Wed
Jun 6 2007
07:21 pm
By: R. Neal  shortURL

Andy Axel tells it like it is in a comment below which I shall post on the front page here...

This is the daily friggin' battle.

We elect a Democrat into the governor's office who trashes workers' comp, throws people off their health insurance, his support for Senate candidates nets the loss of the Senate majority, he chides supporters of the Kerry candidacy in 2004, and we help to re-elect him anyway because JIM! Bryson is such a nutsack.

We throw our support behind Harold Ford Jr. even though he quickly proceeds to sell out progressive causes throughout his campaign, and watch helplessly as he jumps into a cozy seat in the GOP-lite DLC chair.

We're forced to endure multiple indignities on progressive issues like gay marriage because stupid Democrats walk right into these traps set for us by Republicans, and because, well, we suck at framing issues and try to lead by following.

We get the John Fords and Ward Crutchfields and Dave Cooleys and Doug Henrys and Jerry Coopers and Jimmy Naifehs working on our account. Big whoop.

It's the daily death by a thousand cuts, and the guy almost always wielding the knife for the coup de grace in this godforsaken place always seems to have a donkey on his lapel. (And I do mean "his.") And then we get to play laughingstock to the smug, self-righteous "fuck the South" types. Not saying that Tennessee doesn't earn it at times, but Brittney Gilbert sure as hell didn't. These people conveniently forget: If Al Gore had spent five minutes here, he'd probably be president today.

This isn't any kind of news to anyone, I'm certain.

Now we have to sweat national bloggers enforcing their own vision of partisan piety, and doing so at the expense of people with the least influence and zero actual power.

Et tu, PatriotBoy?

To which I can add... not much right now, because that pretty much sums it up. I'm still formulating my thoughts. I will have more on this later.

Topics:
109
like
autoegocrat's picture

Andy nails it again

Whoever you are Andy Axel, you hit it on the head again.

stiffy08's picture

What about Brittney's opinion?

Hi everyone:

In all the fervor, I think many of us may have missed the point of Brittney's resignation. This gong-show hasn't happened in isolation. As per Brittney's resignation letter:

-------------
I’ve been thinking about this decision for a long, long time, so don’t go thinking that anyone in particular won here. Nobody specifically pushed me out. This decision is the culmination of lots of long hours of pondering, checking myself, and wondering if I’ve got what it takes. I decided I don’t.
-------------

So why don't we all leave well enough alone and let her get on with her life? Same goes for Patriotboy. They both made mistakes, they both admit it, and they both apologize. Brittney makes it clear that she wasn't too happy in her job anyway. So Andy Axel and all the rest of you, if you're unhappy with her decision, take it up with her, rather than her those who critiqued her to keep her accountable.

Terry Troll's picture

It's about the same on the

It's about the same on the national level. Only 14 Senators can be found to try to overide the veto of the war funding bill even though the will of the people is evident. I wrote Dean, Pelosi and Reid after that embarrasment and said after 40 years of supporting Democrats, my donations and probably my vote just started going elsewhere. Of course, I got not even an acknowledgement of my letters.
James Carville nailed it the other night on C-Span. He said he had good news for both Republicans and Democrats. For the D's: The American people want to vote Democratic. For the R's : The Democrats are perfectly capable of talking the American people out of it.

Ennui's picture

We get the John Fords and

We get the John Fords and Ward Crutchfields and Dave Cooleys and Doug Henrys and Jerry Coopers and Jimmy Naifehs working on our account. Big whoop.

Well said. A very salient, if depressing point.

Andy Axel's picture

And onward goes this thing of ours.

I'm still somewhere between outrage and sadness over this whole deal. Obviously, there's a lot tied up in this, and I'm trying my best to keep my feelings about Brittney's professional decision separate from this thing we do.

A lot has been bubbling up in my own personal and professional life, and I'd like to do this community a courtesy that we won't be getting from the Smug Soldiers in JG's rank & file.

By way of an example: "Democommie" showed up over there and outlined his rationale (or, rather, his rationalization). I still don't agree with what he did there, and I'm still heartsick over this outcome. I have a long post that I had been considering sticking up on NiT, but they're well up on 340+ comments and the horse is dead, in repose, and will start to turn fallow soon.

Still, blogging is just a tactic. And in some ways, I think it's actually a distraction from the real work that needs to be done in this Republic as a whole. I still believe that you can only put the truth out there, and then to trust that the outcome will be favorable. Many times, it's not. Many times, it feels like the deck is hopelessly stacked against progress.

I am, however, sick to tears of rage of being blamed, time and again, for the crap state of affairs by people who should goddamned well know better. Brittney was unfairly targeted because JG could use her employment status as leverage, but she was also unfairly called to account for generations of racism and unfairly called to account for printing someone else's words in a manner summarily judged to be unfit. Later, she didn't apologize correctly enough, or sincerely enough, or whatever enough a vaffanculo. The shit people were slinging her way was breathtakingly ungrounded, much of it vile, and it was far out of proportion to any sin that she was alleged to have committed.

I believe this was an outgrowth of an incipient set of myopic political heuristics that perpetuate the myth that The South is the wellspring of this society's troubles, and is therefore expendable politically. I watched this spin out of control on DKos last year as dedicated progressive citizens of TN were chided, lambasted, and called every name in the book for supporting Harold Ford Jr. and his stupid, doomed candidacy. Then, in the wake of that, we're to blame for not being progressive enough for the progressives, even though there's no infrastructure to support that cause, but we won't get that infrastructure because we don't win, so we continue to lose out on progressive causes.

(And the prescription from Democommie at NiT? "Go make [more progressives]." Yeah. It's just that easy, huh. [slaps forehead] Gee, I've been doing this the hard way! Say, I believe I'll go make nuclear fusion while I'm at it. Shall I solve world hunger on my way home today, too?)

And so it goes.

Thanks for promoting this to the front page, Randy. I look forward to seeing what thoughts this whole episode has brought up for you.

So Andy Axel and all the rest of you, if you're unhappy with her decision, take it up with her, rather than her those who critiqued her to keep her accountable.

Well, I will. That is, I plan to.

All the same, there is indeed a wider context to these events, and I invite you to learn about it. (In this case, the wider context was Egalia's observation that "I think there's some kind of awful lesson in the fact that the final straw came from the left"). That's truer than n00bs to this community realize, and it has much larger implications in 3D reality.

The Tennessee blogging community isn't just about people and their jobs, it's about passions and politics as well, and there are a lot of voices to add to that chorus.

And I will still feel free to critique people who say ungrounded things about people that they don't know. I will absolutely critique unfair treatment from people who can't see past their petty assumptions. If you don't like my opinions? I invite you to engage responsibly or to find your browser's back button.

(some late edits for clarity.)

____________________________

I'm a guy in a Reagan mask -- and I'm running for President!

metulj's picture

And then we get to play

And then we get to play laughingstock to the smug, self-righteous "fuck the South" types. Not saying that Tennessee doesn't earn it at times, but Brittney Gilbert sure as hell didn't. These people conveniently forget: If Al Gore had spent five minutes here, he'd probably be president today.

Look, I moved away to the North nearly 2 years ago. I hear the forget-the-South rhetoric a lot. I went to one Democratic party meeting here and saw a floor fight that lead to two Democratic columns appearing on the ballot. One was the Machine. The other was the Wants-to-be-Machine.

Check out the primary results:

(link...)

You know what? That's looks damn sure like a Knox County Primary. No wait. That's not fair. A Knox County election is more balanced.

I like living here. As a matter of fact, I love it in many ways, but anytime I hear somebody rip on the idiocy of Southern politics, I need only remind them that at least there is some politics in the South.

True happiness is knowing you are a hypocrite. -- Ivor Cutler

Andy Axel's picture

[edited]

(I'd imagined that I had something pertinent to say, I thought, but then I read it again, I realized, "Jeez. I'm fast becoming the Tennessee blogosphere's answer to Walter Sobchak.")

"F*ck it, Dude. Let's go bowling."

And yeah, metulj. Fair enough.

____________________________

I'm a guy in a Reagan mask -- and I'm running for President!

Andy Axel's picture

(blump)

(blump) See above.

____________________________

I'm a guy in a Reagan mask -- and I'm running for President!

R. Neal's picture

Is it just me, or has anyone

Is it just me, or has anyone else noticed that NIT has taken a turn to the right in the short time since Brittney's departure?

Also, some blogs that came out strong in her support seem to no longer be showing up on the aggregator, including Michael Silence.

Nice work, PatriotBoy!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is used to make sure you are a human visitor and to prevent spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

Upcoming events:

Lost Medicaid Funding

To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Local Media Blogs

Local News

News Sentinel

State News

Wire Reports

Site Statistics

Last 7 days:
  • Posts: 27
  • Comments: 315
  • Visits: 11,496
  • Pageviews: 30,308
Last 30 days:
  • Posts: 133
  • Comments: 1806
  • Visits: 48,421
  • Pageviews: 136,755

TN Progressive

Nearby:

Beyond:

At large: