Thu
May 17 2012
02:59 pm

The League of Women Voters of Knoxville/Knox County released a statement endorsing the Knox County Schools budget increase. Their statement lists the reasons for their support based on facts sourced from Knox Co. Schools, Metro Pulse, and the Knoxville Chamber of Commerce. Press release after the jump...

League of Women Voters Endorses $35 million Increase in the Schools' Budget as Recommended by the Knox County School Board

The League of Women Voters of Knoxville/Knox County supports adequate funding for public schools based on our state position, and formally endorses the $35 million increase in the schools budget as recommended by the Knox County School Board.

The Education committee has urged all members to read the following facts and contact their commissioners immediately to support adequate funding for education and this once-in-a-decade opportunity to invest in a stronger community.

1) OUR SUPPORT IS BASED ON THESE FACTS (sources: KCS, Metropulse, and Chamber)
* Only 47% of our third-graders scored proficient or advanced in reading under the new higher state standards.
* In the Class of 2011, only 19% hit all 4 ACT benchmarks, a nationally recognized indicator of college and workforce readiness (only 685 students out of 2,905 are prepared!).
* Over 60% of students going to area community colleges need remediation.
* Per pupil expenditures of $8,508 this past school year fall well below the state average of $9,084, and further yet, below Hamilton County’s $9,398 and Davidson County’s $11,080, let alone Oak Ridge’s $12,112.
* Knox County has not increased its $2.36 property tax rate in over 12 years. The median homeowner would pay around $10.65 a month , given how the current proposal is written. For someone with a $100,000 house that amounts to .21 cents/day, much less than a cup of coffee.

2) OUR ANALYSIS
The proposed budget is based on Knox County School's first ever five year strategic plan, a roadmap to the investments needed to improve our school performance. The budget adds a $35 million increase over the $384,670,000 base budget. This is on top of the expected $13 million increase in state funds due to enrollment growth. We consider the $35 million the equivalent of a permanent raise. It is a bold plan to advance the schools quickly and ensure that more children succeed.

Key points:
-- Spending will pay for school renovation costs up front, avoiding debt and large interest costs over the long term.
-- In the first years, most of the increase goes to renovating schools; The proportion shifts after Year 1 and more of the increase will go to the classroom and operation portion; The operational budget will increase by $7 million more over each of the next 5 years. See charts atwww.bethebestknox.com
-- The plan targets 9 research-based strategies for improvement including: instructional coaches, full day and five year age kindergarten, additional teaching days, learning technology, including school-wide wifi access, devices, training, and tech support, community schools to address family and community involvement and non-academic needs [local League position], and performance pay. See full list at: (link...)
--The base budget includes a 2.5% base raise for all teaching staff plus merit raises for nearly half the teaching staff. Under this plan, if granted a "raise," the increase in funds coming from enrollment growth could then go toward increasing base salaries for teaching and support staff [*LWV position promotes raise in base pay for teachers and staff, we rank 37th in state].
-- The schools agree to be accountable to the citizens and produce improvement [*LWV would like to see an annual report].

DOCUMENTS AND RESEARCH
1. Knox County Schools lists documents and past presentations on their homepage to understand the budget and Five Year plan: (link...)
2. As a public service, the Chamber created an easy to read website to help citizens learn about the school budget and strategic plan at:www.bethebestknox.com. Budget charts and documents are found in one place: (link...)
3. All the news articles related to the budget, with good analysis: (link...)
4. Critics say Central Office is bloated, but salaries and numbers do not reflect this. See report: (link...)

League of Women Voters members will be at the following meetings wearing yellow to show their support of our schools.

May 21: County Commission work session at 2:00pm.
May 29: County Commission meeting at 1:45pm.
May 30: THEY VOTE! County Commission special called meeting re: KCS' Budget at 5pm*

bizgrrl's picture

Compassion Coalition supports

Compassion Coalition supports the school budget.

jcgrim's picture

The devil is in the details.

I expect the League of Women's Voters to advocate for more funding for our schools, particularly for programs that have demonstrated the outcomes our community wants for our students. However some of the funding targets in this budget are highly questionable.

Let's clear up one statement that is false: merit pay for teachers is not a research based method for improving learning and achievement or for teacher retention. Period. Every recent independent study shows it is a FAILURE. History of the last 100 years shows merit pay for teachers has failed. Despite this research, NYC tried starting merit pay in 2007, wasted $75 M on it and dropped it in 2010, because it had null results, according to studies by Roland Fryer and RAND.

The only two observable factors that have been found consistently to lead to higher student achievement are reduced class size and teacher experience. Performance pay will undermine both.

So when people who claim to care about kids learning promote known snake oil in place of demonstrated methods don't believe them.

Who will be accountable when this latest absurd proposal fails our children?

mld's picture

County Budget

Thanks for your comments. When will our leaders see the light? I have taught in Knox County for 26 years. Over those 26 years, I have spent a lot of time and effort supporting plans to increase educational funding in our county for the right reasons. I have served with KCEA and TEA in the past to try to make teachers and the community aware of the need to increase school funding. Knox County's expenditures per student and teacher pay have always been out of line compared with other Tennessee public school systems in regard to citizens ability to pay.

I have always felt as elected officials, the school board should have taxing power. That is the only possible way that we can raise enough money to adequately fund our schools.County Commission will never have the integrity to do what is right for our students.Even when teachers and former teachers have served on County Commission they have never served the best interests of our students.

I have been disappointed in the lack of leadership on the School Board in regard to the proposed budget. As you point out, the devil is in the details. How can a plan that focuses on teacher merit pay have any credibility with the school board? How can the school board take anything serious that comes from people that want to increase class sizes in public schools and push for vouchers? Study after study has shown merit pay does not improve education. The recent teacher evaluation plan and the merit pay idea are just schemes to manipulate and give tremendous power and control to the "Kings" of our county and state.

Our school board needs to take the lead and reject merit pay and other ideas that have proven by all serious studies to be flawed plans that benefit the rich and powerful at the expense of our kids.They need to push for funding that has real proven benefits for students such as lower class sizes.

GSD's picture

Thanks, Mid...

For speaking up. It's good to see another Knox County educator speaking up about the poison pills McIntyre has slipped into this budget.

I am guessing that the staff at your school also got the mandatory, after-school "If you know what's good for you, you'll support this budget whether you like it or NOT!" meeting last week?

mld's picture

Yep, that is my

Yep, that is my understanding.

We have many outstanding teachers and administrators in Knox County. We get more bang for the buck in Knox County than any other system in our area. The attack on teachers by the governor and legislators has led to the morale in schools being at the lowest point since I have been involved in education. I have been told that this year's retirement numbers are much higher than in recent years. That is part of their scheme. The leaders have a losing plan for our kids, increase class sizes and get rid of experienced teachers. Merit pay, vouchers, charter schools, it's not about kids, it is all about them!

R. Neal's picture

It takes a village

It's way too late for any new ideas, and I'm certainly not qualified, but...

Maybe the incentive should be a higher base salary for all teachers and a small bonus for every kid who graduates plus another small bonus for every kid who scores > X on the ACT.

The bonus would be divided up between every teacher who taught the kid from K-12.

I agree on the smaller class sizes. Haslam wants to increase them.

It seems like most of the current education "reforms" are designed to run good teachers out of the profession and guarantee that public schools fail so they can justify outsourcing them.

fischbobber's picture

12 year bonus retention plan

Maybe the incentive should be a higher base salary for all teachers and a small bonus for every kid who graduates plus another small bonus for every kid who scores > X on the ACT.

The bonus would be divided up between every teacher who taught the kid from K-12.

You may be on to something here Randy. It could act as a retention bonus, or something. At the very least, it is a compelling idea that deserves to be examined.

Bbeanster's picture

Endorsements from the

Endorsements from the League and the Compassion Coalition are extremely unlikely to persuade those who are inclined to oppose it.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

TN Progressive

TN Politics

Knox TN Today

Local TV News

News Sentinel

    State News

    Wire Reports

    Lost Medicaid Funding

    To date, the failure to expand Medicaid/TennCare has cost the State of Tennessee ? in lost federal funding. (Source)

    Search and Archives