The fallout from the state Supreme Court ruling is a mess. It is throwing the Knox County election into turmoil and threatening the integrity of the commission. On the other hand, we are talking about a rubber-stamp legislative body...
More after the jump
whose members seem more concerned with guarding each other's backs than with making good choices based on informed deliberation. Several of the commissioners impacted by this ruling went along with Paul Pinkston's mathematically inept analysis of the sale of the old South High building, a mistake that will cost the county at least $200,000 plus the missed opportunity for a responsible development project in a neighborhood that welcomed the investment.
Nonetheless, the temptation to disregard county commission as already broken must be resisted. This mess is primarily the responsibility of the Supreme Court for handing down a poorly timed decision without any remedy or recommendation for applying it to the real world. The justices have been negligent. Responsibility also lies with Mike Moyers, the county law director, and his predecessor for valuing the opinion of the state attorney general ahead of the expressed will of the voters he serves and not forcing a formal court ruling long ago.
Figuring out who to blame solves little, however, and it seems to me we have precedent of some sort in the decision that came down when Knoxville instituted term limits. It was decided that terms would be counted from that day forward, so sitting city officeholders were all defined to be serving the first of two terms regardless of how many terms they had actually served. That would suggest that we do the same in this instance. All current county commissioners should be declared to be in their first term and eligible for one more election, and we can proceed with this year's votes as planned and avoid the chaos.
|
Topics:
|
149
vote
|
Discussing:
- A couple of good books (9 replies)
- Who do you like in the Super Bowl? (13 replies)
- Campfield's willingness to mislead surmounts itself: abortion causes breast cancer (22 replies)
- What is the purpose of printing this type of letter to the editor? (30 replies)
- Bean on His Staceyness, Mayor Burchett, & the Governor (5 replies)
- Did Gloria Ray get a raw deal? (23 replies)
- Komen Foundation backs down (10 replies)
- In the wake of KTSC - another local vendor contract that needs a closer look (2 replies)
- Burchett: Duncan may have to resign as Trustee (3 replies)
- Gov. Haslam's administration fires top TDEC officials (1 reply)
- More Campfield greatest hits (35 replies)
- The other side of Governor Haslam's three-dollar bill (6 replies)
Upcoming events:
- Feb 13 2012 - 6:30pm (1 week 18 hours from now)
- Feb 15 2012 - 12:00pm (1 week 2 days from now)
User login
Navigation
TN Progressive
- Update on proposed 6th and Garfield development (Enclave)
- Half Time In America (Southern Beale)
- Bridges v. Walls – Annexation Edition (Vibinc)
- The Honest Rape (Southern Beale)
- From Our "Shocked" Dept: TVA's Watts Bar project will take longer, cost more (RoaneViews)
- Clay Bennett (RoaneViews)
- Colbert's Legendary Defense of Planned Parenthood: Pap Smears at Walgreens (Video) (TN Guerilla Women)
- Belmont working on community relations (Enclave)
- Lame logic (Enclave)
- Vanderbilt Students Bristle at Notion of Inclusiveness (Sean Braisted)
- The real Problem With the "Cure" (Kitchen Table)
- Haynes Is Out, Who's In The Bullpen? (Sean Braisted)
- Selenium Contamination Needs to be Monitored Closely (RoaneViews)
- Getting Past Guns, God And Gays Legislation (Newscoma)
- What The Hell Is Stacy Campfield Doing? (Southern Beale)
- Obama (Probably) Gonna Be On Georgia Ballot (Sean Braisted)
TN Politics
- Environmentalist, Governor Agree: Consolidation Won't Change Things (Tom Humphrey)
- Two NRA-Drafted Bills Filed on Guns in Cars (Tom Humphrey)
- Kingsport Alderman Challenging Shipley in GOP Primary (Tom Humphrey)
- New Locks for Ballot Boxes (Tom Humphrey)
- UT Folk Happy With Haslam Budget (Tom Humphrey)
- Hamilton County Lincoln Day Dinner, storified (TN Ticket)
- Mayfield churns 3rd District race (TN Ticket)
- Team delay (Post Politics)
- Congressional race roundup, District One (TN Ticket)
- That's twice as long as he lasted previously (Post Politics)
- Planned Parenthood sues state (Post Politics)
- The state wants in on the action (Post Politics)
Local Media Blogs
- The inventor of the camera phone may surprise you (Jack Lail)
- Lies, Damn Lies, and Statistics (Metro Pulse)
- Friday briefing (Josh Flory)
- The Weekend Plan-It: Feb. 3-5 (Metro Pulse)
- Black Wednesday anniversary slipped by (Jack McElroy)
- Culver Schmid joins new firm (Josh Flory)
- Gloria Ray's Job Not Long for This World? (Metro Pulse)
- Film Notes: ET First Friday Film Series + The Innkeepers (Metro Pulse)
- O Youth Wins Last Sound Off Qualifier (Metro Pulse)
- Thursday briefing (Josh Flory)
- KTSC hires spin team, board chair quits (Mike Donila)
- Voting locations, sample ballot released (Mike Donila)
Local Paper
- East Knoxville house fire ruled suspicious (KNS News)
- UT educators like Haslam's budget proposal (KNS News)
- TVA's Watts Bar project will take longer, cost more (KNS Business)
- Ray maintains competitive spirit amid KTSC turmoil (KNS Business)
- Marriage licenses issued in Knox County (KNS News)
- Haslam seeks more control over Tennessee's agencies (KNS News)
- City has no independent record of KTSC performance evaluations (KNS Business)
- Births (KNS News)
- People and Honors: February 5 (KNS Business)
- Business Bulletins February 5 (KNS Business)
Local TV News
- Knoxville bars, law enforcement working to reduce drunk driving after Super Bowl (WATE)
- One injured in shooting between father and son (WATE)
- Local businesses hoping for a touchdown on Super Bowl Sunday (WATE)
- Westbound lanes back open on I-40 after rockslide cleanup (WBIR)
- KFD: East Knoxville fire is 'suspicious' (WBIR)
- One I-40 westbound lane opens after Cocke County rockslide (WATE)
- Meet Herschend, Dolly's silent partner in family fun parks (WBIR)
- Knoxville-based RAM aims to help more people in more places (WATE)
- East Tennesseans receive free healthcare (WBIR)
- Haslam administration fires 2 top TDEC leaders (WBIR)
- TDOT announces "extensive" plans to stabilize spot of recent rock slide (WVLT)
- Interstate 40 west reopens as fallen rocks removed (WVLT)
State News
- Teen indicted in fatal Lakeland wreck (Commercial Appeal)
- Eli Manning directs late drive as Giants beat Patriots 21-17 to win the Super Bowl (Commercial Appeal)
- 2 brought to Erlanger after Marion County crash (Times Free Press)
- Fears grow of Israeli attack on Iran (Commercial Appeal)
- Band from Seattle wins Memphis blues battle (Commercial Appeal)
- Tennessee Titans owner treats 33 Fort Campbell soldiers to Super Bowl (Commercial Appeal)
- Search on for escaped Silverdale inmate (Times Free Press)
- Top Web Stories - Jan 29- Feb 3 (Times Free Press)
- SWAT standoff resolved; man in custody (Times Free Press)
- Lady Mocs lead Wofford at half (Times Free Press)
Wire Reports
- Goldman's Blankfein campaigns for gay marriage (Reuters) (Yahoo News)
- Glencore offers 8 percent premium to Xstrata to seal merger: FT (Reuters) (Yahoo Business)
- GOP race turns to Colorado, Minnesota (AP) (Yahoo Politics)
- Analysis: Romney win leaves rivals few options (AP) (Yahoo Politics)
- Class War 2012: Why Both Parties Are Flying the Anti-Wall Street Banner (Time.com) (Yahoo News)
- Inside Facebook's IPO: How the Social Web Will Reshape the Economy (Time.com) (Yahoo News)
- "Intentional" explosion kills husband, two sons of missing woman (Reuters) (Yahoo News)
- As Facebook grows up, it courts Madison Avenue (Reuters) (Yahoo Business)
- Police clear DC Occupy site, protesters look to a new day (Reuters) (Yahoo News)
- CommVault says will go it alone, despite M&A buzz (Reuters) (Yahoo Business)
- Greek parties face Monday EU bailout deadline (Reuters) (Yahoo Business)
- Obama says he deserves re-election, job's not done (AP) (Yahoo Politics)
- Colorado rocky for Republicans in 2012 (AP) (Yahoo Politics)
- In Minn., rightward drift challenges Romney (AP) (Yahoo Politics)
- With sparse data, focus returns to Europe (Reuters) (Yahoo Business)
Popular today
Popular this week
- What is the purpose of printing this type of letter to the editor?
- First Friday with Mayor Rogero and the KCDP
- “If you were to rank big mistakes in the history of this country,”
- More Campfield greatest hits
- Layoffs report
- Haslam: Believe in Better
- In the wake of KTSC - another local vendor contract that needs a closer look
TN Progressive
- BlountViews
- Cup of Joe Powell
- Left Wing Cracker
- Newscoma
- Out of the Blue
- RoaneViews
- Sean Braisted
- Southern Beale
- TN Citizen Action
- TN Talking Points
- Tiny Cat Pants
- TN Guerilla Women
- Vibinc
- View From My Kitchen Table
- Wade Munday
- WhitesCreek Journal
Nearby:
- AC Entertainment
- Agrarian Urbanite
- Blount Dems
- Bottom Line
- Craig Thomas
- Daily Pulse
- David Oatney
- Discover ET
- Domestic Psychology
- Dwight Van de Vate
- Ellen Smith
- Erin Chapin
- Fletch
- Fort Sanders
- Frank Murphy
- Frussie's
- Gene Patterson
- Home/Work
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jack McElroy
- Jim Stovall
- Julie Apple
- Knox Dems
- KnoxBlab
- Knoxify
- Knoxvillager
- Last Home
- Les Jones
- Long Pauses
- Lynn Point Records
- MamaPundit
- Michael Silence
- Mike Donila
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Mushy's Moochings
- Pam Strickland
- P.E.N. Studio
- Phyllis Patterson
- Pittman Properties
- Political Leverage
- Property Scope
- Randall Brown
- Reality Me
- Resonance
- Rikki Hall
- Rob Huddleston
- School Matters
- Snark Bites
- Stacey Campfield
- Stick With a Nose
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
- Suzy Trotta
- Tabloid Boy
- Terry Frank
- Thirteen Letters
- TN Clean Water
- Tom Humphrey
- Tri Cities
- Wendy Pitts Reeves
Beyond:
- Andy Axel
- Daily Docket
- Democratic Talk Radio
- Enclave
- Ginger Snaps
- Just Wonderin'
- Lean Left
- Post Politics
- Quiet Life
- Smart City Memphis
- Southern Liberal Living
- TN Dems
- TN Ticket
- TN Trivia
- TN Women's Caucus
- West TN Liberal
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South
- Great Smoky
- Lovable Liberal
- Newsrack
- Opinari
- Wandering Hillbilly
At large:
- Agonist
- Alterdestiny
- American Street
- Atrios
- Burnt Orange Report
- Buzzflash
- College Dems
- Common Cause
- Crooks and Liars
- Daily Kos
- Democratic Strategist
- Democrats.org
- Digby's Hullabaloo
- DSCC
- Ezra Klein
- The Fix
- Huffington Post
- Lefty Blogs
- Liberal Oasis
- Media Matters
- MyDD
- Open Secrets
- Pam's House Blend
- Political Wire
- Politico
- Progressive States
- Seeing the Forest
- Skippy the Bush Kangaroo
- Suburban Guerrilla
- Swing State Project
- Talk Left
- Talking Points Memo
- Think Progress
- Truthdig

Why so worked up?
I think this is a bit overblown. What remedies did the TN Supreme Court need to give everyone? Term limits are constitutional...what else needs to be added? Sure, it's an election year, and the filing deadlines are not that far away (I'm assuming so for Knox...not sure though)...but are you *that* afraid that your local government is going to collapse? Are you *that* afraid that capable people won't be running for these offices? They can, I assume, extend the filing deadlines, right?
I'm also not understanding where R is coming from when he said, "Unbelievable. It no longer appears there is government in Knox County by the people, for the people. It's government by the powers that be, for the powers that be."
What "powers that be?" The powers that be are the ones who are getting booted off the ballot. Or one would think.
This is far from anarchy. Don't get too worked up about it. :)
Just checking in between
Just checking in between copying/restoring files, but I couldn't let this pass.
Blake, if you read what I wrote, the "unbelievable" was in reference to the fact that a) term-limits were voted in overwhelmingly by Knox County voters 12 years ago, b) the Knox County Election Commission (nor the voters, nor the candidates) has ever abided by them, c) the Knox County Election Commission nor the County Law Director has ever asked for a definitive ruling, yet d) in the aftermath of a TN Supreme Court decision saying all of that was wrong for twleve years, the Election Commission now wants to ask "permission" from those affected to enforce the law.
And I don't think Rikki's assessment is overblown. I think it's an idea with merit and could help avoid total chaos. I'm just not sure what the legal precedent or authority would be. It would seem to require an amendment to the Knox County Charter. Which would take a referendum. Which there is no way could happen before May 2.
So, see, it really is approaching total chaos. Hell, even Victor Ashe is demanding a new ballot from Poland. How much more screwed up can an election get?
Well, it appears this is
Well, it appears this is more or less settled. The Election Commission has been advised that they do not have the authority to remove names from the ballot at this point. So all the names will stay on the ballot for the May 2 primary.
After the primary, however, if any of the incumbents win, they will be declared inelgible to appear on the ballot for the August general election. Their party will be allowed to choose a replacement candidate.
E.g., if Mary Lou Horner wins against the two Republicans running against her in the primary, she will be declared ineligible and the local Republican party will choose her replacement. It does NOT, btw, have to be one of the other two people running in the primary. The replacement will run against any D or I already on the ballot.
This basically means the party apparatus is going to end up choosing a bunch of Commissioners rather than the voters. But in essence that kind of happens now, so maybe it's never mind.
All of this assumes no successful law suits to the contrary. But the State Supreme Court was pretty damn clear (and unanimous), and its ruling is not subject to reconsideration.
Don't worry, be happy--
Here's why:
You say "I think this is a bit overblown. What remedies did the TN Supreme Court need to give everyone? "
--The Supreme Court gave no "remedies" regarding the impending election.
"Term limits are constitutional...what else needs to be added? Sure, it's an election year, and the filing deadlines are not that far away (I'm assuming so for Knox...not sure though)...but are you *that* afraid that your local government is going to collapse?" Are you *that* afraid that capable people won't be running for these offices? They can, I assume, extend the filing deadlines, right?"
--Yes, it is an election year, but aside from that, you are wrong on all counts. Filing deadlines are long since past. Election dates and deadlines are set by law and cannot be "extended."
"I'm also not understanding where R is coming from when he said, "Unbelievable. It no longer appears there is government in Knox County by the people, for the people. It's government by the powers that be, for the powers that be.
"What "powers that be?" The powers that be are the ones who are getting booted off the ballot. Or one would think."
--The powers that be are the party executive committee members who will choose the replacements for the egotistical incumbents, who are going to use this damned glitch in election law that denies anyone the right to remove their names from the ballot even though they cannot serve, to continue to campaign as though it were business as usual. And of course, working with those party regulars are the usual big money special interests that keep this body doing things like not passing storm water regs and looking the other way when big developers flout the law--
"This is far from anarchy. Don't get too worked up about it. :)"
--So what if an election that should, by rights, be a victory for democracy is about to turn into a bonanza for party hackocracy and special interests, eh, Blake?
Bean is right. If the Dirty
Bean is right. If the Dirty Dozen stay on the ballot (which apparently they are) and "win," they are not eligible to serve (that is, unless they file their own lawsuit using taxpayer funds to still try to still have a grip on power, and some are meeting with an attorney next week. So how do you feel getting to fund last gasp litigation to ignore the will of the voters and the Supreme Court?) .
But if everything holds up and these folks can no longer serve, but "win" their primary, these "winners" help get to hand pick their successor through the party caucus system. And how much say do you, the voter get? None. It's the ultimate backroom deal.
The only way to stop this hand picking of the successors is to vote for the opposition of the Dirty Dozen whenever possible.
I think Bean's and Carguy's
I think Bean's and Carguy's analyses are correct, and I'm none too happy about the seats being filled by party caucuces. As far as I can tell, however, that's the (most) legal way to do it. It's too, too bad this decision didn't come down before that filing deadline.
That said, I'm still happy with the decision itself. At least we'll only have to deal with these particular new bozos for 8 years, instead of an entire quarter century.
why so kneejerk?
Instead of making dismissive assumptions, why don't you read one of the many articles RNeal linked to that discuss the particulars. The filing deadline passed several weeks ago. Early voting starts in two weeks. The timing on this decision is horrible.
And what is it about pointing out some of the problems with the decision and how it was handled, mentioning a precedent that could help resolve the situation and proposing a solution that minimizes the disruption that strikes you as "so worked up"? It seems to me you are the one going off half-cocked.
Any chance we can get the
Any chance we can get the President to send in the National Guard to install a democracy?
Several of the commissioners
Several of the commissioners impacted by this ruling went along with Paul Pinkston's mathematically inept analysis of the sale of the old South High building, a mistake that will cost the county at least $200,000 plus the missed opportunity for a responsible development project in a neighborhood that welcomed the investment.
Just so you know, the nine Commissioners who voted with Pinkston (it was a 10-8 vote) were Jordan, Harmon, Hammond, Moore, Horner, Cawood, Mills, McMillan, and Clark. All but Harmon, Hammond and Moore are impacted by the Supreme Court decision.
Strickland, Collins, Tindell, Moody, Schmid, Guthe, Leuthold, Griess voted to sell the building. I believe Stephens did not vote.
BTW, I hear some in the County are back to advocating a metal storage warehouse on the school site - the very same proposal that set off the movement to save the school almost 4 years ago. Sigh.
democrats
I am advocating the democrats do 3 things if an incumbent wins the primary & is not put on the general election ballot.1.Hold County Commission District Conventions.2.Only allow voters from those districts to vote.3.Allow everyone that voted in the County Commission District Democratic Primary to vote.In the 1st district,4yrs ago,1300 voted
http://www.hallsnews.com/columns/bean.htm
Here's Betty Bean's column on the whole mess.
Word has it this afternoon that Shurf-suing Herb had a meeting with Bee Deselm and John Schmid and Schmid is joining the suit tomorrow to oust Tim Hutchison. Apparently Schmid turned down the opportunity to sue his cohorts on commission, instead going after Hutchison, but that in turn will pull in the other office holders such as Martha Phillips, Mike Lowe and Mike Padgett.
Also, Mary Lou Horner was MIA from discussing on live television at WBIR this morning the term limit issue. Despite being able to be at a banquet last night and campaiging there, she suddenly called WBIR at already 10 minutes into the airing of the live Inside Tennessee broadcast to say she couldn't come. Hmm....