Mon
Nov 9 2009
01:45 pm

How does one go about getting a referendum item on a ballot in Knox County? I know that it requires collecting signatures, but how many, and where is the necessary paperwork filed?

We need to get rid of these traffic cameras, which are sucking funds out of taxpayers' pockets and moving the cash into the accounts of the companies that run the cameras and the politicians who are bribed by them, I mean whose campaigns are funded by them.

ShannonSz's picture

yep...have to agree, got my

yep...have to agree, got my first ticket in thirty years from the one on the broadway off ramp.

when I saw red light on the envelope, thought I was being blamed for doing something else illegal.

well this will only happen once and at least it did not do any damge to my driving record, but it certainly was not a 'real' violation just based on my careful driving record....and that was a driving record from one coast to the other.

Rachel's picture

This again. Don't like red

This again. Don't like red light cameras - don't run a red light (and I say that as someone who got a ticket from a red light camera - a ticket I deserved, as I was trying to beat the light at Kingston Pike and Papermill and knew I had failed).

ShannonSz's picture

I would feel worse if it

I would feel worse if it effected my driving record, but it does not.

I agree, but the one I was cited for was on a right hand turn in a right hand turn lane. I am still confused as to if a stop and go is allowed here. I think I just rolled at the right hand turn instead of making a complete stop. In Calif it is called a 'California roll'

I do feel running a red light in an intersection is not quite the same.

Rachel's picture

I got a ticket once for

I got a ticket once for coming to a rolling stop at a stop sign, so I symphatize.

OTOH, it's only legal to turn right on red if you come to a full stop first. I've got no problem with that being enforced - I've seen far too many instances of people breezing right through w/o paying much attention to traffic conditions.

Come to a full stop at red lights - which is the law - and you've got no problem. Fussing about the cameras is fussing at the thing that captures illegal behavior, not at the illegal behavior itself.

Referenda cost a ton of $$$ - no way I'd support one because people thought they should be able to disobey the law.

reform4's picture

My problem

is that they changed the law for red light runs so that you no longer get points on your license (to allow for the privatization aspects).

End result? If I have $500, I can run 10 red lights, and they're ain't f**kall you can do about it.

If I have $50,000, I can run 1,000 red lights, and you can't legally stop me.

To me, that's just stupid, if you're concerned about safety.

Democracy means we get to vote on how we wish to be governed. I'd happily sign a petition to see this put on the ballot. And I'm all for public safety, I just want it to be smart.

R. Neal's picture

Yellow means stop. Red means

Yellow means stop. Red means do not go. Green means proceed.

ShannonSz's picture

I get my license renewed for

I get my license renewed for some five or seven years by mail so it has been a long time since I reviewed the rules....and in fact never took tests the sixteen years I have been in Tennessee. Can you proceed after stopping at the red arrow for a right hand turn?

Help me with this....I just stop now and wait for it to turn and hope someone is in front of me stopping so I don't need to deal with a horn honker.

Appreciate your response on this one....thanks

and the way the envelope is posted in bold letters as 'red light violation' is still funny to me. I thought it was a joke or a bazzar add for something. Glad I opened it.

Virgil Proudfoot's picture

That's up to interpretation.

"Yellow means stop. Red means do not go. Green means proceed."

A friend of mine came to a complete stop at a red light, looked both ways, and then turned. This cost him fifty American dollars.

He tried to fight it, but the clerk told him that, even though he thought he came to a complete stop, and any policeman present would have agreed, the computer didn't register it as a complete stop, so he had to pay the ticket.

Isn't this how Sky Net got started?

"I used to be with it, but then they changed what it was. Now what I'm with isn't it, and what's it seems scary and weird. It'll happen to you."
—Abraham Simpson

ShannonSz's picture

that was kinda what happened

that was kinda what happened to me and I am still confused as to if I can go right at the red arrow after stopping or not. I did not just barrel forward, but stopped, went out far enough to make sure it was clear, then made a right hand turn....now I am wondering if the right hand turn is allowd and will just wait to make sure I am not ticketed again.

bizgrrl's picture

I believe you can make right

I believe you can make right hand turns on red in the Knoxville area. You do have to come to a complete stop before turning. I wonder if the camera gets confused if you stop completely, then slowly edge forward to see if it is clear then turn without coming to a second complete stop.

Now, there are signs at selected intersections that say no right turn on red. In these instances I suppose it could be possible that by the time you get to the intersection, preparing to turn right, you might not be able to see the sign.

Hayduke's picture

I turn right on red (after a

I turn right on red (after a full stop) from Summit to Broadway fairly frequently without triggering the cameras. The financial arrangement is a lousy deal for the taxpayers, but I don't have any problem with more tickets for running red lights. Can they be configured to enforce turn signals as well?

Greg Mackay's picture

Section 709 of the City of Knoxville Charter

709. Initiative and referendum.
(A) Any proposed ordinance may be submitted to the council signed by qualified voters equal in number to the percentage hereinafter required. The signers, verifications, authentications, inspections, certification, amendment and submission of such petition shall be the same as provided for petitions under section 708.
(B) If the petition accompanying the proposed ordinance is signed by registered voters equal in number to thirty (30) percent of the total votes cast for all candidates for mayor in the last election and contains the request that the ordinance be submitted to a vote of the people if not passed by the council, the council shall either:
(1) Pass the ordinance without alteration within thirty (30) days after the attachment of the certificate of the election commission to the accompanying petition; or
(2) Immediately after expiration of thirty (30) days, the council shall call a special election, unless a regular election is fixed within six (6) months, and at such election, the ordinance shall be submitted without alteration to the vote of the people. The ballots used when voting upon said ordinance shall contain these words: "For the Ordinance" (stating the nature of the proposed ordinance); "Against the Ordinance" (stating the nature of the proposed ordinance).
If a majority vote in favor, the ordinance shall become a binding ordinance, and any ordinance proposed by petition, or which shall be adopted by a vote of the people cannot be repealed or amended, except by vote of the people.
(C) Any number of proposed ordinances may be voted upon at the same election in accordance with the provisions of this section; but there shall not be more than one (1) special election in any period of six (6) months for such purpose.
(D) The same procedures for petition and elections shall apply to any regular ordinance passed by the council which any group of qualified voters desires to have brought to a vote of the people.
(E) Whenever any ordinance or proposition is required by this section to be submitted to the voters at any election, the recorder shall cause the ordinance or resolution to be published in the daily newspaper of general circulation in the county, the publication to be not more than twenty (20) nor less than five (5) days before the submission of the proposition or ordinance to be voted on.
(F) Any initiative that would amend any provision of this charter that relates to pensions shall comply with the requirements of section 1355.

Virgil Proudfoot's picture

Thanks, Greg!

You're the only one who answered my question. Thanks again!

You know, if a convicted child molester ran for any local office on the platform of getting rid of these cameras, he'd be elected in a landslide.

Why don't I see anyone doing it?

"I used to be with it, but then they changed what it was. Now what I'm with isn't it, and what's it seems scary and weird. It'll happen to you."
—Abraham Simpson

Rachel's picture

You know, if a convicted

You know, if a convicted child molester ran for any local office on the platform of getting rid of these cameras, he'd be elected in a landslide.

Why don't I see anyone doing it?

Maybe because they think there are more important issues facing Knoxville?

bizgrrl's picture

If the petition accompanying

If the petition accompanying the proposed ordinance is signed by registered voters equal in number to thirty (30) percent of the total votes cast for all candidates for mayor in the last election and contains the request that the ordinance be submitted to a vote of the people if not passed by the council, the council shall either:

If I am correct, it would appear now would be the time to do this referendum since there was such a large voter turnout for the last city mayor election, half the turnout as the previous election. Less than 2,000 signatures would be needed.

Nelle's picture

My ballot initiative

I would support a ballot referendum requiring everyone not to drive like a maniac.

As in, obey the speed limit, drive appropriately for road conditions, put down the damn phone, slow down for yellow, stop for red, let other drivers merge, yield the right of way to pedestrians where you should, watch out for bicyclists and motorcyclists, be on the lookout for kids, be patient with older drivers/pedestrians -- really crazy stuff like that.

Who's with me?

Anonymously Nine's picture

Stop, wait two full seconds,

Stop, wait two full seconds, turn right, no ticket. I do not understand why it takes two seconds, but I imagine it is a camera thing.

ShannonSz's picture

thanks....I honestly did not

thanks....I honestly did not know. I'll wait five to make sure next time

Mike Cohen's picture

Traffic light cameras

The cameras have had one real affect on me: I now stop when a light turns yellow instead of racing through the intersection. that's probably a good thing.

Interesting that the GPS companies (at least TomTom, since that's the unit I have-but I assume they all have) put in software so that when I approach an intersection with a camera my unit beeps and flashes a picture as a warning. Of course just driving around town I never have the GPS in the car and on anyway.

michael kaplan's picture

that's probably the best

that's probably the best reason i've heard to buy a GPS unit. the savings from one $50 fine would probably pay for the box.

Hayduke's picture

Of you could just stop at

Of you could just stop at all the lights for free.

Rachel's picture

Apparently, this is too

Apparently, this is too complicated.

michael kaplan's picture

easier and cheaper to just

easier and cheaper to just vote them out of office.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives