Amazing WalMart Stats

Submitted by RedDog on Thu, 2006/09/14 - 10:03pm.

" The median household income of Wal-Mart shoppers is under $40,000. Wal-Mart, the most prodigious job-creator in the history of the private sector in this galaxy, has almost as many employees (1.3 million) as the U.S. military has uniformed personnel. A McKinsey company study concluded that Wal-Mart accounted for 13 percent of the nation's productivity gains in the second half of the 1990s, which probably made Wal-Mart about as important as the Federal Reserve in holding down inflation. By lowering consumer prices, Wal-Mart costs about 50 retail jobs among competitors for every 100 jobs Wal-Mart creates. Wal-Mart and its effects save shoppers more than $200 billion a year, dwarfing such government programs as food stamps ($28.6 billion) and the earned-income tax credit ($34.6 billion). People who buy their groceries from Wal-Mart -- it has one-fifth of the nation's grocery business -- save at least 17 percent." -- George Will

I like Wal-Mart; my significant other can't stand it due to all the fat ugly people in the south Knox store - it may be true but I still call her a snob

(sorry - I can't find the first source of this quote, but the analysis seems resaonable) 

14
vote

Socialist With A Gold Card's picture
Yes, but

The average full-time Wal-Mart employee makes less than the federal poverty level, and fewer than half of its full-time employees can afford even the cheapest health insurance plan offered by the company.

Furthermore:

One of the most telling of all the criticisms of Wal-Mart is to be found in a February 2004 report by the Democratic Staff of the House Education and Workforce Committee. In analyzing Wal-Mart's success in holding employee compensation at low levels, the report assesses the costs to US taxpayers of employees who are so badly paid that they qualify for government assistance even under the less than generous rules of the federal welfare system. For a two-hundred-employee Wal-Mart store, the government is spending $108,000 a year for children's health care; $125,000 a year in tax credits and deductions for low-income families; and $42,000 a year in housing assistance. The report estimates that a two-hundred-employee Wal-Mart store costs federal taxpayers $420,000 a year, or about $2,103 per Wal-Mart employee. That translates into a total annual welfare bill of $2.5 billion for Wal-Mart's 1.2 million US employees.

Wal-Mart is also a burden on state governments. According to a study by the Institute for Labor and Employment at the University of California, Berkeley, in 2003 California taxpayers subsidized $20.5 million worth of medical care for Wal-Mart employees. In Georgia ten thousand children of Wal-Mart employees were enrolled in the state's program for needy children in 2003, with one in four Wal-Mart employees having a child in the program.

That's hardly a ringing endorsement of unfettered capitalism or a justification for the fawning adulation spewed on the company by the free-market types. But, I guess as long as we're all able to continue buying Chinese-sweatshop-made landfill crap at extra low prices, it doesn't really matter all that much, does it?

--Socialist With A Gold Card


"I'm a socialist with a gold card. I firmly believe we need a revolution; I'm just concerned that I won't be able to get good moisturizer afterwards." --Brett Butler

 

 

yes but, but

Yes but, but……………………

Accepting your figures and the ones I quoted - Wal-Mart cost the tax rolls $2.5 billion yet saves the people $200 billion. And most of that $200 billion is saved by those at the lower end of the economic ladder.

Should we get rid of the discount stores (i.e., by paying higher wages) and lose jobs for those on the lower economic ladder - meaning those working in discount stores and those who benefit from shopping in discount stores most?

Hummmm... have you happened to notice that those pushing for higher minimum wages are from those STATES that already have a STATE mandated minimum wage? Could it be that those states are losing jobs to those states that have prevailing wages closer to what the economy/market desires? Economics 101.

 Socialism - a failed economic theory embraced by the short-sighted

 

 

Andy Axel's picture
Wal-Mart cost the tax rolls

Wal-Mart cost the tax rolls $2.5 billion yet saves the people $200 billion.

There's so much wrong with that figure it's hardly even worth arguing.

One example: Balance of trade. How much would Wal-Mart help US businesses if Wal-Mart would only market "Made in the USA" like they used to? How much trade imbalance is Wal-Mart responsible for, since it imports much of its stock from China?

There's a lot of shadow costs which that "savings" doesn't account.

____________________________

On tops of mountains, as everywhere to hopeful souls, it is always morning. --H. Thoreau

 "Hummmm... have you

 "Hummmm... have you happened to notice that those pushing for higher minimum wages are from those STATES that already have a STATE mandated minimum wage? Could it be that those states are losing jobs to those states that have prevailing wages closer to what the economy/market desires?"

Market desires or employer desires? There is a difference. What if an employee wants a higher wage? She goes to her boss at WalMart and says "I'd like a raise. I've been here 5 years and I work hard. My attendance and evaulations are great." Would she get it? At At Walmart, supervisors are not allowed to make wage recommendations and they can get reprimanded for doing so.  Keeping wages low is WalMart raison d'etre. Even the sainted Sam Walton was a notorious payroll miser. Raising wages at a 200 person WalMart $1 an hour raises their payroll close to $4 million a year for the store. Four million a year in "lost revenue" at one store is one highly paid store manager out of a job. Spread that $1 an hour over 1.8 million employees that's $4 billion a year. I guess $4 billion isn't real money anymore in W's world. Hell, it doesn't even cover one month's "YEEEHAAAAW" in Iraq.

BTW, the numbers that you quote for WalMart's economic impact comes from George Will, an unapologetic apologist for Big Business, and frankly wrong

 

True happiness is knowing you are a hypocrite. -- Ivor Cutler

I wouldnt exactly call Media

I wouldnt exactly call Media Matters.com the epitome of "fair and balanced".

This implies that you have

This implies that you have an idea of a source that is "fair and balanced." Please. Enlighten us to which... 

 

True happiness is knowing you are a hypocrite. -- Ivor Cutler

Factchecker's picture
Did you get paid to write

Did you get paid to write this, RedDog, the way Wal-Mart is buying off think tanks that publish similar praise.  Moreover, why do you feel you need to defend such a successful corporation anyway?  Can't they make it in the "free marketplace" on their own, without political apologists doing free marketing campaigns for them?

I havent seen anyone being

I havent seen anyone being forced at gunpoint to apply/work at Wal-Mart. If someone wants to earn more money/benefits look for another job.

Restaurant Review

Would this be a good time to let folks know of what I thought about Flemings Steakhouse? ;-)

Wal-mart

If you research Wal-mart you will stop trying to defend a company that is driving the US & Canadian economy into the toilet. It's goal seems to be to turn Canada and the US into third world coutries. By squeezing suppliers to cut wholesale costs, the company has hastened the flight of U.S. manufacturing jobs overseas. By scouring the globe for the cheapest goods, it has driven factory jobs from one poor nation to another.
Driving down wages, sending manufacturing to China, Bangladesh, and Honduras. Monthly wages: China= $63.75, Bangladesh= $18.53, and Honduras= $139.00, USA= $893.00. Do you want Salmon that is caught in China and shipped to the US, handled hundreds of times just to save $2.00. I am more than willing to pay more for things to keep our economy growing and healthy. Lets keep our products made in North America, before it is too late.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Captcha
This question is used to make sure you are a human visitor and to prevent spam submissions.
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.
Blog-O-Rama

Bela Fleck's Star Spangled Banner
(Cup of Joe Powell)

Kingston's Going to Smoke the Ash Spill Today
(Enclave)

What I Learned In The News This Week
(Newscoma)

There Can Only Be One
(Newscoma)

Sarah Palin - Train Wrecks Get Top Ratings
(Cup of Joe Powell)

Play Her Off, Keyboard Cat
(Southern Beale)

Feel Good Independence Day
(Silence Isn't Golden)

The Sicko Attacks on Sarah Palin's Baby
(TN Guerilla Women)

KNS: Ash to be Dumped in Loudon?
(RoaneViews)

Jump!
(Domestic Psychology)

Now she 's done it, now I have to go nuclear!
(Left Wing Cracker)

Palin's Resignation: Political Masterstroke Or Extreme Mental Instability of a Castrating Bitch?
(TN Guerilla Women)

Innocent Blogging Fun
(Newscoma)

Scott McNutt cuts to the truth...
(RoaneViews)

Harriman Care and Rehab in the News
(RoaneViews)


Media Blogs

Happy Fourth of July
(Michael Silence)

Happy
(Michael Silence)

This is a joke, right? Top 25 sports outings in TN
(Michael Silence)

Just curious
(Michael Silence)

Memo to the Republican Governors Association
(Michael Silence)

Son of Big Box
(Josh Flory)

TVA Tries Sending Inspection Reports Directly to Landfills
(Snark Bites)

The Wa$hington Po$t
(Michael Silence)

Chapter 11 for condo developer
(Josh Flory)

Gone Fishin': Pith is Off Today
(Pith in the Wind)

Thoughts On Kyle's Kinda, Sorta Kickoff for Governor
(Tom Humphrey)

Bredesen Lectures Legislators on License Plates -- Again
(Tom Humphrey)

Robin Has a Website
(Tom Humphrey)

Cobb Successor To Be Elected on Oct. 13
(Tom Humphrey)

Gibbons 'On Target' With $415,000 In Contributions
(Tom Humphrey)


Post Politics

Proving Her Critics Right
(AC Kleinheider)

Makes As Much Sense As Anything I’ve Heard Yet
(AC Kleinheider)

Resigned On The 3rd Of July: Sarah Palin Steps Down As Governor
(AC Kleinheider)

Like He Never Existed
(AC Kleinheider)

You’re Light, Son
(AC Kleinheider)

Can Jim Kyle Win The Democratic Nomination For Governor?
(AC Kleinheider)

Shout Out To Tuke
(AC Kleinheider)

Alexander Wishes You A Happy Independence Day
(AC Kleinheider)

Cammack, North Of Two Hundie
(AC Kleinheider)

Ford Dynasty Member Says He’ll Make A Run At Memphis Mayor
(AC Kleinheider)


Local News

Drownings reminder to use pool alarms, gates and buddies
(Knoxville News Sentinel)

TWRA plans extra boat patrols
(Knoxville News Sentinel)

Father's fraud followed son's debt woes
(Knoxville News Sentinel)

Lockett is subject of 3 investigations
(Knoxville News Sentinel)

Loudon residents fight against ash disposal
(Knoxville News Sentinel)

Downtown condo developer files bankruptcy
(Knoxville News Sentinel Business)

Auto fallout still felt locally
(Knoxville News Sentinel Business)

Loudon residents fight against ash disposal
(Knoxville News Sentinel Business)

Hospital management at issue in Claiborne County
(Knoxville News Sentinel Business)

Tazewell hospital proposals to be heard Monday
(Knoxville News Sentinel Business)

Governor Bredesen Issues Writ of Election
(State of Tennessee)

Bredesen Breaks Ground on Recovery Act Project in Nashville
(State of Tennessee)

Extended Unemployment Benefits Available for Eligible Tennesseans
(State of Tennessee)

THP Gears Up For July 4th Weekend Crackdown on Drunk Drivers
(State of Tennessee)

Tennessee Announces 2009-10 School Meal Guidelines
(State of Tennessee)

Blount County K-9 officer loses battle with cancer
(WATE local)

Deadly Knoxville shooting and police pursuit ends in crash
(WATE local)

Stripper upset kidnapping, rape charges were dropped
(WATE local)

Family's gas grill explodes catching house on fire
(WATE local)

Blount County K-9 loses battle with cancer
(WATE local)

Teacher trainees get more face time with students
(WBIR Local)

Dandridge woman dies in Sevier Co. car crash
(WBIR Local)

Local fireworks laws, displays in your area
(WBIR Local)

Update: Victim dies after Friday afternoon shooting
(WBIR Local)

Hero Central: Help feed hungry kids with Backpack Buddy Club 10
(WBIR Local)

Beefing up patrols on Tennessee highways
(WVLT Local)

Honduras rejects OAS appeal to restore president
(WVLT Local)

UPDATE: Police investigate shooting, high speed chase and crash
(WVLT Local)

SKorea says NKorea fires 2 missiles off east coast
(WVLT Local)

Alleged victim, estranged wife talk about dropped kidnap and rape charges
(WVLT Local)


Wire Reports

Obama's trip: 3 more countries, 1 broad mission (AP)
(AP Politics)

60 votes not so super for Obama, Senate Democrats (AP)
(AP Politics)

Offensive is first test for Obama's Afghanistan strategy (AFP)
(AP Politics)

Colin Powell cautions Obama on big government (AP)
(AP Politics)

INSIDE WASHINGTON: Archives' many missing items (AP)
(AP Politics)

Colin Powell: Celebrate Michael Jackson's art (AP)
(AP Politics)

Texas brewer, once near defeat, shines again (AP)
(AP National News)

Obama calls for reform in Independence Day address (AFP)
(AP Politics)

Both Parties Try to Cash In on Passage of Climate Change Bill (CQPolitics.com)
(AP Politics)

Mrs. Obama bringing glamor to Moscow this weekend (AP)
(AP Politics)

Obama cites his agenda in holiday address (AP)
(AP Politics)

Palin resignation leaves questions on 2012 run (AP)
(AP Politics)

Palin resignation leaves questions on 2012 run (AP)
(AP National News)

SC serial killer conjures memory of 60s murderer (AP)
(AP National News)

Out of failure, the American Dream (Politico)
(AP Politics)

Police: Arizona woman led sons on crime spree (AP)
(AP National News)

Jackson was loving and attentive father, many say (AP)
(AP National News)

Jackson kids face hurdles to coping with his death (AP)
(AP National News)

Calif. bullet train hits criticism on SF Peninsula (AP)
(AP National News)

Calif. regulators warn of pot's cancer capability (AP)
(AP National News)