Submitted by bizgrrl on Mon, 2009/11/09 - 4:01pm

A report from Transportation for America (T4America) and the Surface Transportation Policy Partnership "ranks metropolitan areas based on the relative danger of walking."

Knoxville has a Pedestrian Danger Index (PDI) of 54.5. This is a pretty good ranking considering the most dangerous metro area for walking (Orlando, FL, my Orlando) has a PDI of 221.5. Knoxville should be pretty safe considering it is in the top 15 metro areas for average yearly Federal transportation dollars spent on pedestrian safety per person ($4.48 per person).

T4America and STPP hosted a conference call today regarding the new report. Some of the information resulting from the call include: 20% of pedestrian fatalities are on interstates (where pedestrians are not allowed), there is always more to do, and it is not an urban, rural or suburban issue (in response to a caller from Montana).

One possible flaw in the report, it did not take in to consideration the age of the driver. A caller from Florida wanted to know if an aging population of drivers might affect the PDI (Florida has the top 4 most dangerous metro areas for pedestrians). The hosts had no answer to the question.

Major factor concerning pedestrian fatalities: speed. Slow down people!

88
vote
R. Neal's picture

One possible flaw in the

One possible flaw in the report, it did not take in to consideration the age of the driver.

Another possible flaw, did it take into account the age of the pedestrian? There are a lot of seniors out there on the sidewalks (some who can't drive and others who just prefer to walk) who are sometimes off the sidewalks where there aren't any.

As I recall, just yesterday we were driving east on the notoriously narrow Kingston Pike near Sequoya Hills, and had to slow down and maneuver halfway over into the left lane to avoid an older couple walking along the right side of Kingston Pike where there were no sidewalks (prompting middle fingers from people behind us and in the left lane).

bizgrrl's picture

Another possible flaw, did

Another possible flaw, did it take into account the age of the pedestrian?

Actually they did discuss that in the conference call. One of the hosts said being older was not really a factor in pedestrian fatalities.

lovable liberal's picture

Florida has lots of

Florida has lots of multi-lane surface roads that look like deathtraps for anyone trying to cross them.

Liberty and justice for all.

My home

Brian A.'s picture

computing the rate of

computing the rate of pedestrian deaths relative to the amount of walking residents do on average.

I'm curious how they estimate the latter.

On its face, Knoxville doesn't strike me as a particularly safe/friendly place to walk (not that I've done any research on it). Some areas are OK, but others aren't. Sidewalk construction/maintenance often seems like an afterthought.

Brian A.
I'd rather be cycling.

bizgrrl's picture

One thing, I think, that

One thing, I think, that skews Knoxville's numbers is that UT is probably included, thus a lot more walking going on around campus.

StaceyDiamond's picture

OK

I'd say Knoxville is an OK place to walk, could be better, could be worse. Downtown and surrounding neighborhoods and greenways are good, Broadway is not and Cumberland is not. Also, city of Maryville has an emerging downtown but you can tell people drive through it like they are not used to walkers. Its unforntunate walking is still sort of an anomaly though, people think its strange or think its dangerous in places where it isn't.

bizgrrl's picture

Maryville has an emerging

Maryville has an emerging downtown but you can tell people drive through it like they are not used to walkers

That is interesting. However, it is also interesting that most drivers through downtown Maryville see the crosswalks (without stop lights) and actually stop to let people cross.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is used to make sure you are a human visitor and to prevent spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

Shortcuts


Upcoming events:

User login

Blog-O-Rama

Media Blogs

Local Paper

TV News

Wire Reports



TN Progressive All-Stars

Nearby:

Beyond:

At large:

Government:

Media: