Mon
Feb 20 2006
12:51 pm

With Winter Olympics and Law and Order pretty much dominating the airwaves at the moment, I was thinking about what makes good TV. In no particular order, here are what I think are some of the greatest TV shows of all time:

  • Seinfeld
  • Andy of Mayberry
  • The Twilight Zone
  • Ed Sullivan
  • The Sopranos
  • Our Gang
  • The Dick Van Dyke Show
  • All in the Family
  • West Wing
  • American Dreams

Yeah, M*A*S*H should probably be on the list, but I think it was a little overrated. As for the greatest, it would be a tossup between the first two for me. Looking at the list, the things most seem to have in common are great writing, great characters, and a message that entertains while communicating values. What do you think are the greatest TV shows of all time?

P.S. I forgot Bonanza. It should be on the list, too.

P.P.S. And of course, The Beverly Hillbillies

Topics:
jah's picture

Sesame Street and Mr.

Sesame Street and Mr. Roger's.

 

;-)

jah's picture

and for a serious answer:

and for a serious answer: the Simpsons.
Bill Young's picture

tv

Disney on Sun. night..The one about the Scarecrow sticks-out..A preacher puts on a mask at night to save the poor folks..The Adventures of Superman 
Tess's picture

You forgot Price is Right,

You forgot Price is Right, the longest running game show of all time.  Bob Barker, well into his 80's, is still host.  The show distributes huge prizes to winners, and is very entertaining, as well. Smile

rikki's picture

Homicide: Life on the Streets

Homicide: Life on the Streets
C Mann's picture

Here here on Homer

  • The Simpsons
  • Andy whatever -- wasn't it called The Andy Griffith Show until it went into syndication?
  • Beverly Hillbillies
  • Dick Van Dyke
  • Nothern Exposure
  • Twin Peaks (tentatively)
  • The Twilight Zone 

Probably Ed Sullivan, All in the Family, and MASH would round out my top ten.  I'm sure I've overlooked a gem or two, though.

I haven't watched Seinfeld or HBO shows. 

 

 

 

 

 

Cousin Andy's picture

How could you forget

How could you forget Northern Exposure?  How?

 

My list (not current favorites, but all-time favorites):

Alice

Taxi

Homicide: Life on the Street

Northern Exposure

Rowan and Martin's Laugh-In

Ed

China Beach

Barney Miller

The Many Loves of Dobie Gillis

Monty Python's Flying Circus

 

***I am leaving out talk shows and educational shows.  They each deserve their own categories.*** 

 

rikki's picture

Second on Barney Miller.

Second on Barney Miller.

 Anyone who thinks Family Guy deserves mention in an "all time" list probably has such a poor conception of time as to think the Grand Canyon formed when Noah's flood dried up.

R. Neal's picture

Yeah, Barney Miller should

Yeah, Barney Miller should probably be on the list. Ed and Northern Exposure were pretty good, too.

(And Northern Exposure featured South Knox guy John Cullum. My Mom used to do his Mom's hair. And David Keith's Mom's. Mom's beauty shop was apparently a nexus of South Knox acting success.)

Monty Python and Laugh In are great picks, too.

And sorry about the reference to Andy of Mayberry. I knew the original and best was "The Andy Griffith Show" but it was as much about Mayberry for me, so they are inseperable in my mind.

As for the Beverly Hillbillies, good point about Southern kin advising Jed to "move away from there." But I liked how Jed always got the best of the scheming Mr. Drysdale and various shysters trying to take advantage of him by using his common sense and taking the moral high ground. And the sexual tension and unrequited love between Miss Jane and Jethro, and Jethro's skirt chasing, and his hare-brained entrepreneurial schemes, and how he protected Ellie Mae, and, oh, Ellie Mae, in her swim suit, out by the cement pond (with a chimp?), and Granny's folk wisdom, a lot of which rang true from my memories of Grandma. There were (and still are) similar characters in my extended family. So maybe that's why I relate. Somebody could write a dissertation, and probably has.

C Mann's picture

I thought The Beverly

I thought The Beverly Hillbillies used stereotypes that were too far over the top to be offensive.  Though, I can't explain your family, skb!  Also, as you point out, the city folk would turn out more embarrassing and got embarrassed by the hillbillies.   

...the Hercule Poirot adventures from the Biography Channel to DVD's.  David Suchet is the Poirot.

So now it's over there?  A&E had it for a while. Redmondkr, you're right about Suchet, who was as good as Brett's Holmes.  It's funny they both had sidekicks who basically were there to constantly make remarks like "REALLY, [insert Holmes/Poirot]!!" or the previously referenced "Good Heavens!". 

aka FC aka volvosnlattes (still working on a new name)

Oren Incandenza's picture

Cheers!

Cheers -- hard to believe no one's mentioned it yet.

The Simpsons -- created and sustained by Cheers alums

Mary Tyler Moore -- the "Chuckles the Clown" episode is still the funniest TV show ever

Homicide --  Great writing and acting, long story arcs, lots of soul

Saturday Night Live -- despite its ups and downs, it remains a cultural barometer

As a southerner, I always hated "Beverly Hillbillies" and found it demeaning and insulting.  If you had a show about a black family moving to wealthy suburban Detroit, would you call it "Negrosse Point"?  I think not.  Besides, the fundamental premise of BH is erroneous -- kinfolks from any part of the South would never encourage anyone to leave, much less for California.

SayUncle's picture

Others to

Others to mention:

Sopranos
Simpsons
Family Guy
Deadwood
Battlestar Galactica (the new one rules)

---
SayUncle
Can't we all just get a long gun?

Jeanne's picture

Lucy , Carol Burnett

I Love Lucy

The Carol Burnett Show

Absolutely Fabulous

any episode of In Living Color with a "Men of Film" segment

The Waltons 

gttim's picture

Bob Newhart Show

The original Bob Newhart Show. I have always loved it. I was given the first two seasons on DVD. As good as ever.
F-Stop's picture

Voting Sopranos for my

Voting Sopranos for my number 1 all time favorite. Though Deadwood is awesome, as was Carnival, when it was on air. Also, West Wing, Seinfeld and Frasier. For older shows, Andy Griffith and I Love Lucy are hard to top.
Johnny Ringo's picture

Rikki's right

Best broadcast show in my lifetime was Homicide.

Best cable: Sopranos.

tennesseevaluesauthority's picture

What's On the TV?

I could invest a lot of thought in this, or I could just type a quick list of the shows that meet my definition of "greatest of all time." I'm trying to list shows that have some sort of consistency in quality or showed steady improvement as they aged. (A few tried to carry on a bit past their point of usefulness, but hey, don't we all?) In the end, my basic list is based on the question, "If it's on and I know I've seen it before, am I willing to watch it again?"

So my favorites of all time are (in no particular order):

  • Homicide: Life on the Street
  • Six Feet Under
  • Sopranos
  • Arrested Development
  • Andy Griffith Show
  • The Smothers Brothers
  • Carol Burnett Show
  • West Wing
  • Quantum Leap (yes, really)
  • Simpsons
  • Hee Haw
  • Lost (maybe it's still early in the show's history, but it is the only show currently on the air I make a point to reserve time to watch, usurping the position once held by West Wing.)
WhitesCreek's picture

The top TEN of all time

The top TEN of all time are:

Monty Python and his Flying cirCUS

The Smothers Brothers Show

Monty Python and his Flying cirCUS

Twilight Zone

Four!

Four!

The top Four of all time.....

LCleavelin's picture

I'm surprised nobody

I'm surprised nobody mentioned:

The Prisoner

Rumpole of the Bailey (the only law-oriented show ever made that was worth watching).

I concur with all the mentions of Monty Python's Flying Circus.
Andy Axel's picture

The Sopranos Fawlty

The Sopranos

Fawlty Towers

The Office (UK)

Chapelle's Show

Law & Order

The Simpsons

Taxi

M*A*S*H

Sex & the City

WKRP in Cincinatti

____________________________

If we heard mortar shells, we'd cuss more in our songs and cut down on guitar solos

Rachel's picture

Umm, I'd have to think too

Umm, I'd have to think too hard.

But yes on Dobie Gillis, and yes on WKRP.  The episode with the turkeys a la Hindenburg is possibly the funniest television show of all time.

The first season of Picket Fences was pretty good, too.

And The Avengers.  Especially Diana Rigg.

Bill Young's picture

The scarecrow thing on

The scarecrow thing on Disney's Wonderful World of Color got me to googlin...In August of '64...The Scarecrow of Romney Marsh was aired...Dr.Syn,an Anglican Vicar,was the Scarecrow by night.The story is pretty old & many argue that this is the first costumed super hero.
redmondkr's picture

Gino Says . . .

 

The Andy Griffith Show was definitely among the best, but I didn’t care for Andy of Mayberry because I missed Barney.

I have grown fond of Last of the Summer Wine on PBS as well.  A&E ran early episodes of it years ago.  It ran in the UK from 1973 to 2005.

I loved Northern Exposure so much, I wanted to call Maggie O’Connell and see if she could find me a house in Cicely.

And, of course, there’s Rumpole with Hilda - “She who must be obeyed”.

nill illigitimi carborundum

C Mann's picture

I've thought of another: 

I've thought of another:  PBS Mystery!.  Especially Poirot and the Sherlock Holmes series starring Jeremy Brett.  Good Heavens, old boy!

redmondkr's picture

Ah! The little grey cells

I have been recording the Hercule Poirot adventures from the Biography Channel to DVD's.  David Suchet is the Poirot.  Once all the diet pill ads and such are edited out, this is some good stuff.

 

nill illigitimi carborundum

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives