Tue
Nov 10 2009
07:28 pm
By: R. Neal

I've been remiss in not commenting on Saturday's historic vote in the House on health care reform.

Even though I have been disappointed by Democrats in Congress, and sometimes puzzled by President Obama's tactics (or apparent lack thereof), something Obama is doing is working. He's due some major props for what may turn out to be a pretty significant accomplishment given the times and the mood of the electorate.

continued...

There hasn't been a major vote on health care reform in 44 years, since LBJ signed Medicare into law. On Saturday, the House passed a bill that, warts and and all, is the most sweeping overhaul of health insurance since 1965 (lowered expectations notwithstanding).

President Obama, coincidentally our 44th president, should get credit for making that happen. Some of it goes back to the 2006 midterms, when people finally figured out that the Bush/Cheney GOP was a fraud. But Obama's election in 2008 (also historic) appears to be waking more people up and motivating them.

And no mere mortal knows what Obama and Rahm (and probably Hillary and Bill) have been doing behind the scenes, but it appears to have worked.

The bill isn't perfect by a long shot, but if it can get past the big-PAC-money Senate weasels it will be a pretty significant step forward. No exclusions, no rescission, caps on premiums v. payouts, two to one ratio for premium adjustments for age and conditions, a (weak but baby step) public option, an exchange that might someday lead to portable insurance, and more. These are Good Things, that would never have happened on the GOP watch.

So we should give President Obama, and Speaker Pelosi, props for getting us a step closer to real reform. When it goes through it will be a major advancement for the People, on a scale not quite but almost equal for the times to Medicare. (Does anyone know any Republican who wants to ditch that program?)

Even if it doesn't happen right now and America has to wait yet another generation or two for real reforms in the form of guaranteed national health insurance or, gasp!, single payer because of Republican obstructionists who don't really care about the people who keep electing them, Saturday's vote says we're getting closer. I believe that we and/or our future generations can thank President Obama for that.

OK, then.

P.S. There's a whole different discussion about Obama's interesting "laid-back, hands-off, here's what I want just do it" style v. the "in-your face" style of some past presidents who some might say were more politically astute. The commonalities at this point are "triangulation." The contrast will be results, which are yet to be determined on this issue. But that's a discussion for another day after we see what happens.

rocketsquirrel's picture

I was pleased to see that

I was pleased to see that Bill Clinton was down in the Senate today giving some Senators an earful on confidence.

Amazing time we're living in. All hands are on deck on this one.

Treehouse's picture

Women under bus

But women were sacrificed to get the votes in the House. This is not ok. Women have reproductive organs that need healthcare too. Rich women have always been able to get what they need. To make a poor woman carry a dead fetus for months because insurance won't pay for abortions is not healthcare, is not fair, and is an insult to women. I remember when my insurance wouldn't pay for birth control pills. But it does pay for Viagra? Come on. I am glad to see reform moving forward but am angry at Obama and the Democrats who run over women's bodies to get it.

EricLykins's picture

That drunken late night deal

That drunken late night deal struck last Friday night will not last. Hopefully "it's a health bill, not an abortion bill" will resonate within both parties who should know that this is not the time to be opportunistic on this hot button.

As Members of Congress we believe that women should have access to a full range of reproductive health care. Health care reform must not be misused as an opportunity to restrict women’s access to reproductive health services.

The Stupak-Pitts amendment to H.R. 3962, The Affordable Healthcare for America Act, represents an unprecedented and unacceptable restriction on women’s ability to access the full range of reproductive health services to which they are lawfully entitled. We will not vote for a conference report that contains language that restricts women’s right to choose any further than current law.

Sincerely,

Rep. Diana Degette (D-CO), Rep. Jan Schakowsky (D-IL), and 40 Democratic congresswomen.

[ADD YOUR NAME HERE]

Virgil Proudfoot's picture

Gotta hand it to the Dems

Yep, these guys are really great. Obama, Pelosi, and Reid have redefined victory to include defeat: reform health care by avoiding even the consideration of Medicare for All and enshrining legally forced payment to the profit-mad inscos that are the root of the problem.

With Democrats like these, who needs Republicans?

"I used to be with it, but then they changed what it was. Now what I'm with isn't it, and what's it seems scary and weird. It'll happen to you."
—Abraham Simpson

EricLykins's picture

Blackburn (and Gordon) voted to keep Medicare

(Does anyone know any Republican who wants to ditch that program?)

Marsha Blackburn was the only Tennessee Republican to have an opportunity to vote to abolish Medicare on it's 44th anniversary when Anthony Weiner introduced this dream amendment in the Energy and Commerce committee this summer. Please thank her for defending government run, government administered, single payer health care. 37043-6362

bizgrrl's picture

No exclusions, no

No exclusions, no rescission, caps on premiums v. payouts, two to one ratio for premium adjustments for age and conditions, a (weak but baby step) public option, an exchange that might someday lead to portable insurance, and more. These are Good Things,

Yes, these are Good Things! These are very important changes. I am actually building up some excitement in anticipation of these changes in health insurance.

I wanted Medicare for all, but for the life of me I cannot figure out how it would get passed. Anyone know what Obama could do to have an LBJ moment?

Did you know? There is a lifetime penalty (10% per year) imposed for not enrolling in [Medicare] Part B [Medical insurance] unless actively working.

Did you know? All Medicare Part B [Medical insurance] enrollees pay an insurance premium for this coverage; the standard Part B premium for 2009 is $96.40 per month.

Did you know? Medicare has deductibles and coinsurance (20%).

Did you know? To get the best coverage you have to purchase a Medicare supplement policy, sold and administered by private companies.

WhitesCreek's picture

Odd that Stupak may bring it all down

Rambling a bit here but I continue to be outraged at conservatives using a divisive hot button issue to stall health insurance reform. Why the pseudo moral grandstanding over Federal money for abortions when not providing health insurance reform kills 40,000 adults every year? Corporations choose to kill actual living people as a cost of doing business and that's fine with conservatives under the auspice of jobs and profits, but my god we must save the zygotes.

Another problem I have with the absurdity of the abortion issue is that Federal money does not just come from conservative idealogues. I myself actually pay tens of thousands in taxes. Why does a group of Campfields get to tell my government it can't spend some of the money I gave them on Women's health issues? I might be willing to make that deal if I can tell their government it can't spend any of their money on war.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives