Eric Schaeffer, director, Environmental Integrity Project: "We now have the full picture about coal dump sites across America and it is not pretty."
According to the report, "The EPA's data shows that the disposal of coal ash, especially in unlined ponds, results in alarmingly high risks of cancer and diseases of the heart, lung, liver, stomach and other organs and can seriously harm aquatic ecosystems and wildlife near disposal sites.
"These risks are driven by exposure to toxic metals that leach from groundwater into drinking water, surface waters and sediment. Power industry lobbyists would rather keep the public in the dark about the risk from coal ash disposal; it's up to EPA to turn the lights on and regulate these hazards.
"Even as recently as December 2008, after the 1 billion gallon spill from its Kingston Power Plant, the Tennessee Valley Authority claimed that the coal ash posed little risk to human health or the environment. The EPA data we are releasing today brings the real threats to light."
Press release with links after the jump...
continued...
Joint press release from the Environmental Integrity Project and EarthJustice:
DATA SHOWING SIGNIFICANTLY HIGHER CANCER RISKS FOR U.S. RESIDENTS NEAR COAL-FIRED POWER PLANT ASH DUMP SITES WERE HIDDEN FOR YEARS BY BUSH ADMINISTRATION
Underlying 2002 EPA Risk Screening Report Only Released in 2009 After Obama Administration Took Power; Five or More High-Risk Sites Found in 21 States: NC, IN, IL, OH, GA, KY, TN, TX, AL, IA, MI, SC, WV, WI, WY, KS, LA, MD, ND, OK and PA.
The Bush Administration dragged its feet for more than five years from 2002-2007 on what it now turns out was only the partial release of Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) data showing a disturbingly high cancer risk for up to one out of every 50 Americans living near more than 200 landfills and wet ponds used to dispose of ash and scrubber sludge from coal-fired power plants across the United States, according to a new analysis from the Environmental Integrity Project (EIP) and Earthjustice. Each year, coal-fired power plants dispose of nearly 100 million tons of toxic fly ash, bottom ash, and scrubber sludge in landfills and wet ponds, such as the one that burst in Kingston, TN., in December 2008.
During the Bush Administration, the EPA made a concerted effort to delay the release of the information about cancer, non-cancer and general environmental risks. Partial disclosure of the coal ash dump site risks was delayed from 2002-2007, with the full picture not coming to light until an underlying 2002 EPA risk screening report was finally made public on March 4, 2009 - seven years after its internal EPA publication. (The 2002 risk screening report pointed to risks associated with the toxic metal selenium, which were omitted from the draft EPA risk assessment issued in 2007.) The 2007 EPA risk assessment came only after substantial delays and Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) pressure, which had resulted in the blacking out of key sections of earlier EPA documents. (See "Timeline" section of this news release.)
What was the Bush Administration EPA hiding? The new analysis from EIP and Earthjustice zeroes in on 100 landfills and 110 surface impoundments examined by the EPA that lack effective synthetic liners to prevent leaks, since the EPA found unlined and clay-lined waste units present far greater risks to both human health and ecosystems.
According to the EIP/Earthjustice analysis of the EPA data, there are high-risk coal ash dump sites in at least three dozen states, with 21 states playing home to five or more such sites: North Carolina (17); Indiana (15); Illinois (14); Ohio (12); Georgia (11); Kentucky (11); Tennessee (11); Texas (10); Alabama (9); Iowa (7); Michigan (7); South Carolina (7); West Virginia (7); Wisconsin (7); Wyoming (6); Kansas (5); Louisiana (5); Maryland (5); North Dakota (5); Oklahoma (5); and Pennsylvania (5). A complete list of these unlined or clay-lined waste disposal units can be found at (link...).
Titled "Coming Clean: What EPA Knows About the Dangers of Coal Ash," the Environmental Integrity Project/Earthjustice report notes: "Can living next to one of these dumpsites increase your risk of getting cancer or other diseases? The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) thinks so, especially if you live near one of those wet ash ponds, or surface impoundments, that dot the landscape near large coal plants, the pond has no protective liner, and you get your drinking water from a well . (N)earby residents have as much as a 1 in 50 chance of getting cancer from drinking water contaminated by arsenic, one of the most common, and most dangerous, pollutants from coal ash. And that's not all. That same risk assessment says that living near ash ponds increases the risk of damage to the liver, kidney, lungs and other organs as a result of being exposed to toxic metals like cadmium, cobalt, lead, and other pollutants at concentrations far above levels that are considered safe. In addition, the danger to wildlife and ecosystems is simply off the charts, with one contaminant-boron-expected to leach into the environment at levels two thousand times thresholds generally considered to be safe."
Eric Schaeffer, director, Environmental Integrity Project, said: "We now have the full picture about coal dump sites across America and it is not pretty. The EPA's data shows that the disposal of coal ash, especially in unlined ponds, results in alarmingly high risks of cancer and diseases of the heart, lung, liver, stomach and other organs and can seriously harm aquatic ecosystems and wildlife near disposal sites. These risks are driven by exposure to toxic metals that leach from groundwater into drinking water, surface waters and sediment. Power industry lobbyists would rather keep the public in the dark about the risk from coal ash disposal; it's up to EPA to turn the lights on and regulate these hazards. Even as recently as December 2008, after the 1 billion gallon spill from its Kingston Power Plant, the Tennessee Valley Authority claimed that the coal ash posed little risk to human health or the environment. The EPA data we are releasing today brings the real threats to light."
Lisa Evans, attorney, Earthjustice, said: "Given what the Agency already knows, coal ash ponds must be phased out-and cleaned out-within five years, to keep their toxic cargo from building up and jeopardizing the health of nearby residents, poisoning wildlife, and contaminating rivers and streams. So called "dry landfills"-especially those that are unlined-also pose unacceptable risks, and ought to be regulated as hazardous waste disposal sites. The EPA's risk assessment clearly establishes that unlined coal ash disposal sites-wet and dry-are hazardous to human health and the environment. We hope the new leadership at the EPA will act on that knowledge before further serious damage occurs to our health and environment."
KEY FINDINGS
* The problem may be twice as big as the data indicate. The number of unlined and clay-lined ash ponds and landfills currently in operation in the United States is likely to be more than double the number of units represented in the EPA survey data. In fact, industry has reported at least 427 waste ponds in response to EPA's March 2009 information request letter, exceeding by 40 percent EPA's estimate of the number of operating waste ponds, EPA does not know how many of these ponds are unlined, but, based on 1995 statistics, approximately three-quarters of these ponds lack any liners.
* The coal ash threat could linger for 100 years. Because some of the EPA data go back to the mid-1990s, it is possible that some of the listed dump sites are no longer in use. The EPA warns, however, that peak pollution from ash ponds can occur long after the waste is placed and is likely to result in peak exposures approximately 78 to 105 years after the ponds first began operation-thus "retired" sites still pose very significant threats.
* Higher cancer risk for up to 1 in 50 nearby residents. The EPA estimates that up to 1 in 50 nearby residents could get cancer from exposure to arsenic leaking into drinking water wells from unlined waste ponds that mix ash with coal refuse. Arsenic has been found to cause multiple forms of cancer, including cancer of the liver, kidney, lung, and bladder, and an increased incidence of skin cancer in populations consuming drinking water high in inorganic arsenic. Threats are also posed by unacceptable high levels of other metals, including boron, selenium and lead.
* Higher non cancer risks seen from lead and other sources. The EPA also predicts that these unlined ash ponds can increase the risk of other "non cancer" health effects, such as damage to vital organs like the liver and kidneys and, in the case of lead, damage to the central nervous system. The agency has set maximum contaminant levels ("MCLs") under the Safe Drinking Water Act to limit exposure to hazardous pollutants. But according to the EPA, unlined waste ponds that mix ash and coal refuse will result in exposures up to nine times the federal standard for lead, a deadly neurotoxin that can damage the central nervous system, especially in young children.
* Even more "eye popping" risks to aquatic ecosystems and wildlife. According to the EPA data, ash ponds are predicted to leak boron into surface waters at concentrations up to 2000 times higher than levels estimated to be safe for aquatic life (2000 times the HQ). Even landfills will release boron at levels 200 times above the HQ, or safe level, according to the EPA. Based on predicted exposures to river otters, lead from ash ponds will reach surface waters at concentrations 20 times higher than the HQ, or safe level, while arsenic and selenium concentrations will be 10 times higher. Selenium is particularly dangerous in aquatic environments because even a very small amount can rapidly attain levels that are toxic to fish and wildlife because of rapid bioaccumulation in food chains and resultant dietary exposure. Toxic metals can also be embedded in the sediment at the bottom of rivers or lakes, where they can be very difficult to remove, and poison bottom feeding plants and
fish.
For the full text of the EIP/Earthjustice report and related charts, please go to (link...) on the Web.
COAL ASH POLLUTION: THE HEALTH/ENVIRONMENTAL THREATS
* Arsenic. Ingesting arsenic, even in low doses, through drinking water or by eating fish in which arsenic has bioaccumulated, can cause nausea, vomiting, decreased production of red and white blood cells, abnormal heart rhythm, damage to blood vessels, and a sensation of 'pins and needles' in hands and feet.
* Lead. The detrimental health effects of lead are well known. No safe blood level has been identified for lead, making it one of the most toxic constituents of coal waste. Because children absorb lead more easily than adults, lead levels of 10 micrograms or more in a deciliter of blood can damage ability to learn. At blood levels greater than or equal to 25 micrograms per deciliter, lead exposure can cause damage to the kidneys, blood and nervous system. At very high levels, lead poisoning can cause mental retardation, coma, convulsions or death Lead ranks second after arsenic on the 2007 CERCLA Priority List of Hazardous Substances.
* Selenium. Short term oral exposure to high concentrations of selenium causes nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea, while chronic exposure to "mildly excessive" concentrations can lead to selenosis, a condition resulting in brittle hair, deformed nails and numbness in the limbs. Selenium causes respiratory and liver damage in animals and may affect reproduction in farm animals. Moreover, because selenium bioaccumulates in plants, farm animals are particularly susceptible to toxic effects from selenium ingestion. Selenium ranks 147th out of 275 toxic constituents on the 2007 CERCLA Priority List of Hazardous Substances.
* Boron. Exposure to large amounts of boron (about 30 grams of boric acid) over short periods of time can affect the stomach, intestines, liver, kidney and brain and can eventually lead to death. Boron can also bioaccumulate in plants, and is therefore ingested in fruits and vegetables as well as in drinking water. Boron is also known to be highly toxic to plants and algae, inhibiting growth, protein content, chlorophyll content and photosynthesis.
* Cadmium. The CDC Third National Report Spotlight on cadmium states that, "exposure to low levels of cadmium in air, food [and]. water over time may build up cadmium in the kidneys and may cause kidney disease," and that long-term effects of cadmium exposure also include fragile bones. Moreover, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services and the International Agency for Research on Cancer have determined that cadmium and cadmium compounds are known human carcinogens and EPA has determined that cadmium is a probable human carcinogen. Cadmium is listed 7th on the 2007 CERCLA Priority List of Hazardous Substances.
* Cobalt. Exposure to high levels of cobalt can result in lung and heart effects and dermatitis. Liver and kidney damage are also possible. Moreover, cobalt from CCW is especially dangerous to human health in the environment when co-disposed with coal refuse because its mobility increases under more acidic conditions. Cobalt ranks 49th on the 2007 CERCLA Priority List of Hazardous Substances.
TIMELINE
* 2002 - EPA finalizes -- but does not publicly release - a risk screening report (the precursor to a risk assessment) showing major cancer, non-cancer and environmental risks from coal ash dump sites.
* November 2006 - Freedom of Information Act request filed by Earthjustice to compel EPA to release any risk assessments for coal combustion waste that examine the potential for metals and other hazardous constituents to leach from coal combustion waste. EPA responds that the risk assessment has not been finalized.
* March 2007 - In response to a second FOIA request, EPA produced documents with key sections blacked out relating to cancer and ecological risks.
* August 2007 - EPA publishes draft risk assessment report on coal combustion waste, but omits discussion of high risk from direct contact with contaminants in waste ponds described in 2002 screening report
* March 2009 - Two months after Bush Administration leaves office, the EPA finally releases the full text of the 2002 screening report, including some risks not addressed in the 2007 draft risk assessment.
ABOUT THE GROUPS
The Environmental Integrity Project ((link...)) is a nonpartisan and nonprofit organization established in March 2002 to advocate for more effective enforcement of environmental laws. EIP was founded by Eric Schaeffer, who was director of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's Office of Regulatory Enforcement. He resigned in 2002 after publicly expressing his frustration with efforts of the Bush Administration to weaken enforcement of the Clean Air Act and other laws.
Earthjustice ((link...)) is a non-profit public interest law firm dedicated to protecting the magnificent places, natural resources, and wildlife of this earth, and to defending the right of all people to a healthy environment. Earthjustice brings about far-reaching change by enforcing and strengthening environmental laws on behalf of hundreds of organizations, coalitions and communities.
Topics:
|
|
Discussing:
- Ancient Lore Village opens in South Knoxville (3 replies)
- Dogwood Trails are open (1 reply)
- Tennessee in 4 lowest for rates of vaccinations (8 replies)
- The situation (545 replies)
- Ladder could become ‘official state tool’ of Tennessee (2 replies)
- White House report highlights Tennessee's infrastructure needs (3 replies)
- Our Coach Should Still Be Our Coach (4 replies)
- Knox County coronavirus pandemic numbers (6 replies)
- Amazon to occupy Knoxville Center Mall property (1 reply)
- Hellbender Press is back (2 replies)
- 533 million Facebook users data exposed (1 reply)
- GOP tries to seize Biden's infrastructure plans (2 replies)
TN Progressive
- Mike Mitchell Gone to Sail That Ship Across the Sea (RoaneViews)
- Friday Toons Saturday (RoaneViews)
- From Our "Republicans Want us All Dead" Dept... (RoaneViews)
- Friday Toons Saturday (RoaneViews)
- Blount County coronavirus pandemic numbers (BlountViews)
- Blount County records highest daily count of coronavirus cases ever (BlountViews)
- The City of Alcoa's uncontrolled and costly development (BlountViews)
- 28% of Blount County coronavirus deaths in last 3 weeks (BlountViews)
- Breathe deeply (Domestic Psychology)
- The 2020 Presidential Debate: We've Been Here Before (Joe Powell)
- Recommendations for August 6 (Left Wing Cracker)
- Facts and Truth - the Vaccine for Our Nation (Joe Powell)
TN Politics
- Should Large Corporations Be Moving Their Operations to Tennessee? (Nashville Scene)
- ‘A massive breakdown in the system’: Tennessee has failed to collect DNA from 76,000 violent offenders (TN Lookout)
- Commentary: Keep a keen eye on sheriff departments (TN Lookout)
- The Weekly Links: A 1974 Kidnapping, Men's Dresses, Roxane Gay and More (Nashville Scene)
- Stockard on the Stump: What’s in your wallet? (TN Lookout)
- Taxes Going Down? Well, Kinda. (Nashville Scene)
- Mayor Cooper vows property tax decrease (TN Lookout)
- General fund surplus hits $1.35B through first 8 months of budget year (TN Journal)
- Nashville Police diversity chief discusses outreach efforts (TN Lookout)
- Bill to Facilitate Intellectual Disability Claims From Death Row Prisoners Advances (Nashville Scene)
- Election board levies $135,000 penalty on Rutherford County Mayor Ketron (TN Lookout)
- Reports: Oracle to Bring 8,500 Jobs to Nashville (Nashville Scene)
- Knoxville ballpark, Tebow charity among entities getting grants in Lee budget (TN Journal)
- Despite Reaction, Woman Urges Her Fellow Nashvillians to Get Vaccinated (Nashville Scene)
- Lee details amendments to annual spending plan (TN Journal)
- Tennessee ranks fifth from bottom in COVID-19 vaccination rate (TN Journal)
- Alexander to be honored in joint convention (TN Journal)
- White House circulates states’ infrastructure needs, but doesn’t detail how much each would get (TN Journal)
Knox TN Today
- Tennessee is a basketball school (Knox TN Today)
- Jesse Scarbrough: Fate led to THP (Knox TN Today)
- Covenant has given 50K Covid shots (Knox TN Today)
- Get ready, get set, start your mowers (Knox TN Today)
- Services Tuesday for Lenore Andes (Knox TN Today)
- Officers call for release of tapes (Knox TN Today)
- Kincannon should release the A-E tapes (Knox TN Today)
- New Harvest Park is ready for market season (Knox TN Today)
- An April stunner: Crossvine (Knox TN Today)
- Stand up for Austin-East (Knox TN Today)
- Explore featured gardens for Dogwood Arts (Knox TN Today)
- Earth Day hikes and Dogwood strolls (Knox TN Today)
Local TV News
- KPD: Fatal single-car crash on Northshore Drive early Sunday morning (WBIR)
- WATCH: Video shows crowd scatter after gunshots were fired at Pigeon Forge gas station (WBIR)
- COVID-19 at UT: New cluster announced tied to women's soccer activities (WBIR)
- Civil Rights attorney Ben Crump to represent family of Knoxville teen killed in Austin-East shooting (WBIR)
- Kincannon: 'Every day the video is not released undermines public trust' (WBIR)
- 'Backlog' of COVID-19 cases since January includes Knox County residents (WATE)
- Family of killed Austin-East student retains lawyer who represented George Floyd, Trayvon Martin (WATE)
- Officer injured in Austin-East shooting discharged from hospital (WATE)
- Knoxville mayor files court petition seeking release of Austin-East shooting bodycam video (WATE)
- KPD officer discharged from hospital after Austin-East shooting (WBIR)
- Walk-in COVID-19 vaccines available Monday at Sevier County Health Department (WATE)
- Vaccine clinic at Pellissippi State Blount County campus back on after J&J pause (WATE)
News Sentinel
- Kincannon pushes again for release of bodycam of police killing of Anthony Thompson Jr. (KNS News)
- University of Tennessee, Knox County Schools and Knox County COVID-19 case counts (KNS News)
- Step inside Ancient Lore, the fantasy-world destination now open in South Knoxville (KNS Business)
- Knoxville Biz Ticker: Fireflies light up the nights in Market Square (KNS Business)
- With downtown growth and new swanky businesses, is Knoxville still scruffy? (KNS Business)
- Bill Haslam's new book on public faith should be a good read | Victor Ashe (KNS Opinion)
- How Knox County is combating COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy, one person at a time (KNS News)
- A bookstore, maker market and coffee shop? This business truly is a 'Jacks' of all trades (KNS Business)
- This week in coronavirus: Who doesn't want the COVID-19 vaccine? White, rural Republicans. (KNS News)
- Knoxville police, DA and TBI transparency fail muddles truth in Austin-East teen's death | Editorial (KNS Opinion)
- Former Texas Gov. Rick Perry: Bill Lee is leading the way on conservative criminal justice reform | Opinion (KNS Opinion)
- We are going backwards on gun violence and failing Tennessee's children | Opinion (KNS Opinion)
- Tennessee failed hungry children through missteps, baffling policies and miscommunication | Editorial (KNS Opinion)
- Regions Bank is departing its Gay Street location. Here's what customers need to know (KNS Business)
State News
- Music City Center COVID-19 vaccinations: Hours, walk-ins and what to know (Tennessean)
- Coronavirus in Tennessee: Nashville launches walk-in vaccines at Music City Center (Tennessean)
- Cerelyn 'C.J.' Davis, police chief in Durham, NC, picked for Memphis police director (Commercial Appeal)
- WATCH: Tim Kelly inaugurated as Chattanooga's mayor - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Davidson County Election Commission lowers bar for special election on 34% property tax increase (Tennessean)
- Williamson Schools' committee recommends denying charter school application (Tennessean)
- Amazon adds more airplanes to its network. How does it compare to FedEx and UPS's fleets? (Commercial Appeal)
- NASA picked Rhodes College to go to space. What it tests could power other space missions (Commercial Appeal)
- Coolidge funeralgoers warned of possible COVID-19 exposure - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- National civil rights leader urges Memphians to reject Byhalia pipeline project (Commercial Appeal)
- Thomas: Power politics - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Schools in Chattanooga region prepare for summer school - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
Local .GOV
Wire Reports
- FedEx shooting: Who were the Indianapolis victims, suspect? Why didn't state's 'red flag' law stop attack? What we know. - USA TODAY (US News)
- Tesla faces another NHTSA investigation after fatal driverless crash in Spring, Texas - CNBC (Business)
- A 7-year-old girl was fatally shot in the drive-thru lane of a McDonald's in Chicago - CNN (US News)
- PGA Tour sends memo encouraging COVID-19 vaccination for players, caddies - ESPN (Business)
- Rift between GOP, corporate America creates opening for Biden’s tax plan - The Washington Post (US News)
- 27-year-old dead after ‘unprovoked’ shooting attack on police officers - MLive.com (US News)
- Union asks NLRB to set aside Amazon election results - POLITICO (Business)
- Joe Biden said climate change has impacted the southern border crisis. But Central American countries haven't been invited to the White House climate summit - CBS News (US News)
- Rep. Steve Stivers, who led House GOP campaign arm, retiring from Congress - Fox News (US News)
- Amazon buys nine ULA rocket launches for its space internet satellites - The Verge (Business)
- McDonald's Just Announced A BTS Collaboration And The Tweets Are Impeccable - BuzzFeed News (Business)
- ‘Exceptional’ North Texas football recruit among those killed in Austin shooting - The Guardian (US News)
- Jim Cramer on U.K. government intervening in Nvidia's $40B Arm takeover - CNBC Television (Business)
- Peloton, Coca-Cola, Tesla: What to Watch When the Stock Market Opens Today - The Wall Street Journal (Business)
- GameStop shares jump after CEO steps down, 'Roaring Kitty' raises stake - NBC News (Business)
Lost Medicaid Funding
Search and Archives
TN Progressive
- BlountViews
- Cup of Joe Powell
- Left Wing Cracker
- RoaneViews
- Southern Beale
- Tiny Cat Pants
- Vibinc
- View From My Kitchen Table
- WhitesCreek Journal
Nearby:
- AC Entertainment
- Backyard Farmer 101
- Blount Dems
- Cameron Brooks
- David Hunter
- David Moon
- Domestic Psychology
- Ellen Smith
- Gerald Witt
- Frank Murphy
- Herston TN Family Law
- Inside of Knoxville
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jim Stovall
- Knox Dems
- Knoxify
- Les Jones
- Lynn Point Records
- Michael Silence
- Mike Donila
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Outdoor Knoxville
- P.E.N. Studio
- Pittman Properties
- Property Scope
- Reality Me
- Rikki Hall
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
- Suzy Trotta
- Tom Humphrey
Beyond:
- Andy Axel
- Enclave
- Pith in the Wind
- Post Politics
- Quiet Life
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Ticket
- TN Trivia
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South
- Lovable Liberal
At large:
- Agonist
- Atrios
- Burnt Orange Report
- Buzzflash
- College Dems
- Crooks and Liars
- Daily Kos
- Democratic Strategist
- Democrats.org
- Digby's Hullabaloo
- Ezra Klein
- The Fix
- Huffington Post
- Media Matters
- Open Secrets
- Political Wire
- Politico
- Seeing the Forest
- Skippy the Bush Kangaroo
- Suburban Guerrilla
- Talk Left
- Talking Points Memo
- Think Progress
- Truthdig
- Truthout
Once more
Once more putting the lie to the "Clean Coal" myth perpetrated by the coal industry associations.
"If ignorance is bliss, why aren't more people happy?"