Wed
Jan 27 2010
08:38 pm
By: R. Neal

Not sure how a bulky iPhone in a neutered notebook replaces an iPhone (or Droid) plus full-featured notebook or netbook. It's a cool looking toy, though, for the person who already has everything.

For those who think it's a Kindle Killer, think again. If you haven't seen e-ink you can't appreciate the difference between that and reading a backlit LCD*. Plus, the iPad requires a $data $plan for comparable access to e-books. The only threat to Kindle is Nook, and actually they validate each other.

(*Hint: Typical LCD static refresh rate: 60 to 75Hz. Typical e-ink static refresh rate: 0Hz.)

Topics:
R. Neal's picture

And another thought. It's

And another thought. It's bad enough that we've forgotten how to write. Now we're going to forget how to type. We'll be reduced to pointing to the banana or the orange. We are Devo.

Which reminds me of another thought. We were at a fast food drive-thru the other day, and they didn't have their sides listed in words. Just pictures. You could get the yellow bowl of glop, the brown bowl of glop, or the green bowl of glop. Only 99 cents more with the meal deal.

Andy Axel's picture

It may not be a Kindle

It may not be a Kindle killer, but it will at least put a sizable dent in Amazon's eBook market hegemony. If NPR was to be believed this morning, a number of publishers weren't happy with Amazon's "take-it-or-leave-it" approach to eBook terms & conditions.

And you have to admit: the functionality of a Kindle (i.e. you can access Amazon but nothing else with its wireless connection, no 3rd party apps) is fairly restricted by comparison. If nothing else, this move should get Amazon to license its Kindle API to allow for 3rd party development.

____________________________

Calling to the underworld. Come out of the cupboard, you boys and girls.

R. Neal's picture

Agreed, Amazon tried to

Agreed, Amazon tried to corner the market with a proprietary approach (and advanced the e-book tremendously in the process).

That's one reason I like the slightly more open Nook. (Plus the color LCD navigation pad/keyboard, and supporting a brick-and-mortar bookstore effort.)

And, you can download 3rd party ebooks to Kindle via your desktop. But then you give up the "free" (i.e. built in to the cost of the unit and the content) anywhere any time electronic distribution and then you're on the same playing field with iPad.

P.S. It just occurred to me, is iBooks next? Maybe this was the master plan setup for that.

P.P.S. Heh. Some smart dude already staked his claim. In 1999.

redmondkr's picture

And you have to admit: the

And you have to admit: the functionality of a Kindle (i.e. you can access Amazon but nothing else with its wireless connection, no 3rd party apps)

Actually you can access any web page on the net Free without searching for a WiFi hotspot. You can send and receive gmail from anywhere Sprint cell phone service is available, and Amazon foots the bill. Savings for this service alone will pay for a Kindle 2 in only a few months.

And third party Kindle apps are right around the corner.

Visit us at:

The Home

Andy Axel's picture

And third party Kindle apps

And third party Kindle apps are right around the corner.

And my point is that it took a serious competitive threat in order to make that happen.

It only took them, what, three years to release PDF support?

____________________________

Calling to the underworld. Come out of the cupboard, you boys and girls.

Factchecker's picture

I do want one, even if it's

I do want one, even if it's just a giant Touch or iPhone (the 3G version) and not really real portable without a backpack or big man-purse. I guess to surf easier around the house? OK, Apple's hooked me and I'm in a major consumer mode at the moment. (New big TV, etc.) Nice value, though. The 16GB version is only $100 more than my 16GB Touch was a year and a half ago. And that is one of my favorite toys ever. I've been wanting an internal mic and speaker my Touch ver. 1 lacks. Hmmm....

Opinari's picture

Mic

I've been wanting an internal mic and speaker my Touch ver. 1 lacks. Hmmm....

Does the iPad have an internal mic? I didn't see one when I watched the keynote. If so, that would be great for doing VoIP calls on this device (and finally, OS 3.2 supports VoIP).

Factchecker's picture

Oh, yes. The woman on NPR

Oh, yes. The woman on NPR called the screen an OLED and said it was pretty good as a reader. I don't think it's really an OLED--Apple calls it LED backlit "in-plane switching," whatever that means. They say it means ultra wide angle. Probably not as readable as e-ink but maybe one heckofa nice color display.

michael kaplan's picture

for those who like such

for those who like such things, there's an interesting demo video with steve jobs et al on the apple site.

Opinari's picture

iPad Thoughts

Plus, the iPad requires a $data $plan for comparable access to e-books.

I think you can download your books via WiFi, without a data plan. With a BT keyboard, this will make a nice device for those who just want to do email, internet and consume media.

I like that they are providing a new version of iWork for these devices, although I'd really like it if those would work on my iPhone.

Things missing from iPad v.1.0: multitasking, camera, HDMI outputs, USB, Flash in Safari, tethering to the iPhone, a provider that isn't AT&T, and notifications.

If I didn't already have a Mac and an iPhone, I'd definitely buy one of the $499 models. As it is, I might get it anyway to serve as a netbook/e-reader/web surfing appliance.

Opinari's picture

e-Books and the iPhone Kindle App

The big question I have is this - will the iPhone and iPad still run the Kindle App? That's how I read my Kindle books right now. I own several books, but no Kindle. It would be a shame, but would make sense, if the iPhone OS suddenly no longer supported the Kindle app.

Factchecker's picture

Does the iPad have an

Does the iPad have an internal mic?

It says it does in the specs at the previous Apple link. Haven't heard anything else about it, though it also lists "audio" under accessibility. Don't really understand that.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives