Fri
Aug 27 2010
07:57 pm
vernon's picture

what did Finley expect when

what did Finley expect when he cancelled the scheduled community meeting with 3 days notice?

Rachel's picture

Not sure I understand the

Not sure I understand the point. The UOR appeal goes to Council, not Commission. Or do you mean you want to ask Harmon about it because he's running for Mayor?

Rachel's picture

Did you get to talk to

Did you get to talk to Harmon?

KnoxCatLady1's picture

Ron Peabody

It is a very strange thing that suddenly Ron Peabody is vitally interested in the folks in South Knoxville. My own opinion is that Mr. Peabody is more interested in protecting what he perceives to be the interests of his own West Knoxville neighbors. I have yet to see anything Mr. Peabody has done that could possibly be construed as in the best interests of South Knoxvillians.

vernon's picture

Suddenly? Where have you

Suddenly? Where have you been? hes only attended every community meeting and mpc meeting and city council meeting alongside the south knox residents since the Teaberry Lane proposal,which as I understand is when the TYP came knocking on his door.There is no west knox site being considered and Burchett has already squashed the TYP going in the county.So, I don't get your point.

Bike Bitchell's picture

You're usually a man of great political wisdom, brotha.

You may be premature on this one, tho--

There is no west knox site being considered and Burchett has already squashed the TYP going in the county.

As to the first, who says? As to the second, I think you need to read the Timspeak with a little more translational discerning. He's not your Tim, you know. You may not be able to suss him out the way you could your model.

vernon's picture

you are incorrect on both

you are incorrect on both points

Rachel's picture

hes only attended every

hes only attended every community meeting and mpc meeting and city council meeting alongside the south knox residents since the Teaberry Lane proposal,

I think catlady's point was that Flenniken has been on the table for a very long time, and no one in south Knoxville saw Peabody showing any interest - until PSH was proposed for his (west Knoxville) neighborhood.

whooshe65's picture

KnoxCatLady1,

Could it be that Ron Peabody is actually the spokesperson for a group called TYP Choice?

And could it be that there are actually people in South Knoxville that are part of TYP Choice?

Could it also be that TYP Choice has members from around the City, and County?

Nah, it's just the Pea Party of one.

Rachel's picture

And could it be that there

And could it be that there are actually people in South Knoxville that are part of TYP Choice?

Could it also be that TYP Choice has members from around the City, and County?

Nobody knows because you refuse to tell us who your members are.

whooshe65's picture

Rachel,

Please see; (link...)

Rachel's picture

I'm trying to be polite, but

I'm trying to be polite, but that's a pretty silly response.

I say again - there's no way to know if TYP Choice does or doesn't have members in south Knoxville, or any other part of the county, because TYP Choice won't say who its members are.

fischbobber's picture

TYP choice really can't

TYP choice really can't release its supporter list can it?

Look at what happens to people on this board that don't fall lock step into line on the TYP plan.

Good nutrition, healthy outdoor exercise, and positive interpersonal interaction are three basics, free basics I might add, when it comes to treating mental illness and addiction. All three are addressed with pedestrian infrastructure which is a one time expense that easily pays for itself over a short period of time. I have advocated this position since Teaberry was brought to the table and I began studying this issue. If we are going to do this, let's do it right.

Look at the amount of abuse I've taken over this simple position. Why would anyone working in sales or the public eye in general expose themselves to the kind of abuse one takes for speaking a truth?

Most people are not brave and shun the limelight. That should be their privilege.

Rachel's picture

TYP choice really can't

TYP choice really can't release its supporter list can it?

Look at what happens to people on this board that don't fall lock step into line on the TYP plan.

They get treated like anybody else who takes a position? Some people don't like it and take issue with their position? KV doesn't have the power to really hurt people.

BTW, I'm not "lock step" in line with either the "pro" or "anti" faction, and nothing has "happened" to me yet, except for a few people calling me names.

Look, it's hard for me to respect a group that feels the need to hide its membership. If you're gonna engage in civic activities, you have to be willing to say who you are.

This isn't a game. It's about real lives, both those of the chronically homeless and those of the people who live in the neighborhoods where PSH is proposed. (and fischerbob, I'm not directing this last paragraph at you)

fischbobber's picture

They get treated like anybody

They get treated like anybody else who takes a position? Some people don't like it and take issue with their position? KV doesn't have the power to really hurt people.

It will be a great move forward in this issue when the day arrives that positions and ideas are debated as opposed to the present norm of personal attacks. I look forward to that day.

BTW, I'm not "lock step" in line with either the "pro" or "anti" faction, and nothing has "happened" to me yet, except for a few people calling me names.

Frankly, you would be a perfect example of one who gets personally ripped every time someone objects to an idea you have put on the board. The people ripping you just usually happen to be different than the people ripping me, but, lets face it, it's the same thing. With a subject that is both intellectually challenging on several levels as well as emotionally charged it is far easier to attack the messengers than debate and (gasp!!!!) compromise on the issues at hand. I think that is why this issue hasn't moved and also think that no one really wants to tackle it until after the November elections.

Look, it's hard for me to respect a group that feels the need to hide its membership. If you're gonna engage in civic activities, you have to be willing to say who you are.

Again, so much of this whole process is done in secrecy, and there are so many "amazing coincidences", I almost think I'm numb to this argument. That being said, I agree with you in principle. I think everything about this process should be transparent and on the table, including the names of those engaged in the debate.

This isn't a game. It's about real lives, both those of the chronically homeless and those of the people who live in the neighborhoods where PSH is proposed.

On this point, we're in total agreement. And on that note I'm happy to report that I continued my on site inventory check of the local greenways today and I'm happy to report that it looks like hooking Flennikan into the Blount county greenway system should be a piece of cake. Maryville Pike appears to be wide enough for a bike lane and there is an access point to the Alcoa greenway just north of Pellissippi Parkway. This would allow access to both jobs and recreation for the formerly homeless. The more I study and the more I investigate and actually check out sites and logistics, the more convinced I am that this can work. Then, of course, I read these threads and the media accounts and I'm convinced that the cause may be hopeless simply because no one is willing to concede anything. We are allowing ourselves to be defined by our problems rather than by our solutions.

bizgrrl's picture

The article states the name

The article states the name of the woman for whom Peabody is filing the appeal. Don't think it matters if she is a TYP Choice member or not. But, at this time, you can put her in a file as someone who is benefiting from Peabody and/or TYP Choice.

KnoxCatLady1's picture

Even if

Even if TYP Choice does have members in South Knoxville, so what? I do not favor the current TYP plan and still think Mr. Peabody is largely representing himself. He certainly has not acted in the best interests of South Knoxville.

whooshe65's picture

You may want to ask the

You may want to ask the Residents of the Verandas apartment complex and the Vestal Community how they feel about what Peabody is doing.

Where do you live?

Rachel's picture

Where do you live? And you?

Where do you live?

And you?

KnoxCatLady1's picture

South Knoxville

I have lived in South Knoxville for over sixty years. And where do you live?

whooshe65's picture

Since you live in South

Since you live in South Knoxville, in your opinion, what has Peabody done to offend folks on the South Side, like yourself?

Or should I ask, in Reference to Flenniken, what do you think is "in the best interest of South Knoxville" ?

sobi's picture

For one thing,...

...you always refer to South Knoxville as the "South Side," which only a carpetbagger would do.

For another, you're patronizing as hell.

whooshe65's picture

Sobi,

Correct me if I am wrong, but is the area of the City of Knoxville that lies to the SOUTH of Downtown, not geographically the South Side of Town?

.you always refer to South Knoxville as the "South Side," which only a carpetbagger would do.

I can unequivocally state that I have been employed by any carpet manufacturer, nor have I ever bagged any carpet.

If you are going to insult people out of your own frustration with the truth, you are going to have to do a better Job than that.

vernon's picture

and you ms sobi are an

and you ms sobi are an idiot,I have read your posts for a long time and most of them offer nothing meaningful,I don't know if you are frustrated because you feel defeated by TYP choice or Mr Peabody but you clearly are lost in whatever position you have, all you do is start insulting in childish ways,making fun of someones appearance or just having no real point in your contributions. Just because this man and this group, believe that the current TYP is not whats best for Knoxville or whats best for the people its supposed to help,doesn't make them wrong,its what they believe.
Make a point, but insulting people constantly makes you looks stupid.

sobi's picture

You go too far, man!!

I've accused Ron Whooshebody of being dishonest, which he is, of not knowing what he's talking about, which he doesn't, of being a detriment to our community, which is not a matter of opinion but of fact, of being a fearmonger, which is incontestably true, of encouraging discrimination against people with disabilities, evidence for which abounds, and of being a bully. I've asked him here and elsewhere to provide evidence for assertions he forwards not as his opinions, but as fact, and he refuses to provide that evidence because it makes him angry that I call him "Ron" and because he can't back up his assertions with proof. I have pointed out that he's a carpetbagger, which he is in the best traditions of carpetbagging, and I'll also say that his hypocrisy is as appalling as it is obvious. I'm not frustrated with Ron, I'm disgusted by him. Not because he is anti TYP, but because he is so dishonest, misinformed, misleading and cruel in his opposition to it.

But I've never made fun of his appearance.

vernon's picture

stop lying sobi

stop lying sobi

MyOpinion's picture

Thank you, Sobi,

for articulating so clearly and accurately the truth about Ron Peabody. The only thing you left out is his motivation: self-promotion. There is simply no other explanation for his bizarre, irrational, and totally self-aggrandizing behavior.

Hoyt Conner's picture

"There is simply no other

"There is simply no other explanation for his bizarre, irrational, and totally self-aggrandizing behavior."

I don't get that. I'm no expert but what I've seen is a plan that constantly changes and homeless numbers that keep going up. Problem is, it looks like we have much less homeless than last year. Drive by KARM any evening and you do not see the crowd you did last year. So how can the numbers be increasing?

I think Peabody and his group are determined to find out what is true. You have to admit when they won't let Jon Lawler talk any more that looks very suspicious. The whole thing looks like a cover up.

Looks to me like another citizen's group trying to question their government. Maybe a little smarter than previous groups, the not revealing the membership seems to be driving some people crazy.

I might be wrong, but I think the Ten Year Plan is dead. Like a opossum that has been run over it is scampering into the woods, but it is dead opossum walking.

sobi's picture

I don't get this.

I don't get that. I'm no expert but what I've seen is a plan that constantly changes and homeless numbers that keep going up.

So plans are supposed to be immutable? You're not supposed to make adjustments as you gain new information? Plans don't change, but if they do the people changing them are evil?

One of Peabody's favorite criticisms of the TYP is his constant cry that when the TYP was founded there were only 400 chronic homeless and now there are a thousand or something like that. Has Peabody ever asked, anywhere at any time, for someone to explain how this could be or what it means? If he has asked, he's not telling. He's just pointed his finger at people who are actually working on solutions and accused them of lying. Might there be other explanations?

Peabody and his group are not determined to find out what is true. They are determined to destroy a plan that makes them feel threatened, and Peabody will say anything to try to make that happen.

This sounds like a little like vintage sock peappetry:

Looks to me like another citizen's group trying to question their government. Maybe a little smarter than previous groups, the not revealing the membership seems to be driving some people crazy.

Peabody lacks the self awareness to understand that nothing he's doing is driving anyone crazy. I can't speak for everyone, but I think the people who see through the Pea view him with disgust and amusement. He's not a big scary villain. He's an annoying pest. But you have to give him this. He's raised awareness of homelessness in Knoxville and has helped to get people talking about it.

But he's also raised awareness about himself, and it's at least believable that that's a pretty big deal to him.

Rachel's picture

southside

I believe he does that to irritate me, since I once pointed out that nobody I know in south Knoxville refers to us as "the southside" and asked him to stop.

It's not irritating, however, it's just kind of amusing.

whooshe65's picture

Updated Article

This updated article, that appeared on the Front Page of the paper Version this morning, and on line is available here;
(link...)

Rachel's picture

That's not fair to Elizabeth

That's not fair to Elizabeth Monday. She has opposed TYP at Flenniken since the beginning, and she is the one who personally paid for the post card to be sent out in south Knoxville soliciting signatures for the "kill the TYP" petition.

Like most south Knoxvillians, she is a strong person capable of speaking for herself.

Rachel's picture

Instead of slinging insults

Instead of slinging insults at one another, I'd be interested to read what folks think of the arguments Peabody makes against the UOR. In order to evaluate those, I'd suggest you read what the ordinance says about UOR evaluations - (link...)

(crap - the link won't take you all the say. See appendix B, article 5, section 3).

You can read the MPC staff report/recommendation here: (link...).

Also, please remember that the chronically homeless are a protected class, and cannot legally be discriminated against.

whooshe65's picture

Rachel,

As many people have now discovered, the reality is that the people to be housed at Flenniken are not exclusively Chronically Homeless. They, according to Ginny Weatherstone, Robert Finley, and Micheal Dunthorn, could also be non-disabled, situationally homeless people that are not covered as a protected class, under the ADA.

What to do now?

See for yourself, here;
(link...)

Rachel's picture

So the argument is that the

So the argument is that the UOR discussion should focus on these few non-disabled, situationly homeless people because it IS ok to discriminate against them?

I'm not trying to be flip; I'm just trying to understand your argument.

Donna Clark's picture

"Also, please remember that

"Also, please remember that the chronically homeless are a protected class, and cannot legally be discriminated against."

That has worn thin. The protected class argument doesn't mean that the government can cram down the throat of a neighborhood a place with untreated drug addicts. You and your friends here are quite happy to volunteer other people neighborhoods for these sites, but I don't see you volunteering your neighborhood.

Why is that?

Rachel's picture

protected classes

That has worn thin.

The Constitution still looks pretty sturdy to me.

You and your friends here are quite happy to volunteer other people neighborhoods for these sites,

You haven't paid one bit of attention to anything I've said.

Donna Clark's picture

"The Constitution still looks

"The Constitution still looks pretty sturdy to me."

Where in the Constitution is the clause "you have no choice on your drug addict neighbors"? Protected class is not in the Constitution.

All I've seen from you is you want this away from you and you fully support it. Sort of NIMBY but I like it otherwise.

Rachel's picture

All I've seen from you is you

Protected class is not in the Constitution.

No, it's in various civil rights & fair housing acts, which courts have held Constitutional under the equal protection clause of the 14th amendment.

BTW, as far as I know, TYP Choice and other opponents accept that the chronically homeless are a protected class under the law. You're one of the few folks I've seen who wanted to argue about that.

All I've seen from you is you want this away from you and you fully support it.

You certainly have not seen the first from me. As for the second, I've said repeatedly that I support the scattered site housing approach, but that I've had quite a few problems with the management of the TYP. If that translates to "fully support" for you, so be it.

Since you insist on ascribing things to me that I haven't said, this will be my last reply to your posts.

Donna Clark's picture

"BTW, as far as I know, TYP

"BTW, as far as I know, TYP Choice and other opponents accept that the chronically homeless are a protected class under the law. You're one of the few folks I've seen who wanted to argue about that."

When the TYP mixes chronically homeless and non-chronically homeless there is no protected class. You don't get to prorate this. The TYP plays games with the HUD rules and when they do so they lose the protected class blackmail.

Could they be more incompetent? Why do you make excuses for them?

Pcarey's picture

Mr. metulj, you should ask

Mr. metulj, you should ask Mayor Burchett about the TYP instead of potentional city Mayors.

Within the next two weeks Mayor Burchett will talk about the TYP. The county is out unless the TYP comes to the table. That means that the city now pays for the TYP all by themselves.

whooshe65's picture

metulj,

Another person who hasn't read the TYP plan.

Don't you mean the Mission statement, cause there is no plan in the TYP document, just a lot of Goals with no cost projections or a real map as to how to get there.

That's why this plan has failed, and should be scrapped.
Like Burchett has said, only when everyone "comes to the Table", will a plan like this have a chance at being successfull.

Melinda S.'s picture

Heard this earlier this

Heard this earlier this morning. This will be the main issue in next year's Mayor's race in Knoxville.

(link...)

Can the TYP continue? I don't see it. They made a huge mistake not listening.

Somebody's picture

Considering his track record,

Considering his track record, I wouldn't be surprised to see that the TYP turns out not to be a major issue in next year's race.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives