Mon
Sep 4 2006
01:56 am

Surprised nobody has mentioned this email that's circulating:

From: Scott West [mailto:booking@preservationpub.com]
Sent: Saturday, September 02, 2006 1:41 PM
Subject: A REQUEST FOR A LETTER ON BEHALF OF BERNADETTE AND SCOTT WEST

Dear friends and family of Bernadette and/ or Scott West,

As you may already know, Bernadette and Scott West have been charged with a federal offence involving money laundering. Further, Scott West has been charged with marijuana trafficking. Bernadette will and Scott has entered a plea of guilty to these charges, but neither has yet been sentenced by the court. We ask that you help us in our efforts to convince the Honorable Judge Thomas W. Phillips to find it in his wisdom to be as lenient in his sentencing of each as is possible. Bernadette and Scott love this community and wish to return to their friends and family as quickly as possible. Will you please help by writing a letter for Bernadette and/ or Scott West to:

The Honorable Judge Thomas W. Phillips
United States District Court, Eastern District of Tennessee
Howard Baker, Jr. U.S. Courthouse
800 Market Street, Suite 145
Knoxville, TN 37902

Do not mail the letters directly to Judge Phillips, instead, return the letters to the following addresses:

For Scott West: For Bernadette West:

Donald A. Bosch, Esq. David M. Eldridge

THE BOSCH LAW FIRM Eldridge & Blakney, P.C.

712 S. Gay Street 900 Gay Street, Suite 1404

Knoxville, TN 37902 Knoxville, TN 37902-1838

Please write and mail the letters immediately (no later than September 25, 2006), so that we may attach them to the Sentencing Memorandums that will be filed on each of their behalves.

When writing your letter, please identify yourself. Tell Judge Phillips who you are with respect to your relationship with Bernadette and/ or Scott and what you do for a living. Include information about civic positions you have held or activities in which you have participated. Also, explain how you know Bernadette and/ or Scott and for how long you have been acquainted, and the nature of your contact with them over the past few years.

In addition, let Judge Phillips know that you are aware that Bernadette and Scott have been charged with this offence. It will not be appropriate to make any comment about your feelings of either Bernadette or Scott’s guilt or innocence. Most importantly, you should tell Judge Phillips why you believe they are worthy of receiving leniency. You may wish to emphasize their characters, backgrounds, upbringing, scholastic achievements, contributions and commitment to the community, hard work, devotion to family, hardship that they and their families have already suffered as a result of this case, or any other factor that you believe to be positive and truthful. You may handwrite this letter.

As long as these guidelines are followed, the structure of the letter is unimportant. Please be sincere and candid. If you know particular examples to illustrate points you are trying to make about either Bernadette or Scott’s character or contributions to the community, please include them in the letter. Being specific increases the persuasiveness of your appeal.

Writing this letter is VERY IMPORTANT. Judge Phillips is conscientious and will read and consider every letter he receives. Bernadette and Scott are in an extremely difficult situation and respectfully ask for your help.

You may pass this letter on to other friends and supporters.

Thank you

R. Neal's picture

Heard about that but never

Heard about that but never got one. Guess I'm not on the A-list.

Wonder how many letters they'll get from City Hall?

I'm too busy to write one. I'm still trying to figure out how many years I will have to work to pay the $800,000 or so in taxes they dodged.

Anonymous's picture

well I posted my opinion and

well I posted my opinion and it was removed- The WESTS are criminals and deserve to go to jail. They have done nothing for Knoxville but take advantage of the taxpayers and their goodwill. They are criminals. Their GREED and EGOS are why they have this problem. How much have taxpayers lost already?

R. Neal's picture

well I posted my opinion and

well I posted my opinion and it was removed- The WESTS are criminals and deserve to go to jail. They have done nothing for Knoxville but take advantage of the taxpayers and their goodwill. They are criminals. Their GREED and EGOS are why they have this problem. How much have taxpayers lost already?

Well Mr./Ms. Anonymous, your first post was removed because it violated the terms of service (see the part about libelous statements, etc.). Anyway, it's for your own protection. Keep violating the terms of service and we'll keep removing your posts.

This post is a little better. At least it doesn't appear to be actionable.

But your previous post also said everybody here was apologizing for them or something to that effect. I just scanned through the comments on this post, and I guess I don't see that at all. Are you sure you are at the right forum? Who are you? What's your agenda?

Anonymous's picture

I find it hard to ask for

I find it hard to ask for leniency for a drug dealer. I could understand getting busted for selling a few dime bags but this is a whole different matter. Dont drop the soap Scott.

Anonymous's picture

Do no such thing!

This was about $. They participated in a trade that is illegal: the "harmless" drug trafficing involves money, guns, corruption, prostitution. Law enforcement officers are killed over this...the ill-gotten gains also fund terrorism / wars.

Anonymous's picture

While not condoning drug

While not condoning drug trafficking and the secondary ill effects of it, it should be noted that every time you gas up your car, you're paying into a revenue stream that supports terrorism and wars, and the significant gray area at the fringes of the oil industry probably also cause/fund/support the other undesireable effects mentioned.

Scott and Bernadette indeed are pleading to offenses that are destructive to individuals and society. As noted in the request for letters to the judge, no one is being asked to comment on the morality or legality of that. It would seem that the letters are simply to give the judge some context in which to judge the appropriate punishment for the drug and financial wrongdoing.

If you haven't been friends of the Wests, or enjoyed their hospitality, or patronized their businesses with a sense of happiness that they simply existed on the square, then by all means don't write a letter. If you've never screwed up and wished that those judging you would also consider your positive accomplishemnts, don't write a letter. On the other hand, maybe it's not a bad thing to think about writing a note to the judge if those things apply to you.

I am sorely disapointed in Scott and Bernadette over this. I also know they've done some good things, too. I don't know for certain if I will write a letter as requested, but I'm certainly thinking about it.

rikki's picture

All outstanding reasons to

All outstanding reasons to normalize and regulate the marijuana market and use tax revenues to fund treatment and mitigation for whatever ill effects are due to the drug itself, and not the black market on which it is traded.

(Which has nothing to do with the Wests. In fact, that approach would destroy their business model.)

redmondkr's picture

I'm afraid I'm going to have

I'm afraid I'm going to have to pass on this one as well.  Just as Rhett Butler told Scarlett she was just like the thief who wasn't a bit sorry he stole, just sorry he was caught.

"Frankly, my dear, I don't give a damn."

Les Jones's picture

Why?

The Wests have done a lot to stimulate downtown development, but that's not a free pass for criminal behavior.

Even if like me you think marijuana prohibition should end, that doesn't excuse drug dealers. As rikki noted, they aren't warriors against drug laws - they personally benefit from those laws. I've yet to see anyone claim the Wests were driven to a life of crime by poverty.

We ate at Oodles Friday for lunch and it was very good, but if good food were a criminal defense the Mafia would own the best Italian restaurants. 


Hey, Les, why don't we just call each other assholes and get it over with. - Somebody on the old Southknoxbubba.net (if that was you, claim your quote and win net.fame!)

Bbeanster's picture

Back in 2001, I had many

Back in 2001, I had many conversations about the Wests' overnight successes, particularly when the Preservation Pub opened and became THE downtown spot to be, siphoning business off MacLeod's, and maybe other establishments. I was very skeptical when they started buying up buildings left and right, particularly when the Pub advertised that a portion of their profits were being donated to "community."

The argument I got back mostly had to do with competition and free marketplaces.

Meanwhile, Scott and Bernadette supported the Powers That Be in most all respects -- opposing the downtown hotel referendum and supporting the sale of the Candy Factory come to mind right off the top of my head. Bill Haslam had a fund raiser at Pres Pub, and the Wests were held up as a success story (often in comparison to people like Susan and John Key, who were considered bad "team players" for questioning the party line). They were extremely adroit at self-promotion and were rewarded with tons of uncritical, even fawning press from the KNS and Metropulse.

They benefitted from whatever government perks were available (although it has been pointed out to me that the workmanship bestowed upon them was not always top drawer) and, whether people want to admit it now or not, Scott West became the poster boy for the resurgence of downtown. Meanwhile, they were chronically behind on their taxes.

It will be interesting to see if those businesses continue to flourish sans the infusion of drug money.

I do feel very sad when I see Scott's father and cannot imagine how tough this must be for him. For his sake, I hope Oodles makes it.

Stacey's picture

The Wests and morality

I hope the above posters on a high horse never legally drank beer in their establishments or others. I wonder how many deaths beer, ciragettes and McDonalds have caused as opposed to pot. I don't think any good can come from The Wests, good, free-spirited people, getting years in prison or for others who have committed "victimless" crimes. I'm for legalizing drugs and I'm not at all interested in doing them. The whole thing saddens me. I've enjoyed their clubs and stores for years. Stacey

Hildegard's picture

Well, I'm in favor of

Well, I'm in favor of legalized dope and I would smoke it. Having said that, I'm getting a little weary of the Scott-on-a-Cross theme. People write about his and Bernadette's plight like they were fighting in the French Resistance, or tunneling slaves to freedom before the Civil War. They were promoting their own interests, just like businessmen do. Which is fine. One of the residual effects of that business was glamorizing downtown. Which is great. They made money, and I guess, if helping people get high or drunk is a form of human benediction, they were true patrons of spiritual growth.

I'm sorry anybody has to do federal time, because it is not easy time. And I don't blame anybody for seeking mitigation through letters. There's nothing wrong with finding all the help you can get, and I hope they find enough support to earn them the mitigation in their sentences that they seek.

But it's pretty naive to assume that the drug trade is victimless, or that any "good" comes from anybody's incarceration.

samH's picture

drug trade

I don't know that anyone would suggest that the drug trade is victimless, but one must admit that the use of pot and many other currently illegal drugs is certainly victimless apart from the user. The dangers of the drug trade are directly tied to the war on drugs and the illegal position of those drugs. Take away the prohibition and most all dangers of the drug trade would disappear. To argue otherwise is to buy into the fog of dishonesty that shrouds all conversation about drugs and drug use.

R. Neal's picture

The dangers of the drug

The dangers of the drug trade are directly tied to the war on drugs and the illegal position of those drugs. Take away the prohibition and most all dangers of the drug trade would disappear. To argue otherwise is to buy into the fog of dishonesty that shrouds all conversation about drugs and drug use.

That pretty much sums up the War on Drugs. And it's a good argument for declaring Victory in the War on Drugs and freeing the Prisoners of War. Just like we should declare Victory in Iraq and bring our soldiers home (what with Saddam being in jail and the WMDs and nuclear drones being "found" and/or neutralized, etc.)

But that's not all that this is about. It's also about the City of Knoxville's involvement in these deals, and the character of the people they do business with, and who they and the local media ordain as champions of downtown revitalization while ignoring others who make legitimate investments and struggle to help make it work.

Not to mention the money laundering and related tax dodging (that Mike West mentioned in taped conversations transcribed by the press) for which every U.S. taxpayer bears the burden.

Not to mention the City's and who knows who else's apparent intervention with the U.S Justice Department to keep these businesses "vital" in spite of their source of illegal funding, because image is everything, and downtown can't survive without this type of business and investment?

What kind of message does this send to legitimate business people busting their butts to make an honest go of it on Market Square and Downtown?

At any rate, I hate to see anyone get their lives so screwed up. But as my late Brother-in-Law said, if you can't do the time don't do the crime.

Up Goose Creek's picture

Cry for help

I seem to remember 3-4 months ago someone posted on Knoxblab how one of their employees had betrayed them and now they were going to be in big trouble. I remember getting the sense that the practical advice being given didn't match the sense of doom the original poster was conveying.

Was that a case of foreshadowing in the quirky drama that is our town?

Les Jones's picture

How discreet were the Wests

How discreet were the Wests about their drug dealing? I'm hearing maybe not so much. As in, if you worked in one of their restaurants for a while you probably knew about it. 


Hey, Les, why don't we just call each other assholes and get it over with. - Somebody on the old Southknoxbubba.net (if that was you, claim your quote and win net.fame!)

smalc's picture

I do feel very sad when I

I do feel very sad when I see Scott's father and cannot imagine how tough this must be for him. For his sake, I hope Oodles makes it.

I went to school with their younger sister, I hope she is not tied up in the whole mess.

Bbeanster's picture

KNS catches up w/this story today

bizgrrl's picture

I thought this statement was

I thought this statement was a little quick on the draw, "Beginning today, he is a convicted dope peddler ".  They might have waited until he actually was a convicted dope peddler.

Jamie Satterfield's picture

He already had signed a plea

He already had signed a plea agreement prior to today's court hearing so not so "quick on the draw."
Also, Betty, this story was written last week and held until today, so this reporter was aware of the email but cannot control when editors seek to run things.

Toad In The Hole's picture

Redevelopment of Market Square is not a Defense to Selling Dope

no more than being engaged in downtown development entitles you to loot the City of Knoxville treasury and have all that you want.

Being engaged in downtown redevelopment is no more a credential than developing beach property, developing strip centers in Turkey Creek, or developing mountainside retreats in Sevier County.

A crime is a crime and the Wests need not be placed in maximum security, nor should they be given any extended time in jail, but the crime they committed is as eggregious as what Tommy Austin did, if not trading on the public trust, they were trading on the public treasury and washing dollars through a business that otherwise would have failed on Market Square a long, long time ago.

R. Neal's picture

Yes, but theoretically he

Yes, but theoretically he could have changed his mind at the hearing and told the prosecutors to go to hell and told the judge he wanted a jury trial. And then punched the court reporter for good measure. But of course, that wouldn't be prudent.

At any rate, your story did note that his e-mail says he had already entered a guilty plea. And now it's official.

Stacey's picture

The Wests

IMO, as a journalist, I hate the way Jamie is so flippant(?) in her stories, she seems to go out of her way to make someone getting several years in prison seem like a joke, like the "dope dealer" remark, wasn't his brother the dealer anyway, her delighting in using gang members nicknames etc. Sometimes crime isn't funny. On other news, I'm ready for hearings on the Ragsdale administration. Stacey

Bbeanster's picture

--Also, Betty, this story

--Also, Betty, this story was written last week and held until today, so this reporter was aware of the email but cannot control when editors seek to run things.--

Jamie, I figured as much, which is why I didn't say "Satterfield caught up with the story."

I probably should've stuck up for you, though. You are a good reporter covering an absolutely huge beat.

Jamie Satterfield's picture

I appreciate that, Betty,

I appreciate that, Betty, and forgive the whine. I normally don't give a hoot what anyone is saying as long as I'm doing my job, which I am in the West case. It just sometimes gets frustrating to be so publicly judged.

Old Hickory's picture

The NS story was hard hitting and did not have the fluff

that the earlier stories had when the indictments were announced and the nature of the description of West was more than accurate and made up for the earlier references of West as a "prominent businessman".

Prominent businessmen do not launder their brother's drug money through their business.

Prominent is a word which indicates that the subject is somewhat anchored in what he has been doing and has risen to this position over time. Neither of which apply to West although there are a number of good people doing good things on Market Square.

In the food and drink business in Knoxville, Mike Chase, Mike Conley, and Bill Regas are prominent.

Number9's picture

There need to be changes at the Knoxville News Sentinel.

I normally don't give a hoot what anyone is saying as long as I'm doing my job, which I am in the West case. It just sometimes gets frustrating to be so publicly judged.

I do not find any problems with Jamie's article on Scott West. I do not see that the problems with the Knoxville News Sentinel are with the reporters. They can only have articles printed that the editor and publisher approve. But there are serious problems at the daily paper.

The dichotomy between the sympathy for the Wests and the apathy towards Mayor Ragsdale's possible criminal actions is difficult to understand. What has happened to this town? An appeal is made for leniency for a “benevolent drug dealer” while the County Mayor does his imitation of Watergate and there is outrage over the reporting on the drug dealer? Are we that messed up in this town?

There need to be changes at the Knoxville News Sentinel.

Anyone can make a complaint to the Knoxville News Sentinel Ethical Program Director. The number is 1-888-397-4911. If you choose not to leave your name a identification number will be issued.

The Scripps Code of Ethics can be found here:

(link...)

The hands off non-reporting of the County Mayor seems to violate the following section of the Scripps Code of Ethics:

POLITICAL ACTIVITY
The Company remains independent in all political matters and will not make monetary contributions, directly or indirectly, to political campaigns or causes, or to political parties. Moreover, its officers will not make such contributions acting on behalf of the Company. Rare exceptions may be made to this prohibition, but then only if permitted by law and approved by the President of the Company.

Although the Company is independent in all political matters, employees are encouraged to register to vote, with party affiliations, and to vote. Employees may pursue their own personal political activities, but may not, either inadvertently or intentionally, represent their personal views or contributions to be those of the Company. Employees must avoid any suggestion that their relationship with the Company constitutes an endorsement of any kind.

Journalists and others working in newsrooms must abide by a more restrictive standard, given the disinterested neutrality from which news organizations must work. They must not serve in elected or politically appointed positions. They must not participate in political fund-raising, political organizing, nor other activities designed to enhance a candidate, a political party or a political-interest organization. They must not make contributions of record to political campaigns nor engage in other such activity that might associate an employee's name with a political candidate or a political cause.

Bbeanster's picture

The Wests enjoyed a long run

The Wests enjoyed a long run as downtown media darlings, mainly due to their own relentless self-promotion and willingness to support TPTB in all things -- compounded by always uncritical and often fawning media coverage. They developed a loyal following, and that crowd resents them being called what they are. There is a classic case of shoot the messenger going on (not on this forum, but elsewhere), and Jamie Satterfield has done nothing but her job.

Jamie has done some very important work over the past decade and gets far too little credit. I wish there were a dozen more like her.

redmondkr's picture

The Wests' situation seems

The Wests' situation seems to be an exaggerated symptom of much of today's business attitude where getting caught in an ethically or legally challenged state is just a chance taken in the normal course of doing business.  Funds for the payment of fines or settlements are then simply a part of the business' overhead to be passed along to the consumer.   An ethical business model would lessen the need for such a contingency, but would adversely affect the profit margin.  You just have to plan on not getting caught.

An example would be the case of GM a few years back.  Their studies showed that a few dollars per pickup truck would have solved the problem of potential fuel tank fires during collisions.  Apparently somebody decided that the possible payout the company would incur from damage lawsuits would be somewhat less than the cost of properly protecting the fuel tanks.

Anonymous's picture

Peas in a pod

I'm not surprised by this solidarity between Betty Bean and Jamie Satterfield. Editorializing within her news "reporting" is what Betty does for a living. Everyone knows that, but some forgive her for it because they perceive her as providing some kind of watchdog service over the powers that be. The fact remains that news reporting should be done without sensationalizing or, as Ms. Satterfield might put it, "razzle-dazzling" the reader. And as for the Tyler Harber reporting, Betty doesn't like Mike Ragsdale and neither does her publisher. They found a guy (one with extremely dubious credibility) willing to help them grind their axe and they provided him the column inches in which to do it. There was not a single tough question put to Tyler Harber. Just space made available for his rant, with a few snipes at Ragsdale from the "reporter" thrown in.

Further, Betty doesn't like Scott and Bernadette West. She's been trashing them and Market Square all over town for years. And now she gets to say, "I told you so."

Oh, and one last thing, Satterfield's comment above about how it can hurt when you're criticized so publicly is classic. Don't ya think?

JaHu's picture

"Betty doesn't like Mike

"Betty doesn't like Mike Ragsdale and neither does her publisher."

Finding out that Mayor Ragsdale was alegedly chucking legitimate petitions in the trash to stop resistance to an unpopular wheel tax should make anyone upset with the mayor, or at least, feel a little betrayed. I'm surprised that you are in support of this. Anonymous... by any chance, are you profiting from the wheel tax?

Goo's picture

I will write a letter the

I will write a letter the West have helped me out a few times. There good folks all naysayers well who's going to help you when the chips are down.

Stacey's picture

help

I agree that they at least deserve a letter and they are more than this act and who hasn't needed help sometime. I was totally attacked by some Democrat politicos after sending out a request to help them, some comments along the lines of we shouldn't help these awful drug dealers. Meanwhile Democrats sure do take donations from lawyers who make their money off helping the Wests and people like them. Its called HYPOCRISY. Stacey

zoomfactor's picture

You just have to plan on not

You just have to plan on not getting caught.

The problem is, as one gets used to the ratcheting up of "lifestyle", carelessness sets in. This was evident to me by the cases that were presented over 18 mo. as I sat in on the federal grand jury. Believe me, they only go after the absolute, lowest-hanging fruit. If a lawbreaker can just maintain "control" as crime is carried out, I am pretty sure they could continue on in that way indefinitely.

Patrick_WKnox's picture

Need our Help?

I do agree that Scott and Bernadette have contributed a lot to the community with their businesses, however, that does not excuse the fact that they were also doing behind the scenes illegal activity, and tax evasion. Their acts not only hurt the reputation on Market Square, but as well hurt all the other local tax payers that have to make up the taxes which they evaded. In addition, how much was lost having to pursue this violation by authorities, and other ramnifications. They definately need to step up, accept their guilt and do their time without lieniency.

lotta's picture

House of Cards

I was wondering when we would hear from the regular folks....


(link...)

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives