Sat
Dec 22 2012
07:24 am
By: bizgrrl  shortURL
They want power and money. Why is it okay to support the NRA as a defender of gun rights but it is not okay to support unions as defenders of workers? The NRA wants to embed more guns into our daily lives. They want to train school guards for our 99,000 schools across the country.
“There were two armed law enforcement officers at that campus [Columbine], and you see what happened — 15 dead,” Ms. Feinstein [Democratic Senator, California] said.
Will we once again rollover? Will our apathy allow this to happen?
|
67
vote
|
Discussing:
- County Commissioner Brad Anders disciplined in police brutality case (164 replies)
- Knox County educators to host roundtable discussion on teacher pay schedules (9 replies)
- Tennessee and Fiat (3 replies)
- How bad is the job market in Tennessee? (8 replies)
- Famous people you have met (80 replies)
- Pilot indictment watch (94 replies)
- WATE: Three more Pilot Flying J employees plead guilty (7 replies)
- World's Fair Park development? (15 replies)
- With us or against us (4 replies)
- Knoxville Retailers, Gone but not Forgotten (257 replies)
- 2013 Shootings in Knox County, TN (59 replies)
- Wheels coming off Meals on Wheels (3 replies)
Upcoming events:
- Jun 19 2013 - 2:00pm (2 hours 16 min ago)
- Jun 20 2013 - 5:00pm (1 day 43 min from now)
- Jun 22 2013 - 10:00am (2 days 17 hours from now)
TN Progressive
- Junk Science: The Last Refuge Of A Losing Argument (Southern Beale)
- Fed Cuts Hurt Elderly, Judge Stops Haslam Layoffs For One More Week, More (RoaneViews)
- Storm Topples Riley Creek Campground Trees (RoaneViews)
- Today In Cheap Labor (Southern Beale)
- Supreme Court: States Cannot Demand Additional Proof of Citizenship To Register to Vote. Ted Cruz: “We’ll See About That.” (TN Citizen Action)
- Quote of the Day (RoaneViews)
- Public Service Announcement: Pet Edition (Southern Beale)
- Student Loan Debt Calculator (RoaneViews)
- Sexist GOP Idiot Says Man's Brain Is Superior (Video) (TN Guerilla Women)
- Photos from the Bellamy Brothers concert posted (RoaneViews)
- Reality Blasts Hole Through NRA Talking Point (Southern Beale)
- A Tale Of Two Federal Budget Items (Southern Beale)
- Business Leaders Back Federal Immigration Reform (TN Citizen Action)
- FROM TIRRC: Tennessee Voters Support Senate Immigration Bill 3-to-1 (TN Citizen Action)
- Fly the Flag for Citizenship (TN Citizen Action)
- Life in the Age of Endless, Invisible CyberWar (Joe Powell)
TN Politics
- Deputy Governor Ramsey to retire; Lt. Gov. Ramsey to not do that (Post Politics)
- Jim Tracy's fun in Fayetteville (Post Politics)
- In the Case of Pilot Flying J: Keep Your Eye on John Freeman (Pith in the Wind)
- I wouldn't say I was surprised (Post Politics)
- Quick and easy (Post Politics)
- More Pilot pleas (Post Politics)
- Tennessee's Stiff-Arm Is an Outstretched Hand (Pith in the Wind)
- Another Administrator Dismissed at Labor Department (Tom Humphrey)
- TN Ranks 6th Among States in Reliance on Federal Funding (Tom Humphrey)
- Haslam Woos Fiat-Chrysler Officials (Tom Humphrey)
- TWRA Corraling Hogs Remotely (Tom Humphrey)
- TN Election Officials to Review U.S. Supreme Decision (Tom Humphrey)
Local Media Blogs
- The Daily Plan-It: Books Sandwiched In, Edward Sharpe and the Magnetic Zeroes, and Attack of the 50-Foot Drag Queen (Metro Pulse)
- Wednesday briefing (Josh Flory)
- Journalists: There's not a less risk-taking crowd (Jack Lail)
- Tuesday briefing (Josh Flory)
- The Daily Plan-It: Kids' Story Time, Zumba, and Jazz on the Square (Metro Pulse)
- Appeals court rules against Mike Ross in civil case (Josh Flory)
- This day in history, 52 years ago … (Gerald Witt)
- Sunday at Bonnaroo: Kendrick Lamar Owns the Stage (Metro Pulse)
- Monday briefing (Josh Flory)
- The Daily Plan-It: The Folk You Buddies, Yoga, and Danielle Howle (Metro Pulse)
- Saturday at Bonnaroo: Jack Johnson Draws a Crowd (Metro Pulse)
- Broyles seeks $500K for 'Meals' plan (Mike Donila)
Local Paper
- UT trustees panel recommends raises for DiPietro, Cheek and Rakes (KNS News)
- KCSO investigating shooting off Alcoa Highway (KNS News)
- Marriott Business Services in Blount County transferred to Accenture (KNS Business)
- One arrested in West Knoxville apartment fire (KNS News)
- Travel options grow as Megabus adds Lexington route (KNS Business)
- UT Foundation to re-evaluate leadership role before finding replacement (KNS News)
- 6 things to know today (KNS News)
- TVA car records found lacking (KNS Business)
- Josh Flory: Developer spins a Bass tale (KNS Business)
- The List: Fewer travellers last year at McGhee Tyson, but national trends point to growth (KNS Business)
Local TV News
- Collector company rolls out new UT Barbie doll (WATE)
- Man arrested at scene of West Knoxville apartment fire (WATE)
- Louisville-based Marriott Business Services to transfer to Accenture (WATE)
- One hospitalized in Alcoa Highway shooting (WATE)
- Knoxville 6-year-old asked to compete in world's largest martial arts competition (WATE)
- App ranks Knoxville as top city for 4th of July activities (WBIR)
- 6-month-old shot at home on Alcoa Hwy. (WBIR)
- Parents arrested after toddler found wandering on train tracks (WBIR)
- 3 arrested after marijuana, crack cocaine found in home (WBIR)
- Tenn. company uses 3-D printing to save duck's life (WBIR)
- Missing Knox Co. teen found (WVLT)
- TBI releases domestic violence report, half of all cases are family related (WVLT)
State News
- Men’s Wearhouse ousts founder, pitchman Zimmer (Times Free Press)
- FBI hunt for ex-Teamster boss Hoffa’s remains ends (Times Free Press)
- Bernanke: Fed could reduce bond buys this year (Times Free Press)
- Feds charge 33 in Georgia gun trafficking case (Times Free Press)
- MLGW Informs Customers of New, Yet Unfunded, Smart Meters (ABC24 Memphis)
- Chattanooga-based CBL opens new center (Times Free Press)
- Live on Local 24 Midday: Juneteenth Jazz Festival (ABC24 Memphis)
- Suspect Charged in Midtown Carjacking, Downtown Crash (ABC24 Memphis)
- Community discussion on teacher training, state building contracts (Tennessean)
- Pollard's bold goals for Titans include Super Bowl (Tennessean)
- Are Chappy's customers unhappy? (Tennessean)
- Medical group recognizes obesity as a disease (Tennessean)
Wire Reports
- Wall St. ends sharply lower after Bernanke comments (Yahoo Business)
- Boston poised to begin condom giveaway in high schools (Yahoo News)
- Bernanke points to reduced Fed bond buying this year (Yahoo Business)
- New York City residents sort their garbage as part of new composting program (Yahoo News)
- Two men accused of bizarre radiation plot (Yahoo News)
- Nvidia's stock jumps on license plan; Wall Street eyes Apple (Yahoo Business)
- Icahn reiterates commitment for Dell buy (Yahoo Business)
- NYC mayoral hopeful Christine Quinn’s memoir so far sells just 100 copies (Yahoo Politics)
- Jury selection in Trayvon Martin murder case moves into final phase (Yahoo News)
- Theft of F-35 design data is helping U.S. adversaries: Pentagon (Yahoo News)
- Wikileaks founder Assange: We are helping NSA leaker Snowden (Yahoo Politics)
- Obama revisits the promises of 2008 in legacy-minded Berlin speech (Yahoo Politics)
- News Corp spinoffs start preliminary trading (Yahoo Business)
- Murkowski becomes third GOP senator to support same-sex marriage (Yahoo Politics)
- The same-sex marriage Senate endorsement tracker (Yahoo Politics)
Site Statistics
Last 7 days:
- Posts: 30
- Comments: 330
- Visits: 10,190
- Pageviews: 25,048
- Posts: 113
- Comments: 1087
- Visits: 38,117
- Pageviews: 82,690
Popular today
Popular this week
TN Progressive
- BlountViews
- Cup of Joe Powell
- Jamie Hollin
- Left Wing Cracker
- Newscoma
- Out of the Blue
- RoaneViews
- Sean Braisted
- Southern Beale
- TN Citizen Action
- Tiny Cat Pants
- TN Guerilla Women
- TN Values Authority
- Vibinc
- View From My Kitchen Table
- WhitesCreek Journal
Nearby:
- AC Entertainment
- Agrarian Urbanite
- Big Good Thing
- Blount Dems
- Bottom Line
- Craig Thomas
- Daily Pulse
- David Oatney
- Discover ET
- Domestic Psychology
- Ellen Smith
- Fletch
- Gerald Witt
- Frank Murphy
- Home/Work
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jack McElroy
- Jim Stovall
- Julie Apple
- Knox Dems
- KnoxBlab
- Knoxify
- Knoxvillager
- Les Jones
- Lynn Point Records
- MamaPundit
- Michael Silence
- Mike Donila
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Mushy's Moochings
- Outdoor Knoxville
- P.E.N. Studio
- People for the Planet
- Pittman Properties
- Political Leverage
- Property Scope
- Reality Me
- Rikki Hall
- Rob Huddleston
- School Matters
- Stacey Campfield
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
- Stuck inside Knoxville
- Suzy Trotta
- Tom Humphrey
- Tri Cities
Beyond:
- Andy Axel
- Daily Docket
- Democratic Talk Radio
- Enclave
- Ginger Snaps
- Pith in the Wind
- Post Politics
- Quiet Life
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Ticket
- TN Trivia
- TN Women's Caucus
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South
- Lovable Liberal
- Newsrack
- Wandering Hillbilly
At large:
- Agonist
- Alterdestiny
- Atrios
- Burnt Orange Report
- Buzzflash
- College Dems
- Common Cause
- Crooks and Liars
- Daily Kos
- Democratic Strategist
- Democrats.org
- Digby's Hullabaloo
- Ezra Klein
- The Fix
- Huffington Post
- Liberal Oasis
- Media Matters
- MyDD
- Open Secrets
- Pam's House Blend
- Political Wire
- Politico
- Progressive States
- Seeing the Forest
- Skippy the Bush Kangaroo
- Suburban Guerrilla
- Talk Left
- Talking Points Memo
- Think Progress
- Truthdig
- Truthout

If more guns make us safer
If more guns make us safer why did the NRA ban guns from its press conference? They are nothing more than chickenshit shills for weapons dealers, spewing bile and paranoia.
Buying judges
You have to give them credit. They were smart enough to buy a judge who would base his ruling on the definitions contained in this book.
(link...)
Isn't it odd, that the treatise that changed two hundred years of constitutional law is so obscure, that the reprint isn't even guaranteed to be free from flaws?
An aside: Reprints of old books often have errors
The reprint's disclaimer is fairly typical, even for important old books of historical interest. :(
Since 2005, RoaneTNHistory.org has made old history-related books and documents available free online in full text, annotated and fully searchable. However, the work of republishing each old book is considerable, essentially a labor of love.
Just a plain OCR of a scanned book tends to contain much more gibberish than one would hope. Even with modern tools such as spellcheckers, it is necessary to hand-type much of each page, then hand-check everything for accuracy. Even so, errors can still be overlooked. :(
-- OneTahiti
The texts
The point I was trying to make is that Scalia's entire argument boiled down to an interpretation of the perforatary clause. He defined that clause by using out of print and somewhat obscure historical grammarical references that were valid neither to the time of the framers nor the time of the interpretation. It seemed to be an example of finding sources to fit an opinion as opposed to basing an opinion on historical rulings of constitutional law.
This is not to say that I place no value on historical texts, indeed I have some in my personal stacks, I'm just not in the habit of quoting obscure information from out of print texts as common knowledge that will become the basis for how society deals with its most vexing problems.
I find Scalia's argument poorly constructed and a stretch from reality.
Dead or Alive: Originalism as
Dead or Alive: Originalism as Popular Constitutionalism in Heller
"The majority presents this account as the original public meaning of the Second Amendment, yet draws upon evidence that may incorporate understandings that emerge long after the founding."
Also, "In practice, originalism appears to be a species of popular constitutionalism. "
In short
Are you saying I am not alone in my opinion?
Yes, and you didn't have to
Yes, and you didn't have to be a Yale Law School professor to come to the same conclusion!
Quick numbers and Unfunded Mandates
100,000 schools
~ 3 resource officers at each one (just to give you 2.5 given time off, sick leave, etc)
x $50,000 for salary, training, equipment
= $15 BILLION per year
Now, I would suggest we embrace the NRA's proposal, contingent on a new tax on gun sales to pay for it. Based on roughly 15 million new gun sales per year, that would be a $1000 tax on each gun sale.
My suggestion would be to pro-rate that by gun type, so maybe only $500 for a home-defense or true sport weapon (non-military shotgun, bolt-action rifle), $800 for a handgun, and $10,000 for AR-15s and the like.
Let's embrace the NRA's suggestion in this manner. And maybe, using Chris Rock's logic, a 50-cent-per-round ammunition tax.
Irony
Not to make light of this situation but in Joseph Heller's "Catch-22" the catch was this.
Insane pilots were not allowed to fly combat missions. The definition of insanity was anyone crazy enough to fly a combat mission, BUT, the only was to act upon this clause was for the pilot to ask that it be invoked, however, once the pilot asked to be declared insane he showed reasonable concern for his well being and thereby proved his sanity.
In Heller vs. D.C. (or vica versa) the catch is that the local governments are in charge of regulating their own militias to provide order and safety but they're not allowed to regulate their own gun owners because gun ownership is now an individual right not tied to being in a militia.
Every time we let this Heller guy come up with something it turns out to be bizarre.
Memorable
"You don't like bigots, bullies, snobs or hypocrites. Subconsciously there are many people you hate."
"Consciously, sir, consciously...I hate them consciously."
*
Personally, I support the placement of armed School Resource Officers in schools. As the NYT reports, about 1/3 of all schools nationally (and locally, I believe) already have SROs on staff, virtually all of whom enjoy strong, positive relationships with the students who are their charges. What I don't support is armed volunteers, to include teachers and/or administrators.
But yeah, it's offensive that the NRA promoted armed SROs, decried inadequate treatment for mental illness, and dissed violence in media, but wouldn't give an inch on the "need" for assault weapons in the hands of the general citizenry.
Sure seems to me that there are lots of preventive changes we could make, and we should enact every last one of them.
“There were two armed law
“There were two armed law enforcement officers at that campus [Columbine], and you see what happened — 15 dead,” Ms. Feinstein [Democratic Senator, California] said.
I think the discussion should go past armed School Resource Officers. They can't be at every entrance at all the times.
What do they want? "This is
What do they want?
"This is the beginning of a serious conversation. We won't be taking questions today.”
I think the implied "shut the hell up" is pretty clear, but I don't plan on it.
What do they want? Absolute
What do they want? Absolute power.
*
Completely agree that SROs (but not armed volunteers, teachers, or administrators) are just part of the fix needed.
I've been arguing with folks at the KNS site for a week that their insistence that the assault weapons ban didn't "lower the crime rate" really misses the point.
The fact remains that assault weapons have been the weapons of choice in virtually every mass shooting, it's mass shootings that are the topic of conversation recently, and their side simply hasn't offered any rationale for why the general citizenry "needs" these particular weapons.
To the folks who insist that reinstating the ban would constitute an abridgement of their Second Amendment rights, I've reminded 'em that they're denied grenades, bombs, and "yellowcake" uranium, too, and that our rights outlined in the Constitution are never absolute.
I even met up with a former Marine yesterday who posited that there really aren't that many people who die in mass shootings, anyway, and that as many die in swimming pool accidents! Wow!
We should do everything that we can do to alleviate this problem and it's perfectly obvious to me that that includes curtailing availability of the weapons most often used in mass shootings.
The wins for home
The wins for home self-defense in D.C. and Chicago were not necessarily wins for the libertarian Mad Maxes.page 193
Scalia, in the Heller majority opinion:"modern developments have limited the degree of fit between the prefatory clause and the protected right
A friend of mine is currently arguing before the ninth circuit that the right to self-defense extends beyond the home as well (audio here,) but I didn't hear any mentions of AR-15s.
*
BTW, the kid pictured in yesterday's KNS article entitled Knox gun sales see surge, who's getting some help installing the Knight's Armament rail system on his Bushmaster XM-15 assault rifle, is a junior at Powell High School.
Unless he were held back a grade in years past (which I don't recall), he's the same age as my son, namely 16 or 17.
Current law says it's none of my beeswax, but I don't understand why a parent would buy his or her minor child an assault rifle, whether or not the child enjoys "target shooting."
*
Eric, I'm not understanding where you're directing us in this last link?
It looks like the linked document is 55 pages long, so where is this "page 193?"
(Interesting background info. Thanks.)
It's actually page 3 of the
It's actually page 3 of the PDF. The pages of the source document are numbered.
*
Oops. Coulda opened the doc, I guess...
Thanks.
Post new comment