Sometimes when someone tries to do something good they get confused and screw up something else. This is often referred to as the law of unintended consequences. Case in point would be Senator John McCain's new bill to crack down on child pornography on the Internet. No one wants child pornography on the Internet but the problem is that this bill is so broadly written it could be used to shut down a website with an innocent picture like this.
It is an important cause and something must be done but this bill is so poorly written it could be used to harm people that have nothing to do with child pornography. If this sounds a little like the War on Drugs or the War on Terror there may be a reason. Could it be Congress Critters? Senator McCain is not alone in not understanding the Internet.
From CNET News:
Millions of commercial Web sites and personal blogs would be required to report illegal images or videos posted by their users or pay fines of up to $300,000, if a new proposal in the U.S. Senate came into law.
The legislation, drafted by Sen. John McCain and obtained by CNET News.com, would also require Web sites that offer user profiles to delete pages posted by sex offenders.
After child pornography or some forms of "obscenity" are found and reported, the Web site must retain any "information relating to the facts or circumstances" of the incident for at least six months. Webmasters would be immune from civil and criminal liability if they followed the specified procedures exactly.
McCain's proposal, called the "Stop the Online Exploitation of Our Children Act" (click for PDF), requires that reports be submitted to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, which in turn will forward them to the relevant police agency. (The organization received $32.6 million in tax dollars in 2005, according to its financial disclosure documents.)
Internet service providers already must follow those reporting requirements. But McCain's proposal is liable to be controversial because it levies the same regulatory scheme--and even stiffer penalties--on even individual bloggers who offer discussion areas on their Web sites.
More after the jump...
Important UPDATE see comments
"I am concerned that there is a slippery slope here," said Kevin Bankston, an attorney with the Electronic Frontier Foundation in San Francisco. "Once you start creating categories of industries that must report suspicious or criminal behavior, when does that stop?"
McCain's proposal comes as concern about protecting children online has reached nearly a fever pitch in Washington. Attorney General Alberto Gonzales gave two speeches recently on the topic, including one on Friday in which he said "we must do all that we can to protect our children from these cowardly villains who hide in the shadows of the Internet."
But the reporting rules could prove problematic for individuals and smaller Web sites because the definitions of child pornography have become relatively broad.
According to the proposed legislation, these types of individuals or businesses would be required to file reports: any Web site with a message board; any chat room; any social-networking site; any e-mail service; any instant-messaging service; any Internet content hosting service; any domain name registration service; any Internet search service; any electronic communication service; and any image or video-sharing service.
McCain scored 31 of 100 points on a News.com 2006 election guide scoring technology-related votes.
And in July, for instance, Congress overwhelmingly approved a bill that made it a federal felony for Webmasters to use innocent words like "Barbie" or "Furby" to trick minors into visiting their sites and viewing sexually explicit material.
Next year, Gonzales and the FBI are expected to resume their push for mandatory data retention, which will force Internet service providers to keep records on what their customers are doing online. An aide to Rep. Diana DeGette, a Colorado Democrat, said Friday that she's planning to introduce such legislation when the new Congress convenes.
Cathy Milhoan, an FBI spokeswoman, said on Friday that the FBI "continues to support data retention. We see it as crucial in advancing our cyber investigations to include online sexual exploitation of children."
In addition, Sen. Chuck Schumer, a New York Democrat, and McCain said that they'll introduce similar legislation dealing with sex offenders and social-networking sites in January.
|
Topics:
|
|
Discussing:
- Open AI escapes, hacks competitor (3 replies)
- Bravo to Michaela Barnett (3 replies)
- Federal Government sending marketing (campaign) messages? (1 reply)
- Knox SOUP Announces New Name, November 5 Community Dinner, and Call for Project Proposals (1 reply)
- Oconaluftee, Cherokee, Newfound Gap (1 reply)
- Pedestrians be careful, drivers (and pedestrians) not attentive (3 replies)
- Check and Recheck your ballot when voting (5 replies)
- Bernie Sanders vs AI (1 reply)
- SoKno discombobulation continues (2 replies)
- Execution failed!!! (3 replies)
- GOP Senator "deserves the obloquy" (2 replies)
- AI company going public says "existential risks to humanity" (2 replies)
TN Progressive
- Blount County pausing on housing growth? (BlountViews)
- Tues., Oct. 20, 2026, Free Flu Shots at Blount County Health Dept. (BlountViews)
- View from the Overlook (Whitescreek Journal)
- Alcoa property taxes will probably not go up (BlountViews)
- Smith & Wesson not a good fit for Blount County (BlountViews)
- WATCH THIS SPACE. (Left Wing Cracker)
- America As It Is Right Now (RoaneViews)
- A friend sent this: From Captain McElwee's Tall Tales of Roane County (RoaneViews)
- The Meidas Touch (RoaneViews)
- Massive Security Breach Analysis (RoaneViews)
- (Whitescreek Journal)
- My choices in the August election (Left Wing Cracker)
TN Politics
- Tennessee governor picks former fed prison official, inmate to lead Correction Department (TN Lookout)
- Tennessee Gov.-elect Marsha Blackburn expected to prioritize closing of primaries (TN Lookout)
- Tennessee’s used EV market is growing, but stood at 1.4% of overall market in 2025 (TN Lookout)
- US loses its 'measles elimination status' after more than 25 years (TN Lookout)
- Battle for US Senate majority leader sets off with Van Hollen uphill challenge to Schumer (TN Lookout)
- Sponsored Commentary: Building connection in divided times (TN Lookout)
Knox TN Today
- LSU remaining goal is to spoil Tennessee season (Knox TN Today)
- KCSO Capt. Tom Walker: He’s ending a long career of service (Knox TN Today)
- Tennessee’s police buffer-zone law under challenge (Knox TN Today)
- Monday Connections: November 16, 2026 (Knox TN Today)
- Game Ball: Paul Foreman wins as Vols defeat Texas A&M, 22–7 (Knox TN Today)
- Youth Scoop: Basketball, holiday giving and opportunities for young people (Knox TN Today)
- Meet Rex: Monday’s Parent-A-Child (Knox TN Today)
- Mission Monday: Faith N Friends announces Boots & Buckles Barn Dance fundraiser (Knox TN Today)
- Meet Atticus: A smart, loving companion looking for his perfect match! (Knox TN Today)
- Stupid things we do in medicine, Part 2 (Knox TN Today)
- Vols down Aggies in slobber-knocker (Knox TN Today)
- Faith Along the Way: Royalty (Knox TN Today)
Local TV News
- Dolly Parton earns three posthumous Grammy nominations (WATE)
- Knoxville Fire Department mourns Master Firefighter Ronnie Layne (WATE)
- ‘Huge step forward’: Parkwest Medical performs Tennessee’s first robot-assisted shoulder replacement (WATE)
- Automated speed cameras in Knoxville school zones to begin issuing warnings (WATE)
- Historical marker venerating Medal of Honor hero, UT alum Larry Taylor unveiled (WATE)
- Knoxville Weather: Slow warm-up this week (WATE)
News Sentinel
State News
- Baylor’s Croucher joins DGG with five-star prospect status - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Meet the chef: Lukas Gilberstad brings culinary dreams to the streets - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Photos: Chattanooga Beard Contest - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Red Bank’s Marcus Jones showed off two-way skills in shutout win - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
Wire Reports
- Mamdani Disbands Controversial NYPD Protest Unit - WSJ (US News)
- Trump backs return of ex-Nvidia boss after 'Bring Jensen Back' campaign launched - BBC (Business)
- Trump Administration Moves to Close A.I. Chip Loophole Ahead of China Trip - The New York Times (Business)
- After one last Sunday, a beloved D.C. golf course is closed. For now. - The Washington Post (US News)
- AAA forecasts another busy — but not quite as busy — Thanksgiving travel week - AP News (Business)
- Stocks Fall Before Nvidia Earnings, Anthropic IPO: Markets Wrap - Bloomberg.com (Business)
- Fed Chairman Kevin Warsh stresses importance of AI to economy, but says it could ‘disappoint’ - CNBC (Business)
- Trump bristles at criticism over grounding of planes, blaming old tech and Biden for the problems - AP News (US News)
- Warren Buffett donates more Berkshire shares, confidence 'as strong as ever' - Reuters (Business)
- U.S. attorney warns Sen. Elizabeth Warren against investigating Trump associates - NBC News (US News)
- Lindsay Clancy to face a new trial in spring of 2027 over children’s killing - NPR (US News)
- Supreme Court rejects case on Trump's bid to cut research grants related to DEI - CBS News (US News)
- Democrats Will Wield Enormous Power in Statehouses. What Will They Do? - The New York Times (US News)
- Flight delays, cancellations return to normal levels after weekend of travel chaos - NBC News (Business)
- International student enrollments at US universities plunge this fall, data shows - The Guardian (US News)
Local Media
Lost Medicaid Funding
Search and Archives
TN Progressive
Nearby:
- Blount Dems
- Herston TN Family Law
- Inside of Knoxville
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jim Stovall
- Knox Dems
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Outdoor Knoxville
- Pittman Properties
- Reality Me
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
Beyond:
- Nashville Scene
- Nashville Post
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Journal
- TN Lookout
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South

Very surprising . . .
That a member of congress doesn't understand how the Internet tubes work.
Do you think the staff members who put these things together are equally clueless? Or are they simply told to keep quiet and stay out of the way?
Brian A.
I'd rather be cycling.
Do you think the staff
Do you think the staff members who put these things together are equally clueless?
A good question. I would doubt it. I suspect McCain is not as clueless as he appears. I don't think Congress Critters like the freedom of the Internet.
Is it possible that in a few short years what we do here today will not be possible?
But!
The idea did get John McCain's name in the news in association with being generally against that one bad thing and more in favor of that other thing. You know - the good one that Katie Couric nodded her head in agreement with?
Which seems to be the point of a lot of McCain's positions. Guy is a shameless media hound, even as politicians go.
Hey, Les, why don't we just call each other assholes and get it over with. - Somebody on the old Southknoxbubba.net (if that was you, claim your quote and win net.fame!)
UPDATE: McCain in full spin control, can he pull out?
UPDATE:
McCain's office is worried about this. They have taken the time to email Glenn Reynolds to "clarify" what Senator McCain "really meant".
Also a good time to point out to McCain's office that this story was posted here at 11:59 AM. It was not posted until 4:21 PM on the InstaPundit site. Catch up Congress Critters, you could have had the the critique 4 hours earlier.
I would point out to Mr. Pablo Chavez of Senator McCain's office that he should read the bill in greater detail. If it affects the MySpaces of the World it affects all blogs.
This is a glaring blunder for Senator McCain and his staff. It is big of McCain to request amendments to the bill AFTER the world has learned of how this bill will affect free speech.
Senator McCain, should you have considered that to begin with?
From Glenn Reynolds AKA InstaPundit: