Former Knox County Commissioner Madeline Rogero recalls a controversy surrounding a School Board vacancy several years ago.
Being new on the County Commission, Rogero was surprised that a presumed nominee was selected to fill the vacancy without consulting commissioners in the district. She notes "backroom politicking was in full swing."
She mobilized residents in her district and organized a public forum which was widely attended and got significant media coverage. As a result, Dr. Paul Kelly emerged as the only nominee, and was appointed with the unanimous support of the community and County Commission.
Madeline Rogero concludes: "I respect my fellow commissioners who, fifteen years ago, listened to the will of the voters. They had the authority to make an arbitrary, expedient, political appointment. They chose instead to open the process, participate in our forum, listen to the potential candidates, and then pick the best qualified. Should we not expect the same of our county commission today?"
Read her full account after the jump...
The case for community forums prior to political appointments
Madeline A. Rogero
Here is my recollection of the 1991 precedent-setting community forum held prior to Knox County Commission’s appointment of a school board member. I share it in the hopes that it might inform the current appointment process.
Exactly fifteen years ago this month, Knox County Commission participated in an unprecedented community forum prior to the appointment of an open seat for Knox County School Board. District 2 School board member Harry Tindell had won a race for state representative and announced that he would vacate his school board seat. I was a rookie on county commission, having just been elected to a District 2 seat the previous September.
Rumors quickly began circulating that a former commissioner, who had recently been defeated in his re-election bid, had the votes to be appointed. This was a surprise to me as I had not been consulted nor had any of my constituents in District 2. Backroom politicking was in full swing.
Though the presumed nominee lived in the 2nd school board district, he had represented the 3rd district on commission and was not well-known among district 2 voters nor well-versed on our school problems. Our schools had many serious issues such as dilapidated facilities, curriculum deficiencies, and we were in the midst of desegregation planning under the orders of the U.S. Office for Civil Rights. We clearly needed a school board member who understood our concerns and the challenges facing our district.
I began talking with District 2 residents and organizations and found that they were in agreement that a community forum should be held before an appointment was made. We formed a coalition of 11 PTAs and school groups, 6 neighborhood organizations, and the Knox County Education Association. We worked together to build support in the community and media for a public forum that would allow District 2 residents and County Commissioners a chance to meet and hear from individuals who sought the appointment. We encouraged potential nominees to step forward and participate in the public forum. We were well aware that county commission would make the appointment – and that we might not change the outcome – but we insisted that the community had a right to this process prior to the appointment.
“That’s not the way it’s done,” one commissioner was quoted as saying. “We’ll teach her a lesson.” I thought they probably would teach this rookie a lesson but it was a lesson I was willing to learn, as were the other coalition members.
Not only did the coalition members invite all commissioners to the forum, but we also called citizens in other districts and asked them to encourage their own county commissioners to attend. Both daily newspapers endorsed the community forum and we received significant media coverage.
On the night of the forum, January 28, 1991, over 170 people attended, and 17 of the 19 commissioners.
The League of Women Voters moderated the event and four candidates (including the presumed nominee) responded to questions and presented their views on education. Imagine the excitement in the room knowing that, for the first time in the history of Knox County politics, county commissioners participated in an open, well-attended, professionally moderated community forum to vet potential nominees before an appointment was made.
Following the community forum, two of the “community” candidates withdrew and threw their support behind the third “community” candidate. District 2 voters called commissioners and attended the commission meeting united in support of our own candidate. When it came time to vote, only one candidate was nominated and received unanimous commission support -- the community’s choice, Dr. Paul Kelley. Dr. Kelley served our school district and Knox County with distinction for 13 years; winning three elections before he chose to not seek re-election in 2004.
I respect my fellow commissioners who, fifteen years ago, listened to the will of the voters. They had the authority to make an arbitrary, expedient, political appointment. They chose instead to open the process, participate in our forum, listen to the potential candidates, and then pick the best qualified. Should we not expect the same of our county commission today?
|
|
Discussing:
- Rep Burchett (5 replies)
- Knoxville stays among top-10 US cities for rising home prices, most realtors expect continued increases over the next year (4 replies)
- How the Cost of a Burger Stacks Up in Every State (1 reply)
- Judge blocks Biden administration rule capping credit card late fees at $8 (1 reply)
- Private equity ownership of hospitals made care riskier for patients, a new study finds (24 replies)
- Labor Dept. says Tennessee firm employed minors to clean meat saws, head splitters at slaughterhouses (3 replies)
- Yowza! That was some storm last night (2 replies)
- Why are prices still so high? Corporate greed, some say (4 replies)
- UT pro-Palestine protests (7 replies)
- Boeing was once known for safety and engineering (11 replies)
- Walmart is closing its health centers and virtual care service (5 replies)
- Accidental shooting at local park? (4 replies)
TN Progressive
- Toons (RoaneViews)
- Appeals court: Wildlife officers’ warrantless searches of private property are unconstitutional (RoaneViews)
- Friday Toon (RoaneViews)
- Kimmell Destroys Trump in Monologue (RoaneViews)
- Chef steals food to serve at restaurant? (BlountViews)
- Blount County, TDOT make road deal for gun mfg ignoring town of Louisville,TN, (BlountViews)
- It's voting time again. Let's get out the vote. (BlountViews)
- Winter at the Big Rocks (Whitescreek Journal)
- Maryville Daily Times Home Delivery changing again (BlountViews)
- Secrets from My Radio Days (Joe Powell)
- Fall 2022 (Whitescreek Journal)
- Mmmm, A Fresh Hot Cup of Joe (Joe Powell)
TN Politics
- Biden celebrates ‘the power of an education’ on Brown v. Board 70th anniversary (TN Lookout)
- Stockard on the Stump: Lee stays on Trump bandwagon despite legal battles (TN Lookout)
- As states loosen childhood vaccine requirements, health experts’ worries grow (TN Lookout)
- U.S. House panel debates voting by noncitizens, which is already illegal (TN Lookout)
- Independent presidential candidate Robert Kennedy, Jr. makes brief, late stop in Nashville (TN Lookout)
- U.S. Senate GOP tries to block states from spending some of their COVID relief cash (TN Lookout)
Knox TN Today
- Beaver Creek Flotilla is Saturday (Knox TN Today)
- Tracking down joy (Knox TN Today)
- Cruising with Headricks, Crockers (Knox TN Today)
- Opening soon: New Harvest Dog Park (Knox TN Today)
- What’s new at Kern’s Food Hall (Knox TN Today)
- Come meet the world’s greatest eater (Knox TN Today)
- College + Industry developing new degree programs (Knox TN Today)
- Research shows effects of chemicals downstream (Knox TN Today)
- Bullhead melody (Knox TN Today)
- Honey Badger gets spectacular shot of northern lights (Knox TN Today)
- Spring brings whirlwind to Realty Executives (Knox TN Today)
- Find some treasures at Vintage, Etc. (Knox TN Today)
Local TV News
- Joey Chestnut takes title of Bologna Eating Champion in Knoxville (WATE)
- Some Knox County Schools graduations rescheduled for inclement weather (WATE)
- Police: Man charged after two fatal shootings near North Broadway (WATE)
- North Carolina couple searches for video of proposal in Market Square (WATE)
- After son nearly dies in crash, East Tennessee mother urges drivers to look twice for motorcycles (WATE)
- East TN man gets 8-year term in connection with boy's death, abuse suffered by girl (WBIR)
- Planned Parenthood looks to reopen Knoxville location two years after fire (WATE)
- Roane County couple accused in children's deaths face key court hearing Tuesday (WBIR)
- Family of fallen Knox Co. deputy Tucker Blakely attends 2024 Tennessee Law Enforcement Officers' Memorial Service (WBIR)
- Tennessee Theatre hosts first-ever Marquee Awards to honor high school musicals (WBIR)
- 'We are heartbroken and grieving' | Zoo Knoxville humanely euthanizes 46-year-old elephant Tonka (WBIR)
- Tennessee Valley Fair announces Ludacris to perform in September (WBIR)
News Sentinel
State News
Wire Reports
Local Media
Lost Medicaid Funding
Search and Archives
TN Progressive
Nearby:
- Blount Dems
- Herston TN Family Law
- Inside of Knoxville
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jim Stovall
- Knox Dems
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Outdoor Knoxville
- Pittman Properties
- Reality Me
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
Beyond:
- Nashville Scene
- Nashville Post
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Journal
- TN Lookout
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South
The Best Choice
I am so sorry that the qualities of Madeline were not better recognized in the community during her run for Mayor. We have all been short changed without her leadership. I look forward to her role as City Development Director.