Sun
Jun 21 2009
05:43 pm
By: redmondkr

David Suchet, the definitive Hercule Poirot, will be presented tonight at nine on PBS's Masterpiece Mystery! in Agatha Christie's Poirot: Cat Among the Pigeons.

Topics:
Tess's picture

What channel?

What channel is PBS?

redmondkr's picture

I get mine from Direct TV

I get mine from Direct TV (satellite) channel 15. I think Comcast Cable uses channel 2 and the new DTV is probably 15 as well.


Visit us at:

The Home

Tess's picture

Thanks!

This looks good to me!

redmondkr's picture

Some years ago the Biography

Some years ago the Biography Channel ran the Hercule Poirot series starring David Suchet and I captured as many as possible on DVDs. When I read the books, my mind's eye pictures him in that role. He has the walk (Poirot had a distinctive walk because of an old war injury) and he has perfected the vanity, he is the Poirot.

This is an episode I haven't seen. It seems that it was first aired in the UK in September of 2008.


Visit us at:

The Home

Jim Lacey's picture

Cat Among the Pigeons on Masterpiece Mystery

I find myself increasingly annoyed by BBC productions which muffle and slur speech to the point of incomprehensibility. The image has taken over completely and directors show contempt for the word, I feel.

The slick (post-modern?) editing of film in complex mysteries is a disaster. In the case of "Cat Among the Pigeons" the Christie's novel is far-fetched enough, but in its linear presentation, it remains interesting. In the Masterpiece TV production, the swift takes and rapid-fire shifts insure that the viewer has difficulty learning much of anything about individual characters. The great mystery is what is going on! An intricate plot requires fairly straight narrative, I believe. In the TV version, Poirot tries to explain what has happened in an excessively long diatribe. Rather than clever or slick, I find these techniques produce unnecessary obfuscation and prevent appreciation of the plot and the characters. I wonder if anyone else agrees.

ANGRYWOLF's picture

Some people are just excellent in certain roles...

as Suchet was for Poirot...

Jim Lacey's picture

Suchet as Poirot

I agree that in the earlier episodes Suchet was perfect as Poirot. In Christie's novels Poirot, except for his little gray cells, is an absurd, comic figure. In "Cat Among the Pigeons" he seems to have lost some of these comic traits.

Tess's picture

I agree that the story was a little complicated

And, so, so far fetched. Only one car came to collect a young lady from the school. I lost count of the teachers who got murdered, but the school would have been cleared in real life after one murder.

Anyway, silly and entertaining.

redmondkr's picture

Anyway, silly and

Anyway, silly and entertaining.

Yes, but that is the charm of Agatha Christie, it's bubblegum for the mind.

I must admit this one was a disappointment. The episodes released in the late 1980s to mid 1990s were more appealing. Peril at End House, Death on the Nile, and Hercule Poirot's Christmas come to mind.


Visit us at:

The Home

JimLacey's picture

Murder is Easy

Did anyone get the impression that Jane Marple was an unnecessary character in this version of the story? After all, there was the retired policeman, who seemed too young to be retired.
The Marple character comes off as a nosy woman who asks rude questions, very unlike Christie's Miss Marple. By the way Miss Marple does not appear in the novel, which is long on romance and short on detective work. Motives, characters, and incidents have also been changed.
When a writer scripts a novel for an hour and a half TV play, characters might be eliminated, not added, and the plot simplified, I think. That's what Christie did when she reworked her novels for the stage.
Joan Hickson, I believe, gave the most accurate, the best representation of Jane Marple.

Nobody's picture

ms marple murder is easy

I think that Ms marple was not a total unnecessary part in this movie. there were other characters in this movie helping solve the crime, that is gathering information as well. not like poirot who gathers info retain it, analyze it, questions the suspects himself and at the end unravels the identity of the killer in the most suspenseful way ever.

redmondkr's picture

Margaret Rutherford was my

Margaret Rutherford was my favorite Miss Marple although Agatha Christie herself was a little disappointed with her. I only saw bits and pieces of Murder is Easy. It's still on the hard drive but I'm not sure I'll bother to save it to a DVD.

I prefer the Hercule Poirot mysteries but my enthusiasm for these recent endeavors has been sort of tepid.


Visit us at:

The Home

Siggenis's picture

Hercule Poirot

David Sushet (Hercule Poirot) is the BEST actor for this role. Too bad he is finishing his legacy as Poirot this year with the final books (films).
i have all the collections and cant get enough of Poirot, whenever I feel tired from work or life in general i pop the dvd's and i go to another world with Poirot, very very very relaxing.

Again, I feel sad that Poirot' legacy has come to an end.

JakeMabe1's picture

Oh, wow....

...don't know if I can handle watching him in the adaption of "Curtain," which presumably they will do. I'll have the tissues nearby.

Ah, that brings back such good memories from early adolescence. Agatha Christie and Hercule Poirot and his "little grey cells" (and, later, David Suchet on the telly in the role).

redmondkr's picture

I read at the beginning of

I read at the beginning of Curtain that, judging by Poirot's age in the Mysterious Affair at Styles, he dies at the age of 124.

Sorry for the spoiler but yes, even Poirot was mortal. I won't tell the other surprise.

David Suchet appeared recently as Jaggers in the 2011 production of Great Expectations on Masterpiece.

Factchecker's picture

Loved the Poirot series.

Loved the Poirot series.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives