Sun
Feb 2 2014
10:56 am

With the disclaimer that I do not know my Sixth District School Board opponent Brad Buchanan, that he appears well-qualified for the office he seeks, and that it also appears he and I share similar views on public education, I'd like to offer some instructive comment to him and likely to other first-time school board candidates to advise that there is no co-orelation between school board voting districts and school zones.

When I read Mr. Buchanan's press release appearing on Mike Donila's Screams From the Porch Blog, it appeared that some of his text sought to distinguish the circumstances of his family's zoned schools and of his children's ages from my own circumstances, here:

Brad and his wife are the proud parents of four children. Two attend Amherst Elementary and their oldest is at Karns Middle School, both District 6 schools. Their youngest will soon enough be following in his older sisters’ footsteps. Having children currently in Knox County schools provides a unique perspective.

I wondered, then, if Mr. Buchanan (and possibly other first-time candidates) was aware that many families within our Sixth School Board District are not zoned for the schools that are specifically represented by the Sixth District school board member? This is because school board districts are determined by voting precinct boundaries, not by school zone boundaries. That is, school board districts must be balanced across the county in a manner that allocates voter populations equally, not school populations equally.

For example, to the east end of the Sixth District, families in this voting district are zoned to attend Powell Elementary and Powell Middle schools, although their school board member will not specifically represent these schools.

Similarly, to the south of the Sixth District, families in this voting district are zoned to attend Cedar Bluff Elementary and Cedar Bluff Middle schools, although their school board member will not specifically represent these schools, either.

Finally, to the south and west of the Sixth District, families in this voting district are zoned to attend Farragut Primary, Farragut Intermediate, Farragut Middle, and Farragut High, although their school board member will not specifically represent these schools, either.

That's eight schools not specifically represented by the Sixth District school board member which the district's families may nevertheless be zoned to attend.

In fact, the only reason even more families are not zoned for even more schools beyond just these eight lying outside the district boundaries is because this particular district abuts the Anderson County line to the north and the Loudon County line to the west.

In other school board districts more centrally located within the county, families on all four sides of a given district will be zoned for schools not specifically represented by that district's school board member, which may well amount to their being zoned for ten or twelve schools lying outside the district's boundaries.

A school board member, though, is charged with representing every constituent living within the boundaries of his voting district.

As for the ages of my children, it is precisely because I have brought two children through the Knox County Schools system that I have been a public school parent long enough to see my representation change following redistricting in response to first the 2000 and next the 2010 Census. I consequently know the process well.

jranagel's picture

Everyone knows this

Anyone that can read zoning maps knows what you pointed out. I know Brad, and I know he is very aware of this. He chooses to focus on test anxiety over excessive testing and selling our kids to big businesses as data points! The point he was making was education has changed so much in the last 5 years that unless you have a student in school right now and see what it is doing to our children, it is hard to fully grasp.

jandscam's picture

Buchanan

As a close friend of the Buchanan family and a District 6 constituent, Mr. Buchanan is very clear on District 6 boundaries. Mr. Buchanan educated me about the differences between school zones and district boundaries as I sat in the kitchen with him and his lovely family just two weeks ago. Mr. Buchanan does not need to be schooled on such a matter as where his constituents live.

jandscam's picture

Buchanan

As a close friend of the Buchanan family and a District 6 constituent, Mr. Buchanan is very clear on District 6 boundaries. Mr. Buchanan educated me about the differences between school zones and district boundaries as I sat in the kitchen with him and his lovely family just two weeks ago. Mr. Buchanan does not need to be schooled on such a matter as where his constituents live.

Tamara Shepherd's picture

*

Yes, I was heartened to learn that Mr. Buchanan is a candidate also attuned to these issues of excessive testing and encroaching privatization. I do hope there are several of us, likeminded, to arise in every voting district!

This post I share only to advise any candidate not aware of this lack of co-relation in boundaries that it exists and also to encourage all candidates to approach their campaigns with a commitment to serve all their respective districts' constituents.

Unfortunately, my family has been in this position of living outside the district in which our children's zoned schools lie since redistricting over a decade ago, in 2001.

In districts across the county, the many families positioned as we are have long wanted to feel assured that our elected representatives recognize us as their constituents, too.

Here's to a spirited discussion of this and the many other issues important to Knox County Schools among the 22-and-counting candidates yet in the fray, Best of luck to Mr. Buchanan.

Bradley Buchanan's picture

School zones and voting district

Wow, I honestly didn't think that a factual statement about where my kids attend school would raise questions. Here's the answers to any questions that could arise from that statement. I live in District 6. My children do attend schools represented by the District 6 BOE representative and as a matter of fact are zoned to attend schools represented by the District 6 representative.

It is true that you can have children that attend a school that is represented by a school board representative you didn't have a chance to vote for or against. It is my intention, if elected, to represent anyone who comes to me with their concerns or wishes. This could mean connecting them with their representative or serving as a go between for someone that may not be comfortable taking issues to their representative. While the voting zones are important, they are not more important than seeing that our kids have access to a quality education.

For those interested, if you wish to see what your school board voting district is, enter you address at this link (link...) and to find your school district use this link (link...). If you are interested in seeing where the borders and are a visual person, like me, there are great maps available at (link...). Note that the School District maps and Political District maps are under two different sections on the left.

These two zones come together in what is defined as the schools represented by the individual members. Here's the link to the main BOE page, (link...) where you can find the details on schools represented by clicking on the individual representatives.

If you would to learn more about me feel free to friend me on facebook, join my facebook group (link...) or visit (link...).

Thanks,
Brad Buchanan

Cece's picture

need to know

Brad, if you had been on the School Board for the McIntyre contract extension, how would you have voted?

If you are elected, will you vote to retain Dr. McIntyre?

In fairness, I will ask this of every candidate that comes on KnoxViews.

Tamara, I want to know from you too.

Dante's Beatrice's picture

Good questions Cece

Mr Buchanan I ,like Cece, would like to know if you had been on the School Board for the McIntyre contract extension, how would you have voted? Also,If you are elected, will you vote to retain Dr. McIntyre? Please don't seek a sophistry of parsing to avoid a simple answer.Simple straight forward answers are always better than edu-babble and $1 million PR flackery.I looked at your links and did not see those answers.Please clear it up once and for all, right here .. right now.If I missed it, please indulge me here.Many of our harried and struggling teachers would like to have those questions answered ,and KV has been a major Samizdat for those in the Resistance.Thank you.

Bradley Buchanan's picture

Answers to the McIntyre questions

Simply stated No and No.

My continued discussions with students, parents, teachers and administrators have cemented these answers.

Please follow up at my website (link...) as I will be posting more there including the video from my campaign kickoff where you will learn more about me. Also, feel free to join my facebook group (link...) and post question there.

Tamara Shepherd's picture

*

(Sorry to have been so long responding, Cece, but my power has been out for over three hours...)

No, I would not have voted to extend Dr. McIntyre's contract, either, nor would I vote to retain him.

I think that such damage has been done to relations between school system administration and personnel and to schools' focus more generally in recent years, no healing is possible until Dr. McIntyre is dismissed

Unlike several hand-wringing school board members who lament that there’s nothing to be done to change our course, my distinct impression is that Dr. McIntyre in contrast does not care to do anything to change our course. In fact, he appears to me to be a willing cheerleader for our course.

That said, I want to explain that I perceive such twin votes to be largely symbolic.

Our more pressing need is to establish representative leadership ready to take what steps we can take locally to undo the damage already done.

Cognizant that a need exists to establish different representative leadership at the state and national levels, too (and especially to reauthorize ESEA), possible local remedies I've mulled are few and less-than-palatable, even to me. These do however include:

1) pursuing a lawsuit against the State Board of Education to argue the converse of teacher's complaints about the teacher evaluation model, namely that the school system is also injured by it because the model forces KCS to retain low performing teachers able to hide behind the higher TVASS scores of teachers in other subject areas and (previously) at other grade levels AND that since the Department of Ed is now urging evaluators' more consistent co-relation between observation scores and TVAAS scores, evaluators are now less able to flush out such low performing teachers via their weak observation scores, either, and

2) researching and replicating how it is a growing number of states and school districts nationally have been able to decline federal RttT monies and the constraints those monies impose.

I am especially guarded about this second of my proposals, as I don't know whether other states and districts have possibly found alternative revenue streams or been able to make spending cuts that largely safeguarded classroom and students? Might their methods be duplicated in Tennessee, already ranked 50th in per capita state spending on education?

The vast majority of we 22 to have announced for office are mad, but we must now turn our thoughts to possible solutions.

And as victors emerge among our races, my sincere hope is that we will all of us join in making the sacrifices required to implement them.

More ideas would be right on time, too.

Tamara Shepherd's picture

*

It is my intention, if elected, to represent anyone who comes to me with their concerns or wishes. This could mean connecting them with their representative or serving as a go between for someone that may not be comfortable taking issues to their representative.

Thanks for your response, Brad (if I may call you Brad?), and again I posted on this topic for the benefit of any and all candidates possibly not attuned to the fact that some of his prospective constituents may be zoned to attend 8 or 10 or 12 schools beyond just those he specifically seeks to represent.

But you say above that your response to such constituents, if elected, might be to connect them elsewhere or to serve as a go-between?

The point of my original post is simply that, if elected, you or I or any of our opponents seeking the seat should realize that it is one of US personally who will be such constituents' representative, no "connecting" or "going-between" required.

To cite other text in your press release, a school board candidate is not "set apart" nor any "obvious choice" for the office only for the reason that his residence happens to be zoned for one of the schools specifically assigned to the responsibility of that school board representative.

You may or may not be aware of the history of representation in our Sixth District, in particular, that has been marred over the last ten or twelve years by our prior representatives' lack of awareness on this very point.

In fact, at the time I see you bought your present home in the district, we had no school board representation at all--due entirely to a prior candidate's single-mindedness as to the narrow constituency he sought to represent.

It's just that I am someone watchful to ensure that such single-mindedness never again rear its ugly head in our district.

I hope you'll agree that a school board member personally represents every resident living in his district irrespective of where that resident is zoned to attend school, period.

Don Daugherty's picture

"I hate rude behavior in a man. I won't tolerate it."

Feel like I wandered right smack into the middle of a political campaign. Maybe I need to appoint myself the Campaign Etiquette Referee on KV. Characterizing someone as a nitwit because she makes an effort to point out something important to voters that you (purportedly) already know, or your friend knows, or your wife or cousin or dog or cat knows, is a bit over-the-top. It certainly doesn't give me a good first impression of Mr. Buchanan. There's no need to be rude. I appreciate Mr. B personally posting. Too bad it wasn't before a couple of his supporters moronically and needlessly tried to "defend" him.

Anyway, I do not know Ms. Shepherd well. We've had plenty of political differences through the years. She may have even campaigned against me once or twice. But from what I DO know about her, the one thing she is NOT is stupid. Ms. Shepherd has an intelligent, analytical, and thought-provoking mind and if she ever appears not to have a grasp of the facts, it sure isn't for lack of trying. She works hard to learn and know the facts. That's exactly the kind of person I'm looking for to be on the School Board.

Finally, take it from someone who has managed dozens of campaigns, been a party chair, and been a candidate, it would serve all candidates well for their supporters not to offend voters in the candidates' names, especially on a public blog. To quote Captain Woodrow Call: "I hate rude behavior in a man. I won't tolerate it."

Knox Observer's picture

WNFZ RobertTaylor

Teacher Robert Taylor will be on WNFZ 94.3 FM between 7:30 am to 8:00 am today.

(link...)

(link...)

Tamara Shepherd's picture

*

Knox, I missed Rob's interview this morning.

If you could possibly offer us a recap, I'd be interested to check in later today to read it.

Knox Observer's picture

It's on YouTube: (link...)

It's on YouTube:

(link...)

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives