, a hotel is being built, Hilton Home 2 Suites. The hotel is being built of steel and concrete. It just looks safer for multi-housing.

The apartments are 3-4 stories and the hotel is 3-4 stories.

WoodbuiltApts_202210_B.jpg

ConcreteSteelbuilt_202209.jpg

I have to say this is not unique to Alcoa. There is a complex going up on Maloney Road, off of Alcoa Highway in South Knoxville, that has the same attributes.

Here is an article from Canada covering this topic, "WOOD VS. CONCRETE: HOW STRUCTURAL MATERIALS ARE CHOSEN." In British Columbia, "building code dictates that the majority of buildings above six storeys must be made from concrete due to its more sturdy and durable properties." Concrete buildings are more expensive. However, buyers and builders "should be mindful of how a building material may impact the long-term value of their new home and a resident’s budget. Concrete absorbs and retains heat and moderates temperature, reducing energy costs to those living within the home. Concrete buildings also tend to hold their value, proving to be a strong property investment choice. Due to the nature of wood, maintenance and heating costs will lean slightly higher compared to a concrete building."

jmcnair's picture

Texas Doughnuts

5 over 1 buildings
WikiPedia on 5 over 1

Bloomberg on why apts look the same.

Spoiler alert: it's money.

bizgrrl's picture

Thanks, good stuff. The ones

Thanks, good stuff. The ones in Alcoa, and I'm pretty sure the ones on Maloney, don't even get the 1 floor of concrete.

And, yes, all these new apartment buildings are looking the same. I would think there could be some variations to make things a little interesting without blowing the budget.

michael kaplan's picture

There are wood hotels being built too

This one is on Henley Street.

I remember when Haslam wanted to demolish the Holiday Inn on the World's Fair site. I told him it would never be replaced by anything built as well. So, it was sold and painted black.

preview_wood_hotel.JPG

bizgrrl's picture

That one surprises me even

That one surprises me even more being in a downtown area where in a more highly populated area they might have stronger building codes.

Are those wooden balconies? No steel reinforcement?

michael kaplan's picture

Yes, wooden balcomies

Looks like cantilevered 2 x 12 beams.

preview_wood_hotel2.jpg

Factchecker's picture

I've been hoping

I've been hoping cross-laminated timber would become a prominent building material of choice. There are some video pieces about its advantages: strength, fire resistance, and all-around environmental impact being three (IIRC). The main disadvantage is that it's limited by weight and strength to something like 12 floors, but that shouldn't be an issue around here. Still doesn't seem to be catching on, though.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives