Tue
Jun 16 2009
05:07 pm

In case you were away on vacation to Mars and out of Twitter range thus missing it, the latest Tennessee Republican racist brain fart has gone national, and once again puts Tennessee in the not-so-flattering spotlight.

continued...

At first blush, it's just more of the same old same old from Tennessee Republicans, who seem to view this kind of stuff as less of an embarrassment and more of an election strategy.

As desensitized as we may have become, owing to the unfortunate frequency of this sort of thing, it IS an embarrassment. And worse, an insult to the people of this state. We can only hope that all the corporate relocation consultants were on vacation to Mars and missed it.

One interesting point. Michael Silence posted the email headers shortly after the story broke yesterday. Note the date of the email - May 28th. Note that one of the recipients was Matt King. Matt King is the chief of staff for Sen. Ron Ramsey (R-Blountville), Senate Speaker, Lt. Governor, and Republican candidate for governor.

Lt. Gov. Ramsey waited until today (June 16th) to issue any kind of statement. And his only statement was that the written reprimand "punishment" issued to her staffer by Sen. Diane Black was adequate and appropriate. And that's that. (I guess that should come as no surprise, since the "blackbird mailer" smearing of House candidate Nathan Vaughn up there in his district was apparently appropriate, too.)

Waiting nearly a month to say anything suggests that a) Ramsey's chief of staff didn't see a problem so he didn't mention it, b) he did mention it but Ramsey didn't think it was any big deal, c) Ramsey has a tin ear when it comes to politics, which doesn't reflect well on his leadership abilities as a potential governor, or d) Ramsey only said something because a blogger exposed it to the light of day, forcing a reaction.

In fact, the email went out to at least seventeen Tennessee Senate Republican Caucus staffers, yet none of them appears to have brought it to the attention of their bosses in the state Republican leadership, or if they did their bosses didn't think it was a big deal.

Oh, and the TNGOP has yet to weigh in on, much less condemn, the email. Or the fact that the email was sent by a state government employee on state government time from a state government computer to other state government email addresses (all paid for by state taxpayers), all of whom work in the Legislative Plaza where our elected representatives are supposed to be representing ALL Tennessee citizens, black, brown, white, or otherwise.

Anyway, in the big scheme of things (such as Tennessee's as yet unresolved $1 billion budget shortfall) it may not be a big deal. The problem is, it's a pattern. It's a pattern going back to the Corker "Call Me" ad, the TNGOP "Obama is a Muslim anti-Semitic" attack ad and the "ashamed to be an American" attack on his wife (both of which gained national notoriety to the embarrassment of Tennessee), the "blackbird mailer," the Chip Saltsman "Barack the Magic Negro" Christmas CD (another national hit), and on and on and on.

And it has distracted attention from the real problems in our state, such as that aforementioned $1 billion budget shortfall, more than a million without health care, 10% unemployment, and the tragic inability for residents to carry their guns with them into bars and onto little league playgrounds.

At any rate, props to Newscoma for breaking the story.

P.S. There have been calls for the termination of Sen. Diane Black's assistant, Sherri Goforth, a twenty year employee, for forwarding the email. I have mixed feelings about that. Perhaps a better response would be a week or two suspension without pay to give her time to reflect, plus some mandatory sensitivity training. In my view, it's a "teaching moment" opportunity to turn someone around v. making them a right-wing martyr.

UPDATE: Liberadio: Resetting the Tone at the Capitol

Please urge Senator Black to grab hold of this moment, get creative, and work with other members of the General Assembly to send the message to their staffers that racism - no matter how casual - is not OK.

Elrod's picture

Teaching moment?

She should be tarred and feathered. Literally.

glostik's picture

CNN tomorrow

CNN just interviewed Chip Forrester regarding this email...see it tomorrow morning at 6:24 and 7:30. I hope he blasts them in to oblivion!

EricLykins's picture

More bad behavior from South

More bad behavior from South Carolina Republicans as well...

Virgil Proudfoot's picture

Nowhere near as embarassing as the Ol' Perfesser

These Republican staff Tweets are awful, but they are nowhere near as embarassing as the Ol' Perfesser, aka Instapundit, who openly spouts his ignorant nonsense right out in the open, 24/7. He has better table manners, of course, and carefully avoids outright racism, but his promotion of provincialism and Know-Nothingism should shame UT and the rest of its faculty to their core.

bobbylife's picture

Huh?

No, Goforth's little joke is really gross, and the party's reluctance to roundly condemn it is wrong and shortsighted, and therefore very much in keeping with the sad state of the GOP in TN. I don't know that Reynolds has ever joined in the same kind of execrable dipsh*ttery.

Reynolds is certainly an ideologue. He may advocate federalism, but he's hardly provincial. If you're saying he's an ignorant embarrassment just because you don't agree with him, you're painting with awfully broad strokes.

And "Know-Nothingism?" Are you suggesting that he's an old-school nativist, or just, again, that he's ignorant? Or are you really saying that Reynolds is just a crypto-racist who gets away with it because of his politesse? If the latter, I've never picked up on it and I think you're wrong.

Interesting but unsubstantiated accusations. Please elaborate.

cafkia's picture

I think it would be

I think it would be appropriate both to fire the young lady and to view this as a teaching moment. This could well be used as justification to spend some time on training throughout the legislature. However, if anyone is to believe that anything more than lip service is to be paid, steps up to and including loss of a job for Ms Goforth and any others with strong culpability is a reasonable step.

----------------------------------------------------------- 

It is impossible to defeat an ignorant man in argument.
  - William G. McAdoo

KC's picture

And at the national level,

And at the national level, the GOP continues to improve its image
(link...)

KC's picture

Adding the above with the

Adding the above with the hate email sent by the Republican staffer, which with the Holocaust Museum terrorist attack, simply compounds this problem for the GOP:

Demographically, the forces at work have chipped away at what was once a GOP-leaning majority in the country. The most important is minorities' rising share of the vote. Whites accounted for 76 percent of the overall electorate last November, down from 85 percent in 1988.
(link...)

And this one too:

There was much attention paid to Obama's trouble winning the votes of white working-class voters. The bad news for Republicans is that these voters represent a declining share of the electorate.
(link...)

What Republicans need to understand, and quickly IMO, is that the little squalid instances like the hate email, if not resolved quickly, openly, and decisively by doing the right thing, will simply add to an image that is far less appealing, if not downright appalling, to many of the voters that Republicans will need in the future.

Obama may appeal to younger voters, but their shift toward the Democrats predates his candidacy. "This really is not Obama," Keeter said. "Young voters were John Kerry's best age group. They were the Democratic candidates' best age group in the 2006 elections, and they were the best age group for other Democratic candidates in 2008."

Younger voters are more diverse demographically than older voters. In 2008, 62 percent were white, compared with 74 percent eight years earlier. Projections show young voters will become increasingly diverse. They are also less religious and more culturally liberal, two indicators of Democratic support.

GOP strategist Mike Murphy described this in Time magazine as a coming Republican ice age. Republicans will need a major shift to begin to reverse these trends. That could start if there is a backlash against Obama's governance -- and the president's agenda certainly will test the country's tolerance for a big dose of government. But Republicans will need to retool in other ways to make themselves more appealing to a changing population. That debate has barely begun.
(link...)

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives