Wed
Apr 27 2011
07:19 am

So much drama ahead of today's Administrator of Elections appointment. According to reports, everyone from the County Mayor on down to the parking garage custodian knew about the confidential HR file memo regarding assistant election administrator Scott Frith, one of the top three candidates for the permanent post after the unceremonious sacking of Greg Mackay.

What is not revealed in any of the reporting is, how and why is this suddenly being made public?

Astonishingly, reporters on the story (Mike Donila at the KNS and Anthony Welsch at WBIR) say that Frith himself provided copies of the memo. Presumably they asked him about it on the day before he was up for promotion to the AOE job.

What prompted them to ask, pray tell?

Donila says on his blog that he knew about the memo, but doesn't say for how long. And Welsch obviously didn't put the story together yesterday afternoon on a whim. Why is this coming out all of a sudden?

Curious timing. Donila says on his blog that "someone 'in the administration' [i.e. Mayor's office] tipped Frith about it," but that's probably neither here nor there.

At any rate, Frith apparently panicked when he could have just said "no comment." No comment, no story. Copy of the memo, big story. Admitting there was some basis in fact with regard to certain elements of the memo, even bigger story. Admitting he shredded the "official" (or unofficial, depending on who you ask) copy, huge story.

What's wrong with that boy? Repeat after me: "no comment."

In the fallout, Election Commission Chair Christopher Heagerty is quoted as saying "I'm not pleased. You just don't do that."

So their hand-picked apprentice has gotten himself thrown under the bus and attorney Clifford Rogers parachutes in out of nowhere to take over the AOE post and save the day. (Because nobody is taking DeFreese seriously are they?) Unless they follow form and keep Frith on despite all this, similar to how they appointed a new election commissioner who admitted violating election laws. You never know with these guys.

Either way, the Election Commission decision will likely be short and sweet. It's amazing how they're able to make so many decisions without any open deliberation at their meetings.

And we probably haven't heard the last of this. Frith leveled some pretty serious charges of "blackmail" against Mackay. It's going to be hard to walk that back.

Mackay is known for following the rules, for good or ill depending on your point of view. He did what he was told by HR, according to the leaked memos, and Frith admits to factual elements of the memo. Did Mackay leak the existence of the memo? Did he really tell Frith he would "smear" him as Frith is quoted as saying in the paper? It seems out of character for Mackay, but who knows? (Actually, Donila knows but he ain't talking.)

On the other hand, it doesn't seem out of character for the GOBs running things now. It would be just as easy to speculate that Frith pissed in somebody's Cheerios and this is an expedient way to get rid of him and save face. That would be ironic, but not surprising.

We may never know. Unless there are depositions.

On a final note, County Mayor Tim Burchett is quoted in the Sentinel as saying "Mackay gave it to our HR director as maybe job insurance, I don't know." Nice cheap shot. It fits the pattern, though.

RELATED:

Knox County election chief Frith shredded harassment memo

Interim election head alleges political play in shredded personnel memo

Minor election memo, big mess

The memo

bizgrrl's picture

I know they are in a hurry to

I know they are in a hurry to hire someone. It would not seem right to hire Mr. Frith at this time. What would that say about the administration and the ability to look away when there is sexual harassment? I don't care what anyone says, it's not cute. Women (and men), young or old, should not be subjected to this behavior.

EconGal's picture

blood suckers in a Libertarian world


"Thought: Let's say the Libertarian unicorns-riding-lollipops utopia of atomistic sovereign beings came to pass and there were no government. What the hell would these people do for a living? No, seriously."

Precisely. Like Victoria Defreese, they would would have piece-meal "careers" being poll workers, census takers, substitute teachers, etc.

Wait a minute...those are government jobs, too.

They would likely be something really meaningful, like economists or restroom attendants. Or those guys wearing foam Statue of Liberty costumes on the side of the road during tax season.

R. Neal's picture

Mike Donila is live tweeting

Mike Donila is live tweeting the interviews...

http://twitter.com/#!/MikeDonila

Rachel's picture

Frith was never gonna get

Frith was never gonna get this job, so nobody leaked the email to keep him from getting it. All 3 R election commissioners had Rodgers as their first choice on their lists.

Everyone involved in this entire affair if tacky. Why can't Knox County get through one single week w/o this kind of crap going on?

Mary the prez's picture

The real crime is ignored!

The real crime was Frith's repeated harassment of these students and even others as witnessed and verified by his co-workers. He admits his illegal acts, then tries to say it was nothing; apparently,he thought by airing all his stupidity in the press and by blaming his boss, he would get the top job. He has a FB page featuring his beautiful wife who I am SURE was hurt and humiliated by his juvenile 'playing around'.

Greg MacKay was and is a man of integrity, fairness, and ran the Elections since 2007 efficiently and accurately, NEVER being challenged by anything improper. His attempt to try to stop Frith's continual disgusting, insulting behavior by warning him repeatedly to STOP, apparently was ignored.

Further, the fact that Frith actually destroyed files, and claimed blackmail, blah, blah, will give Greg a good case for a lawsuit. (Slander, loss of integrity and good name/reputation, and unproven accusations of wrong doing).

Go, Greg. You deserve total vindication! I have met your Momma and she did not raise a bad young'un!

Tamara Shepherd's picture

*

Greg MacKay was and is a man of integrity, fairness, and ran the Elections since 2007 efficiently and accurately...

Greg served us well since before that, Mary.

I can't recall just when he assumed the post, but I know he held the office in 2003-2004 and that he was there some time before that?

Anyway, belated thanks for your dutiful service through a number of politically-rocky years, Greg. You were always straightforward and fair.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives