Today's Knoxville News Sentinel editorial says "Plan to bum-rush appointments is outrage":
Since the appointments run only until the 2008 elections, Moore and some other commissioners evidently don't want to be bothered with the niceties of public forums, open discussion and candidates making their cases before an open meeting.Instead, what Moore and the others want is the same system they have had for too long - a political country club where the members say who can be admitted and who is excluded.
That would be a serious mistake, not only for the commission but as well for the credibility of county government.
Lots of folks are not going to have a chance to have their voices heard. Will it come back to haunt the sitting, non-term limited commissioners? Probably not. Most people just don't seem all that interested. But it will be interesting to see who goes on record in support of an open process at today's meeting.
I was talking to some folks at the News Sentinel and they said the controversy isn't generating much reader interest. There was speculation on why this is. One reporter noted that it's complicated, and it may be that people simply don't understand it. (Which may have prompted this primer in Sunday's paper.)
My theory is that most people see it as a lot of inside baseball they just don't care. As evidence, look at the 20% turnout in local elections. Or the fact that voters (and those who don't bother) keep electing the same people they voted to term limit twelve years ago.
In other term limit news, over at the Halls Shopper Sandra Clark has a farewell love letter to Sheriff Tim, and Betty Bean has this backgrounder on his presumed successor.
|
|
Discussing:
- How the Cost of a Burger Stacks Up in Every State (1 reply)
- Judge blocks Biden administration rule capping credit card late fees at $8 (1 reply)
- Knoxville stays among top-10 US cities for rising home prices, most realtors expect continued increases over the next year (1 reply)
- Private equity ownership of hospitals made care riskier for patients, a new study finds (24 replies)
- Labor Dept. says Tennessee firm employed minors to clean meat saws, head splitters at slaughterhouses (3 replies)
- Yowza! That was some storm last night (2 replies)
- Why are prices still so high? Corporate greed, some say (4 replies)
- UT pro-Palestine protests (7 replies)
- Boeing was once known for safety and engineering (11 replies)
- Walmart is closing its health centers and virtual care service (5 replies)
- Accidental shooting at local park? (4 replies)
- Oracle is moving its world headquarters to Nashville (2 replies)
TN Progressive
- Toons (RoaneViews)
- Appeals court: Wildlife officers’ warrantless searches of private property are unconstitutional (RoaneViews)
- Friday Toon (RoaneViews)
- Kimmell Destroys Trump in Monologue (RoaneViews)
- Chef steals food to serve at restaurant? (BlountViews)
- Blount County, TDOT make road deal for gun mfg ignoring town of Louisville,TN, (BlountViews)
- It's voting time again. Let's get out the vote. (BlountViews)
- Winter at the Big Rocks (Whitescreek Journal)
- Maryville Daily Times Home Delivery changing again (BlountViews)
- Secrets from My Radio Days (Joe Powell)
- Fall 2022 (Whitescreek Journal)
- Mmmm, A Fresh Hot Cup of Joe (Joe Powell)
TN Politics
- Judge refuses to dismiss all claims by transgender child against state, Williamson County Schools (TN Lookout)
- ‘Mom’ legislators see their numbers, influence grow but barriers to elected office remain (TN Lookout)
- Editor’s notebook: Gushy Mother’s Day posts from Tennessee lawmakers don’t reflect reality (TN Lookout)
- Tariffs to be sharply hiked by Biden administration on Chinese-made products (TN Lookout)
- Appeals court: Wildlife officers’ warrantless searches of private property are unconstitutional (TN Lookout)
- The Tennessee Legislature and Stone Cold Steve Austin (TN Lookout)
Knox TN Today
- Tom Underwood: A life in education, with jokes (Knox TN Today)
- Kronick’s Chronicles: Program of all programs (Knox TN Today)
- Mountain Laurel: Close to being at peak bloom (Knox TN Today)
- Gresham STEM class grows lettuce (Knox TN Today)
- Rotary awards 2024 Peace Award to Baker, CareCuts (Knox TN Today)
- Erin Pate is all books and smiles (Knox TN Today)
- Holston High class of ’64 celebrates 60th reunion (Knox TN Today)
- Beaver Creek Flotilla is Saturday (Knox TN Today)
- Northern lights come south (Knox TN Today)
- Oldest Vol to throw out first pitch (Knox TN Today)
- Losing a hand never slowed Kenny Bosch (Knox TN Today)
- Covenant Health gets ‘America’s Best’ nod (Knox TN Today)
Local TV News
- Improvements seen under Knox County's new ambulance contract (WATE)
- 2024 National Safe Boating Week comes up, TWRA to participate (WBIR)
- Remains found in 2022 identified by the Knox County Regional Forensic Center (WATE)
- WATE set to air 4 SEC games Labor Day weekend (WATE)
- Roane County couple accused in children's deaths face key court hearing Tuesday (WBIR)
- Pigeon Forge breaks ground on new $46.5 million police, fire headquarters (WATE)
- Nicotine product growing in popularity, attracting underage users (WATE)
- Habitat for Humanity working to tackle housing crisis in Knoxville (WATE)
- Family of fallen Knox Co. deputy Tucker Blakely attends 2024 Tennessee Law Enforcement Officers' Memorial Service (WBIR)
- Tennessee Theatre hosts first-ever Marquee Awards to honor high school musicals (WBIR)
- 'We are heartbroken and grieving' | Zoo Knoxville humanely euthanizes 46-year-old elephant Tonka (WBIR)
- Tennessee Valley Fair announces Ludacris to perform in September (WBIR)
News Sentinel
State News
- Sinkhole closes State Highway 111, detour imposed - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Two die in Meigs County after jump from bluff - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Linda Kapperman Obituary - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Glenda Pinckard Obituary - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
Wire Reports
- Canada wildfire smoke puts Kansas City, Kansas air quality among U.S. worst - The Washington Post (US News)
- 8 dead, dozens injured in farmworkers bus crash in central Florida - The Associated Press (US News)
- Biden raises tariffs on Chinese EVs, chips and other goods - The Associated Press (Business)
- Storms kill at three people in Louisiana; flood risk looms for Texas - The Washington Post (US News)
- Comcast to Launch Streaming Bundle of Peacock, Netflix and Apple TV+ - The Wall Street Journal (Business)
- Walmart Will Cut, Relocate Hundreds of Corporate Jobs, WSJ Says - Bloomberg (Business)
- In Michael Cohen's testimony against Donald Trump, a possible defense witness emerges - CBS News (US News)
- GameStop and AMC Shares Soar as Meme Stock Revival Continues - The New York Times (Business)
- Harvard Reaches Agreement With Protesters to End Encampment - The New York Times (US News)
- Stocks Edge Higher As Powell Sees This Rate Move Likely; GameStop Soars Again In Revived Meme Frenzy - Investor's Business Daily (Business)
- Mike Johnson defends Trump outside N.Y. criminal trial - Axios (US News)
- Amazon's cloud unit CEO Adam Selipsky to step down - Yahoo Finance (Business)
- Jon Stewart calls out Nancy Pelosi, Hunter Biden and Bob Menendez in segment on political corruption - Fox News (US News)
- Boy, 9, narrowly missed in drive-by shooting caught on home security camera - NBC News (US News)
- Anglo American eyes break-up as it fends off BHP offer - Reuters (Business)
Local Media
Lost Medicaid Funding
Search and Archives
TN Progressive
Nearby:
- Blount Dems
- Herston TN Family Law
- Inside of Knoxville
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jim Stovall
- Knox Dems
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Outdoor Knoxville
- Pittman Properties
- Reality Me
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
Beyond:
- Nashville Scene
- Nashville Post
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Journal
- TN Lookout
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South
The Best Thing
Probably isn't a popular view, but the best thing would probably be for the existing officeholders to stay in place until a new election in August. The reason is to eliminate the political crony appointment process and to avoid creating an incumbency by the apointees.
The Supremes allowed for this possiblility in their decision by saying that the incumbents could stay in office until their replacement was appointed or elected.
That would give possible candidates time to really prepare for the next election and would eliminate a lot of the maneuvering going on right now.
The politicos don't want this because they see the appointment process as a way to retain control.
The Best Thing -- the problem I have
My initial thoughts were the same as yours -- if you let the incumbents stay until the election it would take the backroom dealings out of it.
Then I realized that the let-stay-until-the-election possibility would really allow the maximum possible time for the incumbents and their pals to think up new and creative ways to cut the best possible backroom deals for themselves.
I like Sheriff Tim myself
I like Sheriff Tim myself and feel like he done a good job considering what he had to put up with and deal with. That Hall Shopper article by Sandra almost made me puke. What a load of crap?
So long to Shurf Tim
That Hall Shopper article by Sandra almost made me puke. What a load of crap?
Well, Sam, at least I used my whole (real) name. -- s.
Well, Sam, at least I used
Well, Sam, at least I used my whole (real) name. -- s.
True, but you left out "Tim's Pet" between the two.
County Commission politics
County Commission politics are so fluid right now that by the time anybody on the outside of the inner circle gets wind of what's afoot and makes a prediction , the game plan's already changed.
Take this paragraph, for example, leaving aside the numerical mistake already pointed out by Mark Harmon:
"County Commission (on which Republicans outnumber Democrats 15-4) has the responsibility of filling these vacancies, but commissioners are apparently willing to allow the lame duck sheriff, trustee and register of deeds (all Republicans) to name their successors. It is unclear whether this privilege is being extended to County Clerk Mike Padgett, a Democrat."
Latest credible rumor is that Billy Tindell will be a place-holder in the clerk's office, and Scott Moore will run for the seat next year. Another less-credible rumor is that Larry Cox may be Tindell's commission replacement. the problem with this is that it violates the Democrat-for-Democrat plan, since Cox has voted in GOP primaries for the past 17 years (as per public election records).
what aboat this
commission appoint per ruling..the re constituted commission request tim (he wants 14 votes for)to introduce a special election bill..sept primary nov general
Math correction
I need to correct one bit of math in Betty Bean's column. Republicans outnumber Democrats 14-5 on county commission, at least at the moment. The five Democrats are: Jordan, Strickland, Tindell, Cawood, and me.
Oops. Sorry, Commissioner
Oops.
Sorry, Commissioner Harmon. I wouldn't intentionally ignore you for nuttin'. Tripped up by force of long-ingrained habit.
Another Math Correction
Jordan may run as a Democrat ..but I do believe she is in the Reublicans back pocket, so actually it is 15-4
Partisan Politics
Jordan may run as a Democrat ..but I do believe she is in the Reublicans back pocket, so actually it is 15-4
Actually, partisan politics are almost never an issue on County Commission. Witness the fact that on a 15-4 Commission the Vice-Chair is a Democrat, and a couple of years ago when the Commission got stuck 9-9 on a vote for chairman it elected as a Chairman pro-tem Billy Tindell, with Tank Strickland as vice-chair. Commission politics are MUCH more about city vs. county or faction vs. faction (e.g. Sheriff vs. County Mayor) than Democrat vs. Republican, and have been for as long as I can remember.
Appointments to county-wide office, OTOH, is a different matter, and party politics do matter much more there. However, if the rumor is right and the Commission is going to appoint Tindell to Padgett's office, it shows again that personal relationships are more important than partisanship on the Commission.
join the club
personal relationships are more important than partisanship
Lots of things are more important than partisanship.
On issues pertinent to county policy, both parties agree. Pay for sewers, squander the land. County policy is property taxes and school budgets. No one favors property tax increases nor thinks our children deserve anything but the best, so both parties pledge balance. Bipartisan agreement.
Neither party is especially good at achieving balance. It's more of a controlled spill, perpetually splashing dollars on the future.
Balance is an illusion...
Neither party is especially good at achieving balance. It's more of a controlled spill, perpetually splashing dollars on the future.
It is the Golden Rule. He who has the Gold makes the Rules.
Lots of things are more
Lots of things are more important than partisanship.
I didn't mean that in a normative sense, but in a realpolitik sense. All I was trying to get across is that for the most part the Commissioners themselves do not line up on issues based on any kind of party line - they divide along other fault lines.
I agree that "they divide
I agree that "they divide along other fault lines". If something goes wrong it's not their fault.
question
Bean or Sandra can probably answer this. How did Scoobie get the ten votes he says he has for appointing on the 31st w/o violating the open meetings law?
another question
what are the names of the 10 commissioners who agreed to this meeting?
The sad thing is that this hooey going on is going to discourage good candidates in the future.
The Quick-Vote 10
How did Scoobie get the ten votes he says he has for appointing on the 31st w/o violating the open meetings law?
Scott's press release did not list the requesters. He simply said upon the request of a majority of commissioners.....
Good question about the sunshine law. Remember, Ragdale and Moore got 12 signatures on the letter to John Owings to drop the One Man/One Vote lawsuit. -- s.
Scott is the Decider.
Scott is the Decider.
It's on...
Scott is the Decider.
Good Lord, they have stepped on a hornets nest. Now the citizens get a chance at the podium. This is must-see TV.
Scoobie the Decider
I knew he reminded me of Dubya.....
I don't know who should be
I don't know who should be more insulted, W or the Scoobster.
Scoobie the Decider
Submitted by gemini on Mon, 2007/01/22 - 3:40pm.
I knew he reminded me of Dubya.....
Nominations from floor
John Owings just said any citizen may nominate from the floor (at the meeting to appoint replacements). By commission rules, nominations will not be limited to commissioners. -- s.
Betty, are you watching this
Betty, are you watching this in the Commission meeting? What a rope-a-dope extravaganza. As Aretha wrote in a song "Who's zooming who"?
YouTube coverage on Tuesday. There are so many subplots I will have to watch this a few times to comment.
Griess's resolution fails, Mark Haron is up now...
Griess's resolution for asking the State to allow a Special Election fails 14-5.
Bums
Griess's resolution for asking the State to allow a Special Election fails 14-5.
Is it possible to find out who the 5 were?
Is it possible to find out
Is it possible to find out who the 5 were?
Only if someone is present at the meeting. You cannot hear well enough on TV and some of the Commissioners speak very softly when they vote. Go figure.
That resolution was
That resolution was submitted by Guthe, Griess, Hammond and Cawood. Assuming they all voted for it as well as Mark Harmon, there is your five. I wish the would speak into their microphones when voting.
Schmid is just confusing things. But at least they are discussing it. However, I am a pessimist and they will eventually vote down anything other than Scoobie's proposal.
they will eventually vote
they will eventually vote down anything other than Scoobie's proposal.
Uh huh. That fix was in before they started.
Just heard Paul Pinkston say he didn't need no stinkin' public hearings, since he already knew what people in his district wanted.
God almighty.
This is too depressing to even watch - I'll leave #9 to it.
I'll leave #9 to it.
I now control the horizontal, the vertical...
Just kidding.
This is spectacular to behold. The end game is that Scott Moore's position will be the most reasonable thing to do because of limitations including, the Mayor's instructions, angle of the Sun, decree of the Supreme Court, interpretations of the County Law Director, fairness to applicants, trust in the process, Astrology, and community fairness.
Betty and Sandra should have a special Wednesday edition for this one.
Roll call on the Harmon resolution for non-binding vote
Failed 2-17 (2 for 17 against)
What a bunch of scumbags
This is such a travesty. Unless you are a buddy of one of the eight term limited incumbents, forget about getting the "annointment". They can talk the right game for the cameras but will do whatever it takes to keep their power. Some public hearings will be held and districts will speak, but they will still go with the cronies. I bet Billy puts up someone just like himself, a repub crony in dem clothing. I am in district 2 and have no trust in anything Billy will be doing. If he ends up as county clerk, he will be doing his business from the golf course. I about puked when Scoobie said Billy knows what his district wants. If you add up the votes Amy Broyles and Jonathan Wimmer got in the primary, it was more than what he got. So the voters did speak but he is so hard of hearing...
I would be a month's salary
I would bet a month's salary that Clark and Pinkston don't bother with even pro forma public hearings in District 9.
District 9 residents could
District 9 residents could call their own meeting, invite Clark and Pinkston and the media. If they don't show, the media would hopefully make that known. Are there any active neighborhood groups in that area?
District 9 - what' s the point?
Not only would Clark and Pinkston not show, their hand-picked candidates wouldn't either.
Perhaps they figure Joe
Perhaps they figure Joe Hultquist has it covered for them. Heh.
District 9 - what' s the point?
Submitted by gemini on Mon, 2007/01/22 - 4:56pm.
Not only would Clark and Pinkston not show, their hand-picked candidates wouldn't either.
Are there any active
Are there any active neighborhood groups in that area?
I think there are active neighborhood groups in District 9, but I am not sure they are active in contacting their County commissioners. The independence of the South side shows and I don't think they think much of their County Commissioners.
There are many active
There are many active neighborhood groups within the City. I'm not so familar with what's going on out in the county.
Island Home Park, Old Sevier, South Haven, Woodlawn/Taliwa, Lindburgh Forest, Lake Forest, Colonial Village all have quite active NAs.
When the neighborhoods sponsored a forum for Commission candidates, Pinkston declined to attend. (He'll tell you he was sick, and he was the day of the forum, but he'd already declined to show up.)
It's not so much that the neighborhoods ignore Commission, as it is that Commissioners don't give a damn about the City neighborhoods.
South Knoxvillians within the city limits are really disenfranchised on Commission. The districts are set up so that every other part of the city essentially has two Commissioners - that is, the districts tend to be primarily county or primarily city.
The 9th district is an anomoly, with everybody south of the river in one district. Commissioners can win without the city votes (approximately 40%) so they just ignore us.
In fact, Howard Pinkston said once at a Commission meeting that his job was to "represent the citizens of south Knoxville outside the city limits."
Someone Needs to Make Sure Scoobie Pays
Whatever fee office position that Scoobie is angling for next election, we all need to remember this travesty and make sure he doesn't get it.
Jesus Christ. Not only will
Jesus Christ. Not only will there be NO public process, but Scoobie says he will not allow Commissioners to ask questions of the nominees, even tho Owings told him that was permissable under state law & the charter.
I knew the fix would be in on these appts, but I didn't expect them to be quite so blatant about it.
Wow.
15-4 (15 yes 4 no) vote to allow a one time special ability/responsibility for Chairman Moore to select committee assignments for the eight new Commissioners.
These guys are a perfect
These guys are a perfect illustraton of why we need term limits, and what happens when you govern primarily by cronyism.
The public should be outraged. The public that's paying attention probably is. Unfortunately, that's a minority, and even most of them have a short attention span.
nominations from floor
does anybody know how that works..do u need a 2nd...
Ninth District Appointment
Clark and Pinkston have formed a seven-member committee to research qualified candidates for Clark's replacement.
More in tomorrow's South Knox Seymour Times.
"It is not the writer's task to answer questions but to question answers." -Edward Abbey
Clark and Pinkston have
Clark and Pinkston have formed a seven-member committee to research qualified candidates for Clark's replacement.
Bet they're all Republicans and all from Clark or Pinkston's inner circle.
9th district committee makeup
At least one claims to be a Democrat. One would not admit to a party affiliation (nor her age). Two are women. At least six are age 67 or older.
As to the "inner circle" question, I am not knowledgeable enough to answer.
"It is not the writer's task to answer questions but to question answers." -Edward Abbey
9th district
Well stop being so damn coy and tell us who they are.
Voting on the process
At least they actually voted on the process before jumping in to the appointments.
So is there more to the adopted plan than "We'll meet on the 31st and appoint people"?
Actually, they voted AGAINST calling upon legislators to enable a special election.
And they voted AGAINST Mark Harmon's proposed plebiscite.
So the default is Moore's call for a Jan. 31 special meeting. The Commission has rules about making appointments. Law Director John Owings said one rule is that nominations can be made by citizens "from the floor," but Scoobie quickly said that meant "just a name" -- not a big speech or anything. -- s.
citizens nominations
how does that work..are there no seconds..or can another citizen second..i cant find the commissions rules
You tube soon?
I want to see the rerun again to see several things that happened. One was when someone asked for a list of the 10 commissioners that Scoobie had lined up for his 1/31 meeting. Several commissioners back away from the question and it appeared that Scoobie indicated his office staff called the commissioners to ask if they would be available for a special meeting on the 31st and that was their agreement for his appointment process. At that time, many said they agreed to attend the meeting he was calling but never were told that agreement meant anything else.
I agree that R Larry was more open and agreeable to a public forum. Lumpy seemed to side with Scoobie on everything. What is it with Tank, can he talk? Larry Clark was very quiet.
There are going to be people coming out of the woodwork wanting to be commissioners. I am not sure if that is good or bad.
Ultimately, Scoobie the decider will get exactly who he wants.
I didn't realize there was a
I didn't realize there was a commission meeting today. At least they actually voted on the process before jumping in to the appointments.
So is there more to the adopted plan than "We'll meet on the 31st and appoint people"? Will each office be voted on separately, or will the replacements be presented as a slate for a single vote? Will nominees be named in advance so people might actually have the chance to call or write their commissioners and express a preference?