Thu
Jul 22 2010
07:24 pm


This is a story about a city park neglected and forgotten, and what happened when one group tried to make a difference. Littered and graffitied, the park hosted one garbage can, trash, drug users and drunks. And thought the park sits across the street from a prestigious condominium complex, it received no more than the obligatory mowing by the city. Within the park sets four large cement containers which grew nothing but weeds for the past five years; this is where the project began, in the abandoned and neglected container gardens.



Three weeks ago

Three months ago, a few neighborhood residents took it upon themselves to beautify the park. With the idea of teaching children how to grow something useful, like food, the group weeded and planted the container beds with tomatoes, sunflowers, watermelon, pumpkins, corn, and other vegetables. The kids in the park immediately became interested. They made a promise to help maintain the gardens and to keep pick up garbage around the park. The adult residents came up with a club name for the kids, and the City Rangers were born. The Agrarian Urbanites covered their story in May ((link...)) and June ((link...)).


Today

Despite a few bumps, the City Rangers met every Wednesday and Saturday to pick up the park and work on their gardens. Though one of the neighborhood residents, Brandy Slaybaugh, requested permission from Parks and Rec, no reply returned; not a yes, or a no that the group could or couldn't garden there, so they expanded the garden to a tilled up space. The City Rangers planted 12 watermelon starts and just as many pumpkin transfers, and the group continued to carefully maintain the area around the patch knowing that at anytime, the city could mow over their project.

But the city didn't mow it down. For over two months during their obligatory mowing of the park, the city mowed around the garden showing great decency for the folks and children who were trying to accomplish something in the park. Since the kids began their gardens, trash diminished and the drug users thinned-out. It was a win-win situation for everyone. The city didn't have to work as hard (not that they ever really did) to maintain the park, and the kids were learning about where food comes from and how to grow it.

Then tragedy struck. True despicable and disgusting tragedy.

During a time when the Mayor of Knoxville is running for Governor, the city of Knoxville tries to make strides with the Sustainably Task Force, and the Knoxville Knox County Food Policy Council diligently works to create more community gardens, the City Rangers' community garden was absolutely obliterated by the city. I couldn't believe it when I heard it, so I drove over to the park to see for myself what happened.


Watermelon trying to survive despite being buried by a tree.

I asked a woman sitting under the gazebo amongst broken glass and used condoms if she knew what happened. She said, "The city was out here working last week, but I don't know much about this park. I don't like coming down here too much. There's always drugs and stuff down here."

It wasn't a pretty site. The container beds that grew nothing but weeds but now were growing tomatoes, watermelon, sunflowers, and corn had been ripped out and, get this, mulched. Nothing new was planted, not even a petunia, but the container beds were meticulously mulched for the first time in five years.

Though the city can't clean-up the graffiti; fix the broken bridge; pick up the broken glass, trash and condoms, they can saw down several trees. And somehow, they can make one of those trees land right on the watermelon patch. Oh, then the city can leave the sort-of, cut-up trees laying where they fell for at least a week. It's carnage, and it doesn't happen in other city parks in Knoxville.

Slaybaugh talked to Joe Walsh of Parks and Rec and he knew nothing of the gardens or the work recently done by the city at the park. When he heard the description of the damage, he suspected it was the horticulture department. In which Slaybaugh replied, "Well you'd think a 'horticulture department' would know what vegetables look like."

Is this really the city I live in? When a few concerned citizens and children take it upon themselves to care for a neglected forgotten park and try to do something good, is this really how people get treated?

At first I felt shock when I heard the news, then I felt seething anger while taking the photos. And now? I feel a mixture that races between anger, sadness and denial. It's a beautiful thing when a few people give their time, money, attention, and love to a park and a group of kids who are eager, excited and willing to learn. It's unbelievable when their project gets shit-on by the very same people who didn't give a shit about the park or the kids to begin with. Its a lot of things, like, disgusting, mean, unjust...and unfortunately, it seems to be how Knoxville's east side is treated.

The best thing the city can do right now, is to leave the pile on the garden alone. Some of the plants are miraculously surviving. If the kids are lucky, they still may get a small harvest. But the dream of growing a melon and pumpkin for each kid, a dream that was well on its way to fruition? That dream isn't going to happen.


This is one way to keep the drug addicts from their bench.

And what about the kids? As her eyes fill with tears, Slaybaugh says, "How do I explain this to them? How do I even...." She breaks off, shakes her head and stares out the window. "I can't even bring myself to go see it. How am I going to face those kids?"


The city sure likes to use its chainsaws, but it doesn't seem to like to fix broken infrastructure.


The red remains of a plastic trike still in the ditch after at least three weeks...there's a photo in June's update of the the City Rangers.


The city can cut down trees, but they can't empty a garbage can?


With a lack of garbage cans, several bags are tied to the back of the bench in an effort to get people to throw out their trash.

Wonder what these people would think about the park today?

First published at (link...)

Tess's picture

Write a letter to the mayor

This certainly calls for an explanation. Please write a letter to the mayor and include pictures. Some of the tv stations might be interested too.

michael kaplan's picture

if your lucky, you might get

if your lucky, you might get an answer from bill lyons ...

i'd send the letter to the mayor, to the members of city council, and to the director of community development. see what you get back.

and speaking of public horticulture, how's that 'urban forest' coming along on the SmartFix40 berms?

Madeline Rogero's picture

Michael: I have spoken to

Michael: I have spoken to one of the families involved to get more information and left a message for another. I don't know who was involved with this or why, but I will check with other city departments tomorrow and report back. How very sad for the children and the adults who were nurturing them. Madeline Rogero, Community Development Director, City of Knoxville.

michael kaplan's picture

madeline, thanks. your

madeline, thanks. your intervention is appreciated.

agrarianurbanite's picture

Thanks

Thanks Madeline,
Chad told me that you called. Your efforts are greatly appreciated.

It's not my project, though. I'm just 'reporting' it. The project was all B. Slaybaugh and those kids. I'll let Ms. Slaybaugh know that you're trying to contact her.

Best,
Tracie Hellwinckel

Tamara Shepherd's picture

A couple of similar questions (re: Knox County)

On the chance that any Knox County staffers are also listening in, I have a couple of similar questions for them.

Here on my Powell-area property, I have a tall, scraggly half-dead tree down by the road that drops large limbs (often into the road) with every storm. Because it clearly needs to come down, two different "tree docs" have rung my doorbell in recent months offering to cut it down for $300.

My husband, though, said the tree is in the county's right-of-way, which he believes to be 25 feet from the center point of the road, so we should call them to remove it.

I called the county's Public Works department just recently to ask their policy in the question and the woman answering the phone confirmed that their right-of-way does run 25 feet from the center point of the road. Per her suggestion, we hung up, I measured the distance of the tree from the road's center point, then called her back to indicate that the tree appeared to be 24 feet from the road's center point, in their right-of-way. She then put me on the department's list for a "look-see."

Within a week or so, two county trucks carrying four employees stopped by to double-check my measurement. They believed the tree to be 26 feet, not 24 feet, from the road's center point and they indicated that, in any event, their right-of-way runs 20 feet, not 25 feet, from the road's center point. They also explained that even if my tree had been in their right-of-way, their tree removal service wouldn't have been free. They said they would have subcontracted the work and billed me, probably around $1200.

Two questions, then:

1) Why would the county bill a property owner for work done on their right-of-way?

2) Why would the county bill that property owner quadruple the charge a private company would assess for the same job?

smalc's picture

1) Why would the county bill

1) Why would the county bill a property owner for work done on their right-of-way?
You'll have to investigate the county's ordinances regarding ROWs, but I suspect the Knox County property owner is responsible for trees. Some localities regulate planting and removal of trees within ROWs, I betting Knox County does not. Calling it "their" ROW is a bit of a stretch. The county and public utilities have right of entry, but it's an easement only.

2) Why would the county bill that property owner quadruple the charge a private company would assess for the same job?
No competition, sweet contract, good ole boy network, etc. Take your pick.

sugarfatpie's picture

Thanks Madeline!

Thanks Madeline!

Up Goose Creek's picture

Thank you

Thank you so much for undertaking this project and thanks for bringing it to our attention. I am so sorry for your loss.

Please let us know when y'all have an idea of what the city could do to make amends. We can put an effort into lobbying on your behalf.

Bird_dog's picture

ditto Beaumont Elementary

My friend worked with the kids to plant fruit trees and and vegetables and daffodils - and recycling. Just when everything was doing so well, the city oversprayed Round-up from the street and killed the fruit trees. Other "landscapers" over-pruned the shrubs in front of the school even though they were well-below the windows... Very discouraging...

sugarfatpie's picture

Yeah, what is the deal with

Yeah, what is the deal with the roundup being sprayed all over Knox county. I took a drive on Taz pike the other day and it was one continuous streak of brown along either side of the road.

Its even more disturbing to hear that the city roundup sprayers can't control themselves when they are near a school.

How is this stuff being sprayed? I haven't seen it done, but I hope its not from a nozzle on a truck, with a dude sitting in an airconditioned cab not really looking at what he is doing.

Average Guy's picture

Amends

Mayor Haslam arranges K-Trans (Trolley) to pick up the City Rangers at 8am. Then the Mayor personally helps lead a tour at Ijams. For lunch, the City will take the kids to Tomato Head (or like restaurant) for some pizza made from fresh local ingredients.

After lunch, K-Trans will take the City Rangers to Organicism Farms for a tour and some goodies, paid for by the city of course.

After a couple hour tour, the kids will head back to Parkridge to find the same idiots who did this “work” have restored the spaces, removed the graffiti, cleaned up the trash and fixed the bridge. A plan for a fall garden will be part of the fix as well.

To end the day, these children will receive their award (whatever is applicable) - presented by the Mayor, Head of Parks and Rec and head of whatever maintenance crew (sounds like the Horticulture Dept) responsible for this.

A lot of this is embarrassing, but the real tragedy happens if just one of these youngsters comes to believe before their old enough to vote – their government doesn’t care about them.

At this point, they have proof.

michael kaplan's picture

that's a great little poster,

that's a great little poster, btw.

David Brace's picture

Garden Damage

I manage the City's Public Service Department, the large City organization responsible for all park maintenance under the Horticulture Division. I will look into this first thing and report back.

sugarfatpie's picture

Thanks!

Thanks!

Rachel's picture

Wow, for an "obscure" blog,

Wow, for an "obscure" blog, this post sure is getting lots of attention from City department heads.

BTW, Madeline and David are both good people. When they say they'll follow up on this, they mean it.

David Brace's picture

Re: Garden Damage

First and foremost, let me apologize for the damage and removal of the garden plantings at Parkridge Park. I want the supporters of this project to know that as our customers, we value yor efforts and truly want to work with the kids and organizers alike to support and formalize the community garden and adopt-a-park effort in Parkridge. Based on my research, the actions of our crews were not malicious.

I visited the park this morning and also talked with Joe Walsh the City's P&R Director regarding the garden and recent damage. In short, the City arborist visited the park several weeks ago and determined (a) that a number of large dangerous trees needed to be removed and that (b) a number of trees needed to be pruned up to help provide a more "open feel" to the park. Jeff initiated the work order and our crews completed the tree removal, hence the piles.

Removing large trees is dangerous and typically not a "soft" action. We use chainsaws, a bucket truck and winches. It is common practice for our tree crew to fell trees in parks, pile the debris and then for one of our "zone" crews to later pick up the debris using a knuckle-boom (hydraulic claw). For very large trees, we often have to bring in a front-end loader and dump truck to augment the work. In most removals large piles of debris are left in parks for several weeks and become an eyesore. This is something I have never liked and prompted Public Service to request and receive funding in this fiscal year to purchase an extra knuckle-boom that will be used by the tree crew during their tree removal projects. This will allows us to "turn-key" jobs and collect all of the debris at the time of removal. The tree crew asked for this capacity and we will make it happen this year thanks to the funding. But for now, tree debris will sit in parks after removal and is an eyesore. This includes all parks and is not unique to Parkridge.

As for the garden, unfortunately Joe and I were not aware of the plantings. We are both strong advocates for community gardens and made possible one of the first large park gardens at Tyson this past spring and summer, a project spearheaded by our Americorps greenways ranger, CAC Americorps and the Public Service Department Horticulture and Construction Divisions.

Not knowing about the plantings is a challenge, since our mowing crews, tree crew and the folks that run weedeaters are on-site to complete basic maintenance. The only way to guarantee protection for something like a community garden would be for the manager and foreman to be aware of it and to visit the site with their crews. We have done this on numerous occasions in the past and will obviously do that as we work to make this situation right.

Based on my visit this morning and after talking with Joe Walsh, we will be adding a second trash receptacle at the park to help curb the litter and overflow issue. The garbage crew was actually emptying the can this morning and I made the request directly to them. We have also put in a work order to repair the bridge and we scheduled a litter clean up session for this weekend, which will include the drainage swale and broken glass. I also set up a meeting Monday morning with the foreman responsible for the park to discuss cleaning up the walk paths, weedeating edges and just cleaning up the park in general, with the goal of keeping that level of service in the future.

Again, I wish this incident had not occurred. I hope those involved will work with Joe and I to formalize the garden project and afford us the opportunity to improve the situation. We are both available to meet/discuss this matter further. Below is our contact information:

David Brace
Public Service Department
dbrace@cityofknoxville.org

Joe Walsh
Parks and Recreation Department
jwalsh@cityofknoxville.org

Pam Strickland's picture

My question would be who did

My question would be who did Ms. Slaybaugh contact at P&R and why did they not follow-up. As well, why didn't Ms. Slaybaugh follow-up that initial contact?

Rachel's picture

Those are both good

Those are both good questions, Pam.

In the past, I have experienced difficulty with callbacks from P&R (although that was before 311, which may have improved the situation because they keep a log). However, I would just keep calling till I got through.

BTW, my experiences with 311 have been extremely good. I called them awhile back about the big hole that the "claws" David Brace talks about above had dug at the edge of our back yard when picking up brush. I was delighted to see the hole filled in two days later, and seeded and covered with straw the day after that.

Pam Strickland's picture

I'm not saying that tearing

I'm not saying that tearing out plantings is excusable, but a little phone persistence upfront could have put the garden on the city's radar.

Rachel's picture

I agree. Althought P&R

I agree. Althought P&R should also have returned that first phone call.

sugarfatpie's picture

I hope those involved will

I hope those involved will work with Joe and I to formalize the garden project and afford us the opportunity to improve the situation.

Interesting. Is formalization what the gardeners are after?
Could be cool to have at least some of these projects formalized.

Regardless, thanks again for the attention, action, and thoughtful response.

David Brace's picture

Re: Beaumont

Bird_dog - Regarding the overspray at Beaumont, if you have more information about this situation, please e-mail me at dbrace@cityofknoxville.org. My son attends Beaumont and I was not aware of us damaging fruit trees. It may have been us or the Knox County School's mowing contractor. Regardless, if I have some details, there is probably a mechanism for getting the trees replaced if they were killed.

Although we try to minimize the use of herbicides, an application of RoundUp is used during the growing season to keep weeds down on curblines, barrier walls, road edges, edges of greenways and in alleys. It's an important, almost essential "tool" that we use to manage all of the public spaces we have under our purview. Having three kids ranging from two weeks to six years old I am very sensitive to the use of RoundUp in alleys due to the direct interface between public and private property (i.e. people/pets/flowers).

Bird_dog's picture

Thanks

I emailed my friend for more details and whether there was any remediation at the time. It was about 8 years ago I think...

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives