Sun
Dec 23 2012
01:57 am
By: EricLykins  shortURL
from the Economic Policy Institute.
in decision after decision in the post-1979 period, policy changes were made that nearly all economic analysts agreed would predictably increase economic inequality—and this is exactly what happened. Yet these changes did not spur any boost in overall growth to compensate for the rise in inequality
Translation, or Economic Policy in 7 Seconds:
"A rising tide lifts all boats."
True, but 98% of middle and low-income households don't own a boat and have been taking on water for 30 years.
|
Topics:
|
63
vote
|
Discussing:
- Tragic news from Oklahoma (3 replies)
- The Taylor Swift Justin Bieber Awards (4 replies)
- TBI accuses non-profit of lying, WSMV of shoddy journalism for repeating it (2 replies)
- Haslam goes off on the media (6 replies)
- Memphis Grizzlies - First time in the NBA Final Four (2 replies)
- Solar disruption (4 replies)
- A game to play on a rainy day (4 replies)
- We Did It Again (1 reply)
- Interruptions make us dumber? (3 replies)
- Food supply under assault as climate heats up (48 replies)
- 2013 Shootings in Knox County, TN (49 replies)
- @AckerMoxley (2 replies)
Upcoming events:
- May 30 2013 - 5:00pm (1 week 2 days from now)
TN Progressive
- Rep. Ron Travis (RoaneViews)
- Alternet: Another TN Rep Makes the News (RoaneViews)
- Rep. Fincher Joins TNGOP’s Starving Children Club (Southern Beale)
- Dinnertime (Domestic Psychology)
- The Daily Buzz (RoaneViews)
- New Natural Predator Beetles Introduced to Help Save Hemlocks (RoaneViews)
- Pellissippi Parkway Extension - TDOT Meeting, Thursday, May 30, 2013 (BlountViews)
- Mild Mannered KNS Reporter Puts On His Cape For Truth Justice and the American Way (RoaneViews)
- Star Trek Into Darkness immediate reaction (Domestic Psychology)
- Not Governing As A Political Strategy (Southern Beale)
- Umbrella-Gate: Obama Scandal (Video) (TN Guerilla Women)
- not-so-great mysteries (Domestic Psychology)
- Taking a little break for LIFE (Left Wing Cracker)
- Good News Friday (Southern Beale)
- Read this...I mean Really...Go Read This and think about it... (Kitchen Table)
- Blood in the Water? (Kitchen Table)
TN Politics
- Whose Faith & Values Is The Tennessean Covering? (Pith in the Wind)
- U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service Comments on Lawsuit (sorta) (Tom Humphrey)
- Bills Signed by the Governor, 5/20/13 (Tom Humphrey)
- No Kane (Post Politics)
- Shots all around (Post Politics)
- Survivor Series (Post Politics)
- Fiscal Review Committee to Eye 'Questionable' Contracts (Tom Humphrey)
- Haslam Warns Republicans: TN Democrats Might Engage Someday (like in North Carolina) (Tom Humphrey)
- Valediction (Post Politics)
- Failure to flaunt (Post Politics)
- Hey, Gov. Haslam — CEOs are Accountable to Shareholders, Right? (Pith in the Wind)
- For Duncan, Other TN GOP Congressmen, Indecision Prevails on Internet Taxing (Tom Humphrey)
Local Media Blogs
- CBID approves grant for Jackson Terminal (Josh Flory)
- Tourism agency plans new mural (Josh Flory)
- The Daily Pulse: Arrowmont Instructors' Art Show, Joy Kills Sorrow, and the Price is Right Live! (Metro Pulse)
- Monday briefing (Josh Flory)
- IBM's Smarter Cities Team Makes Recommendations to Lower Utility Bills (Metro Pulse)
- Corker should support federal shield law (Jack McElroy)
- Reeves nominated for U.S. judge gig (Mike Donila)
- The Weekend Plan-It: PAWS Among the Blooms, the Biscuit Festival, and Darius Rucker (Metro Pulse)
- Friday briefing (Josh Flory)
- Trustee's chief of staff steps down (Mike Donila)
- Music From This Week's Issue: May 16 (Metro Pulse)
- Panel denies St. John's demolition request (Josh Flory)
Local Paper
- Gov. Haslam signs bill lowering sales tax on food (KNS Business)
- District attorney: Pain pill arrest surge jamming area jails (KNS News)
- 4 things to know today (KNS News)
- State gives UT OK to buy, demolish three historic homes (KNS News)
- New street named for former educator, KCDC leader Juanita Cannon (KNS News)
- Violin of Titanic bandmaster showing at Pigeon Forge museum (KNS News)
- Study: Bonnaroo has $51M economic impact (KNS Business)
- Gerdau adding 40 jobs in Knox County (KNS Business)
- Knoxville Glove Co. to close shop after 99 years (KNS Business)
- People and honors: May 19 (KNS Business)
Local TV News
- Camp Creek tornado survivors reflect on their road to recovery (WATE)
- Rebar finishing will add 40 jobs in Knox County (WATE)
- Crossville neighborhood demanding rat infested home be demolished (WATE)
- Ownby censure placed on May 28 meeting agenda (WATE)
- Officials find Cocke County man wanted for sexual assault (WATE)
- Authorities arrest Cocke Co. man accused of sexually assaulting teens (WBIR)
- At least 51 dead in Okla. twister, including at least 20 children (WBIR)
- Mosquitoes starting to bite in East Tennessee (WBIR)
- Teaching kids to dial 911 in the digital age (WBIR)
- 4th graders offer message of hope to cancer patients (WBIR)
- Pop Culture kicks off National Orange Popsicle Week (WVLT)
- Rebar finishing will add 40 jobs in Knox County (WVLT)
State News
- Today's weather forecast (Times Free Press)
- Should we let wunderkinds drop out of high school? (Times Free Press)
- Former IRS commissioner heads to Capitol Hill amid scandal (Times Free Press)
- Jodi Arias speaks on own behalf as jury considers death (Times Free Press)
- FBI: Agents fell to deaths training off Virginia coast (Times Free Press)
- Music City Center hotel bookings goal hit (Tennessean)
- Vandy pitcher masters the oddball (Tennessean)
- Oklahoma tornado levels suburb, at least 20 kids killed (Tennessean)
- Contractors Booted from City's Embattled HARP Program (ABC24 Memphis)
- Haslam approves new conservatorship law (Tennessean)
- Haslam signs bill expanding distillery sales (Tennessean)
- Memphis Cancer Survivor Publishes National Study on Breast Reconstruction (ABC24 Memphis)
Wire Reports
- Frenetic search for survivors as 91 feared dead in tornado-hit Oklahoma (Yahoo News)
- Housing recovery boosts Home Depot results; outlook raised (Yahoo Business)
- Witnesses describe deadly Oklahoma tornado: ‘All you could hear were screams’ (Yahoo News)
- Amid fears about debt, one family goes to the extreme to avoid student loans (Yahoo News)
- Dollar firms as Fed suspense builds, shares off highs (Yahoo Business)
- Sprint receives SoftBank waiver to consider Dish offer (Yahoo Business)
- JPMorgan investors on edge over vote on Dimon; what if they win? (Yahoo Business)
- Despite Rubio’s wooing, radio hosts protest immigration reform bill (Yahoo Politics)
- Pentagon to take over some CIA drone operations : sources (Yahoo News)
- Connecticut rail delays continue, seen repaired by Wednesday (Yahoo News)
- Obama directs FEMA to ready help for tornado-ravaged Oklahoma (Yahoo Politics)
- Obama to meet Chinese President Xi in June (Yahoo Politics)
- GOP official: ‘Institutional barriers’ remain for Republican women seeking office (Yahoo Politics)
- Obama to visit Senegal, South Africa, Tanzania (Yahoo Politics)
- Yahoo buying Tumblr for $1.1 billion, vows not to screw it up (Yahoo Business)
Site Statistics
Last 7 days:
- Posts: 28
- Comments: 193
- Visits: 9,523
- Pageviews: 19,508
- Posts: 100
- Comments: 1012
- Visits: 38,630
- Pageviews: 79,796
Popular today
Popular this week
TN Progressive
- BlountViews
- Cup of Joe Powell
- Jamie Hollin
- Left Wing Cracker
- Newscoma
- Out of the Blue
- RoaneViews
- Sean Braisted
- Southern Beale
- TN Citizen Action
- Tiny Cat Pants
- TN Guerilla Women
- TN Values Authority
- Vibinc
- View From My Kitchen Table
- WhitesCreek Journal
Nearby:
- AC Entertainment
- Agrarian Urbanite
- Big Good Thing
- Blount Dems
- Bottom Line
- Craig Thomas
- Daily Pulse
- David Oatney
- Discover ET
- Domestic Psychology
- Ellen Smith
- Fletch
- Gerald Witt
- Frank Murphy
- Home/Work
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jack McElroy
- Jim Stovall
- Julie Apple
- Knox Dems
- KnoxBlab
- Knoxify
- Knoxvillager
- Les Jones
- Lynn Point Records
- MamaPundit
- Michael Silence
- Mike Donila
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Mushy's Moochings
- Outdoor Knoxville
- P.E.N. Studio
- People for the Planet
- Pittman Properties
- Political Leverage
- Property Scope
- Reality Me
- Rikki Hall
- Rob Huddleston
- School Matters
- Stacey Campfield
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
- Stuck inside Knoxville
- Suzy Trotta
- Tom Humphrey
- Tri Cities
Beyond:
- Andy Axel
- Daily Docket
- Democratic Talk Radio
- Enclave
- Ginger Snaps
- Pith in the Wind
- Post Politics
- Quiet Life
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Ticket
- TN Trivia
- TN Women's Caucus
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South
- Lovable Liberal
- Newsrack
- Wandering Hillbilly
At large:
- Agonist
- Alterdestiny
- Atrios
- Burnt Orange Report
- Buzzflash
- College Dems
- Common Cause
- Crooks and Liars
- Daily Kos
- Democratic Strategist
- Democrats.org
- Digby's Hullabaloo
- Ezra Klein
- The Fix
- Huffington Post
- Liberal Oasis
- Media Matters
- MyDD
- Open Secrets
- Pam's House Blend
- Political Wire
- Politico
- Progressive States
- Seeing the Forest
- Skippy the Bush Kangaroo
- Suburban Guerrilla
- Talk Left
- Talking Points Memo
- Think Progress
- Truthdig
- Truthout

*
I know a 52 year-old woman who has been unemployed for over 18 months since being laid off her position as an office coordinator for a medical practice.
She got a call to interview with Kroger last week, where she had applied for any open position, and had anticipated that this unionized employer would pay a starting wage of maybe $9.00 per hour per advice from her friends.
She was disappointed to learn at the interview that Kroger starts all new hires at minimum wage (or a few cents higher), $7.25 per hour.
So when I was shopping there yesterday, I asked an employee how minimum wage employees could afford union dues and, probably more to the point, why they'd be inclined to join the union if it were as ineffective as that in negotiating any living wage.
The employee, who's been with Kroger over 30 years, said their union membership is way, way down.
She also said that their contract, which had expired in May, was renegotiated just last week and that members were dismayed at its particulars.
The moral of this story appears to be that unions are most effective when there are lots of them.
mld
mld
Since 1979?...
(link...)
The "Greatest Generation" and "Boomers" have the right to their money, they earned it.
And without the first, we would probably be speaking German.
That said, "that giant sucking sound" of outsourcing isn't the only drain on this economy.
Lack of investment in subsequent generations plays a part. A LOT of money is being hoarded for retirement and health care. (something a single payer system would have helped alleviate)
As it stands, generations are being left with little other than the service industry: http://education-portal.com/articles/Tennessee_Job_Outlook:_Fastest_Growing_Tennessee_(TN).html
The upside is subsequent generations will likely be left with considerable real estate, but unless something like this passes, that too will just be more debt. Many parts of America has more people dying than being born.
Schumer-Lee housing proposal:
Schumer-Lee housing proposal: We have so many empty houses that people can't afford that we need to import immigrants that can pay cash? Yes, I suppose that would partially satisfy some short term banking industry "growth" expectations...
Better to do nothing than
Better to do nothing than inherit land in areas that have fewer and fewer buyers? (link...)
And that assumes the property is free and clear. If not, the debt generation will just inherit more debt.
There is so much to be said
There is so much to be said when this information is reported. So much to think about. Could Alex Pareene be a bit of a complainer?
The fact that this gap is getting worse helps explain why so many older Americans don’t get it, when the young people complain.
young people have gone from a generation that worried they’d never be able to afford the homes they grew up in to one that is unable to leave those homes (and then they’re called shiftless and lazy)
Do older people hoard their money because they know the children are returning home? Unable to leave their homes? Could be it depends on where you live. I personally know a young person (around 30) who works at a fast food restaurant and just got an apartment with his girlfriend who also works at a fast food restaurant. And, no, Mom and Dad aren't paying the rent. I'm pretty darn sure the apartment is nothing like living at "home" but they are happy to not be living with their parents (nor living in the park).
Do you want to know how many new cars, cellphones, televisions, computers, tablets, GPSs, dishwashers, washers/dryers, cable TV, Internet, etc. "old" people had by the time they were 30-35? How old were the "old" people when they obtained the house the current generation believes they can't afford or is not willing to leave?
Did the old people pay 3-4% interest on their mortgages? What was the income tax when old people were starting their careers? Were community colleges available when old people were considering college? How many old people had the opportunity to even consider college? How many old women even considered college an option? How many old people had the threat of the military draft? When was the last major conflict that 60,000+ young people died?
Let's not pit the old people against the young people. Let's try to figure out a way that everyone can be happy. Maybe we have to define happy.
Not a pitting,
just the reality.
If one had a college age child, it would be smart to direct them into job sectors that would cater to retirees. If one doesn't want their child returning home, best they enter fields where the money is.
Around here, that would healthcare and service industries.
As for previous generations living leaner, I don't disagree.
I would speculate before the popularity of 401k's and international markets, investors used to put their money into more local endeavors. DW Proffitt wasn't as concerned with Fifth Avenue as he was East Tennessee.
Reality? What is real?
Reality? What is real? Rhetorical question.
Living wage calculator at MIT
Living wage calculator at MIT ...
Knoxville. $8.86 per hour for a household with one adult and no children
Knox County. same
Living wage calculator
How much does an employee cost
"The costs to this point (basic salary, employment taxes and benefits) are typically in the 1.25 to 1.4 times base salary range- e.g. the cost range for a $50,000/year employee might $62,500 to $70,000."
How much does an employee cost
About to sound like like the
About to sound like like the old woman yelling for kids to get off her lawn, but...
I got my first (used) car when I started grad school because I got married, moved to Rutledge, and had to commute. Now kids EXPECT their own cars when they turn 16.
Also, when my sister gave me a list of what my niece wanted for Christmas, one of the items on the list was $50 eye shadow. I don't think I've paid $50 combined for all the eye shadow I've bought in my entire life.
I mean really. Maybe she
I mean really. Maybe she would be better off asking for a savings bond to help pay for college.
This will sound snippy in print as well,
Maybe because their parents BELIEVE and REPEAT the Over-Consumption Myth, a close relative of the Welfare Cadillac. EVERYBODY else is doing it!
I used to work with an
I used to work with an electrician who said he told both of his children they could attend any college in the country and he would provide them with free room and board.....right there at home in Oak Ridge.
Now kids EXPECT their own cars when they turn 16.
Just as the public education system does not fail all children, not all children have that level of expectation.
That came off snippyier than I intended, but watching my kids adjust to lower expectations this Christmas has really made me proud.
Merry Christmas from all of us thankful for 14$ tennis shoes from Costco.
*
Dear Bob,
Every time my kids whine to spend in ways we can't (or at least "shouldn't"), I make them finish this sentence--
Mom: "Even Donald Trump..."
Petulant child (rolling eyes): "...has a budget. Sigh."
Mom: "That's right. If he didn't, he'd be bankrupt."
I, for one, think you're doing a great job. Hang in there.
Fondly,
Tam
Tone
I didn't intend the tone of my last post to be quite as brusque as it was but I think I would be remiss to let the fact that many of notice the gap between the upper and lower classes widening.
My guess is that there are two ways to raise one's children to grab at the opportunity to stay on the upper side. One is to heighten the parent's level of expectation from the child. This method involves being as honest as is age appropriate of the way the world works. That doesn't mean there is no Santa Claus. It just means he's busting his but to make stuff happen and being good is just what's expected if the whole deal is to work. This holds true with grades, sports, scouts, etc. Doing one's best is just what it takes. Deal with it.
The other is to heighten the child's level of expectation of what to expect from the world. The Paris Hilton effect, if you will. Rich people want friends and marriage partners too, and raising a child to fill that role by teaching the chameleon effect works. Plus, it's easier.
The parents I generally see tend to use the former technique or a reasonable blend of the two styles. I have a tendency to be too blunt for my own good at times and folks too concerned about social climbing tend to look for others with more percieved social standing than they feel I offer.
As for the older generation hoarding money, part of the problem with half of a generation jumping on the Ronald Reagan bandwagon is that they think it's all about them. They can marry and divorce with no consequence, they don't pay taxes, and they don't save. At one time there was a universal obligation to family, no more. If subsequent generations aren't being staked, then when it's time to care for their elders, the resources just aren't there.
Again, sorry about being snipey , it being Christmas and all, but if peer expectation is that there are no social obligations and everyone not participating in "every man for himself" is a chump, then social order will begin to crumble.
We have met the enemy, and he is us.- Pogo
it being Christmas and all,
I'm going to hug a Republican today if I can find one. I just read that they are less optimistic about the future than Syrians, Greeks or Afghans.
$50 eye shadow. Jeez. When I
$50 eye shadow. Jeez. When I was 16, my butt would have been whipped for asking for such a thing. I had tons of eye shadow in college, but it was from the drug store. For real. These days I mostly use what comes in the bonus gift package when I macke my twice a year Clinique purchase. And that's probably what I would have told the niece. I'm blunt like that.
I got a car when I was a senior in high school, but it was practical -- a used VW. And unlike most I had insurance money from when my parents were killed and a first car was one of the things it was expected to buy. As was a college education. I'm ever thankful.
NPR had an article the other
NPR had an article the other day about vendors who offer customizing options online for their products. They interviewed a high school kid who was bragging about his designs for several custom pairs of Nike athletic shoes and about how 'everybody wanted them' although they cost about 20% to 25% more than the already ridiculous prices for their shoes.
I can just imagine the pressure a parent in my income level would endure when they heard that everybody else is wearin' 'em.
*
Yeah, Converse is doing it, too.
I told my teenage son we'd just carry our 40% off coupon over to Hobby Lobby and scope out their multi-packs of colored Sharpies, small iron-on transfers, and bright colored grommets.
(BTW, that 43 year-old hand-held grommet setter Mom put in my very first sewing kit has saved me probably $3000, over the years. You heard it first here.)
Have you seen the brush-tip
Have you seen the brush-tip Sharpies for fabric?
Ten states will raise minimum
Ten states will raise minimum wage Jan 1.
I-Pads, I-phones, laptops,
I-Pads, I-phones, laptops, and video games galore.
The middle class has spent their savings on spoiling their kids and keeping up with the Jones's spoiling of their kids.
I have no sympathy.
You don't want to know how many clients I had as a social services case worker who had brand new model cars and better and newer cell phones than my flip top.
I would like to know. How
I would like to know. How many? Produce a verifiable number or shut up.
Flashback from last March:
Flashback from last March: Where did you spend the money?
Lively discussion, 25 comments, several of them lengthy
More data on frivolous spending today vs. a generation ago here.
As has been pointed out, this is all very much an educational issue, but I don't need Elizabeth warren to explain to me the bidding war for suburban homes in good school districts. After my stepfather died last year I moved in with my whole famdamily. We rent a quarter of a million dollar home so my 13 year old niece can go to a good school, and it takes 5 incomes to make that happen.
I don't understand why most solutions being offered hinge upon further abandoning public education and further segregating communities by income. Warren makes a case for a different kind of voucher system that would be highly disruptive in the short term but should rebalance simultaneously the public education system and the housing market. Proposals that don't link the two are nothing more than snake oil and band-aids. You can read this section of the book here.
Educational choices
Like TV, how one uses digital technology is up to them. It's just as easy to watch the Smithsonian channel as it is to watch "Honey Boo-boo". iPads can be used for online courses, not just Facebook. iPhones can be a great tool for telecommuting.
IMO, the real tragedy in this century is that schools haven't taken enough advantage of technology. There's no reason every French class in America shouldn't be video chatting with their French peers.
Research shows no meaningful
Research shows no meaningful benefit of computers and what not in the classroom. But, that is science and should be disregarded out of hand.
Reaserch on what?
I'd say research on the dusty old 486 in the corner of a French class that provides the same text in a book doesn't provide much.
Is there research on an American student sharing hours of FaceTime with peer students in France?
I'm pretty sure immersion learning has been researched at length.
Clap. Trap.
So, your kid shows up to French class at 11am, given the tilt of the earth's axis at 23.5 degrees and the concept of time zones, what would a French student be doing at the same time?
Let's try...,
Quebec.
Feel better?
I thought you wanted them to
I thought you wanted them to speak French.
Poverty
Poverty is, among other things, an education issue. Just because some rich f*** tells you you need to buy something, doesn't mean he's not lying.
Just because he can afford a real slick ad campaign to convince you he's not lying, doesn't mean he's not lying.
Illusion is not reality.
Class dismissed.
*
Not to discount the legitimate topic of this thread, Toby, which is growing income inequality (due to stagnant wages, union-busting, etc.), I think AnonymousOne is speaking to another equally legitimate topic, namely our national ignorance of basic personal financial management--as in that guy I carried the groceries to, only to learn he'd just spent his paltry paycheck on $90 shoes I don't feel I can afford!
Like Bob observes, poverty is--at least in part--an "education issue."
Case in point: TN is the bankruptcy capital of the nation, hence the legislature's decision to add a semester of persoanl finance coursework to the state's high school graduation requirements.
Yeah, I know there's lots more the TN legislature could do to help and, again, I don't trivialize the urgent need to address why our growing income inequality, BUT that problem only makes more crucial the need to manage prudently what income we do have.
(Please don't insult the hausfrau lacking any cell phone, paying just $20/month for Basic Cable, and driving an eight year-old salvage vehicle. I am adding $100/month to the required amount for every mortgage payment and managing that payroll deduction to the 401-k, alright?!)
Sure people have a problem
Sure people have a problem with personal finance, but the manner in which this person talks about it is just ridiculous. He/she rolls out the new wingnut trope -- the welfare middle class -- and then makes a claim without support. Troll.
*
And I don't mind speaking about such matters on a public forum because I know full well what the average household income is in Knox County, which means I'm also perfectly confident that a whole lotta folks live like I do.
Probably most.
*
In the way of explaining my pointedness, my husband covered this month the November mortgage payment for one of my relatives--but not before I personally dialed the number for Direct TV and handed the woman the phone to cancel her service.
I also went into her garage and unloaded her second refrigerator (she lives alone) to stash its contents in the fridge sitting in her kitchen.
Suck it up.
When I talk to employers some
When I talk to employers some say they have a hard time finding skilled workers and workers who can pass a drug test.We are running out of young people who are interested in becoming skilled carpenters,masons,plumbers,welders etc.Maybe better training for those skills would provide more opportunity for some.
Wages for skilled labor
Those are 35 dollar an hour jobs that currently pay about one third of that. When the wages catch up to the wealth that these jobs produce and the workers are reasonably compensated for their labor, people will return to these professions.
Until then, there should be a moratorium on building nuclear facilities as the quality in the labor market does not justify the inherent risk involved in the building of said plants. The risk that the welds won't hold is just too great.
I want it all now,Thats
I want it all now,Thats exactly the attitude that leads people to a job flipping burgers.$35 is high but someone who is skilled should make 20 25 an hour.Heck even using your guess starting at $17.00 an hour pays the bills.The point is learn a trade,have a way to make a living.
Let me finish this for you:
...for the wage that they are paying.
Wages for skilled labor
As you would know if you worked for a living as opposed to brokering others production, a man's worth is measured by the market value of his work. The entire value of a half million dollar house is produced by the laborer, yet the contractors, developers, real estate agents and banks take the lion's share of the profit.
Why would a reasonably intelligent person choose a high risk career, subject to the whims of the market, just so a bunch of snot nosed rich kids could steal from him the rest of his life? That's why there is a skilled labor shortage.
35.00 dollars an hour is low. Try buying insurance, saving for retirement. buying a house and educating two fairly intelligent children on that. It's a slightly lower middle class existence.
Lets use your reference to
Lets use your reference to home building.First I don t know any rich snot nosed kids who make it very long in any business with the attitude you make reference to.Second,who cares who pays you as long as the money is paid.Most General contractors started as a sub,doing the work for a wage with no risk of losing all they have and all they will ever have.After a couple of years they use their experience and relationships to borrow enough money to build a spec house ,then 2, then 4.I see this happen frequently,but it takes someone with drive. Thats how successful, driven people start a business.Sorry,there are no trade schools for "rich guy".Now, that doesn t mean that if someone doesn t have that desire they can t survive,I know numerous tradesman that are perfectly happy putting in the hours and doing what they do.The original complaint was that too many people are forced to work for minimum wage.If you sit around and wait for guaranteed wealth you ll find yourself without success or you ll end up taking a job for a large company only to be laid off and constantly be a number. I can tell you story after story of people who started small and are now some of the wealthy "boogie men" you complain about.
Story after story
And I can tell you story after story of rich kids born with a silver spoon up their nose that think the function of every other living creature is to serve their neverending quest for primal pleasure. These are the sort of people that would hunt praire dogs with .223 centerfire ammo for the sick joy of watching them blow up.
Just because you know numerous tradespeople happy being underpaid doesn't make it right, nor does it address the shortage of skilled tradespeople. The craftsmanship on modern housing is no where near it was fifty years ago and , indeed, were it not for specs being reduced to the point of being barely safe, most contractors couldn't make a living. Were illegal aliens to leave the trades in Knoxville wages would increase 25% to 50% overnight.
Do you think all those happy tradesman you know would keep working at a reduced wage?
The issue you brought to the table is that there was a shortage of skilled tradesman. The response was that the market does not justify a competent worker entering those trades when there is more money to be made elsewhere. Contractors are destroying their own market by offereing inferior product produced by lower skilled workers for higher prices simply because there are enough suckers to support them at present. This is a major driving force in the reduction of property values. Modern structures are built with a limited lifespan. The no longer out-live the purchaser. Your attempt at obfusticating the truth doesn't change it.
The entire value of a half
The entire value of a half million dollar house is produced by the laborer, yet the contractors, developers, real estate agents and banks take the lion's share of the profit.
A couple of problems with that statement. You are discounting the value of the property it is built on and the value of the materials used in construction. That plus labor are the "lions share" of the value. Further, the contractors, developers and bankers all add value by investing and taking on risk to get the house built and financed. The real estate agents, through their labor, add value by putting buyers and sellers together and getting it sold.
The product
You are correct about the property and materials.
However, the contractors, developers, bankers and agents are all dependent on the wealth that the laborer has produced in order to recieve payment for their services. The market will operate without any of the functions you mention, but without a product, there is no market.
A market does, however, sometimes function more efficiently with contractors, developers, bankers and agents involved. The issue is the relative value of all these functions. The idea that capitol providers are entitled to anything beyond 5% of the fed rate for anything is ludicris, yet we accept it as a way of life. While putting more responsibility on the laborer, (see the various certification procedures for trades) the laborers wages have remained stagnent and often declined in purchasing power while the others in the food chain have taken more and more of the final value of the product and put that in their own pocket. It has resulted in a lower quality product (go to Choto and ask some newer homeowners) and lower wages and consequently, less skilled and often illegal workers performing the labor. The housing industry is killing its goose that has traditionally laid its golden egg. It has been going on incrementally for years, it's just now coming to the forefront because it's just now reaching critical mass.
The idea that capitol
The idea that capitol providers are entitled to anything beyond 5% of the fed rate for anything is ludicris, yet we accept it as a way of life.
I think you meant "capital" and "ludicrous," but regardless I don't know where you come up with the fed rate + 5%. I imagine every deal is different, and ends up more or less than 5% depending on the amount of risk. Higher risk = higher reward in most normally functioning financial markets.
As for what an investor is "entitled" to or what their "relative value" might be, normally functioning markets generally decide that, too.
There is always fraud and abuse, but those are also a part of normally functioning financial or any other kinds of markets. Regulation and enforcement are, too, but are unfortunately absent a lot these days.
Anyway, the point is you are devaluing the work of entire professions and classes of people who actually do add value to our economy most of the time, and even make things possible for labor and everyone else from time to time.
Shoes and feet
If what you are saying is that I've succeeded in puting the shoe on the other foot, I'll accept that as a compliment.
What I have done is use the right's own arguments against labor against them. Studying Samuel Gompers had a profound effect on me years ago and I think the grandest disservice modern education does to this generation is not teaching extensively how the working class, through their own risk, toil and determination built this nation throughout the twentieth century.
Lest we forget the roots of the labor movement;
1890: I believe that the trade unions will bring about both the improvement of conditions and the ultimate emancipation of workers. . . . I think that the emancipation of the working classes has to be achieved by the workers themselves. Trade unions are the pure, unadulterated organizations of the working classes.
(Vol. 2: New Yorker Volkszeitung, Dec. 21, 1890)
(link...)
Finally I'd like to point out that the value of the professions I'm accused of devaluing is perceived and not absolute. The absolute value of wealth and the perceived value of the people deciding how much wealth will be produced and how it will be distributed are two different things. This is not to say there is no value in the professions you defend, only that the value is out of proportion to any sense of its worth. It's why unregulated capitalism is doomed to failure. Its ultimate end is that one entity controls it all.
Good Catch
Good catch on the spelling, by the way. Ludicris made it through my spell check, which, I just noticed was turned off. Looks like I picked the wrong day to quit drinking.
Man what is your deal?,Do you
Man what is your deal?,Do you just wake up pissed off and miserable every day or what.I ve never come across someone who claims to be an expert on every issue in the world, but doesn t know jack about any of them.
The glory days as you refer to them, in most cases had no specs at all.Most houses were built without the numerous inspections and engineering that there are today.They did use better materials because they could.
As for constant bemoaning of profits-you have met the enemy and he is you.Big profits are made on the back end of big real estate deals.A major player in driving these profits is the employee pension fund mangers.Investment property usually gets sold to retirement and pension fund mangers.They buy a variety of property types such as Walmart,home depot, Walgreen,hotels,apts,etc.Numerous employee and union pension funds,including UPS, invest heavily in real estate developments.In the end, lots of real estate developers and contractors not only employ tradesman, they provide a vehicle to support their retirement funds as well,maybe even yours.
So again I don t get the argument against a more focused approach to encouraging trades as a more viable career choice and I definitely don't get the attitude,I don t slam truck drivers,yet you always want to slam real estate as an occupation.
State of Working America
I thought this was a thread about the State of Working Americans not how the real estate industry has destroyed our pension system.
A discussion of inequality
A discussion of inequality wouldn't be complete without talking about pension funds blowing up prices.
Pension Funds
Once managers were allowed to skim funds from the top of so-called overfunded pensions the script was written for this impending catastrophe. Typically, as a nation, we have waited until a collapse to regulate financial markets.
It would be nice for the government to be proactive for once but Boner is not likely to let that happen.
Surplus
One of the big problems for home building labor is the housing surplus.
New construction still runs about $120 per sq/ft. As long as there are existing market homes that are selling for $80 - $100 a sq/ft, there will be dearth in the housing labor market. One that allows contractors to get laborers cheaper than they otherwise would.
Apprentices
Apprentices don't make the same wage as a journeyman. There is a wage progression as one gains knowledge and experience in accordance to the value and worth one brings to the marketplace.
Post new comment