Tue
Nov 20 2012
04:10 pm
By: R. Neal  shortURL
More than 83% of respondents said they favor extending the parkway to Governor John Sevier Highway. Just over 16% of voters said they oppose extending the parkway.
According to the report, support is stronger outside the city limits.
|
Topics:
|
41
vote
|
Discussing:
- Famous people you have met (49 replies)
- County Commissioner Brad Anders disciplined in police brutality case (126 replies)
- Wheels coming off Meals on Wheels (3 replies)
- 2013 Shootings in Knox County, TN (58 replies)
- Pandora et al (2 replies)
- Pilot indictment watch (93 replies)
- Heart & Soul at Knoxville Center Mall (4 replies)
- St. John's and the Proposed Walnut Street Building Demolition (11 replies)
- Knoxville group on America's worst charities list (4 replies)
- Johnson City doc sentenced to two years for dispensing unapproved foreign drugs (2 replies)
- She may be crazy but she's not stupid (1 reply)
- Congrats to Bill Shory (17 replies)
Upcoming events:
- Jun 20 2013 - 5:00pm (2 days 17 hours from now)
TN Progressive
- Supreme Court: States Cannot Demand Additional Proof of Citizenship To Register to Vote. Ted Cruz: “We’ll See About That.” (TN Citizen Action)
- Quote of the Day (RoaneViews)
- Public Service Announcement: Pet Edition (Southern Beale)
- Student Loan Debt Calculator (RoaneViews)
- Sexist GOP Idiot Says Man's Brain Is Superior (Video) (TN Guerilla Women)
- Photos from the Bellamy Brothers concert posted (RoaneViews)
- Reality Blasts Hole Through NRA Talking Point (Southern Beale)
- Excellent TED Talk from Lawrence Lessig (RoaneViews)
- A Tale Of Two Federal Budget Items (Southern Beale)
- The Daily Buzz (RoaneViews)
- Good News Friday (Southern Beale)
- Business Leaders Back Federal Immigration Reform (TN Citizen Action)
- FROM TIRRC: Tennessee Voters Support Senate Immigration Bill 3-to-1 (TN Citizen Action)
- Fly the Flag for Citizenship (TN Citizen Action)
- Life in the Age of Endless, Invisible CyberWar (Joe Powell)
- Tennessee Gun Report (Southern Beale)
TN Politics
- Meet the World's Worst Visitor to Nashville (Pith in the Wind)
- Dean's Proposed Affordable Housing Fund Heads to Council (Pith in the Wind)
- LIHEAP Moves from DHS to THDA (Tom Humphrey)
- Frank Niceley Takes Up Blogging (Pith in the Wind)
- Procuring on the low (Post Politics)
- Is Tennessee hot for prison reform? (Post Politics)
- Cutting our way to full employment (Post Politics)
- Franklin County Jumps Ahead of Legislature in Regulating Meth-Linked Drugs (Tom Humphrey)
- Comish: Cutting Jobless Services Will Help the Jobless (thanks to fed funding) (Tom Humphrey)
- New State Procurement Office Claims Savings of $113 Million (Tom Humphrey)
- Cooper's doom? (Post Politics)
- Cooling Republicans (Post Politics)
Local Media Blogs
- Appeals court rules against Mike Ross in civil case (Josh Flory)
- This day in history, 52 years ago … (Gerald Witt)
- Sunday at Bonnaroo: Kendrick Lamar Owns the Stage (Metro Pulse)
- Monday briefing (Josh Flory)
- The Daily Plan-It: The Folk You Buddies, Yoga, and Danielle Howle (Metro Pulse)
- Saturday at Bonnaroo: Jack Johnson Draws a Crowd (Metro Pulse)
- Friday at Bonnaroo: Sir Paul Still Rocks (Metro Pulse)
- Broyles seeks $500K for 'Meals' plan (Mike Donila)
- MPC approves demolition of Walnut buildings (Josh Flory)
- Friday briefing (Josh Flory)
- MPC approves St. John's plan for Walnut Street buildings (Metro Pulse)
- Where Am I? Vol. XVII (Gerald Witt)
Local Paper
- Residents blast Loudon County Commission over codes, zoning rules (KNS News)
- Pair accused in fatal drive-by shooting waive preliminary hearing (KNS News)
- Another protest filed on $22B Y-12/Pantex contract (KNS News)
- Court records: Knox traffic stop unveils immigrant smuggling operation (KNS News)
- Storm damages Nissan dealership in North Knoxville (KNS News)
- Appeals court rules against Mike Ross in civil case (KNS Business)
- Expert on 'Theory of Constraints' to speak at UT (KNS Business)
- Watts Bar ready to start in 2015 (KNS Business)
- People and honors: June 16 (KNS Business)
- Business bulletins: June 16 (KNS Business)
Local TV News
- Men arrested for soliciting prostitutes receive trial dates (WATE)
- Murdered woman's family frustrated at justice system, worried about safety (WATE)
- Elderly Morgan County man's death investigated as homicide (WATE)
- Scam artists promise free or low cost medical alert systems (WATE)
- Roane County campground hit hard by storms (WATE)
- Philadephia City Council meets in elementary school after city hall collapse (WBIR)
- Niota lays off 7 workers, closes library as insurance crisis continues (WBIR)
- McMinn sheriff named TN Officer of the Year (WBIR)
- Community remembers Scott Co. teen who collapsed suddenly (WBIR)
- New Bearden butcher shop offers custom cuts, experience (WBIR)
- Military plans would put women in most combat jobs (WVLT)
- Former firefighter faces prostitution charges (WVLT)
State News
- Best of Preps 2013 (Times Free Press)
- White House threatens veto of House farm bill (Times Free Press)
- Georgia radio hosts fired; mocked ex-player with ALS (Times Free Press)
- California serial murder suspect delivers opening remarks (Times Free Press)
- Jury convicts Arizona man in terrorism hoax (Times Free Press)
- Germantown's Red Light Cameras Aren't Running (ABC24 Memphis)
- Germantown Residents Prepare For Taxes to Go Up (ABC24 Memphis)
- Unified Schools Superintendent Devises Merged Payroll Solution (ABC24 Memphis)
- Rep. Cohen Appeals to Airlines to Expand in Memphis (ABC24 Memphis)
- Petition demands Williamson school board eliminate "anti-Semitic" textbook (Tennessean)
- MPD detective on child porn suspect: I had never seen this level of debauchery (Tennessean)
- Cruelty Case Dismissed against Former Memphis Animal Shelter Worker (ABC24 Memphis)
Wire Reports
- Obama defends Syria policy, plays down NSA spying ‘ruckus’ (Yahoo Politics)
- Obama says Bernanke has 'stayed a lot longer' than he wanted at Fed (Yahoo Business)
- Asian shares slide as upcoming Fed meeting jangles nerves (Yahoo Business)
- China May home prices rise at fastest pace this year (Yahoo Business)
- Japan says G8 stance is sign of approval for "Abenomics" (Yahoo Business)
- Sprint sues Dish, Clearwire as key deadline looms (Yahoo Business)
- Lawyer Cliff Sloan faces tough assignment: Closing Guantanamo (Yahoo News)
- Gruesome photos from California's 'Alphabet murders' open trial (Yahoo News)
- Hunt for Jimmy Hoffa's body brings investigators to Michigan field (Yahoo News)
- Supreme Court strikes down Arizona voter ID citizenship law (Yahoo Politics)
- Snowden: U.S. ‘not going to be able to cover this up by jailing or murdering me’ (Yahoo News)
- Utah businessman known for good deeds accused of Internet fraud (Yahoo News)
- Obama’s job approval tumbles, Americans split on spying: Poll (Yahoo Politics)
- Is Edward Snowden hiding in the wrong country? (Yahoo Politics)
- Ahead of G8, A-list actors urge Obama to push for ‘world without nuclear weapons’ (Yahoo Politics)
Site Statistics
Last 7 days:
- Posts: 34
- Comments: 264
- Visits: 9,585
- Pageviews: 21,218
- Posts: 118
- Comments: 1039
- Visits: 37,504
- Pageviews: 79,339
Popular today
Popular this week
TN Progressive
- BlountViews
- Cup of Joe Powell
- Jamie Hollin
- Left Wing Cracker
- Newscoma
- Out of the Blue
- RoaneViews
- Sean Braisted
- Southern Beale
- TN Citizen Action
- Tiny Cat Pants
- TN Guerilla Women
- TN Values Authority
- Vibinc
- View From My Kitchen Table
- WhitesCreek Journal
Nearby:
- AC Entertainment
- Agrarian Urbanite
- Big Good Thing
- Blount Dems
- Bottom Line
- Craig Thomas
- Daily Pulse
- David Oatney
- Discover ET
- Domestic Psychology
- Ellen Smith
- Fletch
- Gerald Witt
- Frank Murphy
- Home/Work
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jack McElroy
- Jim Stovall
- Julie Apple
- Knox Dems
- KnoxBlab
- Knoxify
- Knoxvillager
- Les Jones
- Lynn Point Records
- MamaPundit
- Michael Silence
- Mike Donila
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Mushy's Moochings
- Outdoor Knoxville
- P.E.N. Studio
- People for the Planet
- Pittman Properties
- Political Leverage
- Property Scope
- Reality Me
- Rikki Hall
- Rob Huddleston
- School Matters
- Stacey Campfield
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
- Stuck inside Knoxville
- Suzy Trotta
- Tom Humphrey
- Tri Cities
Beyond:
- Andy Axel
- Daily Docket
- Democratic Talk Radio
- Enclave
- Ginger Snaps
- Pith in the Wind
- Post Politics
- Quiet Life
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Ticket
- TN Trivia
- TN Women's Caucus
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South
- Lovable Liberal
- Newsrack
- Wandering Hillbilly
At large:
- Agonist
- Alterdestiny
- Atrios
- Burnt Orange Report
- Buzzflash
- College Dems
- Common Cause
- Crooks and Liars
- Daily Kos
- Democratic Strategist
- Democrats.org
- Digby's Hullabaloo
- Ezra Klein
- The Fix
- Huffington Post
- Liberal Oasis
- Media Matters
- MyDD
- Open Secrets
- Pam's House Blend
- Political Wire
- Politico
- Progressive States
- Seeing the Forest
- Skippy the Bush Kangaroo
- Suburban Guerrilla
- Talk Left
- Talking Points Memo
- Think Progress
- Truthdig
- Truthout

According to the report,
According to the report, support is stronger outside the city limits
Do tell.
Folks are often happy to let
Folks are often happy to let someone else bear a burden.
Robo call
I don't believe the Focus' polling. Ever.
I don't really trust robo
I don't really trust robo polls.
This article doesn't say how they selected their sample, which is kind of important info.
500 is a good sample size, but... over half their 500 respondents were over 65 - that seems off.
I can pretty much guarantee that more than 16% of the folks who show up on 12/6 will oppose completion, but whether that reflects the size of their numbers or the intensity of their opposition I can't say.
"over half their 500
"over half their 500 respondents were over 65"
That, plus their linking of respondents to specific precincts strongly suggests a land-line only effort.
You'd have to do the research to back this up, but I would postulate that "land line respondent" correlates highly to "old-school thinking with regard to building highways."
I also wonder how much the
I also wonder how much the Henley Street Bridge being closed might influence people's perception of the need here.
Create a problem, offer a solution
TDOT is good at both, even better at timing.
I can tell you it's changed
I can tell you it's changed some merchant's minds. And average guy, I mean from "support" to "oppose." The detour has been hard on businesses. Seems to have made some think about the possible effects of a permanent detour around more of Chapman Highwa.
Land line
I guess as someone under 65 with a landline that puts me in a minority. As I voted no that means I'm really in a fringe group. I'm just glad I was in the majority in last week's poll. You know, the one that really matters.
Tonight the robocall asked my answering machine whether or not textbooks should be rated like movies. Not something I'd thought a lot about. Funny thing is, these robocalls don't have a button to push for undecided.
"Tonight the robocall asked
"Tonight the robocall asked my answering machine whether or not textbooks should be rated like movies. Not something I'd thought a lot about. Funny thing is, these robocalls don't have a button to push for undecided."
If you consider nothing else about these polls, this one point is sufficient to pretty much invalidate any results from them. Consider the question about textbooks. It's not hard to imagine that lots of people haven't thought about that question. With the "don't know" option available, that question might yield results like: 12% for, 10% against, and 78% don't know. Instead, having only two options means that they will publish results that say a majority of respondents are either for or against the concept, which leads to a very different understanding of the issue.
In the example above with the neutral option, the fact that so few respondents chose yes or no means the two-point difference between them would have little statistical significance. The understanding of that result would be that the vast majority have no opinion on the subject, and those who do are more or less evenly divided. You could not claim that there is any broad support or opposition for the textbook rating concept.
By forcing a binary choice however, even if the results came out 51% for and 49% against, the misguided read would likely be that, while it's close, a majority are in support. That would be wrong. Even in the unlikely event that they came up with a dead-even 50/50 result, the editorial misinterpretation would probably be that it's a hotly contested issue, when in fact it's not, because most people haven't given it any thought.
*
Off-topic, but...
Textbooks relate factual material.
How (and why) might one arrive at any rating as to whether a given set of facts is "offensive???"
Divided Highway: The James White Parkway Extension That Won't Go
Metro Pulse by Joe Tarr ...
Divided Highway: The James White Parkway Extension That Won't Go away
I wish they had labeled the
I wish they had labeled the precincts. Found them on KGIS.
26th precinct - Sevier Ave./Island Home, which includes the existing JWP.
Affected by new JWP ext.
25th precinct - Vestal, which includes Moody Avenue East of Chapman Highway and could include the beginning of the JWP ext.
29th precinct - The heart of South Knoxville, the main area that will be affected by the JWP ext. All East of Chapman Hwy, from Stone Road to just past Little Switzerland to the river.
93rd precinct - East John Sevier Hwy, Seymour, Chapman Hwy from Little Switzerland to the county line.
Not really affected by new JWP ext.
27th precinct - Colonial Village plus some, all west of Chapman Hwy.
89th precinct - Alcoa Hwy and Maryville Pike areas
90th precinct - All West of Chapman Hwy, John Sevier Hwy area, South Knox County.
Not really affected by JWP ext except for access to new road.
92nd precinct - Kimberlin Heights, Bays Mountain, Seymour. All East of Chapman Hwy., to the river.
Not that it really matters. I'm betting I could do a poll and get a completely different response.
It's not really true that the
It's not really true that the 27th precinct is unaffected by the JWP. There are lots of businesses along Chapman Highway in that precinct and they could be affected by the change in traffic patterns. (One could argue that the impacts would be negative, as they've been with the detour due to the bridge closing; one could argue they would be positive due to getting rid of through traffic and making it easier for local traffic to access the businesses).
Also, you left out the 28th (did the poll?), which is approximately the south woodlawn area and which is certainly affected by the JWP, both current and proposed. I haven't looked at a GIS map, but I suspect the current end of the JWP is in the 28th.
50% Over Age 65
It's not likely that these folks commute to downtown Knoxville or anyplace else on a regular basis. Two possible well used justifications for their response: "We want a direct connection from south Knox County to the interstate." or "It's been planned and we want it built."
Given TDOT's pay-as-you-go policy, perhaps the question should have been, "In the immediate future, would you rather see improvements to Chapman and Alcoa Highways in Knox County or would you rather TDOT build the JWP?"
Thanks Bizgrrl, for researching the precincts. Interesting information.
Because there's no "don't
Because there's no "don't know" option, you can't really draw any conclusions from the response. Some unknown percentage of respondents to that survey actually had no opinion, but chose one of the two available options. Their reason for selecting one or the other of the two options could range from "t's been planned so maybe they should build it," to "I like roads," to "what was the last thing they said?" to "Well, my thumb is already on the number 2," to "ice cream!" There's no telling how many people were in that position, and there's no way to know why the people who had no opinion chose one option over the other. You cannot draw any valid conclusions from the survey.
At one time I thought JWP was
At one time I thought JWP was a hot topic in part to get federal money from the now expired TEA-21 program more than any true functional purpose. Sort of a, hey there is some money, let's find some way to get some of it.
TEA-21
Wonder how they count
Wonder how they count answering machines and other non-responsive responses? Probably as "not opposed" as in "support."
Also, a proper poll would have given the three alternative routes and a "no build" option.
What about Park & Ride MASS TRANSIT Out CHAPMAN HWY...
for the commuters/visitors from outlying neighborhoods and other counties?
Let these folks become more innovative with Transportation DOLLARS.
Let the out of county commuters/visitors from Sevier and other counties create their own Park and Ride/businesses in their own counties so that they can commute to downtown Knoxville or wherever they desire to go?!?
THis idea would save commuters money and time. They could spend time on a Park and Ride bus resting, relaxing, computing, and saving wear and tear on their own vehicles.
I lived in the metro Denver/Boulder Colorado area in the 80's and 90's. They have developed a wonderful mass transit for Park and Ride commuter/visitors. I could catch a regular bus in my neighborhood in east Denver to downtown Denver. Then, transfer to a commuter bus to go visit friends and shop in Boulder. I SAVED SO MUCH MONEY and could relax. The entire trip only cost $2.00 one way.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
WHy do some folks think it is necessary to destroy other people's neighborhoods, in an area where they only drive through, in order to make their lives faster by three minutes?!?
LET THEM SPEND THEIR MONEY to create car pools and buses for Park and Rides. THey don't even stop to shop on Chapman Hwy unless it's out near John Sevier Hwy and the big box chains.
AND the world is going to be different in a very short time, after PEAK OIL, during and after the energy descent.
We are finding ways to be more productive whilst leaving neighborhoods intact. We are becoming more innovative and creative.
WE ARE the ones we've been waiting for. Let's create and maintain a GREAT PARK AND RIDE system out Chapman Highway! Let there be a Park and Ride station out near John Sevier Hwy and Chapman Hwy And others along Alcoa Hwy and other main thoroughfares.
On a Somewhat Related Note
I am pleasantly surprised to see Google updated its map to include the South Knoxville Wilderness Trails. May have to do a little hiking tomorrow.
Google Didn't do that
I put in those trails. It's a very time consuming process and required me to be approved by google. I ride the trails with a GPS and then manually trace the trails into Google.
-1 for the iPhone killing google maps and now all my trails have disappeared on apple maps.
Yes!
Thank you, thank you, for the Park and Ride promotion. All of Knox County and the surrounding counties could use this but it would be particularly helpful for South Knoxville and South Knox County. It could even help get folks to and from Pigeon Forge without so much danger in driving on Chapman Highway. We need Park and Rides all over!
Anonymous 3, definitely
Anonymous 3, definitely appreciate both your technical and mountain biking expertise.
+1
Thanks likewise from me anon 3.
Post new comment