Tue
Mar 13 2007
10:34 pm

Viacom is suing Google over the use of unauthorized Viacom content on YouTube, which Google recently purchased. Mark Cuban, among others, predicted massive lawsuits over YouTube's copyright violations once Google's bank accounts became involved.

In other recent Google legal news, Google lost a case in Belgium which claimed that Google News violated newspaper's copyrights. However, Google won a case in which the U.S. court found that Google's choice of ads to display constituted protected speech and that Google could therefore choose not to run certain ads.

Incidentally, some of the Slashdot comments on Google cases were like these:

"Maybe Google should just delink the sites altogether, that way the offended media organizations can watch their traffic plummet to zero?"

"Well if they want to be assholes about it, why not just drop them off of the database completely? It seems to me that Google is in a good position now to offer a deal to sites; they can either agree to be crawled, and thus end up in a cache for 30 days or whatever, or they can just not end up in the index at all. Their option."

"If I'm Google, I turn the morons off and see how fast they come screaming back when their ad revenue plummets. Seriously, IT'S FREE FREAKING ADVERTISING. Google should be charging *them*."

"Google ought to just pull-out from indexing anyone who complains about their methods. You effectively disappear off of the Internet w/o Google, and these whiny complainers deserve exactly that. Maybe after they've lived in a black hole for a while they'll realize the benefit of having their free material easy for web users to find and view."

I find those attitudes scary. Google isn't always right, and they're not always going to be right. Substitute "Microsoft" or "the government" for "Google" and those comments are eerie. Google is on track to be more of a monopoly than Microsoft.

Topics:
Number9's picture

Give Andy some credit...

He called it a long time ago.

In the long run, I don't think it will matter. The tubes will rule.

I see the buggy whip people raising hell not understanding they should be getting in the automobile business.

Everything you thought you knew about copyrights will change.

Rachel's picture

Hey, Nine, heard back from

Hey, Nine, heard back from the CTV folks yet?

R. Neal's picture

Everything you thought you

Everything you thought you knew about copyrights will change.

How so?

Andy Axel's picture

(Jeopardy Theme plays...)

I note how you're not getting an answer here, Mr. Neal.

____________________________

Recursive blogwhore.

Rachel's picture

answers

I'm not getting one either - what did ya hear from CTV, Nine?

Number9's picture

So far nothing.

what did ya hear from CTV, Nine?

But so far there have been 3582 viewers on YouTube Channel Nine. So even without posting the links people know where to go.

YouTube Channel Nine, where you can see your government in action. Whether they want you to or not.

Rachel's picture

No response from CTV

Let me suggest once again that your chances for a response would be enhanced if you signed your real name rather than a psuedonym.

But whatever floats your boat.

Number9's picture

Sorry, low priority

I note how you're not getting an answer here, Mr. Neal.

The question is similar to the question of TIVO. Will Sumner Redstone come after your beloved TIVO. There have been threats to do exactly that. Won't happen. This is the new distribution method. Some day there will not be video stores, just as you can no longer buy 8-tracks.

We have been here before with Betamax.

This is more about Viacom trying to force a special deal with Google than a real lawsuit. YouTube has a ten minute limit, so the excerpts are actually more like previews. This is helping Viacom not hurting them.

Also, you have to wonder if Sumner is pissed he didn't think of YouTube first. YouTube isn't going anywhere.

Andy Axel's picture

Everything you thought you

Everything you thought you knew about copyrights will change.

DMCA pretty much changed the landscape already, and not in favor of end users.

____________________________

Recursive blogwhore.

Andy Axel's picture

The question is similar to

The question is similar to the question of TIVO. Will Sumner Redstone come after your beloved TIVO. There have been threats to do exactly that. Won't happen. This is the new distribution method.

They're not going to give it away, and they made sure of that under the color of DMCA.

Plus, plenty of content providers have come after Tivo. It's hurt them. Tivo has had to make big concessions to get HDTV on their Series3 boxes. Home networking features (still available on the S2) may never show up on the S3. None of the S3's can do Multi-Room Viewing or Tivo2Go, and there's no timetable on when those might be available.

(That said, the ability to record 1080i/AC-3 programming right off the air and the dual tuner CableCard capability make the S3 worth it, at least to me.)

This is more about Viacom trying to force a special deal with Google than a real lawsuit. YouTube has a ten minute limit, so the excerpts are actually more like previews. This is helping Viacom not hurting them.

Viacom runs CMT, MTV, BET and VH1 -- music video outlets.

Most music videos are less than five minutes in length, well under the Google/YouTube limit. Those are "complete" works of art, not derivatives, not previews, not excerpts.

Still don't see why Viacom claims material harm here?

____________________________

Recursive blogwhore.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives