Earlier today, WATE reported TVA as saying the toxic sludge that wiped out a Roane Co. community when a retaining pond dike failed contained no hazardous materials, which is not exactly accurate. The News Sentinel later reported that it contains "heavy metals," without elaborating.
Just now, Fox 43 local news (which I believe is produced by WATE) said that residents in the affected area should boil their drinking water. They didn't say why.
As I understand it, boiling water is only effective if there is a bacterial or viral contamination. Boiling water is the last thing you want to do in the case of toxic waste contamination, because all it does is increase the concentration of toxic materials in the contaminated water.
Does anyone know why area residents are being told to boil their water, or who is advising this? Has the toxic sludge contaminated ground water and local water supplies? Has it cause some disruption of water treatment resulting in higher levels of bacteria? The news report didn't say.
Anyway, I don't know which is worse - TVA misleading the public about the hazard, other unknown officials giving out bad information, or local media blindly accepting it and passing it on without explanation or even bothering to question or google it.
I realize local news operations are operating on a shoestring budget, but maybe they should just not report anything at all if what they report is misleading or potentially makes the situation worse than it already is.
|
|
Discussing:
- Trump: U.S. takeover of Gaza Strip, "Riviera of the Middle East" (3 replies)
- Gay Street Bridge will never reopen to vehicular traffic (3 replies)
- 22 states sue over Medical Research Funding (NIH) (3 replies)
- Rep. Barnyard Tim after the UTK furries? (1 reply)
- U.S. Treasury Dept. data breach? (2 replies)
- 19 (was 13) states to sue over Treasury data breach (2 replies)
- Hail, Caesar! (1 reply)
- Let them eat cake... (2 replies)
- How an arcane Treasury Department office became ground zero in the war over federal spending (6 replies)
- TN Voucher bill contracts with Arkansas reject (1 reply)
- Are Meta/Zuckerberg paying a bribe? (3 replies)
- Plane crash in the Potomac (3 replies)
TN Progressive
- Do Not Listen to Deranged Fascists Who Can Barely Read (RoaneViews)
- Must Read (RoaneViews)
- It's Time to Call For the Arrest of Elon Musk! (RoaneViews)
- Books (RoaneViews)
- (Whitescreek Journal)
- Lee's Fried Chicken in Alcoa closed (BlountViews)
- Alcoa, Hall Rd. Corridor Study meeting, July 30, 2024 (BlountViews)
- My choices in the August election (Left Wing Cracker)
- July 4, 2024 - aka The Twilight Zone (Joe Powell)
- Chef steals food to serve at restaurant? (BlountViews)
- Blount County, TDOT make road deal for gun mfg ignoring town of Louisville,TN, (BlountViews)
- Winter at the Big Rocks (Whitescreek Journal)
TN Politics
- Tennessee Sen. Becky Massey’s bad day (TN Lookout)
- Federal freeze includes $156M solar power program for low-income Tennessee households (TN Lookout)
- Tennessee Gov. names mix of officials, utilities and conservationists to Duck River advisory group (TN Lookout)
- Stockard on the Stump: Sexton and bail bond industry headed for collision (TN Lookout)
- Pain clinics made millions from ‘unnecessary’ injections into ‘human pin cushions’ (TN Lookout)
- Republican Senator says immigrant students won’t be blocked from public schools in Florida (TN Lookout)
Knox TN Today
- Football Vols will go as far as Nico takes them (Knox TN Today)
- Presidents’ Day in review of National Random Acts of Kindness Day (Knox TN Today)
- Public trust in physicians: Apology and explanation (Knox TN Today)
- HEADLINES: 2/17 (Knox TN Today)
- Karen Weekly speaks to KBA +++ (Knox TN Today)
- Covenant Health is leader in cardiac care (Knox TN Today)
- Barnes beat Vandy with halftime talk; Ziggy helped (Knox TN Today)
- Lady Vols secure much-needed SEC win (Knox TN Today)
- Book now to vacation at a TN state park (Knox TN Today)
- HEADLINES: 2/14 (Knox TN Today)
- Tom Harrington hikes Porters Creek: Finds February wildflowers (Knox TN Today)
- Coughing and Nikki Giovanni (Knox TN Today)
Local TV News
- Kentucky State Parks offers lodging to flood victims (WATE)
- East Tennessee roads closed due to flooding, storm damage (WATE)
- Church distributes food boxes to those in need following EF2 tornado in Morgan County (WATE)
- Police: Missing woman last seen leaving Home Depot in Morristown found safe (WATE)
- 'Like lightning striking twice' | Siblings share same rare congenital heart defect (WBIR)
- TDOT awards contracts for Greene, Washington County bridge rebuilds (WATE)
- 'I want to give that sense of Dolly to the world' | A Newport woman was named a finalist in the 'Search for Dolly' (WBIR)
- 'We want people to come up and meet us' | KPD training horses and officers on its mounted patrol unit (WBIR)
- Making memories: Couple reflects on 57 years of marriage despite wife's memories being stolen by encephalitis (WBIR)
- Tennessee lawmaker revives bill that would make written driving exams English-only (WBIR)
- Knox County planning to buy fire-plagued Fort Loudon Waste and Recycling in North Knoxville (WBIR)
- Knox County Schools names new chief of security after national search (WATE)
News Sentinel
State News
- Opinion: For a change, let’s get rid of our change - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Opinion: Signposts on the road to authoritarian rule - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Pay attention! Democracy in peril and more letters to the editors - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Shavin: My terrible, horrible, no good, very bad idea - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
Wire Reports
- Asia-Pacific markets mostly rise; Tencent shares at highest in over three years - CNBC (Business)
- Xi Jinping meets China’s tech titans including Alibaba’s Jack Ma - Financial Times (Business)
- Asia shares cautiously higher, yen buoyed by upbeat GDP - Reuters (Business)
- ‘Total shock’: Some federal employees dismissed just before ending probation - WTOP (US News)
- DFW Weather: North Texas should prepare for dangerous cold this week - WFAA.com (US News)
- Trump administration turns to US Supreme Court in bid to fire agency head - Reuters (US News)
- We've finally cracked why egg prices are really rising... bird flu is only a shell of the truth - Daily Mail (Business)
- Chance for wintry mix in the Piedmont Triad next week - WGHP FOX8 Greensboro (US News)
- U.S.-Russia meeting on Ukraine war expected on Tuesday, sources say - Axios (US News)
- Exclusive: Five Iraqi banks to be banned from US dollar transactions - Reuters (Business)
- Justice Department's independence is threatened as Trump's team asserts power over cases and staff - The Associated Press (US News)
- Investigators find 3rd victim from fiery Wyoming highway tunnel crash - Hindustan Times (US News)
- Severe flooding in Kentucky claims nine lives, prompts federal disaster declaration - Turn to 10 (US News)
- MAGA influencer Ashley St Clair claims Elon Musk is father of her child - KEPR 19 (Business)
- ‘Trump trades’ like the dollar and bitcoin are stalling, while Chinese stocks are racing ahead - MarketWatch (Business)
Local Media
Lost Medicaid Funding
Search and Archives
TN Progressive
Nearby:
- Blount Dems
- Herston TN Family Law
- Inside of Knoxville
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jim Stovall
- Knox Dems
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Outdoor Knoxville
- Pittman Properties
- Reality Me
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
Beyond:
- Nashville Scene
- Nashville Post
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Journal
- TN Lookout
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South
Boiling water?
What strange advice. Won't matter. Might make things a whole lot worse. The advice given is bizarre.
This is a new level in local reporting. Or omission. This is a journalistic event locally. Did we just quietly tilt into the realm where PR replaced reporting?
Not really sure but I
Not really sure but I believe the sludge contains a mild sulfuric acid or maybe lye. The sludge ponds contain fly ash from the burnt coal. I don't think I would drink it even after boiling it, but some old timers could use it for making lye soap.
Boiling water does seem like
Boiling water does seem like strange advice. Did they say who these residents are who should be doing this? The failure seems to be downstream of any likely water intake, except that the rupture looks like it happened on the uphill side of the retention pond, and the sludge actually flowed up a length of Swan Pond Creek. It may be that the force of the water and ash caused local seismic events that muddied well water, but not necessarily with sludge.
Anyway, this is a serious mess. It completely buried the mouth of Swan Pond Creek and polluted the last stretch of the Emory River where it is inundated behind Watts Bar Dam. Swan Pond Creek could potentially back up when it next rains, and if it does not, it will be transporting more ash into Watts Bar Lake. That impoundment already collects silt from Oak Ridge, so it's hardly pristine to begin with.
That retention pond seems awfully large, like it may have outgrown its capacity. The sludge was likely saturated from the recent rains, then freezing caused the exposed earthen bank to crust up and wick water toward it, and the expansion weakened it, setting the stage for a crack to become catastrophe. I wonder whether TVA expanded the pond instead of dredging it and transporting ash off site.
Boiling water does seem like
Boiling water does seem like strange advice. Did they say who these residents are who should be doing this?
I believe the reference was to folks in the area with well water. I didn't really understand it either.
Some more info posted over
Some more info posted over at RoaneViews that might provide a clue re. the water situation:
If I read some of the other comments correctly, some people are using untreated spring water and well water.
This still doesn't explain the "boil your water" advice or where it's coming from.
Our newsroom got a call from
Our newsroom got a call from Roane County EMA (I think) last night around 7:15. They asked us to get the word out that anyone who gets their water from the gravity-fed spring in the Swan Pond area should boil their water until further notice. When asked if the sewage had ruptured and contaminated the drinking water, EMA said it's not about the sewage, but rather out of concern for the chemicals in the ash mixture (See Randy's earlier post with link to info about ash).
Earlier in the day Monday, TVA CEO Tom Kilgore said in a news conference that there was concern about the level of chemicals in the sludge and that TVA will be testing the water in a nearby river where there is a water intake site.
So, suffice it to say that TVA admits that there are chemicals of concern in the mixture, and the water should be boiled because there are people who get their water from a spring in the area that may be contaminated or at risk of contamination.
Clear as mud?
Thanks for that info,
Thanks for that info, Michael. If there are concerns about toxins, then boiling water won't do anything except make it worse. You could probably find someone over at UT to explain that to your viewers (and to TVA and public officials).
I see WBIR is also advising
I see WBIR is also advising people to boil their water. From the dead fish report mentioned in another post:
This is what happens to media when they just rewrite pressers
and other spin sheets from the phalanx of spin shops and pr flacks in our community, they get all dumbed down and their idea of newsgathering is calling a spokesperson for comment.
Why does no one bother to contact people who are familiar with the construction and monitoring of earthen dams, the Army Corp. of Engineers would be a good start, they took a butt whipping in Katrina and they know what causes water to burst through all types of materials. Also, EPA and TDEC would have a comment on fly ash and what it is and what its properties are and any assorted dangers which may flow from it, why would it be kept in a water pond anyway?
TVA owns or manages most of the waterways being polluted by the Ash such that it's probably not newsgathering to continue to stick a mike in the face of Gil Francis or any of the rest of the TVA honchos, even if they will speak.
Wonder if the same guys monitoring the earthen dams are the guys monitoring radiation levels at the TVA nuclear facilities.
why would it be kept in a
why would it be kept in a water pond anyway?
It's probably more accurate to think of it as an evaporation pond. Take a look at the aerial video TVA released. It's 12 minutes long and worth a hell of a lot more than what has come out of Gil Francis' mouth. You can see the solid bank of ash left behind by the collapse and get a fair idea of how that retention area worked. They probably slurry the ash to control dust then let it air dry.
TVA is now saying it was an 80-acre basin that held 2.6 million cubic yards of ash and was one of three on site. Comparing the video with the low-res satellite image at Google Maps makes me wonder whether an upper pond collapsed into a lower pond, which then collapsed into the inundated mouth of Swan Pond Creek, but I'm speculating based on before/after images with the before image being lousy and undated.
Past is
Past is prelude:
(link...)
(link...)
(link...)
(link...)
There'll be a lot of denials of harm until the eventual fines and settlements are reached.
____________________________
Dirty deeds done dirt cheap! Special holidays, Sundays and rates!
Remember a corporation is a
Yuh huh. And TVA counts on that very fact, given the behavior of their peers/suppliers... (link...)
____________________________
Dirty deeds done dirt cheap! Special holidays, Sundays and rates!
Those are all coal slurry
Those are all coal slurry disasters, right? Those seem to occur more often that containment pond breaches at power plants. They are probably even less regulated, coming under the Office of Surface Mining regulation or some other even worse sold-out agency.
Not sure which is worse - coal slurry or fly ash sludge. I'm still trying to find an example of a fly ash containment pond failure, what damage it caused, the cleanup involved, etc.
Can't find one yet, but I'm still looking.
Regardless, those are previews of the policy and legal battles that will play out over the next few years.
Those are all coal slurry
Sure. But in both instances, you take bulk solid contaminants of similar composition, add water, sluice them into a pit, and thereby "manage" the tailings. How TVA could fail to draw the parallel would be breathtakingly irresponsible.
(Ash is probably worse; the unusable gunk left over after combustion is probably more concentrated - all that usable and stable carbon having been incinerated - and friable than the raw stuff.)
____________________________
Dirty deeds done dirt cheap! Special holidays, Sundays and rates!
Ash is probably worse You
Ash is probably worse
You are comparing ash to coal. Sludge at mine sites is something else entirely. Tailings and spoil are mostly the rock surrounding the coal seam that had to be worked through to get at the coal, plus coal residues too fine to be useful. Pulverized rock can be quite acidic when mixed with water.
At metal mines, spoil ponds often contain solvents used to separate ore from rock, so they can contain seriously corrosive stuff. I think coal mining is more of a physical than chemical process, however, so coal slurry is probably less toxic than slurry from other types of mines. Still, I'm thinking it is worse than ash.
Arsenic and selenium and nickel are fairly inert and only problematic in high concentrations. The immediate impacts of an ash slide versus a mine waste slide are comparable, but the mine waste probably keeps polluting for a lot longer.
Drink the Water?
I wouldn't drink that water even if it was boiled. This is insane. Some agency should bring safe water to these people. Some agency should test the water today and let the people know what is in it.
Makes NRR look small time.
Boiling water would only
Boiling water would only reduce biological agents - microorganisms. Does nothing to reduce heavy metal contamination, dissolved solids, etc.
Reverse osmosis or activated carbon would be more effective reductors of these agents, in case anyone is interested. But those are expensive and TVA wouldn't want to have to admit anything looking like "fault."
____________________________
Dirty deeds done dirt cheap! Special holidays, Sundays and rates!
Or
Proper distillation would work.
"When the going gets weird, the weird turn pro."
Hunter S. Thompson
But those are expensive and
But those are expensive and TVA wouldn't want to have to admit anything looking like "fault."
This reminds me of the Coster Shop dumping fiasco. The TDEC folks were explaining all the various solvents and metals that had been detected in well water, stuff you obviously shouldn't drink if you know what it is, but when it came to simple facts in simple language -- can we drink our water? -- City Attorney Michael Kelley stepped in to obfuscate, call the results preliminary and insist that no certain proof that the water was harmful existed. It was obvious that his main concern was saving the city the expense of providing water to the impacted population (who lived outside city limits).