Wed
May 31 2006
11:19 am
By: R. Neal

Man, WATE is catching a lot of heat for their story about the Knox Co. Sheriff's Dept. and Sheriff Tim personally taking overtime pay from FEMA during the Katrina rescue effort.

Betty Bean has this scathing commentary, and commenters at Gene Patterson's blog are hammering him here, here and here.

What do you think?

Rachel's picture

I think WATE has gone

I think WATE has gone overboard with the sensational journalism stuff lately.  I have no doubt they chose to present Shurf Tim in the worst possible light.

That said, it's not difficult to present him in a bad light.  He's an arrogant SOB who thinks he answers to no one.

If I understood correctly, he was paid his county salary while "volunteering" on the Gulf Coast.  He also had to request the pay from FEMA (contrary to his story that FEMA forced him to accept it).  I believe that he was uncomfortable while working on the Coast, but it bothers me that he got paid twice for what was publicized as "volunteer" work, done while he wasn't available to do his primary job here at home.

A real volunteer wouldn't have asked for the FEMA money, or would have donated it to the rebuilding effort.  And a real public servant would actually talk to the media, whether or not he likes them.

 

Drake's picture

Gene seemed genuinely

Gene seemed genuinely shocked that folks think he has an agenda because he worked for Mayor Ashe. Far or not, I think people will be skeptical of media types that dally with the gubmint. It happens at all levels of gubmint too.

Oren Incandenza's picture

So many analogies...

Local TeeVee News versus His Holiness Hutchison -- talk about a race to the bottom.  It reminds me of when the "rock band" Great White burned up that nightclub in Rhode Island and everything came down to a choice between believing the club owners or the band's promoters -- two groups not normally noted for their honesty or professionalism.  Similarly, picking sides here is like choosing between J.R. Ewing and Cliff Barnes, or two one-legged men in an ass-kicking contest.  This is the result when both sides are weak and ugly.

Gene's picture

I've been called ugly

I've been called ugly before, but never "weak" and ugly.  ha.

Oren, you should watch more local news.  You might be surprised that there is some good work going on there.  Not always, but from time to time a story pops up that might interest or impact you.

As for this story, when an elected official (in this case the Sheriff), in an official capacity, personally profits from the action, that is - at the very least - the "appearance" of a conflict of interest.  

We did not suggest he did anything wrong, but certainly the appearance of what he did was worth the public knowing. 

 

 

 

 

redmondkr's picture

Well put, Oren. nill

Well put, Oren. 

nill illigitimi carborundum

Hildegard's picture

Yeah, what bothers me about

Yeah, what bothers me about this WATE thing is the effect it has of making Hutchison look good. It's like they're saying, "Wow, that scumbag helped desperate people in the wake of the worst natural disaster in US history! And got PAID for it!" The fact that he got a FEMA check seems more like the kind of news that merits a snicker in MP's Ear to the Ground or Sandra Clark's column (although Sandra would be more likely to excoriate FEMA for not sending him a medal and a free helicopter in addition to the ten grand). Whatever terrible injustice WATE has done to this bold Aryan hero, and that WATE has committed in league with the vast, anti-Hutchison conspiracy infecting all major media in the Greater Knoxville area, it must comfort him that he can always rely on his cheerleading squad at the Halls Shopper.

Joe P.'s picture

this is fun!

hey R. Neal, thanks for the links to this hoo-ha. fun to read the back and forth of "journalists" like Patterson and Walker J.

and somewhere in the hoo-ha is a story - not sure if it's news, but it qualifies as entertaining reading! 

 

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives