School superintendent responds to KNS editorial

Submitted by R. Neal on Thu, 2007/08/09 - 5:43am.

Knox County Schools Superintendent Roy Mullins responds to yesterday's KNS editorial that demeaned Knox County Teachers and criticized a plan to enhance their retirement benefits.

Mullins says "I take exception to the opinion expressed in the editorial" that is "clearly written from a position of ignorance concerning the Knox County school system’s budget, and it misrepresents an initiative that is designed to help keep certified teachers in our classrooms every day and in our school system for a career."

It also sounds like a page from the GOP playbook -- constant attacks on teacher's unions and public education to promote private school vouchers for rich kids instead of making public schools better for everyone.

8
vote

Odd that they'd criticize

Odd that they'd criticize teachers for a relatively modest pension upgrade when they never said a mumbling word about former police chief Phil Keith walking out the door with a lump sum of more than $200,000 (I forget the exact number) under the "DROP" (deferred retirement) plan.

Double-post

Well, please forgive my double-post on this subject, but I feel pretty strongly about it!

The comment below was the last one on yesterday's thread, and no one really chimed in to agree or disagree with me. Truly, isn't this the context in which we should consider teacher pay and benefits? Below...

Still inadequate
Submitted by Tamara Shepherd on Wed, 2007/08/08 - 3:11pm.
"Well, leave it to the beancounter, here, to ponder that $100 per day times 5 days per week times 52 weeks per year equals just $26,000 annually.

WRT leave time, every employer I ever worked for had some kind of "use 'em or lose 'em" policy in place, but all allowed a certain (capped) number of leave days to be rolled over into a new calendar year. Come termination or retirement, though, these accrued days were ALWAYS PAID OUT AT THE EMPLOYEE'S PAY RATE IN EXISTENCE AT THE TIME OF TERMINATION OR RETIREMENT.

Since no teacher either terminating or retiring from teaching is earning just $26,000 annually, I wondered why teachers would settle for only $100 per day, much less $20!

It appears to me, then, that both the old and the new policy "charge" teachers with paying for their own substitutes! In what other industry does that happen!

And contrary to the N-S position that a policy change of this sort "would do little or nothing for education," people who haven't pored over the specifics of the BEP funding formula should be aware that teacher salary and benefits are considered in that formula as direct "classroom costs." Rightly so.

Until the day society ceases to value a 21 year-old chemical engineer at $51,000 annually and a 21 year-old mathematics teacher at $31,000 annually, we should lend our support for whatever manner of teacher pay increase presents itself."

It's been my experience that

It's been my experience that teachers who don't use sick days are there because they love their jobs and the kids. They feel like it's their duty to be there to instruct the kids, and that sense of duty, in today's world of education, should be rewarded.

If Knox Co. wants to retain teachers who love their jobs, then paying them more than $20 for unused sick days is the right thing to do and a good start.

So a teacher can start at 21

So a teacher can start at 21 years old making $31,000 dollars and complain that's not enough? How many of their students come from families that don't make that?

Unsung heroines

A few years ago, one of my children had an excellent elementary teacher with a masters +45 and 13 years teaching experience in a neighboring school system (and who would say "Excuse me?" repeatedly until her students spoke to her using correct grammar, "please," and "thank you"--I loved it).

She confided to me that her starting salary with KCS in that, her first year in Knox County, had been $30,000/year. She stayed with KCS that one year only, and left the profession.

KCS has since begun recognizing for compensation purposes teachers' years of service earned in other school districts. It was a long time coming, though, as was that 25 minutes for lunch they now get, just since about 1995.

Some people point to teachers' "summers off," but if you're a parent, you know how that break is shrinking with each successive school calendar (note that school started this year today, August 9). Teachers return to class a week or two earlier, of course, and continue to work beyond the time kids' school year ends.

Through the school year, they work well beyond eight hours daily.

Every school in Knox County opens at 7:10 am, including middle and high schools in which classes begin at 8:30, and teachers must be there first. In elementary schools, teachers rotate duties attending the bus loading docks, the car riders lines, and the crossings used by "walkers," both before and after school, and some monitor the "bus room" in the mornings. In middle and high schools, teachers sponsor numerous clubs and organizations and offer study sessions, before and after school both. Those club sponsors often give their time on weekends, too.

They're at parent orientation sessions, open houses, and PTA programs evenings and they're often gracious enough to schedule parent conferences before or after school, or occassionally on those 25 minute "lunch hours."

They undertake paper-grading *every* night and many still share thier home phone numbers and/or e-mail addresses with families (my elementary-aged child's teacher last year told me she spent one hour nightly speaking with parents of the 120 5th graders who rotated through her classroom each day).

There is a reason young children think that their teachers live a their school.

How many of their students

How many of their students come from families that don't make that?

What's your point? If their parents didn't know what to do with free public education and use it to their advantage, teachers should make less?

Tamara said

KCS has since begun recognizing for compensation purposes teachers' years of service earned in other school districts.

That is correct, Chuck James and I sponsored the Resolution and a majority of the board voted with us to recognize past service in other districts.

That was one injustice out of several that I am pleased to have been a part of in my 4 years on the board.

No slight intended

I didn't mean to slight you, Brian, I just couldn't recall who had sponsored the measure.

I think the "25 minute lunch hour" was a "perk" delivered from the state legislature?

Oh, That's fine

I don't expect that everyone will remember each item, ultimately a majority of the board approved it.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Captcha
This question is used to make sure you are a human visitor and to prevent spam submissions.
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.
Blog-O-Rama

Bela Fleck's Star Spangled Banner
(Cup of Joe Powell)

Kingston's Going to Smoke the Ash Spill Today
(Enclave)

What I Learned In The News This Week
(Newscoma)

There Can Only Be One
(Newscoma)

Sarah Palin - Train Wrecks Get Top Ratings
(Cup of Joe Powell)

Play Her Off, Keyboard Cat
(Southern Beale)

Feel Good Independence Day
(Silence Isn't Golden)

The Sicko Attacks on Sarah Palin's Baby
(TN Guerilla Women)

KNS: Ash to be Dumped in Loudon?
(RoaneViews)

Jump!
(Domestic Psychology)

Now she 's done it, now I have to go nuclear!
(Left Wing Cracker)

Palin's Resignation: Political Masterstroke Or Extreme Mental Instability of a Castrating Bitch?
(TN Guerilla Women)

Innocent Blogging Fun
(Newscoma)

Scott McNutt cuts to the truth...
(RoaneViews)

Harriman Care and Rehab in the News
(RoaneViews)


Media Blogs

AG: Political Firings Could Have Fiscal Impact on Counties
(Tom Humphrey)

Happy Fourth of July
(Michael Silence)

Happy
(Michael Silence)

This is a joke, right? Top 25 sports outings in TN
(Michael Silence)

Just curious
(Michael Silence)

Memo to the Republican Governors Association
(Michael Silence)

Son of Big Box
(Josh Flory)

TVA Tries Sending Inspection Reports Directly to Landfills
(Snark Bites)

The Wa$hington Po$t
(Michael Silence)

Chapter 11 for condo developer
(Josh Flory)

Gone Fishin': Pith is Off Today
(Pith in the Wind)

Thoughts On Kyle's Kinda, Sorta Kickoff for Governor
(Tom Humphrey)

Bredesen Lectures Legislators on License Plates -- Again
(Tom Humphrey)

Robin Has a Website
(Tom Humphrey)

Cobb Successor To Be Elected on Oct. 13
(Tom Humphrey)


Post Politics

Proving Her Critics Right
(AC Kleinheider)

Makes As Much Sense As Anything I’ve Heard Yet
(AC Kleinheider)

Resigned On The 3rd Of July: Sarah Palin Steps Down As Governor
(AC Kleinheider)

Like He Never Existed
(AC Kleinheider)

You’re Light, Son
(AC Kleinheider)

Can Jim Kyle Win The Democratic Nomination For Governor?
(AC Kleinheider)

Shout Out To Tuke
(AC Kleinheider)

Alexander Wishes You A Happy Independence Day
(AC Kleinheider)

Cammack, North Of Two Hundie
(AC Kleinheider)

Ford Dynasty Member Says He’ll Make A Run At Memphis Mayor
(AC Kleinheider)


Local News

Woman dies in wreck on Chapman Highway
(Knoxville News Sentinel)

Drownings reminder to use pool alarms, gates and buddies
(Knoxville News Sentinel)

TWRA plans extra boat patrols
(Knoxville News Sentinel)

Father's fraud followed son's debt woes
(Knoxville News Sentinel)

Lockett is subject of 3 investigations
(Knoxville News Sentinel)

Downtown condo developer files bankruptcy
(Knoxville News Sentinel Business)

Auto fallout still felt locally
(Knoxville News Sentinel Business)

Loudon residents fight against ash disposal
(Knoxville News Sentinel Business)

Hospital management at issue in Claiborne County
(Knoxville News Sentinel Business)

Tazewell hospital proposals to be heard Monday
(Knoxville News Sentinel Business)

Governor Bredesen Issues Writ of Election
(State of Tennessee)

Bredesen Breaks Ground on Recovery Act Project in Nashville
(State of Tennessee)

Extended Unemployment Benefits Available for Eligible Tennesseans
(State of Tennessee)

THP Gears Up For July 4th Weekend Crackdown on Drunk Drivers
(State of Tennessee)

Tennessee Announces 2009-10 School Meal Guidelines
(State of Tennessee)

Blount County K-9 officer loses battle with cancer
(WATE local)

Deadly Knoxville shooting and police pursuit ends in crash
(WATE local)

Stripper upset kidnapping, rape charges were dropped
(WATE local)

Family's gas grill explodes catching house on fire
(WATE local)

Blount County K-9 loses battle with cancer
(WATE local)

Joey Chestnut's 68 hot dogs win third straight eating contest
(WBIR Local)

Update: Victim dies after Friday afternoon shooting
(WBIR Local)

Teacher trainees get more face time with students
(WBIR Local)

Dandridge woman dies in Sevier Co. car crash
(WBIR Local)

Local fireworks laws, displays in your area
(WBIR Local)

Beefing up patrols on Tennessee highways
(WVLT Local)

Honduras rejects OAS appeal to restore president
(WVLT Local)

SKorea says NKorea fires 2 missiles off east coast
(WVLT Local)

Flames engulf boat on Fort Loudoun Lake
(WVLT Local)

Kyle says gubernatorial race decision coming soon
(WVLT Local)


Wire Reports

Coroner: Teen 5th killed by apparent serial killer (AP)
(AP National News)

Europe's free, state-run health care has drawbacks (AP)
(AP Politics)

Chestnut wins NY hot dog eating match, again (AP)
(AP National News)

Analysis: Palin's resignation hurts her future (AP)
(AP Politics)

Calif. bullet train hits criticism on SF Peninsula (AP)
(AP National News)

Fireworks explosion on NC island kills 1, hurts 4 (AP)
(AP National News)

Soldier who fought in pink boxers home for 4th (AP)
(AP National News)

Obama's trip: 3 more countries, 1 broad mission (AP)
(AP Politics)

Palin keeps low-profile after surprise news (AP)
(AP National News)

Police: Arizona woman led sons on crime spree (AP)
(AP National News)

U.S. hopes Obama's visit to Ghana will spur others (Reuters)
(AP Politics)

Russia to grant U.S. Afghan supply route (Reuters)
(AP Politics)

Night of barbecue, fireworks on tap at White House (AP)
(AP Politics)

INSIDE WASHINGTON: Archives' many missing items (AP)
(AP Politics)

60 votes not so super for Obama, Senate Democrats (AP)
(AP Politics)

Curious Russia prepares to welcome Obama (AFP)
(AP Politics)

Offensive is first test for Obama's Afghanistan strategy (AFP)
(AP Politics)

Palin shocker a boon to her lieutenant (Politico)
(AP Politics)

Colin Powell cautions Obama on big government (AP)
(AP Politics)

Colin Powell: Celebrate Michael Jackson's art (AP)
(AP Politics)