John Kerry's Hypocrisy and Incompetence

Submitted by Les Jones on Sun, 2007/01/28 - 10:57pm.

John Kerry was in Davos, Switzerland last week speaking to an international audience, and took the opportunity to fire a few shots at Bush.

"When we walk away from global warming, Kyoto, when we are irresponsibly slow in moving toward AIDS in Africa, when we don't advance and live up to our own rhetoric and standards, we set a terrible message of duplicity and hypocrisy," Kerry said.

Captain Ed counters:

Once again, we have the spectre of Kyoto haunting the Bush administration, when it was the Clinton administration that refused to submit the treaty to the Senate -- and the Senate that unanimously passed a resolution saying they'd never ratify it. The Byrd-Hagel Resolution in 1997 made it clear that the US would not allow itself to be bound by the treaty as long as it exempted India, China, and other developing nations. That's the same position as the Bush Administration has taken -- and the same position that John Kerry himself took in 1997 when he voted in favor of the Byrd-Hagel Resolution.

That's yet another example of the hypocrisy of John Kerry -- but there's more.

He took the time to scold the Bush administration for its lack of effort on AIDS and other diseases in Africa. However, Bush has already spent more on these issues than the last Democratic administration did in eight years. Humanitarian aid to Africa comprised $1.4 billion a year at the end of the Clinton administration, but Bush has tripled that to $4 billion per year -- and wants to more than double it over the next two years:

Not only is Kerry hypocritical here, he's frankly incompetent. There are plenty of legitimate criticisms of Bush. He has eroded civil liberties even beyond what might be considered necessary in wartime. He used gay marriage and the promise of a marriage amendment to the Constitution to win votes (and then dropped the amendment once the election was over). His habit of picking political cronies for appointments gave us the incompetent Michael Brown at FEMA during one of the worst civil disasters in history. He fumbled badly in nominating the unqualified but sycophantic Harriet Miers to the Supreme Court.

Even conservatives have legitimate beefs with Bush. He has no comprehensive immigration policy. Millions of people can walk across our border unannounced, yet INS stonewalls and quota limits doctors, engineers, scientists, and programmers who want to immigrate here. He hasn't prosecuted the war as effectively as he could have, and has taken a long time in addressing Iran's role in turning Iraq into a proxy U.S.-Iran war. He's also been the opposite of a small-government conservative - increasing the size of the Federal budget and creating a new Medicare prescription drug plan that creates a new intergenerational liability without raising Federal revenues a cent to fund it.

Of course, bumbling Kerry couldn't field any of those legitimate complaints. He had to pick two issues where Bush was either no worse than his predecessor or was significantly better, and on Kyoto Kerry himself voted against U.S. ratification before Bush ever stepped into office. One thing you can say about a second Bush administration is that it's no worse than a first Kerry administration would have been.

5
vote

Andy Axel's picture
One thing you can say about

One thing you can say about a second Bush administration is that it's no worse than a first Kerry administration would have been.

No, that's one thing you can say.

____________________________

Recursive blogwhore.

Sven's picture
I won't disagree with the

I won't disagree with the bumbler label, but I think there's some rewriting of history going on here.

Clinton didn't submit the treaty because Republicans promised to kill it. And once again typical parliamentary maneuvering is turned into "flip flopping." This was Kerry's position:

"What we have here is not ratifiable in the Senate in my judgment," Sen. John F. Kerry (D-Mass.) said. According to aides in Washington, Kerry wanted Clinton to sign the deal but hold off submission of it until follow-on conferences scheduled for Bonn in June and Buenos Aires in November.

[...]

Kerry said a delay in formal approval of the treaty need not impede compliance with its goals, noting that the United States often has gone along with treaties before they were ratified. He and Sen. Joseph I. Lieberman (D-Conn.), who also supports the treaty, said in Kyoto that they are confident strong U.S. public support for action on global warming will help them eventually push the pact through the Senate.

Les Jones's picture
Sven:

Clinton didn't submit it because Senators Republican and Democrat were against it. Kerry and every other Democrat either voted for Byrd-Hagel or abstained. Was he for it or against it? According to his vote he was for Byrd-Hagel and against Kyoto as it stood and stands.

Democrats aren't proud of Byrd-Hagel, but it's a fact that not one Senate Democrat voted against it.

That's why I say people concerned with global warming don't have a party, people who are for gay marriage don't have a party, and people who want smaller government don't have a party.

www.lesjones.com

Sven's picture
it's a fact that not one

it's a fact that not one Senate Democrat voted against it.

I don't know if you're being coy or just thick. Yes, there were and are Democrats opposed to Kyoto, just as there are a few Republicans opposed to reckless tax cuts and wars.

Kerry and other Democrats, who would have otherwise voted for Kyoto as it stood, voted for the resolution in hopes of gaining the supermajority needed for ratification of a re-negotatiated treaty. That doesn't mean they were opposed to Kyoto. It means they were being realistic and trying to make the best of it; they understood that if a vote went forward, the treaty was done for good.

Even the NRDC doesn't hold it against him.

Um, why waste time kicking

Um, why waste time kicking this particular horse? Isn't John Kerry dead enough for you?

Les Jones's picture
gemini:

"Um, why waste time kicking this particular horse?"

Good question. Sometimes I think Kerry is my white whale.

www.lesjones.com

Sven's picture
Oh, Jeebus: The US

Oh, Jeebus:

The US government wants the world's scientists to develop technology to block sunlight as a last-ditch way to halt global warming, the Guardian has learned. It says research into techniques such as giant mirrors in space or reflective dust pumped into the atmosphere would be "important insurance" against rising emissions, and has lobbied for such a strategy to be recommended by a major UN report on climate change, the first part of which will be published on Friday.

I might actually respect some Machiavellian machinations on the Bushies' part. That's just F-ing pathetic.

That's why I say people

That's why I say people concerned with global warming don't have a party, people who are for gay marriage don't have a party, and people who want smaller government don't have a party.

I thought you said you weren't concerned with the problems the GOP faces going into the new millennium, Les...

Les, thanks for the honest

Les, thanks for the honest accounting of Bush's failings. I've been stewing recently over how unrepentent many Republicans seem in the wake of the 2006 elections, so it was especially refreshing to read this post. With various Republican Senators rediscovering their honesty and independence, perhaps we can look forward to more civil conversations soon, without the cheap "hate America" dismissals and polarizations.

The notion of interest groups without a party also resonates with me. I think the most serious bias in our nation's press and politics is the bias of omission. Think of all the aspects of American statesmanship and leadership omitted from the 2004 Presidential election. Of course, the media is working hard to bring us another soulless popularity contest in 2008 as well.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Captcha
This question is used to make sure you are a human visitor and to prevent spam submissions.
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.
Blog-O-Rama

I just don't have any words for this....
(Left Wing Cracker)

Happy 4th & About Nashville's Fireworks Celebration
(TN Guerilla Women)

R.I.P. Steve McNair
(Silence Isn't Golden)

Bela Fleck's Star Spangled Banner
(Cup of Joe Powell)

Kingston's Going to Smoke the Ash Spill Today
(Enclave)

What I Learned In The News This Week
(Newscoma)

There Can Only Be One
(Newscoma)

Sarah Palin - Train Wrecks Get Top Ratings
(Cup of Joe Powell)

Play Her Off, Keyboard Cat
(Southern Beale)

Feel Good Independence Day
(Silence Isn't Golden)

The Sicko Attacks on Sarah Palin's Baby
(TN Guerilla Women)

KNS: Ash to be Dumped in Loudon?
(RoaneViews)

Jump!
(Domestic Psychology)

Now she 's done it, now I have to go nuclear!
(Left Wing Cracker)

Palin's Resignation: Political Masterstroke Or Extreme Mental Instability of a Castrating Bitch?
(TN Guerilla Women)


Media Blogs

Titans Legend Steve McNair Found Shot and Killed in Downtown Apartment Complex
(Pith in the Wind)

AG: Political Firings Could Have Fiscal Impact on Counties
(Tom Humphrey)

Happy Fourth of July
(Michael Silence)

Happy
(Michael Silence)

This is a joke, right? Top 25 sports outings in TN
(Michael Silence)

Just curious
(Michael Silence)

Memo to the Republican Governors Association
(Michael Silence)

Son of Big Box
(Josh Flory)

TVA Tries Sending Inspection Reports Directly to Landfills
(Snark Bites)

The Wa$hington Po$t
(Michael Silence)

Chapter 11 for condo developer
(Josh Flory)

Gone Fishin': Pith is Off Today
(Pith in the Wind)

Thoughts On Kyle's Kinda, Sorta Kickoff for Governor
(Tom Humphrey)

Bredesen Lectures Legislators on License Plates -- Again
(Tom Humphrey)

Robin Has a Website
(Tom Humphrey)


Post Politics

Proving Her Critics Right
(AC Kleinheider)

Makes As Much Sense As Anything I’ve Heard Yet
(AC Kleinheider)

Resigned On The 3rd Of July: Sarah Palin Steps Down As Governor
(AC Kleinheider)

Like He Never Existed
(AC Kleinheider)

You’re Light, Son
(AC Kleinheider)

Can Jim Kyle Win The Democratic Nomination For Governor?
(AC Kleinheider)

Shout Out To Tuke
(AC Kleinheider)

Alexander Wishes You A Happy Independence Day
(AC Kleinheider)

Cammack, North Of Two Hundie
(AC Kleinheider)

Ford Dynasty Member Says He’ll Make A Run At Memphis Mayor
(AC Kleinheider)


Local News

Woman on holiday outing drowns in Douglas Lake
(Knoxville News Sentinel)

Woman dies in wreck on Chapman Highway
(Knoxville News Sentinel)

Drownings reminder to use pool alarms, gates and buddies
(Knoxville News Sentinel)

TWRA plans extra boat patrols
(Knoxville News Sentinel)

Father's fraud followed son's debt woes
(Knoxville News Sentinel)

Downtown condo developer files bankruptcy
(Knoxville News Sentinel Business)

Auto fallout still felt locally
(Knoxville News Sentinel Business)

Loudon residents fight against ash disposal
(Knoxville News Sentinel Business)

Hospital management at issue in Claiborne County
(Knoxville News Sentinel Business)

Tazewell hospital proposals to be heard Monday
(Knoxville News Sentinel Business)

Governor Bredesen Issues Writ of Election
(State of Tennessee)

Bredesen Breaks Ground on Recovery Act Project in Nashville
(State of Tennessee)

Extended Unemployment Benefits Available for Eligible Tennesseans
(State of Tennessee)

THP Gears Up For July 4th Weekend Crackdown on Drunk Drivers
(State of Tennessee)

Tennessee Announces 2009-10 School Meal Guidelines
(State of Tennessee)

Some East Tennesseans celebrate independence with tea parties
(WATE local)

Blount County K-9 officer loses battle with cancer
(WATE local)

Deadly Knoxville shooting and police pursuit ends in crash
(WATE local)

Stripper upset kidnapping, rape charges were dropped
(WATE local)

Family's gas grill explodes catching house on fire
(WATE local)

Hundreds gather for Athens TEA Party
(WBIR Local)

Festival on the Fourth gears up at World's Fair Park
(WBIR Local)

Former Titans quarterback Steve McNair found dead in Nashville
(WBIR Local)

Crews recover woman's body from Douglas Lake
(WBIR Local)

Joey Chestnut's 68 hot dogs win third straight eating contest
(WBIR Local)

Beefing up patrols on Tennessee highways
(WVLT Local)

Honduras rejects OAS appeal to restore president
(WVLT Local)

UPDATE: Police investigate deadly shooting, high speed chase and crash
(WVLT Local)

SKorea says NKorea fires 2 missiles off east coast
(WVLT Local)

Alleged victim, estranged wife talk about dropped kidnap and rape charges
(WVLT Local)


Wire Reports

Obama says U.S. a strong partner of Iraq despite pullout (Reuters)
(AP Politics)

Palin links resignation to 'higher calling' (AP)
(AP Politics)

Ghana, but not forgotten (Politico)
(AP Politics)

Former NFL quarterback McNair killed in Tennessee (AP)
(AP National News)

Fireworks explosion on NC island kills 2, hurts 3 (AP)
(AP National News)

Obama says supports Kremlin chief on more freedoms (Reuters)
(AP Politics)

Soldier who fought in pink boxers home for the 4th (AP)
(AP National News)

Palin keeps low-profile after plan to resign (AP)
(AP National News)

INSIDE WASHINGTON: Archives' record-keeping lapse (AP)
(AP Politics)

Obama, McCain give dueling holiday addresses (AP)
(AP Politics)

Palin fires back at press on Facebook (Politico)
(AP Politics)

Chestnut wins NY hot dog eating match, 3d in row (AP)
(AP National News)

Colin Powell cautions Obama on big government (AP)
(AP Politics)

Obama's trip: A mission to reshape US image (AP)
(AP Politics)

More than 1 million seek tix for Jackson memorial (AP)
(AP National News)

Analysis: Palin's resignation raises questions (AP)
(AP Politics)

Curious Russia prepares to welcome Obama (AFP)
(AP Politics)

Lady Liberty's crown reopens on July Fourth (AP)
(AP National News)

Coroner: Teen 5th killed by apparent serial killer (AP)
(AP National News)

Europe's free, state-run health care has drawbacks (AP)
(AP Politics)