Reality continues to intrude upon the Bush-McCain-Lieberman "surge & accelerate" roadmap to victory.
You know that "troop surge" of 20,000 that the president is requesting?
Not so much, um... what's the word... possible.
The military maintains that they can only commit to 9,000.
The president is expected to give his speech on a new way forward in Iraq next week. CBS’s David Martin has learned military commanders told the President they could execute a ‘troop surge’ of 9,000 soldiers and Marines into Iraq, with another 10,000 on alert in Kuwait and the U.S. Two army brigades — about 7,500 troops — would go into Baghdad in an effort to control the violence, clearing neighborhoods and staying long enough for reconstruction projects to take effect. 1,500 Marines would go to the western province of al-Anbar, heartland of the Sunni insurgency. This, even though the Commandant of the Marine Corps was quoted as saying he did not see a need for more battalions. But aides say the President still hasn’t decided for sure on a plan.
Gee, that's only a -55% error. (Calculate it yourself.)
The backpedalling is already in progress:
Escalation backers have already begun distancing themselves from this plan. Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) said yesterday that not sending enough troops would be “worse than doing nothing.”
Which is another way of saying "par for the course," isn't it, Senator?
|
|
style="display:block"
data-ad-format="autorelaxed"
data-ad-client="ca-pub-3296520478850753"
data-ad-slot="5999968558">
Discussing:
- News Sentinel editor stalking county employee (49 replies)
- DNC sues re: conspiracy to disrupt the 2016 campaign (1 reply)
- Western Plaza construction (24 replies)
- There is an 'avalanche' of women running for office (2 replies)
- DTV discusses the Face to Face Program in the Knox County Detention Center (2 replies)
- Washington, D.C., may let 16-year-olds vote for president (6 replies)
- South is NY (and others ) dumping ground (1 reply)
- Knoxville SOUP (2 replies)
- Facebook Likes Marsha .. or does it? (1 reply)
- Local news under attack (4 replies)
- Tennessee trains (1 reply)
- Methinks they do protest too much (2 replies)
Upcoming events:
- Apr 25 2018 - 12:00pm (1 day 11 hours from now)
- May 3 2018 - 6:30pm (1 week 2 days from now)
TN Progressive
- Forced Arbitration: Wells Fargo Wins, Consumers Lose (TN Citizen Action)
- Nashville Shooter on Top 10 Most Wanted List...UPDATE: Got Him! (RoaneViews)
- Got 2 Minutes? (TN Citizen Action)
- Two Things I learned Today (RoaneViews)
- Wasteful Spending and Work Requirements (TN Citizen Action)
- TN Ready Testing Doesn't Work, Legislators Ditch It, Vendor Still Gets Paid (RoaneViews)
- Ten Finalists for TBI Director Include Former Rockwood Police Chief (RoaneViews)
- Corker, Alexander Vote to Allow Racial Discrimination in Auto Lending (TN Citizen Action)
- Hey Memphis! Want to meet your next Governor? (Left Wing Cracker)
- Let’s Arm Teachers, They Said (Southern Beale)
- Since you asked.... (Left Wing Cracker)
- March Book Count (Domestic Psychology)
TN Politics
- Takeaways from the GOP gubernatorial debate in Memphis (Tom Humphrey)
- TN tax take in March: Complicated but basically about what was expected (Tom Humphrey)
- Corker defends favorable comments about Bredesen on national TV shows (Tom Humphrey)
- House GOP retaliation for Confederate monument removal: A scripted political show? (Tom Humphrey)
- TBI crime report for 2017: More murder and rape, less DUI (Tom Humphrey)
- Feds approve $26M for new veterans home in Bradley County (Tom Humphrey)
- With Haslam signature, legal Sunday booze sales can begin this weekend (Tom Humphrey)
- TN National Guard disapproves of taking oath of office with a dinosaur puppet (Tom Humphrey)
- Ohio law — similar to TN ‘defunding Planned Parenthood’ bill — voided by appeals court (Tom Humphrey)
- Bill requiring some to work for TennCare coverage gets final legislative approval (Tom Humphrey)
Knox TN Today
- Project GRAD honors 99 (Knox TN Today)
- Pruitt spanks absent fans (Knox TN Today)
- (Knox TN Today)
- (Knox TN Today)
- ‘Corteo’ puts the ‘fun’ in ‘funeral’ (Knox TN Today)
- How high’s the water, Mama? (Knox TN Today)
- Get Out & Play: Keep calm and paddle on (Knox TN Today)
- Burchett ‘will roll,’ predicts Cohen (Knox TN Today)
- Emerald Youth Foundation is PBPA topic (Knox TN Today)
- It’s a ‘Mother with Sons’ thing… (Knox TN Today)
- SOUP pot goes to SPARK games (Knox TN Today)
- Rogero affirms support of Pellissippi State’s Magnolia campus (Knox TN Today)
Local TV News
- Family of woman killed in accident at Bush Brothers' facility speaks, asks how (WATE)
- Demand for rehab stresses raptor center (WBIR)
- Search underway for armed, dangerous men after West Knox County shooting (WATE)
- Community mourns 6 people killed in Alcoa house fire (WBIR)
- Roane County considers $68 million dollar schools project (WBIR)
- Sevier County animal shelter dealing with Parvo outbreak (WBIR)
- LCUB considers offering high speed internet service (WBIR)
- Misdemeanor assault case against Knox doctor dropped (WBIR)
- Watchdog group wants new TVA audit (WATE)
- TBI adds Antioch Waffle House shooter to Top 10 Most Wanted List (WATE)
- State lawmakers pass bill to hold students, teachers harmless from TNReady results (WATE)
- Chattanooga senior's armed graduation photo goes viral (WATE)
News Sentinel
- Autopsies begin on 6 victims of deadly Alcoa blaze; cause of the fire unknown (KNS News)
- Opinion | 3 ways to avoid nutrition misinformation on the internet (KNS Opinion)
- Opinion | Love them or hate them, dandelions herald spring (KNS Opinion)
- Knoxville biz ticker: Cumberland Trust hits asset milestone (KNS News)
- Rick Dover tours restored Knoxville High (KNS News)
- Opinion | U.S. Rep. John J. Duncan Jr. should join Climate Solutions Caucus (KNS Opinion)
- Vice President Mike Pence endorses Marsha Blackburn's bid for Senate (KNS News)
- South Knox drive-by shooting suspects captured after fiery crash (KNS News)
- Victor Ashe: Slap at UT board reflects long-term public frustration (KNS News)
- Owner of 3 East Tennessee clinics catering to poor admits to unlicensed patient care (KNS News)
- Sunday sales don't thrill Knoxville liquor merchants (KNS Business)
- Pink slime, cockroaches, moldy foods and more found during restaurant inspections (KNS Business)
- New 19-story waterfront mixed-use development proposed for downtown Knoxville (KNS Business)
- Knoxville's Dragon Lights festival will take your breath away (KNS Opinion)
State News
- The List: Median weekly wages in Chattanooga metro area counties (Times Free Press)
- High-profile Memphis couple from Mexico take oath and are now U.S. citizens (Commercial Appeal)
- Waffle House shooting suspect Travis Reinking in custody, booked on $2 million bond (Tennessean)
- Critics claim top officials' use of TVA aircraft may be illegal [documents] (Times Free Press)
- Chattanooga area bankruptcy filings, April 16-22, 2018 (Times Free Press)
- Waffle House shooting: ATF agent says shooting suspect's father may have violated federal law (Tennessean)
- Beale Street Music Festival stages and set times confirmed (Commercial Appeal)
- Waffle House shooting suspect was 'looking real nervous,' woman who called 911 says (Tennessean)
- Local chef Tamra Eddy brings home the groceries in big win on Food Network (Commercial Appeal)
- Nashville mayoral candidate Carol Swain: More lives saved if Waffle House patrons had been armed (Tennessean)
- Bennett, Cook win national journalism awards (Times Free Press)
- Top Memphis basketball targets discuss Penny Hardaway, Mike Miller and recruiting process (Commercial Appeal)
Local .GOV
- Karaoke, Integration and Other Topics at Knoxville History Project Luncheon (Knoxville)
- Parks and Recreation Summer Camps, Classes, and Job Opportunities Around the Corner! (Knoxville)
- Mayor, BGCTNV Kids Play a Pick-Up Game to Celebrate MLB 'Play Ball' Intiative (Knoxville)
- Community Development Partners Receive Equity Awards (Knoxville)
- Reversing Trickle-Down Effects of Damaged Creeks (Knoxville)
- A More Accessible City: ‘We’re Going in the Right Direction’ (Knoxville)
- County budget presentation, public meetings planned (Knox County)
- Knox County splash pads to open May 5 (Knox County)
- Annual rabies vaccination clinics scheduled for May 5 and May 12 (Knox County)
- New Harvest Park Farmers Market season kicks off April 12 (Knox County)
- County offices closed Friday, March 30 (Knox County)
- It's National Public Health Week (Knox County)
Wire Reports
- 'I thought I was done': George HW Bush faced death at 20 during WWII (US News)
- How Europe's New Privacy Rules Favor Google and Facebook (Business)
- Kyle Kashuv says school security questioned him for visiting gun range with his dad (US News)
- Waffle House shooting suspect Travis Reinking arrested, refusing to answer questions, police say (US News)
- United Continental Board Seeks New Chairman, Cuts CEO's Pay (Business)
- Google Parent Posts Surge in Profit, but Expenses Also Jump (Business)
- A woman was tackled by officers at an Alabama Waffle House. Police are defending the arrest. (US News)
- Poll: Coal baron Blankenship fading in W.Va. Senate primary (US News)
- Video: American Airlines passenger tased 10 times after allegedly groping woman on plane (Business)
- Mike Pompeo advances out of committee with favorable recommendation, following Paul flipping his vote (US News)
- The Daily Prophet: What's Gotten Into the Dollar These Days? (Business)
- Wells Fargo Faces Wrath of Activists Over Scandals, NRA Work (Business)
- Trump ramps up personal cell phone use (US News)
- Net neutrality is all but officially dead. Now what? (Business)
- Starbucks' 'unconscious bias training' isn't enough, protesters say (Business)
Lost Medicaid Funding
Search and Archives
TN Progressive
- BlountViews
- Cup of Joe Powell
- Left Wing Cracker
- RoaneViews
- Southern Beale
- Tiny Cat Pants
- Vibinc
- View From My Kitchen Table
- WhitesCreek Journal
Nearby:
- AC Entertainment
- Backyard Farmer 101
- Blount Dems
- Cameron Brooks
- David Hunter
- David Moon
- Domestic Psychology
- Ellen Smith
- Gerald Witt
- Frank Murphy
- Herston TN Family Law
- Inside of Knoxville
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jim Stovall
- Knox Dems
- Knoxify
- Les Jones
- Lynn Point Records
- Michael Silence
- Mike Donila
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Outdoor Knoxville
- P.E.N. Studio
- Pittman Properties
- Property Scope
- Reality Me
- Rikki Hall
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
- Suzy Trotta
- Tom Humphrey
Beyond:
- Andy Axel
- Enclave
- Pith in the Wind
- Post Politics
- Quiet Life
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Ticket
- TN Trivia
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South
- Lovable Liberal
At large:
- Agonist
- Atrios
- Burnt Orange Report
- Buzzflash
- College Dems
- Crooks and Liars
- Daily Kos
- Democratic Strategist
- Democrats.org
- Digby's Hullabaloo
- Ezra Klein
- The Fix
- Huffington Post
- Media Matters
- Open Secrets
- Political Wire
- Politico
- Seeing the Forest
- Skippy the Bush Kangaroo
- Suburban Guerrilla
- Talk Left
- Talking Points Memo
- Think Progress
- Truthdig
- Truthout
Guess who agrees with you?
Oliver North!
The call for incrementally increasing U.S. troop strength in Iraq -- a "solution" that was first proffered last summer as the congressional election campaign heated up -- sounds eerily like Lyndon Johnson's plan to save Vietnam in the mid 1960s. Johnson saw "gradual escalation" as a way not to lose, and to avoid the unpleasant necessity of directly confronting North Vietnam. Regrettably, that also meant we could not win.
Adding 10,000 or 20,000 more U.S. combat troops -- mostly soldiers and Marines -- isn't going to improve Iraqi willingness to fight their own fight -- an imperative if we are to claim victory in this war. While putting 200,000 American or NATO troops on the Iranian and Syrian borders to stop infiltration might make sense, that's "mission impossible" given the size of U.S. and allied armed forces.
...
A "surge" or "targeted increase in U.S. troop strength" or whatever the politicians want to call dispatching more combat troops to Iraq isn't the answer. Adding more trainers and helping the Iraqis to help themselves, is. Sending more U.S. combat troops is simply sending more targets.
This is Vietnamization in
This is Vietnamization in modern garb.
As news of this impending plan started to leak around the holidays, I thought, "Hm. Shades of the Christmas Day Bombing."
After recognizing that the Mahdi have infiltrated the Interior Ministry, I think it's painfully apparent to even the most Bush-happy jackanape on these here intarwebs that "standing up the Iraqis so we can stand down" is a vain hope, if not a farce.
____________________________
Dirty mouth language -- it's the new black.
Sounds dangerous. What if
Sounds dangerous. What if some other conflict arises? What if we are attacked again on our soil? What exactly are we prepared for?
So, Andy
Are you saying Donald Rumsfeld was right about the number of troops he committed to Iraq?
Disclaimer: I've always been pretty well agnostic on the troops issue. Maybe it would have made things easier at one time by putting down the insurgents, or maybe it would have made things worse by creating more casualties, burnout, and expense.
I suspect, though, that some people (not necessarily you, Andy) who criticized Rumsfeld for not sending enough troops are now going to criticize Bush for ... sending in more troops. It's probably possible to construct an argument that it would have been better then, but worse now, but that argument is likely to be pure sophistry.
Hey, Les, why don't we just call each other assholes and get it over with. - Somebody on the old Southknoxbubba.net (if that was you, claim your quote and win net.fame!)
Fuck no. And you of all
Fuck no. And you of all people should know better.
The issue is that the president shot off his mouth about committing troops before even figuring out how many troops that he could commit.
It's like "bring 'em on" or "mission accomplished." He's completely out of his depth, and this is just another repetition of the same old.
And when McCain says that "doing nothing would be preferable," that about sums up my feelings about this misadventure starting in 2003. We should never have invaded Iraq in the first place.
____________________________
Dirty mouth language -- it's the new black.
So what then?
Against sending more troops. Against training more Iraqi troops. So - what? Get out now and watch events unfold? You bringing the popcorn?
Where did I say I was
Where did I say I was against training Iraqi troops?
I did say that training an army loyal to Muqtada al Sadr is an uphill battle. How do you recommend that we train a bunch of militant Shi'a Muslims to be unwavering friendlies to the West? Hm?
Where's your truckload of great ideas? Or are you just going to keep pissing on anything brought up by so-called "partisan Democrats?"
Thought so.
____________________________
Dirty mouth language -- it's the new black.
Where did I say I was
Where did I say I was against training Iraqi troops?
Well...
After recognizing that the Mahdi have infiltrated the Interior Ministry, I think it's painfully apparent to even the most Bush-happy jackanape on these here intarwebs that "standing up the Iraqis so we can stand down" is a vain hope, if not a farce.
If I was mistaken in reading into the above your being against the attempt, then I apologize.
I personally don't see how
I personally don't see how training Iraqi troops will ever help the situation in Iraq. Won't the soldiers still be loyal to their own personal factions. I know I'm not one of the brightest fireflies in the field but I can't conceive how it will work?
Adrift in the Sea of Humility
Johnny Ringo is a welcome
Johnny Ringo is a welcome addition to KnoxViews. Nice to have another perspective. I have enjoyed the lively debate on several threads Mr. Ringo.
Carry on.