Thu
Apr 3 2014
08:43 pm

I missed this yesterday...

WATE reported that a Knox County Schools parent found TWO errors in his/her student's practice TCAP for math.

There were two math problems for which the multiple choices the practice test provided did not include the problems' correct answers. Neither did students have any option to answer "none of the above."

WATE has posted at their site the two test pages containing the two errors (click to enlarge).

The practice test was a Houghton Mifflin Harcourt product.

(Hat tip to Lee Dunham Sessions on the SPEAK Facebook page.)

Topics:
Average Guy's picture

Report left me with a few questions,

I hope someone can answer.

How many questions did the test have overall in math?

How long before it was caught?

And I'm not sure if was the how the editing in the story was done or if Ms. Coats was referring to the eventual real test when she said this could affect teacher performance. Does this practice test affect teachers in any way?

Tamara Shepherd's picture

*

No, the practice test doesn't affect teachers.

Neither is the actual TCAP a testing product of Houghton Mifflin Harcourt (the culprit here); the actual TCAP is a testing product of Pearson, the story says.

Finally, the story also says that the Department of Ed prefers the Pearson practice test product, too, although it apparently allows practice tests of other companies and just advises teachers and schools to check them carefully.

I think Ms. Coats' comment was only to suggest that if the one company could make such errors on its practice test product, the other company could conceivably make such errors on its "for real" test product, too--and I'd guess she's right.

I found the story to offer one more reason why we're not prudent to attach just every measure of student achievement or teacher effectiveness, either one, on a single high-stakes test.

Min's picture

This is particularly concerning...

...because teachers are not allowed to review the actual TCAP test and can be disciplined for discussing what was on it with students, even after the test is over. Who knows how screwed up the test may be? Pearson has a dreadful track record on its products.

Average Guy's picture

I mistook administer to mean

I mistook administer to mean Pearson was the proctor.

You mention the Department of Ed put the onus of checking the test on the schools. The WATE report said a parent found the error. These two things led to my question on timing.

A little off topic, but searching Pearson led me to some of their Tennessee links. This one, from the TN Department of Ed titled, ‘“Test-Time” Strategies for Students, Parents, and Teachers” is an interesting read. It ends with this; “Be careful not to over emphasize the importance of the test.” For bonus fun, read it from the end to beginning. “ANXIETY!”

zoomfactor's picture

rounding?

Clearly question 20 has no correct answers, but in question 18, couldn't "0.4" be considered a plausible answer for 0.384 if rounded up?

Tamara Shepherd's picture

*

I caught that too, Zoom.

Guess we'd have to know if the practice test instructions made any mention of rounding.

It seemed more likely, though, that the correct answer was supposed to be "H." That choice reads "3.8," but if a printing error in the placement of the decimal point occurred, it may have been that that answer was supposed to read ".38?" That would constitute a correct answer.

Tamara Shepherd's picture

*

I am hearing this same concern voiced over on the SPEAK Facebook page.

TNchickadee's picture

Teachers would never know if

Teachers would never know if there were mistakes on the actual test because they could be fired for looking at the test. We do have Pearson textbooks though, and the classroom materials do contain mistakes from time to time, either on the worksheets or in the teachers' addition.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives