I saw this on The Carpet Baggers Report. I don't know how many of you (if any) read it but this entry caught my eye and gave me plenty to think about.
What Michigan and Florida re-votes would mean to the Clinton campaign
Behind-the-scenes talks continue at a fairly aggressive pace about what Dems are going to do with Michigan and Florida. There’s a growing sense that Michigan may end up hosting a do-over primary in June, while influential Floridians continue
to float various compromise proposals.
There’s apparently a sense among Clinton supporters that the Clinton campaign should be more forceful in advocating re-votes in the two states. Mark Schmitt explains why this seems like a very bad strategy.
What would happen if an agreement were announced today that there would be re-votes in Florida and Michigan? Immediately, the previous primaries in those states would become dead letters. Instead of being 200,000 votes down in the popular vote (by her campaign’s count), or 500,000 down (by my count, which gives Clinton her Florida votes), Clinton would be down in the popular vote by almost 1 million. And 193 delegates that they are currently counting would suddenly disappear. (More after the break)
And at that point, the magnitude of Clinton’s deficit would be too obvious to spin away. Yes, there would be two additional large-state contests in which to win back the million popular votes and hundreds of delegates. But unless she did significantly better in both states than she did in the illegal primaries, she would lose, not gain, ground, by her own calculations. Since she was on the ballot alone in Michigan before, it’s highly unlikely that she will do better there. It’s very possible that she could do better than the 50 percent she won in Florida in January, but since it would now be a two-person race, it’s a dead certainty that Obama would do significantly better than the 32 percent he got in January, thus adding to his total popular vote margin and delegate count even if he lost again, and so it would be a net loss for Clinton. Re-votes cannot help Clinton be “perceived” as the winner of the popular vote.
Contrary to the gullible media’s belief that “time” is a “powerful ally” on Clinton’s side, in fact, Clinton’s only ally is uncertainty. The minute it becomes clear what will happen with Michigan and Florida — re-vote them, refuse to seat them, or split them 50-50 or with half-votes, as some have proposed — is the minute that Clinton’s last “path to the nomination” closes.
The only way to keep spin alive is to keep uncertainty alive — maybe there will be a revote, maybe they’ll seat the illegal Michigan/Florida delegations, maybe, maybe, maybe. In the fog of uncertainty, Penn can claim that there is a path to the nomination, but under any possible actual resolution of the uncertainty, there is not.
It’s hard to overstate how persuasive this is.
There are practically zero circumstances in which re-votes would help the Clinton campaign. She won’t beat Obama by 20 points in Florida again, and she won’t beat him by 55 in Michigan again. Clinton benefits from a) leaving things just as they are, and convincing the DNC to throw its rules out the window; or b) having the situation unresolved indefinitely.
The first is unlikely, because it constitutes changing the rules in the middle of the game. Clinton supported stripping Michigan and Florida of their delegates, and supported the agreement whereby no candidate would campaign in the states. Now that she wants/needs the states to appear competitive, those previous positions, apparently, are no longer operative. Most reasonable observers find this a little hard to swallow.
Nevertheless, while the possibility of competitive contests in Florida and Michigan remain on the table, the Clinton campaign can argue that the fight for the nomination is unresolved, and should stay that way. As Ezra explained, it seems like a strategy premised on delaying the inevitable, given Obama’s lead in delegates, votes, states, and increasingly, superdelegates.
[W]e know that her only path to the nomination is to crush Obama’s candidacy, to wound him so heavily that the superdelegates will abandon him and turn to Clinton as the savior of the party. It’s not because she’s a mean person, but because that’s the only strategy left to her. She’s in the weird position of being famous enough that the media is willing to grant her candidacy legitimacy long after other campaigns would have been written off. And that’s convinced her to stay in the race. But it’s left her in a race she can’t win, and in a position where she has to go so brutally negative that she makes Obama lose, and the superdelegates pick her by default.
But that outcome only looks viable from within the Clinton campaign. Sitting outside their tent, it’s vanishingly unlikely. And I say that as someone who’s long been sympathetic to her candidacy, and who’s not particularly enamored with Obama. If her strategy succeeds, and she somehow does uncover the piece of opposition research or force the gaffe that destroys Obama’s campaign, it seems likelier that Al Gore gets the nomination through a brokered convention than that Hillary Clinton gets it through the intervention of the superdelegates. There’s just too much fear as to what the repercussions among African-American voters would be.
So her path to the nomination involves either a brutal and divisive convention battle, or a campaign that does nothing save damage the eventual nominee.
Eventually, Pelosi and Reid and Dean are going to realize that, and convince a solid bloc of superdelegates to make an endorsement that ends this process.
Presumably, that would happen after Pennsylvania. But what Clinton is trying to do is draw out uncertainty over Michigan and Florida so that it can’t happen until after that question is resolved, and that question isn’t anywhere near resolution. Since those states sound big, it seems superficially plausible that their intervention could change the dynamics. But if you look at the delegates, and you look at the votes, that’s actually not true. And this is why clarity hurts the Clinton campaign.
If there’s a flaw in this thinking, I don’t see it.
© 2008 The Carpetbagger Report · Powered by WordPress · Developed by Blogging ExpertiseAbout Archives Contact
Topics:
|
|
Discussing:
- Executive Order on Protecting the Federal Workforce and Requiring Mask-Wearing (1 reply)
- Minimum Wage for Federal Contractors, as of January 1, 2021 (2 replies)
- The situation (458 replies)
- How to stay safe as coyotes are out and about in East Tennessee (1 reply)
- Burchett imprecise on 25th Amendment (9 replies)
- Sad day in America (17 replies)
- We made it! (4 replies)
- President Biden (3 replies)
- A New Day (1 reply)
- Pruitt out (7 replies)
- Burchett votes to overturn legal election (41 replies)
- State of Tennessee vaccine distribution incompetence (20 replies)
TN Progressive
- Friday Toons (RoaneViews)
- Breathe deeply (Domestic Psychology)
- If You See One Thing Today... (RoaneViews)
- Sometime Today Roane County Will Record Its 80th Covid Death (RoaneViews)
- Friday Toons (RoaneViews)
- Blount County coronavirus cases over 9,300 as of 12/27/2020 (BlountViews)
- Blount County coronavirus cases nearly 8,000 as of 12/17/2020 (BlountViews)
- Blount County coronavirus cases over 7,000 as of 12/11/2020 (BlountViews)
- Blount County coronavirus cases over 6,100 as of 12/4/2020 (BlountViews)
- The 2020 Presidential Debate: We've Been Here Before (Joe Powell)
- Recommendations for August 6 (Left Wing Cracker)
- Facts and Truth - the Vaccine for Our Nation (Joe Powell)
TN Politics
- Commentary: Giving gratitude for the lessons of Trump (TN Lookout)
- New guidance from Tennessee officials says hospitals cannot limit vaccines to existing patients (TN Lookout)
- Former Sen. Jim Tracy joins Commerce Department (TN Journal)
- Power Poll Prediction: Hagerty & Blackburn Will Not Vote to Convict Trump (TN Lookout)
- Legislature passes COVID education plan; penalties for Metro Nashville, Shelby on hold (TN Lookout)
- Nashville Mayor Cooper says city can handle more vaccine, as President Biden promises to speed up process (TN Lookout)
- One senator catches COVID-19, another under quarantine in special session (TN Lookout)
- COVID diagnosis in Senate raises concerns (UPDATED) (TN Journal)
- New charges filed against Democratic Sen. Robinson (TN Journal)
- Here is Gov. Bill Lee’s special session address to lawmakers (TN Journal)
- New Affordable Housing Task Force Has Plenty to Tackle (Nashville Scene)
- Attorneys Say DNA Testing Results Consistent With Pervis Payne’s Innocence Claim (Nashville Scene)
- Tennessee senators praise Alabama HQ for Space Command (TN Journal)
- Dems’ effort to require face coverings punted in House (TN Journal)
- Tennessee Democrats Elect Hendrell Remus New Party Chair (Nashville Scene)
- The Weekly Links: The Insurrectionists, Justin Townes Earle and Trump's Last Execution (Nashville Scene)
- Get a Load of This Unhinged Email From Dave Ramsey and Co. (Nashville Scene)
- Community Members Discuss How to Be an Antiracist in Metro's Upcoming Panel Series (Nashville Scene)
Knox TN Today
- Fighting masks and vaccines, it’s hard to be Humble (Knox TN Today)
- Off season improvements continue (Knox TN Today)
- Tree ID class at UT Gardens (Knox TN Today)
- Farmers Market open through winter (Knox TN Today)
- Get your Ripley’s Ultimate Fun Pass (Knox TN Today)
- O’Steen left Oak Ridge a better place (Knox TN Today)
- Tom Catani: ‘Be fast, fantastic’ (Knox TN Today)
- Tennessee has new AD: Up, up and away they go (Knox TN Today)
- Fans channeling Pat Summitt need to hush (Knox TN Today)
- First Presbyterian: Witness to history (Knox TN Today)
- Mary Costa receives National Medal of the Arts (Knox TN Today)
- Friends of the Smokies working on park’s issues (Knox TN Today)
Local TV News
- Karns community mourns the death of beloved barber Clark 'Sparky' Walker (WATE)
- THP: Three injured in collision with tower that resulted in widespread outages in Oak Ridge (WATE)
- Shotgun blast fired at Planned Parenthood front door (WBIR)
- Most power restored after outages in Oak Ridge due to transmission tower hit by truck (WBIR)
- Nurse rushes to help in apparent accidental shooting at Clinton Highway Walmart (WATE)
- Monroe Co. man shares vaccine experience, highlights struggles rural communities face (WATE)
- Pair of KUB employees were paid $10K for hours they did not work, comptroller's office finds (WATE)
- Sevierville family looking for missing parakeet (WATE)
- Tennessee National Guard troops return home after securing U.S. Capitol during inauguration (WBIR)
- Top 5 winter hiking spots in Knox County (WBIR)
- Legislature adopts bills to tackle COVID-19 effects on students' proficiency in reading, math (WBIR)
- Appointments for Saturday's COVID-19 vaccine clinic in Knox Co. were taken in minutes (WBIR)
News Sentinel
- Knox County will have vaccinated 6,000 by the time the weekend is through (KNS News)
- See these 40 Under 40 honorees celebrating virtually (KNS Business)
- University of Tennessee, Knox County Schools and Knox County COVID-19 case counts (KNS News)
- Execution of King Charles I in 1600s Britain reveals the unintended consequences of insurrections | Opinion (KNS Opinion)
- Two former KUB employees falsified timesheets to the tune of $10,595, comptroller says (KNS News)
- COVID-19 spotlighted how the poor nutrition in Tennessee is intertwined in racial, health disparities | Opinion (KNS Opinion)
- Will Regal Cinemas' spring reopening hopes be dashed by James Bond? (KNS Business)
- Knox County law department shreds unfounded ethics complaint from public health critic (KNS News)
- Tennessee plan to hold back third graders who fall behind in reading draws scrutiny (KNS News)
- Trump may show up, though late, for his (political) party | George Korda (KNS Opinion)
- Report: Donor threatened to withhold contribution if GOP AG's dark money group didn't promote Capitol rally (KNS News)
- Tennessee's physician assistants deserve to continue their work without restrictions | Opinion (KNS Opinion)
- The choice is clear: get the COVID-19 vaccine or the virus | Opinion (KNS Opinion)
- Shape, scrape, bend, glue: A downtown Knoxville shop turns wood blocks into 'Fine Violins' (KNS Business)
State News
- 'Coaches can't want it more than the players': Tigers believe turnaround has started (Commercial Appeal)
- The family running a Memphis funeral home are stars of new Netflix series 'Buried by the Bernards' (Commercial Appeal)
- Nashville bombing: 'Not your typical type of crime scene' may take years to investigate (Tennessean)
- TBI charges man accused of editing photo to make it look like cop's grave was desecrated (Tennessean)
- 'Zip tie guy' Eric Munchel can be released from federal custody on Monday, judge rules (Tennessean)
- Hank Aaron showed Black Americans they can dream big. Here's how I know (Commercial Appeal)
- A timeline of Friday's downtown explosion in Nashville (Tennessean)
- Engine manufacturer Cummins to close Memphis plant, move operations to South Carolina (Commercial Appeal)
- Planned Trader Joe's site cleared in Chattanooga with construction to start soon - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Business Calendar - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Boating deaths in Tennessee highest in 37 years - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
- Remember When, Chattanooga? Do you recognize this Signal Mountain church? - Chattanooga Times Free Press (Times Free Press)
Local .GOV
- Update: I-275 Business Park Access Improvements Project Making Major Progress (Knoxville)
- Both Jackson Avenue Ramps Now Open; Compare 'Before' and 'After' Photos (Knoxville)
- New Jackson Avenue West Ramp About to Open; East Ramp to Open by Mid-January (Knoxville)
- Neighborhoods Decorate for Holiday Trails (Knoxville)
- Facade Funding Recipient Likewise Coffee Open on Magnolia (Knoxville)
- Winter Fishing at Fountain City Lake Made Possible by Years of Restoration Work (Knoxville)
Wire Reports
- Winning Numbers For $1 Billion Mega Millions Jackpot Announced - CBS San Francisco (Business)
- Ghost Ship fire: Warehouse tenant pleads guilty to 36 deaths - NBC News (US News)
- Chick-fil-A adds grilled spicy chicken sandwich to menus nationwide - Fox News (Business)
- Pfizer ships fewer Covid vaccine vials to U.S. after Trump FDA label change - POLITICO (Business)
- 2021 tax season: What to prepare for - Fox Business (Business)
- Biden says his mask mandate is common sense. Republicans say ‘kiss my ass.’ - Politico (US News)
- California man injured in apparent shark attack off Maui - CNN (US News)
- Senate Leaders Agree on Impeachment Trial Delay, Giving Biden Breathing Room - The New York Times (US News)
- Biden sticks to vaccine goals nearly met by his predecessor - The Washington Post (US News)
- Bus heading to Grand Canyon rolls over; 1 dead, 2 critical - The Associated Press (US News)
- Jill Biden visits National Guard troops, thanks them for keeping family safe - New York Post (US News)
- Bitcoin on track for biggest weekly fall since September as Janet Yellen and 'double spend' spook traders - Business Insider (Business)
- AMD earnings: If Intel gets its act together, can AMD maintain swollen valuation? - MarketWatch (Business)
- Dow, S&P close lower as IBM, Intel weigh, coronavirus concerns rise - Reuters (Business)
- Dow Jones Dips As Intel, IBM Weigh; Nasdaq Hits New High Ahead Of Apple Earnings - Investor's Business Daily (Business)
Lost Medicaid Funding
Search and Archives
TN Progressive
- BlountViews
- Cup of Joe Powell
- Left Wing Cracker
- RoaneViews
- Southern Beale
- Tiny Cat Pants
- Vibinc
- View From My Kitchen Table
- WhitesCreek Journal
Nearby:
- AC Entertainment
- Backyard Farmer 101
- Blount Dems
- Cameron Brooks
- David Hunter
- David Moon
- Domestic Psychology
- Ellen Smith
- Gerald Witt
- Frank Murphy
- Herston TN Family Law
- Inside of Knoxville
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jim Stovall
- Knox Dems
- Knoxify
- Les Jones
- Lynn Point Records
- Michael Silence
- Mike Donila
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Outdoor Knoxville
- P.E.N. Studio
- Pittman Properties
- Property Scope
- Reality Me
- Rikki Hall
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
- Suzy Trotta
- Tom Humphrey
Beyond:
- Andy Axel
- Enclave
- Pith in the Wind
- Post Politics
- Quiet Life
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Ticket
- TN Trivia
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South
- Lovable Liberal
At large:
- Agonist
- Atrios
- Burnt Orange Report
- Buzzflash
- College Dems
- Crooks and Liars
- Daily Kos
- Democratic Strategist
- Democrats.org
- Digby's Hullabaloo
- Ezra Klein
- The Fix
- Huffington Post
- Media Matters
- Open Secrets
- Political Wire
- Politico
- Seeing the Forest
- Skippy the Bush Kangaroo
- Suburban Guerrilla
- Talk Left
- Talking Points Memo
- Think Progress
- Truthdig
- Truthout
193 delegates
"193 delegates..currently counting..would suddenly
disappear."
I dont understand what delegates these are.
Bill, I understood them to
Bill,
I understood them to be the ones from FL and MI that she 'won' if the oringinal primary vote was validated.
Take Care, Be Good and don't play in the street!
SteveMule
Those delegates aren't
Those delegates aren't "currently counted" tho.
193???
For a more clearer understanding of the "193" in question go to the original Carpetbager post read it (my attempts to fix the formating after a crude cut and paste leave much to be desired) and read the early comments (they also ask this question).
It seems that IF the Florida and Michigan votes are counted HRC gets 193 delegates out of it. These go poof if there's a do-over. The point of the article (as I understand it) was that HRC will, in all likely hood not do as well as this. And thus a do-over is not really in her interests.
Take Care, Be Good and don't play in the street!
SteveMule