Mon
Nov 3 2008
06:22 pm

A tearful Coach Phil Fulmer says farewell to UT Football with class and dignity during a just concluded press conference. Mike Hamilton and Jim Haslam should be ashamed by how this was handled.

But this is $80 million SEC Football, where the final score is measured by "what have you done for me lately?"

Teddy Roosevelt, 1910:

It is not the critic who counts; not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles, or where the doer of deeds could have done them better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood; who strives valiantly; who errs, who comes short again and again, because there is no effort without error and shortcoming; but who does actually strive to do the deeds; who knows great enthusiasms, the great devotions; who spends himself in a worthy cause; who at the best knows in the end the triumph of high achievement, and who at the worst, if he fails, at least fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who neither know victory nor defeat.

Fulmer will play out the season if he wants. The only explanation for the timing of this is to sell tickets for the last three games. For shame, for shame.

knoxvegas99's picture

Ditto

What Randy said.

Larry Van Guilder

Lisa Starbuck's picture

Bad Handling

It's a travesty the way this was done and it's shameful that business interests are driving it.

The players are really pissed that they didn't know first, and I don't blame them. They still have to play three more games and maybe a bowl game and this is a body blow.

Fulmer has done as much for UT and the community as anyone. He didn't deserve this after only two bad seasons.

Farmgirl's picture

Actually, It's been more

Actually, It's been more than two bad seasons...it's been two (most likely) losing seasons. TN Fans expect more than to just have a winning season.

I applaud Fulmer for the first 10 years of his head coaching time. I applaud him for what he's done for the program. But if you look at this program it's been in a decline for the last 6-8 years. The numbers speak for themselves and the analysis is out there.

We don't win at home the way we used to(against teams that count), we get high recruiting classes but can't develop them, we haven't been to a BCS bowl since the the National Championship. The only reason we played in the SEC title game last year was because other teams lost--and we haven't won the SEC title in that time either.

If Cutcliff hadn't come back this losing season would have happened right after the last one. This was coming. Losing Cutcliff and Trooper Taylor just exposed the rest of the staff.

I've followed this team for at least two decades and what bothers me the most is the way the current players behave (with only a few exceptions--Eric Berry being one). They have no discpline and don't seem to care. They don't respect the uniform. They make stupid penalties, laugh and joke on the sidelines after poor play and seem to give up over and over again. That's not UT football traditionaly.

I'm glad they did this now because Fulmer deserves to be honored at his last homecoming and his last home game and if they hadn't announced it now he would have been booed at both...by the few that did show up.

Now the stadium will be full of orange giving him the recognition he deserves for what he's done for the program. Now it's time to hand it to someone else to carry on the tradition and get the program back to where Fulmer once had it.

Brian A.'s picture

I expected this to come at

I expected this to come at the end of the season.

That said, there are pros and cons to either doing it now or in a month. There's merit to the argument that this is the best way to unify a divided fan base. If you wait until the end of the season, the last two home games would probably have been pretty ugly with boos and empty seats. Now fans can come out and show their appreciation for the coach.

As far as tickets go, a vast majority of them are already sold already.

I hate to see this happen to Fulmer, but the program was dying.

Brian A.
I'd rather be cycling.

R. Neal's picture

the program was dying.Yep.

the program was dying.

Yep. One NCAA Championship and two (don't recall exactly) SEC titles over seventeen years is not necessarily a legacy for a football program of UT's alleged "stature." But I don't track such things so who knows?

Funny, though, how Tennessee is content with mediocrity in so many fields except football.

You also have to wonder how much of UT's game is controlled from the AD's office and the luxury skyboxes v. coaches on the field.

Brian A.'s picture

OK, dying may have been a

OK, dying may have been a bit of an overstatement. But clearly it has ceased being competitive with the top tier SEC schools. I believe Fulmer's winning percentage against the top five SEC coaches in the 2000s is in the neighborhood of 30%. No SEC champsionships or BSC Bowls in 10 years. The best season I could see us having with Fulmer from here on out would be 8-4 or 9-3.

I do feel bad for Fulmer on a personal level. But it's worth noting he is contracted to receive a $6 million parting gift. If only most of us suffered such misfortune.

Brian A.
I'd rather be cycling.

KC's picture

I'll stick this here too. I

I'll stick this here too.

I don't think the excessive expenditures made by UT sports over the last few years are Fulmer's fault. Teams have bad seasons. It's a fact.

Financially speaking, UT sports shouldn't have expected the financial good times to go on forever, pouring more and more money into the department. I don't think the lack of conservative fiscal administration is Fulmer's fault. The fault is with the sports department's administration.

They're not worried about the coaching strategy for the future. They're worried about how they're going to justify all the expenditures. Look for a big name to replace Coach Fulmer, to grab the media attention back.

Opinari's picture

Sad.

I have never been so disgusted by a fan base as I am with ours. The message boards crawl with those who would dance on Coach Fulmer's grave. And lest they be forgotten, out come the 'Bama fans, once again on top, forever pissed that Coach Fulmer called them on their B.S. and (egad!) led to a pretty serious probation.

Fulmer wins three quarters of his games, a national title (we only have two in over 100 years, you know), a couple of SEC championships, averages nearly 10 wins per season. But in the world where gratification is expected instantly, and consistently, Coach Fulmer apparently didn't provide enough of that.

Yeah, maybe changes were needed. But the way this was handled, and the chorus of hurrahs emanating from the corners of the "internets" is simply bothersome. One of these days, we'll be wishing we had a coach who did so much for this university, with such dignity and class, and who didn't resort to paying recruits to get them to come here to do it.

Sad, indeed.

Nobody's picture

YES! That should be the

YES! That should be the reaction of every last UT fan in the area. It's not been all that great and the convicts he has had on his team is the great shame. I say right on to him leaving, why wait until the end of the season? I mean, look at the Johnny Majors debacle.

KO's picture

I think this Sports

I think this Sports Illustrated columnist provides a fair analysis of the situation.

www.herstonlaw.com

CathyMcCaughan's picture

Make judgements about the

Make judgements about the job performance, but not about the person. Phil Fulmer is a good person who has made a powerful impact in the mental health community.

colonel angus's picture

"What have you done for me lately?" indeed...

It is truly a shame that things have changed so much in college football. College football used to be about tradition and honor, not just about wins and losses. It used to be that a man who gave his all for his alma mater not only as a player but as a coach was appreciated and given the benefit of the doubt. But college football has just become a big business, and "what have you done for me lately?" is all that matters these days.

Whoever takes this job should definitely watch his back - this athletic department is obviously only concerned with wins and losses and dollar signs. Years of service to the coach's alma mater be damned.

(Note: I have been in a coma for 17 years. This is the first opportunity I have had to react to the athletic department's shameful handling of the firing of Coach Majors. This new-fangled internet thing is amazing, by the way.)

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives