With regard to this impasse on healthcare reform, I've been meaning to look up the 1935 and 1965 votes tallied in the successful passage of the Social Security Act and the Medicare bill, respectively. I have also been curious to learn the level of Republican support for both bills. Here 'tis...
1935 Social Security Act:
House voted 372 for and 33 against with 81 Republicans in tow
Senate voted 77 for and 6 against with 16 Republicans in tow
1965 Medicare bill:
House voted 307 for and 116 against with 70 Republicans in tow
Senate voted 70 for and 24 against with 13 Republicans in tow
Politifact.com had some other interesting historical tidbits, including a mention of Johnson's 2/3 majority in the House following the 1964 elections.
(I wasn't looking to prove or disprove any assertion Howard Dean made last August, which is the focus of this Politifact piece. That's just where I happened to find the numbers I wanted.)
|
111
vote
|
Discussing:
- Faith (5 replies)
- North Knox residents unhappy with prostitution problem (45 replies)
- Summit Towers and Lakeshore (16 replies)
- Tomato Head comes clean (15 replies)
- Are Beasley's for-profit EMOs yet running TN charter schools? (3 replies)
- Journalism from the rear view mirror: who's watching the road ahead? (6 replies)
- League of Women Voters endorses Knox Co. Schools budget (1 reply)
- Post Office to shed 28,000 jobs, close 229 facilities (17 replies)
- Williamson County Schools restricts student teachers... (3 replies)
- Facebook IPO watch (6 replies)
- For-profit EMO running two TN charter schools (3 replies)
- 2012 Shootings in Knox County, TN (33 replies)
User login
Navigation
TN Progressive
- When The U.S. Media Lost Its Collective Mind (Southern Beale)
- News Flash!!! Ladies Room Part of TN State House Floor (RoaneViews)
- TN Voter ID Law (RoaneViews)
- From the Justice Department... (RoaneViews)
- When You Think You're The Only Expert At Something...Remember This Lesson (RoaneViews)
- Happy Endangered Species Day! (Whitescreek Journal)
- National Review Takes Down False Plagiarism Charge Against Elizabeth Warren (TN Guerilla Women)
- Shh… Use Your Indoor Voice! (Southern Beale)
- Jeff Barbra and Sarah Pirkle at Market Street Fountain (RoaneViews)
- WHO are the Job Creators??? (Left Wing Cracker)
- Good News Friday (Southern Beale)
- Updates on cohousing and development (Enclave)
- If You’re A Horse Stay Out Of Tennessee (Southern Beale)
- Donna Summer, 1948-2012 (Left Wing Cracker)
- When You’ve Got Nothing Else (Southern Beale)
- Rachel Maddow & Jane Lynch Tallk About Gay Rights Evolution (Video) (TN Guerilla Women)
TN Politics
- Harwell's 'Ghost Voting' Commentary Rated Half True (Tom Humphrey)
- So, What Exactly is 'Gateway Sexual Activity'? (Tom Humphrey)
- James DuBois (father of Tom) Dies, Age 68 (Tom Humphrey)
- Dems targeting DesJarlais (Post Politics)
- Comptroller Recommends Changes to Complete College Act (Tom Humphrey)
- DesJarlais Denounces Fed Funding of Soft Drink Tax Advocacy (Tom Humphrey)
- Horsefeathers (Post Politics)
- Straight cash, homey (Post Politics)
- Disconnection? (Post Politics)
- High on homegrown (Post Politics)
- Trying to stop bullying (Cara Kumari)
- The Common Core Concept (Cara Kumari)
Local Media Blogs
- BankEast branches officially change hands (Josh Flory)
- Judge dismisses Rarity-linked bankruptcy (Josh Flory)
- Friday briefing (Josh Flory)
- North Knoxville Wok Hay closes (Josh Flory)
- One Last Summer for Plainclothes Tracy (Metro Pulse)
- University of Tennessee buildings aim for National Register status (Josh Flory)
- Knoxville's "Self-Evident Truths" Portraits Online (Metro Pulse)
- Help pours in for evicted senior (Jack McElroy)
- The Tomato Head To Close Maryville Location, Open in West Knoxville (Metro Pulse)
- Nellie McKay at the Bijou (Metro Pulse)
- Maybe newsrooms need to kick the front page habit (Jack Lail)
- Bearden girl wins $5,000 1st Amendment prize (Jack McElroy)
Local Paper
- 1 dead in multiple-vehicle wreck (KNS News)
- MoonPie festival set in Cocke County (KNS News)
- Children's Festival of Reading at World's Fair Park celebrates kids' imaginations (KNS News)
- Man believed to have been involved in fatal crash surrenders to police (KNS News)
- 'Tookie' forum part of 'The Hubert Smith Radio Show' on WUTK (KNS News)
- Judge clears path for Rarity Pointe foreclosure (KNS Business)
- University of Tennessee buildings aim for National Register (KNS Business)
- BankEast branches officially change hands (KNS Business)
- UT Medical Center aids Scott County EMS (KNS Business)
- Magazine names Blackberry Farm top resort for service (KNS Business)
Local TV News
- Knoxville residents chow down at International Biscuit Festival (WATE)
- Fleenor Security Systems warns of scammer posing as employee (WATE)
- Summitt named Tennessean of the Year (WBIR)
- The Soldier's Medal awarded to National Guard pilot (WATE)
- East Tennesseans try to help paralyzed girl walk again (WBIR)
- Three Ridges gets facelift for NGA tour next week (WBIR)
- East TN remembers Fraterville Mine Disaster 110 years (WBIR)
- TN National Guard Pilot receives rare, prestigious medal (WBIR)
- Two girls flown to UT Medical Center after Hamblen Co. collision (WATE)
- 'Grainger Strike' operation leads to 55 indictments (WATE)
- Scott County hospital shutting down, other hospitals helping (WVLT)
- Police: missing Knoxville boy is found and back home (WVLT)
State News
- 'A worthy project' (Commercial Appeal)
- Senior swimmers hit the pool for Olympics (Commercial Appeal)
- Germantown adventurer hopes expedition brings closure to Amerlia Earhart's disappearance (Commercial Appeal)
- Pickin' Picnic (Commercial Appeal)
- My Life/My Job: Michelle Croom Johnson helps stitch visions to reality (Commercial Appeal)
- Top Web Stories and Videos - May 13-18 (Times Free Press)
- Top Video - May 13-18 - Lauren Alaina talks about Mother's Day with her mom (Times Free Press)
- Facebook's Mark Zuckerberg marries sweetheart (Times Free Press)
- NAACP backs same-sex marriage as civil right (Times Free Press)
- I'll Have Another wins Preakness (Tennessean)
- First tropical storm of the season forms off SC (Times Free Press)
- Decision day on Denver hotel project goes Gaylord's way - partly (Tennessean)
Wire Reports
- Chicago braces for largest anti-NATO protest (Yahoo News)
- China keeps up pressure Chen's family, supporters (Yahoo Politics)
- NATO leaders seek common path out of Afghanistan (Yahoo Politics)
- Status update: Facebook's Mark Zuckerberg gets married (Yahoo Business)
- Two smaller unions agree deals with Lockheed (Yahoo Business)
- Google says it has China's approval for Motorola deal (Yahoo Business)
- Civil rights group NAACP endorses gay marriage (Yahoo News)
- Weather helps battle against Southwest wildfires (Yahoo News)
- Anti-NATO activists weighed Obama HQ attack: prosecutors (Yahoo News)
- Political vulnerabilities in Sen. Rubio's past? (Yahoo Politics)
- Gay marriage could be big voting issue in Colorado (Yahoo Politics)
- Is GOP trying to sabotage economy to hurt Obama? (Yahoo Politics)
- Possible engine problem delays U.S. rocket launch (Yahoo News)
- Historic Facebook debut falls flat (Yahoo Business)
- Wall St Week Ahead: The market is oversold, but major signs say "sell" (Yahoo Business)
Site Statistics
- Posts: 29
- Comments: 219
- Visits: 8,597
- Pageviews: 20,944
- Posts: 122
- Comments: 1253
- Visits: 39,213
- Pageviews: 95,845
Popular today
Popular this week
- Another Snapshot: Heritage Foundation tracks school privatization efforts, state-by-state
- Document dump: ALEC bills coming soon to a state legislature near you
- Happy Mother's Day!
- Jobs4TN Online
- In Black and White: Resegregation Indisputable per Annual TN Charter Schools Rpt
- Books that Inspired Movies - 99¢ until Midnight
- Verizon cuts price on Razr MAXX
TN Progressive
- BlountViews
- Cup of Joe Powell
- Left Wing Cracker
- Newscoma
- Out of the Blue
- RoaneViews
- Sean Braisted
- Southern Beale
- TN Citizen Action
- TN Talking Points
- Tiny Cat Pants
- TN Guerilla Women
- Vibinc
- View From My Kitchen Table
- WhitesCreek Journal
Nearby:
- AC Entertainment
- Agrarian Urbanite
- Blount Dems
- Bottom Line
- Craig Thomas
- Daily Pulse
- David Oatney
- Discover ET
- Domestic Psychology
- Ellen Smith
- Fletch
- Frank Murphy
- Home/Work
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jack McElroy
- Jim Stovall
- Julie Apple
- Knox Dems
- KnoxBlab
- Knoxify
- Knoxvillager
- Les Jones
- Lynn Point Records
- MamaPundit
- Michael Silence
- Mike Donila
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Mushy's Moochings
- Outdoor Knoxville
- P.E.N. Studio
- Pittman Properties
- Political Leverage
- Property Scope
- Reality Me
- Rikki Hall
- Rob Huddleston
- School Matters
- Stacey Campfield
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
- Stuck inside Knoxville
- Suzy Trotta
- Tom Humphrey
- Tri Cities
Beyond:
- Andy Axel
- Daily Docket
- Democratic Talk Radio
- Enclave
- Ginger Snaps
- Post Politics
- Quiet Life
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Ticket
- TN Trivia
- TN Women's Caucus
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South
- Lovable Liberal
- Newsrack
- Wandering Hillbilly
At large:
- Agonist
- Alterdestiny
- Atrios
- Burnt Orange Report
- Buzzflash
- College Dems
- Common Cause
- Crooks and Liars
- Daily Kos
- Democratic Strategist
- Democrats.org
- Digby's Hullabaloo
- Ezra Klein
- The Fix
- Huffington Post
- Liberal Oasis
- Media Matters
- MyDD
- Open Secrets
- Pam's House Blend
- Political Wire
- Politico
- Progressive States
- Seeing the Forest
- Skippy the Bush Kangaroo
- Suburban Guerrilla
- Talk Left
- Talking Points Memo
- Think Progress
- Truthdig
- Truthout

More context
And here's the composition by political party of each house during each era...
1935 (73rd Congress):
Senate had 59 Dems, 36 Repubs, 1 other* (composition 61% Dem)
House had 313 Dems, 117 Repubs, 5 other (composition 72% Dem)
* I don't know why only 96 Senate seats were occupied...
1965 (88th Congress):
Senate had 68 Dems, 32 Repubs (composition 68% Dem)
House had 259 Dems, 176 Repubs (composition 60% Dem)*
* It appears, then, that Politifact.com's assertion that Johnson had a "2/3 majority in the House" is slightly overstated...unless I should be looking at numbers for the 89th Congress?
Senate stats here (link...)
House stats here (link...)
More context (corrected)
OK, here's the (corrected) composition by political party of each house during each era...
1935 (73rd Congress):
Senate had 59 Dems, 36 Repubs, 1 other* (composition 61% Dem)
House had 313 Dems, 117 Repubs, 5 other (composition 72% Dem)
* 96 seats because Alaska and Hawaii weren't yet states.
1965 (89th Congress):
Senate had 68 Dems, 32 Repubs (composition 68% Dem)
House had 295 Dems, 140 Repubs (composition 68% Dem)
So the Politifact.com assertion that Johnson enjoyed a 2/3 majority in the House in 1965 is correct.
Also, my 1965 stats as to the Senate are unchanged here because I had previously given you 89th Congress stats for the Senate, but 88th Congress stats for the House.
Clearly, I hadn't drunk enough coffee prior to posting. Apologies.
Senate stats here (link...)
House stats here (link...)
I don't know why only 96
I don't know why only 96 Senate seats were occupied...
Alaska and Hawaii weren't states yet?
(Blush.)
(Blush.)
89th Congress
...and Medicare was, indeed, passed in the 89th Congress, not the 88th.
Please talk among yourselves while I continue trying to get this right. Repost forthcoming...
Realizing there were only 48
Realizing there were only 48 states when I was born makes me feel really old.
Most repubs nowadays
would vote against those bills, as well as the Fair Housing Act and the Voting Rights Act if they were up for a vote now..
The right wing of their own party would force them to..the Rush Limbaughs and Fox News that exist now that didn't exist back then.
My unspoken question
That was really my unspoken question in looking into these stats: Is the cause of this impasse on healthcare reform that Dems hold a smaller majority today than in 1935 and/or 1965, or is the impasse due to something else--like a different brand of Republican legislator today, or a different focus among today's media, or maybe just today's greater influence from lobbyists?
If you looked at those two charts indicating the political party composition in this session's Senate/House, you saw that we do hold smaller majorities in both than we did in 1935 or 1965. Today, Dems comprise just 59% of legislators in both chambers, but...is that the only reason this legislation has stalled?
health care reform
Republicans have slways been emphatically pro-business. Thus, any legislation that will ultimately hurt the bottom line for insurance companies and their CEOs will be vigorously lobbied against by those companies, and our airways will be filled with scare tactics and prophesies of doom. FOLLOW THE MONEY.
Here's a provocative question: Why are health insurance companies exempt from anti-trust laws?
Post new comment