Submitted by R. Neal on Tue, 2009/02/24 - 12:41pm.

A bill sponsored by Stacey Campfield has cleared subcommittee.

(Is this a first? At least it's not a crazy talk bill.)

107
vote
Gary's picture
He has to show signs of

He has to show signs of pragmatism before he runs in the seventh.

This is the first step.

gonzone's picture
but

Are there nappies under those britches? :-)

"The arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice."

Konamazing's picture
Nope...

His mom or somebody wrote that for him.
He's just not smart enough to render such a piece of proposed legislation by himself.

That much is obvious.

Pam Strickland's picture
Amazing. I agree that I

Amazing. I agree that I doubt he wrote it himself. The clue is that it actually makes sense.

Pam Strickland

"We are what we pretend to be, so we must be careful about what we pretend to be." ~Kurt Vonnegut

rikki's picture
That is a horrible bill.

That is a horrible bill. First of all, how many people will it affect? How many men have visitation rights and are also in the military? I'm going to presume no women are in those circumstances because a woman usually has to be pretty irresponsible to not have custody of her children and would likely be too irresponsible for the military too. Either way, we are talking about a tiny fraction of the population impacted by this bill.

Second, who are these proxy parents going to be? How will the courts determine whether the proxy parent can be trusted with the children? It seems like only in the case of a really ugly divorce would it even be necessary to appeal to the courts, as opposed to just saying, "My parents are willing to take the kids every other weekend while I'm in Iraq." If something like that can not be worked out and the courts need to get involved, you likely have a volatile situation.

So this bill's primary impact will be to further entangle the courts in a handful of messy divorces. Since divorce courts will hear appeals to modify the terms of custody, is this bill even necessary?

Bbeanster's picture
I agree with Rikki.

I agree with Rikki. Campfield gets these domestic court bills from a so-called fathers' rights group, and most of them are misogynistic and goofy as hell.

metulj's picture
Interestingly, the "father's

Interestingly, the "father's rights" movement has its roots in the right-wing nationalism movement in Australia and its brazenly racist One Nation front organization.

True happiness is knowing you are a hypocrite. -- Ivor Cutler

GOP Stimulus Plan: Hunger motivates the lazy.

Tamara Shepherd's picture
Odd...

...Campfield didn't think, either, to exclude HOMOSEXUALS from those eligible to become "proxy parents."

My gawd, this bill could be a travesty!

(Sarcasm.)

R. Neal's picture
Good analysis, Rikki. It

Good analysis, Rikki. It certainly sounded like one of his "oppressed deadbeat baby daddy" protection bills, but not as onerous as some others.

Such as:

Link...

Plus, if you oppose this one you aren't supporting our troops. Clever.

KO's picture
It's a dumb bill. The Court

It's a dumb bill. The Court of Appeals has held that, as a general proposition, it is not in a child's best interest for the child's time with one parent to be diminished in favor third parties other than the other parent. See, e.g., McDaniel v. McDaniel, Western Section Court of Appeals, Dec. 18, 2008.

What is Campfield's obsession with government micro-managing everyone's life with such broad strokes? We have a whole branch of government staffed with people who are very qualified to determine what is best for individual children on a case-by-case basis. I wish Campfield would try to legislate about something he understands, like landlord-tenant law. Oh wait....

www.herstonlaw.com

metulj's picture
He's signed on for the

He's signed on for the "Asking for Concealed Carry Records is a Crime Bill" too. I wonder what the constitutionality of that is?

True happiness is knowing you are a hypocrite. -- Ivor Cutler

GOP Stimulus Plan: Hunger motivates the lazy.

Rachel's picture
I nominate this thread title

I nominate this thread title for best KV thread title of all time.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Shortcuts

Upcoming events

Public meeting re. Henley Street Bridge projectTue, 2009/12/08 - 6:00pm2 days 19 hours from now
The Brian Setzer Orchestra Christmas Rocks Extravaganza Tue, 2009/12/08 - 8:00pm2 days 21 hours from now
Knoxville Jazz Orchestra's "A Swingin' Christmas" Tue, 2009/12/22 - 8:00pm2 weeks 2 days from now
Tennessee Shines featuring Buddy MillerWed, 2009/12/30 - 7:00pm3 weeks 3 days from now
B.B. King Fri, 2010/01/08 - 8:00pm4 weeks 5 days from now


User login

Blog-O-Rama

Media Blogs

Local Paper

TV News

Wire Reports



Nearby:

Beyond:

At large:

Government:

Media: