Compass reports on a bill by Rep. Jason Zachary that would shift control of public health orders from county health departments to the county mayor. What could possibly go wrong?

Sen. Richard Briggs led the effort to derail the bill, saying: “Should we have a political person who is going to be dealing with public opinion, who’s going to be dealing with economic forces, social forces, or are we going to have, in the large counties, health officials who are going to be looking at data?”

Mayor Jacobs' office said they had nothing to do with Zachary's bill. OK, then.

Compass: Determining the Decider

Mike Knapp's picture

Whatever, GOP amateur hour is killing ppl and they want more

They have no idea about science, they don’t respect it because their ideology doesn’t recognize it as valid so of course they want to have primacy over the real public health professionals who actually know what the hell they're talking about. Jacobs, Trump et al are a joke when it comes to serious, salient issues like how to operate in a pandemic. That’s why Jacobs and Trump refuse to wear a mask in public and it’s why they think that they should be the uncredentialed deciders about public health. This overreaching legislative effort shouldn’t be interpreted as anything else except an attempt to fundamentally destroy public health departments by removing their ability to be the informed decisions maker about transmissible disease. It’s so predictably brazen that what Briggs should be doing, beyond a vital rearguard action, is penning legislation that protects DoH decision making from know-nothing’s like Jacobs and others. This idea is in the similar vein as what was being discussed 20,000 years ago in early April when Trump was running the same, predictable Randy Sanders-like bubblescreen against Fauci.

Congress can prevent this: It ought to pass a law stipulating that directors of the centers and research institutes that are part of the National Institutes of Health—officials like Fauci—should be removable only for malfeasance, neglect of office, or incapacity, but not for mere policy differences or politically inconvenient messaging. Similar protections exist for the heads of numerous independent agencies, such as the Federal Trade Commission and Social Security Administration. These protections prevent presidential politics from excessively influencing an administrator’s performance.

What the Pandemic Revealed

Making or keeping government as small as possible is an ideological fixation, not a sound principle of good governance. Small government is a false idol, and it is time we smash it. In its place, we should erect effective government as the goal that guides the development and evaluation of public policy. For maxims, we can look to America’s greatest stateman. “The legitimate object of government,” wrote Abraham Lincoln, “is to do for a community of people, whatever they need to have done, but can not do, at all, or can not, so well do, for themselves—in their separate, and individual capacities.”

fischbobber's picture

Health Directors

Health directors work at the pleasure of County Mayors. They can be removed any time, for any reason. Unfortunately, that status is in consideration with every decision made. The health director not only has to consider the affects of her every decision, but must consider the affects likely made by any buffoon Jacobs is likely to appoint as his lackey as well. Jacobs has undercut his health director at every juncture possible. The reason he doesn't wear a mask is to shove in the face of every at risk person in Knoxville that he's actively trying to kill us.

Mike Knapp's picture

Prediction

Jacobs fires Buchanan once she makes the decision to ratchet back reopening as cases continue to spike in the red light zone; he leans heavily not to ratchet back despite red light spike. Wanted legislative authority to make decision because he knows this is coming.

fischbobber's picture

I'd say you're right.

Thus far, citizen response on the various legislative facebook pages has been limited. On the county page, covid responses tend to be about what a great wrestler Kane has been, US Senate has Alexander taking the outbreak seriously, but deflecting mostly to other issues. Burchett has toned down the partisanship and is largely ducking the issue, and Martin Daniels blocked me weeks ago for calling him out on what a crappy idea it was to institute the Swedish protocol to begin with. (That's illegal, by the way, and I may or may not report him to the attorney general and pursue civil compensation for his role in the outbreak.)

On a positive note both Dr. Briggs and Mayor Kincannon are both taking this issue seriously and seemed determined to get facts and best science available out to the community.

I'd say as soon as Dr. Buchannon steps up and takes charge, she's gone. I think knowing that, and the real danger it would put the county in, plays into her decision making process. At this point, even looking at the alarming rise in these numbers, I believe she is what's in between our situation and a really bad outbreak. It's not a secret that there is disagreement on how to handle this situation.

fischbobber's picture

A few Knox County numbers to ponder.

Knox County population-448164

Rate of diabetes-14%

Rate of hypertension-33%

Rate of heart disease-3.38%

Rate of obesity-28.6%

These are the groups that the Swedish Protocol (the protocol we're using in Knoxville) will target and these are the groups Covid-19 is particularly at risk for death.These are the groups of people that Mayor Jacobs is instituting policy that will actively target these groups for debilitating disease and death.

The death rate due to the Holocaust was about 7.5% (that's actually a little high I believe) of Nazi Germany's occupied territory's population. Draw your own conclusions.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives